| Re: New toy law to adversely affect collectors market? (862582) Posted by It Is Him on January 7th, 2009 @ 6:43am CST I don't expect the law to affect Ebay sales between collectors. | |
| Re: New toy law to adversely affect collectors market? (862585) Posted by King of Terror on January 7th, 2009 @ 6:47am CST Dude, the law is broad enough that eBay could litterarrly see many of their toy auctions disappear overnight come Feb 10th | |
| Re: New toy law to adversely affect collectors market? (862600) Posted by Energon on January 7th, 2009 @ 7:12am CST Then just re-list them as an adult collectable. | |
| Re: New toy law to adversely affect collectors market? (862605) Posted by Chaoslock on January 7th, 2009 @ 7:35am CST
That was what I was thinking... still, is it possible to go around the law that way? And if not, what will be the reaction of online TF sellers as BBTS, or others? And how will this influence orders in and out of the US? | |
| Re: New toy law to adversely affect collectors market? (862606) Posted by Sledge on January 7th, 2009 @ 7:38am CST Sounds like this would be a good time for those of you across the pond to start harrassing your local politicians. | |
| Re: New toy law to adversely affect collectors market? (862631) Posted by Energon on January 7th, 2009 @ 8:38am CST
Online retailers would probably not be as affected as toy conventions where any age person can purchase items. BBTS is large and sells tons of new products, their resale market is small comparatively. The law states "toys used by children under 12". I think all on-line retailers need to do is put a disclaimer that the item is not for children under 12. | |
| Re: New toy law to adversely affect collectors market? (862634) Posted by King of Terror on January 7th, 2009 @ 8:42am CST
But what defines "adult collectible"? Out of the box where it will have no "For ages X+" I do understand this will be hard to enforce. But who is to say ebay will fold fast and pull everything they think will be affected by this? This will slap more people in the face then this law wants to and might get changed or pulled before Feb 10th any way. | |
| Re: New toy law to adversely affect collectors market? (862665) Posted by TheMuffin on January 7th, 2009 @ 9:43am CST You know, I'm looking for some other place to have this info, but I can't find it on CNN, MSNBC, Yahoo etc. Anyone wanna help me out? | |
| Re: New toy law to adversely affect collectors market? (862677) Posted by Dead Metal on January 7th, 2009 @ 9:59am CST There is nothing else to add to this stupidity. | |
| Re: New toy law to adversely affect collectors market? (862679) Posted by Prime's Trailer on January 7th, 2009 @ 10:00am CST Another fantastically pointless law from the control obsessed state. That is really going to screw over us collectors and parents who rely on ebays bargain toy prices at christmas. I'm sure it won't be long before the UK follows suit. Instead trying to properly regulate serious problems such as international and homegrown terrorism, our governments target law-abiding citizens and, at most, low-level crime. Rant over. | |
| Re: New toy law to adversely affect collectors market? (862682) Posted by Cyber Bishop on January 7th, 2009 @ 10:04am CST For the lazy.
Shame that all this is from those toys being recalled due to the lead issues. | |
| Re: New toy law to adversely affect collectors market? (862687) Posted by Kique on January 7th, 2009 @ 10:22am CST
I second that ! | |
| Re: New toy law to adversely affect collectors market? (862748) Posted by DISCHARGE on January 7th, 2009 @ 12:34pm CST You know, this is completely obsurd! With the state of the current economy they are going to destroy even more peoples income. I just lost my job, day after x-mas nonetheless, and now am resorting to selling portions of my collection until I can find another place to work. This gov is getting out of control in telling us what we can/can't do, and I'm getting fed up. They are supposed to work for us, not the other way around. One minute they want us to recycle the next they tell us not too. That's just what selling used clothing and toys is, recycling. Does this mean that places like Goodwill and Salvation Army, not forgetting all the resale/thrift store, will have nothing to offer except used silverware and tvs that won't work without a converter box? This law is trash and the politicians that pushed it through should have looked beyond their manicured estates and taken a drive down skid row. All those people rely on used goods to get by. Out-of-control! | |
| Re: New toy law to adversely affect collectors market? (862773) Posted by King of Terror on January 7th, 2009 @ 1:29pm CST
The law making don't know the coats that the smaller companies will have to take on to make sure everything "has nothing that will hurt anything" in it. They don't mean to get angry letters from moms how just caught their kid licking a toy that had lead in it and now they are mildly retarded. But hey lets make sure this fine nation can make sure the little guy has no leg to stand on. | |
| Re: New toy law to adversely affect collectors market? (862777) Posted by Dead Metal on January 7th, 2009 @ 1:35pm CST
![]() | |
| Re: New toy law to adversely affect collectors market? (862780) Posted by Energon on January 7th, 2009 @ 1:39pm CST Here is one link that I found related, I am sure from here if someone wants to spend the time they can find the original source. http://www.cpsc.gov/library/foia/advisory/322.pdf | |
| Re: New toy law to adversely affect collectors market? (862821) Posted by Mkall on January 7th, 2009 @ 2:33pm CST I wonder if this explains BBTS's recent warning?
| |
| Re: New toy law to adversely affect collectors market? (862836) Posted by nemesis-prime on January 7th, 2009 @ 2:52pm CST
I rember having a voltron toy taken away from me when i was 7 because of the lead paint. That was 1987. | |
| Re: New toy law to adversely affect collectors market? (862837) Posted by nemesis-prime on January 7th, 2009 @ 2:55pm CST
It must ill have to start outting a warning on my ebay auctions. Screw u Gov-ment they are prolly still pissed they cant tax eBay sellers unless they have a business and tax liscence. | |
| Re: New toy law to adversely affect collectors market? (862859) Posted by Symbiote Spiderman14 on January 7th, 2009 @ 3:33pm CST More info on it but it is very confusing http://www.latimes.com/business/la-fi-t ... 3247.story http://www.govtrack.us/congress/billtex ... =h110-4040 | |
| Re: New toy law to adversely affect collectors market? (862863) Posted by nemesis-prime on January 7th, 2009 @ 3:42pm CST
yes very confusing still gonna sell my stuff on eBay screw them | |
| Re: New toy law to adversely affect collectors market? (862877) Posted by Agent 007 on January 7th, 2009 @ 4:05pm CST lame, now quick we gotta form a tf underground railroad! | |
| Re: New toy law to adversely affect collectors market? (862881) Posted by El Duque on January 7th, 2009 @ 4:09pm CST
You beat me to it, but I was thinking the same thing. I bet this has something to do with this new law. | |
| Re: New toy law to adversely affect collectors market? (862882) Posted by nightbolt on January 7th, 2009 @ 4:09pm CST the link you provided doesnt lead to the topic at hand. the government has failed the economy again! | |
| Re: New toy law to adversely affect collectors market? (862895) Posted by Kaiser Convoy on January 7th, 2009 @ 4:21pm CST i really have no clue about the US legal system and why stuff like this happens, hell i have no clue about the UK legal system, but thats because they are even more retarded over here and listen to the 3% of the population that sits on their arses and do nothing but whine about almost everything that isn't done in a certain way, hell they whine if you sneeze in the wrong direction. anyroad, i hate to be a killjoy, but i had toys with lead paint in them, i handled and worked with lead metal miniatures (games workshop) and i've had nothing serioulsy detrimental happen to me. i stuck toys in my mouth when i was a kid, held onto them with my teeth whilst getting something else, and i;ve not had anything happen to me. personally it not the fault of the parents, its more down to the media and the manufacturers. the media for all the bloody scaremongering that they do when something "catastrophic" or "harmful" happens, and the manufacturers for not holding tighter QC on their overseas factories | |
| Re: New toy law to adversely affect collectors market? (862924) Posted by nemesis-prime on January 7th, 2009 @ 4:44pm CST
| |
| Re: New toy law to adversely affect collectors market? (862931) Posted by Kaiser Convoy on January 7th, 2009 @ 4:53pm CST
was that what you meant to write?? lol | |
| Re: New toy law to adversely affect collectors market? (862938) Posted by i_amtrunks on January 7th, 2009 @ 5:01pm CST
If it is, it means BBTS think that they might get sued by parents if the toys are tested later. Funny usually laws like this are made to give the public a sense of feeling that their government is doing something to help and protect them, but its all for show and they never follow through with it and enforce it. The only thing to come from unenforceable laws like this are law suits... | |
| Re: New toy law to adversely affect collectors market? (862942) Posted by Kaiser Convoy on January 7th, 2009 @ 5:06pm CST which means someone gets hurt and another walks away with a huge wad of cash and their face in the paper for a few weeks - but bragging rights that get overused | |
| Re: New toy law to adversely affect collectors market? (862947) Posted by nemesis-prime on January 7th, 2009 @ 5:16pm CST
yes i was just stating stuff gets shipped anyway no matter way, suppliers arnt just gonna throw away inventory | |
| Re: New toy law to adversely affect collectors market? (863071) Posted by Mkall on January 7th, 2009 @ 9:01pm CST Found this little tidbit sorting through the law: http://www.govtrack.us/congress/billtex ... =h110-4040
So it looks like second-hand merchandise may not be banned, but the government will see to their "education" whatever that means. Also it looks like if you're only selling stuff on ebay unaffiliated with a business, you should be all right. Unless you're selling stuff that's suposed to have been recalled. I think | |
| Re: New toy law to adversely affect collectors market? (863096) Posted by Nekoman on January 7th, 2009 @ 10:43pm CST FP&C'ed | |
| Re: New toy law to adversely affect collectors market? (863103) Posted by Orion_Prime48 on January 7th, 2009 @ 11:11pm CST wow they are goin outta the way to make new laws anymore arent they....... that is smart in a way to prevent lead poisoning but cmon | |
| Re: New toy law to adversely affect collectors market? (863109) Posted by Shadowstream on January 7th, 2009 @ 11:44pm CST It's times like this I wish I could point out everything wrong with humanity in general, but that would take years. | |
| Re: New toy law to adversely affect collectors market? (863111) Posted by Bumblebeast on January 7th, 2009 @ 11:51pm CST I'm surprised that there are still toys with lead in them. | |
| Re: New toy law to adversely affect collectors market? (863113) Posted by Serpent O - R on January 7th, 2009 @ 11:55pm CST
We can start with H-O-S Optimus Prime... ok, not that funny, but still. This is retarded [no offense intended]. All this is is a way to generate more revenue for the american government and its patron saints, the lobbyists. | |
| Re: New toy law to adversely affect collectors market? (863121) Posted by nemesis-prime on January 8th, 2009 @ 12:32am CST This will only make someone put some "LEAD" in some government ass. LOL | |
| Re: New toy law to adversely affect collectors market? (863122) Posted by CollectionTF on January 8th, 2009 @ 12:33am CST It's not going to affect us as a collector. Plus BBTS was thier every product has a safety warning that says "not suitable for children under 16 years of age." I mean so what, the toy has be tested, big deal. It has happened before. | |
| Re: New toy law to adversely affect collectors market? (863125) Posted by First-Aid on January 8th, 2009 @ 12:43am CST It's very interesting to see how the US works anymore. This is supposedly a democracy (or a representative republic, according to the Constitution) in which the majority should rule. However, what we are finding more and more is that it is not the majority that rules, but the MINORITY. One example: several states put up votes on gay marriage...which to me is really a non-issue, but the governments felt that the people should choose. The people voted and the majority ruled in those cases. However, the MINORITY proceeded to get the law changed in their favor or altered DESPITE the majority vote. Now I am using this only as an example; gay rights, like I said, are a non-issue for me...6 of one, half dozen of the other as far as I'm concerned. I don't want to get in the middle of it. This lead paint thing is another of these situations where a SMALL minority of the toys used these paints. I'm all for safety but is anyone really aware 1) how much lead it takes to have an adverse affect on a human being and 2) how relatively LITTLE exposure this is? There are ZERO news reports about kids being affected by this...just that lead was found in the paint! This would be another case where, if properly researched numbers were to come out to the public and they were allowed to actually vote on it, the majority would vote the law down...and then it would promptly be overturned by the minority. Pathetic, really. This could conceivably be a MAJOR economic blow, especially to people who sell these for a living (and it is a major market). THe small business lobbies have to be spinning in their seats right now. | |
| Re: New toy law to adversely affect collectors market? (863132) Posted by Savage on January 8th, 2009 @ 1:44am CST This is sad. Why target the sellers and consumers? We don't need this law, we need reliable and thorough quality control in the manufacturing process. | |
| Re: New toy law to adversely affect collectors market? (863149) Posted by Stormrider on January 8th, 2009 @ 2:53am CST
I tend to agree. I think the U.S. Government is going to cave on this law and requirements for resellers, the same way they are caving right now on the terms they setup for retailers with toys and clothes. The terminology is too broad and unenforceable. They are also too costly and prohibitive. Can you imagine how many laboratories there need to be in order test all the potential clothes and toys in the U.S. for each reseller? There would be a back log of testing for months and months. I don't see them going after small resellers. In fact, the terms above state that most eBay sellers are excluded from the term "reseller". However, with all of that said, I wouldn't put it past eBay to come up with some new ridiculous rule that makes it difficult to sell toys. | |
| Re: New toy law to adversely affect collectors market? (863160) Posted by Ravage XK on January 8th, 2009 @ 4:37am CST Its all a bit daft. If we are talking G1 toys containing lead and I dont know if they do or not. These a mostly sold/bought by collectors and I dont know many collectors that would hunt down a G1 Smokescreen just so he could give it a good lick. | |
| Re: New toy law to adversely affect collectors market? (863197) Posted by Counterpunch on January 8th, 2009 @ 7:17am CST Laws have to be enforcable. This will never fly. You guys are too jumpy. ::kicks dirt at reactive legislation:: | |
| Re: New toy law to adversely affect collectors market? (863230) Posted by Optimist_Prime on January 8th, 2009 @ 8:34am CST They want to enforce this with flee markets and yard sales? Hey, all the more luck to 'em | |
| Re: New toy law to adversely affect collectors market? (863240) Posted by Zeds on January 8th, 2009 @ 9:00am CST Glad I sold off the majority of my collection on eBay already. This is stupid. I would just start posting on eBay CANADA to get around the issue, but US customs may confiscate the parcel once it tries to cross the border once inspected. I really think the US government has more pressing issues than this to deal with don't you? | |
| Re: New toy law to adversely affect collectors market? (863248) Posted by Counterpunch on January 8th, 2009 @ 9:14am CST
| |
| Re: New toy law to adversely affect collectors market? (863249) Posted by insanityzmaster on January 8th, 2009 @ 9:18am CST Yeah you would think in a day and age when we have starvation and poverty and all kinds of wars and crazy crap happening that the govt would worry a lil less that (insert name) is trying to eek out a meager existence by selling old stuff at a flea market or in his eBay store seriously wtf!!! | |
| Re: New toy law to adversely affect collectors market? (863270) Posted by nemesis-prime on January 8th, 2009 @ 10:35am CST well im gonna sell stuff untill i get some kind of notice to stop, i might have to stop shipping to canada thou | |
| Re: New toy law to adversely affect collectors market? (863275) Posted by DMSL on January 8th, 2009 @ 10:51am CST DOn't they have anything better to do than to come up with stupid restrictions like this? I understand the part about lead in new toys, but come on. | |
| Re: New toy law to adversely affect collectors market? (863278) Posted by Sunstar on January 8th, 2009 @ 11:09am CST holy cripes... ugh... | |
| Click here to view an additional 27 comments about this topic at the Energon Pub Forums ... | |