Seibertron.com Energon Pub Forums

burning_sirius wrote:HOW DARE THEY USE STUFF FROM THE 1986 MOVIE! Seriously, this is why I kind of hate reading comments on Seibertron.

We're sorry.

Seibertron's news staff is great (one of the best imo), don't get me wrong, but when I scroll down to the comments I read insightful comments like 'They should stop quoting the 1986 movie, and my ShOuLdEr's HuRt because of it'. Ridiculous, I remember when I would of jumped out of my seat if I heard "Light our 'darkest hour'". How dare they use 'darkest hour' to describe probably what will be the Autobot's darkest hour. Are they going to off Optimus? WHO KNOWS? I mean, this time around Hot Rod won't do it for sure, maybe it will be Smokescreen instead.

Aren't we entitled to opinions?

I mean I guess we could take quotes from the Bay movies with such gems like:

"AHHHHHHHHH" Shia Lebouf screaming as per normal (This was a Rifftrax parody)

How about Bumblebee peeing on people. That would just be great to homage.

On a show rated TV-Y7? Deaths make it dark enough, we don't need to see robo-genitals.

How about Devastator having two wrecking test...'balls'.

Again, we don't need to see robo-genitals.

One wonders why the live action movies are not homaged more and why the G1 movie is and always be a jewel of Transformers-dom.

And if it wasn't? Who knows where we'd be now.

I am fine with 1986 homages. Those who are not fine with them are a very small vocal minority who thinks they are the majority.

When Optimus and Megatron use "One Shall Stand, One Shall Fall" 100 times in 52 episodes...

If what you all are saying is true, then Fall of Cybertron should not of sold very well. It sold very well because it hit all the right notes when it came to referencing the movie.

More power to it, we're not saying the G1 Movie should be banned from modern TF media dialogue. It's when these lines become a common occurrence. When there's no dialogue variety, it tends to become boring; that's all.

You don't get it, burning_sirius. It's not that they simply keep quoting the G1 movie. It's that it's done so often that all the repeated quotes lose their luster. Quoting something as often as the G1 movie makes its repeated lines no longer feel as good as they originally did, and reeks of being an excuse for coming up with something more original.

It's not that we want them to quote something else like the Bay movies, it's that we want them to just stop with over-quoting in and of itself, period.

Taking an old quote and using it over and over and over again in so many cases isn't creative, it's lazy.

Look at last week's TF: Prime episode, for example. The sword fight between Otpimus and Megatron could have had some familiar quote(s) thrown into it in an attempt at fanwank, but it didn't. Instead, it had its own script with unique and original dialogue and was all good by its own merit, without having to rely on any past material.

Sabrblade, you are completely right in your post. I cannot agree with you more. The last episode had some great original banter. I hate it when people are uncreative and dredge up old banter. Now using old banter creatively, I approve of, but then it becomes a matter of taste. Some here hate Generation 1 and thus will never approve of G1 ever getting any nods. Sometimes they are right, and sometimes they are wrong. Video games are different imo in terms of writing given my support of using iconic phrases in FoC. I do not think Prime has beaten into the ground any Transformers phrasology. I mean 'Autobots Roll Out' is used a ton. I do not begrudge them for using that, or other phrases that can have duel meanings like 'Darkest Hour'. Obviously, this season will end on a very sour note, which I approve of.

burning_sirius wrote:Sabrblade, you are completely right in your post. I cannot agree with you more. The last episode had some great original banter. I hate it when people are uncreative and dredge up old banter. Now using old banter creatively, I approve of, but then it becomes a matter of taste. Some here hate Generation 1 and thus will never approve of G1 ever getting any nods. Sometimes they are right, and sometimes they are wrong. Video games are different imo in terms of writing given my support of using iconic phrases in FoC. I do not think Prime has beaten into the ground any Transformers phrasology. I mean 'Autobots Roll Out' is used a ton. I do not begrudge them for using that, or other phrases that can have duel meanings like 'Darkest Hour'. Obviously, this season will end on a very sour note, which I approve of.

The way something is used also plays a factor into this. An example of how an old quote was used in a unique and clever way would be in "Darkness Rising, Part 5", in which Ratchet said, "Then by all means, let us light our darkest hour." the context in which it was used shows he meant "light" as a metaphor for "blow up the space bridge to smithereens". But when they recreate Starscream's coronation scene in Fall of Cybertron and use all the exact same lines word-for-word with nothing new, it feels more like a ripoff of the original version rather than a new take on it.

Though, when I said that old quotes have been overused and run into the ground, I didn't mean to imply that TF: Prime or any one thing had done that. If it came across that way, I apologize. Rather, I meant to imply that many sources over the years have repeated the quotes so often that each new use of them feels unoriginal.

The worst offender, "One shall stand..." has been used at least thirteen times across different media and, as the years go by, its uses begin to pile up with each time it's repeated. Sometimes I wish a new ultimatum, like even one that's a new spin on this one, would be used.

The difference with something like "Transform and roll out" is that, unlike the movie quotes, it's something that was already said over and over from the get-go, so it's expected to be repeated like standard procedure. Like it's as common a military command as "Fire!" "Take cover!" "Retreat!" "Attack!" etc.

Thanks to the AT&T U-verse program guide we finally have the synopsis for the Transformers Prime season 2 finale, "Darkest Hour". The season finale is scheduled to air on November 2nd, and just in case you've missed any episodes leading up this point the Hub will be airing all of the previous episodes starting on November 1st. See the episode description below:

Megatron comes up with a complex plan and once it's put together, Optimus is placed in a position where he is forced to make a risky decision that, if not carefully considered, could have an inescapable effect on the entire Autobot team.

That is a long winded sentence. Almost like some academics I know.

So, Zap2it really never provided a synopsis, eh? That's new.

As for this one, despite the last several from AT&T U-Verse being more descriptive, it seems they went out of their way to not spoil anything this time.

Though, we can pretty much assume that the Autobots lose this season.

So, is it TFP: Beast Hunters after Season 2?

daimchoc wrote:So, is it TFP: Beast Hunters after Season 2?

Yes, it's season 3.

Sabrblade wrote:So, Zap2it really never provided a synopsis, eh? That's new.

Nope, I checked their program before posting to see if they had any additional info.