Seibertron.com Energon Pub Forums

[ScottyP]

The Death of Optimus Prime, which ushered in what has arguably been the best long-form run of Transformers comics in history

I liked your review very much, but with this opinion I disagree wholeheartedly.

You disagree that the 2012-summer 2016 IDW run is arguably the best long-form, cohesive story run of Transformers comics ever? Does that mean you agree that it is? Or that it is not and this is inarguable? The words of my sentence in the review express that this is one opinion some have that others do not, and those that prefer another run over this one would have valid points to argue, hence use of the word "arguably".

I re-worded that sentence about 8 times last Tuesday night. Guess it still missed the mark.

On a different note:

The Necrobot's planet. Apparently the die from which Cybertron was cast (Optimus Primal: "It's a lost art").

That raises a lot of questions in terms of Cybertron's creation. Was it really Primus? Or is Roberts taking some cues from his own fan novel and trying to bridge the gap between the cartoon and comic creation myths?

Were the planets Skids saw on the other side of Tyrest's portal exact copies of Cybertron?

We're on the same heading here. Here's my insane, not-rooted-in-evidence-and-more-speculation-than-anything theory about all of that: the planets that Skids saw in issue 21 are the Knights of Cybertron, bound into planetoid forms. They were trying to express to Skids what was going on and how to help, but he ended up having to go back to the other side of the portal to help a certain bot from being destroyed...

As for Nightbeat he's been "dead" already so--. But Rung??? How can the universe go on without the historical constant???

All we really know is that something apparently quite bad would happen:

[Kurona]

While browsing through TFWiki again I remembered something that somehow makes this issue all the more painful

[Rodimus Prime]

The Death of Optimus Prime, which ushered in what has arguably been the best long-form run of Transformers comics in history

I liked your review very much, but with this opinion I disagree wholeheartedly.

You disagree that the 2012-summer 2016 IDW run is arguably the best long-form, cohesive story run of Transformers comics ever? Does that mean you agree that it is? Or that it is not and this is inarguable? The words of my sentence in the review express that this is one opinion some have that others do not, and those that prefer another run over this one would have valid points to argue, hence use of the word "arguably".

I re-worded that sentence about 8 times last Tuesday night. Guess it still missed the mark.

OK, maybe I misunderstood. I don't think it is the best run of TF comics ever, though it's in the top 3. The Marvel U.S. G1 comics will always be better to me than anything else that has come along so far. MTMTE is quite good, though. It got me back into reading comics after I haven't kept up with them for 7 years.

[ArmadaPrime]

On a different note:

The Necrobot's planet. Apparently the die from which Cybertron was cast (Optimus Primal: "It's a lost art").

That raises a lot of questions in terms of Cybertron's creation. Was it really Primus? Or is Roberts taking some cues from his own fan novel and trying to bridge the gap between the cartoon and comic creation myths?

Were the planets Skids saw on the other side of Tyrest's portal exact copies of Cybertron?

We're on the same heading here. Here's my insane, not-rooted-in-evidence-and-more-speculation-than-anything theory about all of that: the planets that Skids saw in issue 21 are the Knights of Cybertron, bound into planetoid forms. They were trying to express to Skids what was going on and how to help, but he ended up having to go back to the other side of the portal to help a certain bot from being destroyed...

Ooooohh, gonna bounce off this idea
I'd have to take another look at the scenes on the other side of the portal to check the number and colour of the planets, but what if they were the rest of the guiding hand? Supposedly the hand became vector sigma, the matrix, and the first t-cog and brain module (with mortilus having been destroyed), but in a lot of fiction primus and cybertron are considered essentially one and the same, so if there's further copies of cybertron, perhaps that's where the sparks of the hand could be...?
EDIT: a couple images for reference

[ScottyP]

On a different note:

The Necrobot's planet. Apparently the die from which Cybertron was cast (Optimus Primal: "It's a lost art").

That raises a lot of questions in terms of Cybertron's creation. Was it really Primus? Or is Roberts taking some cues from his own fan novel and trying to bridge the gap between the cartoon and comic creation myths?

Were the planets Skids saw on the other side of Tyrest's portal exact copies of Cybertron?

We're on the same heading here. Here's my insane, not-rooted-in-evidence-and-more-speculation-than-anything theory about all of that: the planets that Skids saw in issue 21 are the Knights of Cybertron, bound into planetoid forms. They were trying to express to Skids what was going on and how to help, but he ended up having to go back to the other side of the portal to help a certain bot from being destroyed...

Ooooohh, gonna bounce off this idea
I'd have to take another look at the scenes on the other side of the portal to check the number and colour of the planets, but what if they were the rest of the guiding hand? Supposedly the hand became vector sigma, the matrix, and the first t-cog and brain module (with mortilus having been destroyed), but in a lot of fiction primus and cybertron are considered essentially one and the same, so if there's further copies of cybertron, perhaps that's where the sparks of the hand could be...?
EDIT: a couple images for reference

This post makes me very happy - these are the exact panels I'd looked up!

[Kurona]

... is it just me or does Primus in that image look like Pyra Magna?

[Ironhidensh]

So, Ive had some time to process. I went back, and re-read MTMTE from the point Megatron joined up till 55. I've sat and thought about it, and I think I'm done with this title for a while.

Now, before anyone jumps up and down screaming "troll", or even worse "1984", I fully acknowledge that a lot of my ill feeling comes from personal bias. I didn't like how the story went, therefore I'm not enjoying it. If I'm not enjoying something, I'm not going to keep paying for it. I don't buy into "support it in case it gets better". To much capitalism in me. Anyway, I'll explain a bit better, but let me say I also don't blame the creators of the book, I blame Hasbro. The stories and conclusions feel rushed, and its because Hasbro is forcing the Titans Return crossover. I know IDW and several of the comic writers and artists have said Hasbro doesn't have that kind of influence, but I firmly believe they are just protecting their jobs. I don't blame them, paychecks are important. However, Hasbro is a major corporation, and all major corporations are all about the control. Hasbro is forcing the comic to align with the sales plan, and its destroying the enjoy ability of the book for me. Anyway.

MTMTE got me back into comics after about a ten year hiatus from reading them. I used to be an avid comic book nerd, but during the original Civil War event, I got tired of them. I got tired of storylines being set up, characters being built up, and big events, reveals, and excitement promised, only for it all to end with little or no payout, simply because it was time to move on to the next big event.

That's what I feel happened this issue. All of the set up was tossed out the window simply because its time for the next big event. Tarn is Glitch? What. The. Actual. ****. For me, its simply not acceptable. I know some of you feel that Tarn being a nobody makes sense, but it was never built up that way, and feels like the biggest of copouts. Deathsaurus was built up as this Decepticon with a conscience, but his big moment was to simply run away.

Hey look! Its Overlord! Hey look! There he goes.....doing nothing....


At the end of the day, this issue, or maybe even this whole storyline, had reminded me of everything that made me quit comics in the first place.

[SW's SilverHammer]

It'd be great for "Lost Light" to pick up with the functionalist universe then transition back to the main story line

[ScottyP]

Now, before anyone jumps up and down screaming "troll", or even worse "1984", I fully acknowledge that a lot of my ill feeling comes from personal bias.

You know what though? We don't hold the same opinions about the book, but you have an honest one, so don't feel ashamed at all to hold it! Not to say you do, but in stating your opinion with a detailed explanation and reason there's no worry about being labeled a troll

Just do let us talk you in to coming back to give things a chance sometime after Lost Light gets going (if Revolution doesn't ruin everything forever.)

[Va'al]

The pitch/outline for MTMTE season 2, from James Roberts to IDW.

http://www.twitlonger.com/show/n_1sov6bs

[Kurona]

The pitch/outline for MTMTE season 2, from James Roberts to IDW.

http://www.twitlonger.com/show/n_1sov6bs

"... and one day they'll come back."

Well great, now I can only imagine Terminus in William Hartnell's voice

[D-Maximal_Primal]

Glitch, did not see that coming. Probably should have, but didn't.

Overall, it was a good story to me. Yes the reveal was really nothing special but how could it be? If they had used Glitch's birth name the reveal would have passed right over several people.

The time-displaced bots? nice touch, and in theory the Necrobot going back in time to save them could very well be the reason they disappeared in the first place (like rung in the bar fight).

Overall, decent and good, but not perfect, as has been stated. Definitely going to be better as a TPB to read. But I liked it. Just gotta wait almost 5 months before we get a resolution to the cliffhanger.

[snavej]

Not sure how a black hole connection helps to siphon antimatter. Black holes really SUCK but they don't give out much!

[Tyrannacon]

Kinda wondering what's next for Megatron from here. I do feel sad about certain Decepticons killed off though, but I'd rather Megatron live to be entirely honest since he's getting some nice character development I feel.

[Rodimus Prime]

Just gotta wait almost 5 months before we get a resolution to the cliffhanger.

Maybe I missed something. What are you talking about?

Also, do any of you think Soundwave might blame Megatron just a little for Ravage's death, and will want revenge?

[Va'al]

Just gotta wait almost 5 months before we get a resolution to the cliffhanger.

Maybe I missed something. What are you talking about?

Lost Light starts in December, so until then, it's unlikely we'll know what actually happened after that last page.

[D-Maximal_Primal]

Just gotta wait almost 5 months before we get a resolution to the cliffhanger.

Maybe I missed something. What are you talking about?

Also, do any of you think Soundwave might blame Megatron just a little for Ravage's death, and will want revenge?

I'm not so sure he will blame Megatron. Now that Soundwave is basically on the same level as the Autobots, I don't think he'll blame Megatron. But then again, who knows how a conversation between the 2 would go now, all things considered.

And like Va'al said, the next 2 issues are titans return with Fort Max and Red alert, then a break, than a single MTMTE Revolution title with the Scavengers, then December comes

[Va'al]

This hurts.



Source: https://twitter.com/Zoner233/status/764895097888440320

[ZeroWolf]

That is very beautiful

[Rodimus Prime]

This hurts.



Source: https://twitter.com/Zoner233/status/764895097888440320

Why? I mean, it's very nice art, but what's the significance?

[Va'al]

This hurts.



Source: https://twitter.com/Zoner233/status/764895097888440320

Why? I mean, it's very nice art, but what's the significance?

The title of the piece is 'Skids and Nautica'. That's Skids' blue flower.

[MemphisR56]

Damnit Va'al.

[D-Maximal_Primal]

That is a pretty work of art. So sad as well

[Va'al]

We did a thing that you both read and listen to.
Both of those things can be done here: http://www.seibertron.com/transformers/ ... men/36133/

Enjoy!

[MemphisR56]

Here's an interesting log on the fire:

There's 2 rungs. One MIA from the alternate lost light, possibly dead.
There potentially exists one of him dead in his alt mode already, not dismantled.

In addition. Rodimus's half of the Matrix, which was destroyed during the events of 'the dying of the light' was also duplicated, and remains MIA. So the full matrix itself is not gone for good.



I wonder how many of these little loose ends there exists because of the the quantum explosion.