Seibertron.com Energon Pub Forums

I have been collecting Transformers comics in the 80s. I have all of them ( except#80) first printing ex condition. I kept them stored away all this time. Now its 2012, after 25 years and 3 motion films based on the comic books I find it outrages that these comics are only valued to face value after all these years. Am I the only one that thinks this? Who really decides whats the value of these comics?? I just dont get it..

They're only worth what people are willing to pay for them, nobody gets to decide how much they are worth.
Plus the movies aren'T based on the comic books, they are based on the same thing the comics where based on - the toys.

Dead Metal wrote:Plus the movies aren'T based on the comic books, they are based on the same thing the comics where based on - the toys.

thats not exactly correct either.

the film did feature characters with the names Optimus Prime,Megatron,Bumblebee,Starscream and so many more.The toys didnt have character names before the comic book publishers got involved.

Tghe toys themselfs didnt have any fiction/story before Marvel so its fair to say the Bayfilms are based on the comics.

sto_vo_kor_2000 wrote:

Dead Metal wrote:Plus the movies aren'T based on the comic books, they are based on the same thing the comics where based on - the toys.

thats not exactly correct either.

the film did feature characters with the names Optimus Prime,Megatron,Bumblebee,Starscream and so many more.The toys didnt have character names before the comic book publishers got involved.

Tghe toys themselfs didnt have any fiction/story before Marvel so its fair to say the Bayfilms are based on the comics.

Sorry, I told you before I won't get into an arguement with you anymore.

Dead Metal wrote:Sorry, I told you before I won't get into an arguement with you anymore.

I dont recall you ever telling me such a thing.

But thats kool, theres no need to argue here.No mater how you cut it,fair to say the Bayfilms are based on the comics.

Yea, they're not worth anything really because to be honest I would assume that most of the comics are still "surviving". Most of the worth comes at the end of the print run and those aren't terribly expensive (~10-20 non-CGC in excellent condition). The reason is that no one wanted them at the time since the series was more or less dying off and therefore fewer were printed. I think I put my whole 1-80 series together from nothing for under 200 total (182 i think to be precise and I have several duplicates).

Not to rehash, but early comics have a worth because they were often thrown away and there was no collector's market for them. Also, they set the tone for comic art and storytelling. Much of the TF artwork wasn't very high quality comparatively (depending on the artist working on the particular issue that did change). To be frank, Modern age (post-1982, but now often referred to as the Copper age -1982-1992ish) comics were typified by the anti-heroes, which TF is not a part of.

The only original art pages that go for any money are from the first several issues with key characters / scenes / first appearances. Otherwise, they're running about $100 or less, generally. The only stuff that really held the worth are the toys because kids opened them and beat the crap out of them, meaning they were "destroyed" in a sense.

Rarity + demand = price and printing "limited series" at the top didn't help the rarity, I can assure you. The only comics that go for significant money are those that have been CGC rated to 9.8+ because those are technically rare.

Basically, your comics are worth something CGC'd but not open, though even CGC'd, they may not be all that desirable due to the quantity of comics out there and the quality.

Also, yes the comics were based on the figures, but the comics and animated series contributed to the mythos surrounding the comics. Ultimately the purpose was to sell Hasbro product (since they do own TF and all). The current movie is EXTREMELY loosely based on comics for the sake of the naming of the bots and factions, but the back stories might as well be night and day. In fact, IDW invented a "movie-verse" to go along with them to keep it separated from their continuities (thank goodness).