Seibertron.com Energon Pub Forums

Emerje wrote:Seems to be the new direction they're dedicated to. We just got animation accurate Ironhide, Hot Rod, and Shockwave. Makes sense that they'd want to revisit some older figures to make them less toy or real world accurate and more cartoon accurate.

I wonder if they're only interested in doing the cars or if we'll see larger figures like a Soundwave in a different shade of blue and with a light blue and yellow chest window? Or a gray and yellow Grimlock?

Emerje

Anyone can correct me if I'm wrong, but I'm pretty sure the only reason we even have "real world accurate" alt modes (ala Wheeljack) is to appease the companies they're licensing from. And since those would sell worse than the proper anime colors, they push them out first because people need their fix.

Sabrblade wrote:You guys know what kinda undermines the aim of this toy (and the whole MP line itself) being more show-accurate? The fact that, thanks to a discovery made by the Wiki, there were episodes of the cartoon that were done by a studio or studios that weren't Toei or AKOM, in which outdated animation models for several season 2 characters (Red Alert included) were used, giving them a slightly different appearance in those episodes from how they looked in other episodes.

Red Alert in particular was colored bright white (like his normal MP-14 toy) in these episodes instead of gray-white (like this new MP-14+ toy), and had a much softer, less detailed looking face and helmet. Here's a comparison of his two designs (along with those of Astrotrain) from one of these episodes and a Toei-produced episode:



More details about the animation model differences of the characters in these episodes compared to those made by Toei and AKOM can be found in the above link.

I didn't know it was a discovery, it was always clear to me from watching the show. Even within TOEI there were different art styles. I think that's part of the beauty of hand-drawn animation VS cg models that look exactly the same in every episode.

Emerje wrote:Seems to be the new direction they're dedicated to. We just got animation accurate Ironhide, Hot Rod, and Shockwave. Makes sense that they'd want to revisit some older figures to make them less toy or real world accurate and more cartoon accurate.

I wonder if they're only interested in doing the cars or if we'll see larger figures like a Soundwave in a different shade of blue and with a light blue and yellow chest window? Or a gray and yellow Grimlock?

Emerje

But Ironhide is also real-world accurate as a car. And Hot Rod & Shockwave don't have real alt-modes.

shajaki wrote:Anyone can correct me if I'm wrong, but I'm pretty sure the only reason we even have "real world accurate" alt modes (ala Wheeljack) is to appease the companies they're licensing from. And since those would sell worse than the proper anime colors, they push them out first because people need their fix.

Nah, man, the real-world car aspect is part of the vision --

From an interview with Shogo Hasui:

MP is the most prestigious series and it is often seen as the series for the main characters, but we released those sub-characters last year. They did not appear in the cartoon very often and may not make the top 10 popular character list, but their vehicle mode is Lamborghini Countach and I thought it might appeal to the generations that Super Cars were the craze in their childhood. For MPs, the most important precondition is the faithful re-creation of cartoon robot and alternate modes, and we obtained the official license from Lamborghini and went ahead with the development.

Cyberpath wrote:

shajaki wrote:Anyone can correct me if I'm wrong, but I'm pretty sure the only reason we even have "real world accurate" alt modes (ala Wheeljack) is to appease the companies they're licensing from. And since those would sell worse than the proper anime colors, they push them out first because people need their fix.

Nah, man, the real-world car aspect is part of the vision --

From an interview with Shogo Hasui:

MP is the most prestigious series and it is often seen as the series for the main characters, but we released those sub-characters last year. They did not appear in the cartoon very often and may not make the top 10 popular character list, but their vehicle mode is Lamborghini Countach and I thought it might appeal to the generations that Super Cars were the craze in their childhood. For MPs, the most important precondition is the faithful re-creation of cartoon robot and alternate modes, and we obtained the official license from Lamborghini and went ahead with the development.

I dont know man, that quote seems to confirm what Shajaki said. Because the alt modes are not faithful to the show but more to the real life car, which is an official license. He doesnt say in there that the point of MPs is to have a car mode that looks like real life. He says the opposite but that isnt reflected in the final product.

How do you feel about MPs now?
H: "I created them in the hope that they would supplement the memories. The toys in the 80s are not even close to the modern toys in terms of refinement, but I think the fans who followed Transformers back then used information obtained through various media such as magazines or the cartoon to supplement the image in their mind.
I believe MPs are meant to be the embodiment of that image. Neither making the cartoon version into a three dimensional form nor making it as realistic as possible is a good idea. The important thing for me has been to create a MP product through which you can meet yourself from the past, in which you can find a toy you have been dreaming of. It was certainly a difficult and harsh challenge.
I made a list of candidates (to be made into a MP figure) and I thoroughly checked what they did in which episodes and with whom. I referred to the list when planning the MP lineup. I also studied the impressive parts of the original toy’s transformation process to see if they could be incorporated into the new toy, and extensively collected cartoon reference materials and comic book illustrations. The MP series was always highly anticipated by the fans and I myself desired to create a better product – I suppose those factors worked out positively in me."

This is from hasui in a interview.

william-james88 wrote:I dont know man, that quote seems to confirm what Shajaki said. Because the alt modes are not faithful to the show but more to the real life car, which is an official license. He doesnt say in there that the point of MPs is to have a car mode that looks like real life. He says the opposite but that isnt reflected in the final product.

I disagree. Hasui said that before he came on board the MP line focused on main charhcters (Prime, Megatron Starscream,Grimlock..) And when he took over he decided to include lesser used characters like Sideswipe because of the appeal of their flashy alt-mode (Lamborghini Countach.)

There's also this piece from an interview with Kobsyashi:

Thanks to the fans' support, the current MP series is very popular right now. I hope the addition of Ultra Magnus as the centric character to the real car series will make the whole lineup more enjoyable.
The factors of the current popularity are the re-creation of the cartoon characters and the use of real cars, of course, and I'd like to explore the next step up while keeping those important factors intact.

What, seriously? We need new MP's not repainted ones that don't even look any better.

You can't really please people.

MP-10 wasn't anime accurate but more or less an amalgamation of both original Diaclone and the show and DW styles. The TT version was in toy colors while the Hb version was in the anime's colors. So what's the biggie with this release?

Maybe some just want the "real world" style release over this new presentation? There's an answer for that, buy the old version in the 2ndary market or simply wait for the 3rd re-issue.

If TT just did that, release the original again for the upteenth time some will complain about TT being lazy and over milking the mold which they already have btw.

Emerje wrote:

Cyberpath wrote:

Emerje wrote:Seems to be the new direction they're dedicated to. We just got animation accurate Ironhide, Hot Rod, and Shockwave. Makes sense that they'd want to revisit some older figures to make them less toy or real world accurate and more cartoon accurate.

I wonder if they're only interested in doing the cars or if we'll see larger figures like a Soundwave in a different shade of blue and with a light blue and yellow chest window? Or a gray and yellow Grimlock?

Emerje

But Ironhide is also real-world accurate as a car. And Hot Rod & Shockwave don't have real alt-modes.

I was mainly talking about Ironhide's bot mode which is as close to cartoon accurate as they could get with the "realistic" van mode. For the other two they could have easily made Hot Rod rust red with arrows on his shins and Shockwave dark purple like their toys, but they didn't, they went for animation accuracy right away instead which is a departure from how a lot of figures in this line have been done.

Emerje

The extra decal designs is handled by 1st party franchised providers like Ocean Designs in the Asian market. The "arrows" you mentioned are optional and 100% certainty will be released (especially for the China market)

As for Shockwave, give TT a year or so and get to see the gray "Shackwave". He was also portrayed as such by StudioOx during their pre Earth modes.

[BW] Rainmaker wrote:What, seriously? We need new MP's not repainted ones that don't even look any better.

This is an easy way for Takara to build the necesasry funds to finance more MPs. Its not like we would get new MPs at that level of frequency anyway, it was 2 molds a year or something like that. Things havent changed except that now people have more options and other chances of getting toys they want.

I was very adamant in not getting that MP14 red thigh til this day and now it pays off. That MP14+ toon robot looks very pleasant to the eyes compare to MP14. He will be great standing next to my MP22 UM, MP29 Shocky, and soon MP30 Ratchet (maybe Hot Rod down the road).

Painting the headlight and removing the license brand decal are a step back. The S1/2 TF figures are suppose to mimic real car, they should've kept those decals and clear headlight. I understand it meant to be toon accurate, but certain aspect should be kept realistic in regard to the car brand decal and clear head light. If this was S3 characters, I would've given them the 2 thumb up with their approach. Thanks goodness I don't display them in their vehicle mode, otherwise, MP14+ may looks out of place compare to Hasui carbots.

In term of whom I want to be next after Red Alert, toon Wheeljack will be lovely!

william-james88 wrote:The biggest news of this listing though is that Takara has announced that this is the first of a whole new line of Masterpiece repaints which aims at achieving a more toon accurate deco. Who do you think is next? Who do you want the most in this style? Let us know!

All I know is I can't wait for MP-29+ Laserwave or MP-29T Laserwave or whatever they want to call a properly colored Shockwave instead of whatever was released last month that has to be one of the most difficult to photograph colors I've ever encountered.

New picture of MP-14+ from the Takara Tomy Mall with what looks like to be MP Inferno

今冬発売予定のマスターピースと名シーンを再現しよう!!

!! Trying to reproduce the Masterpiece and scenes scheduled to be released this winter

The text above the picture suggests that Inferno will be a winter release.

Discussion of the Inferno rumour to be had over here please!

*sigh* I'd be all over an "animation accurate" release of MP Red Alert IF they had just kept the Lamborghini details that the rest of the "Sideswipe and Friends" uses of the mold retained, and used the proper Autobot symbol, not the lazy Sunbow one. Yuck. As it is, I think I'm just going to stay with the regular MP-14 release.

xMXUx wrote:New picture of MP-14+ from the Takara Tomy Mall with what looks like to be MP Inferno

今冬発売予定のマスターピースと名シーンを再現しよう!!

!! Trying to reproduce the Masterpiece and scenes scheduled to be released this winter

The text above the picture suggests that Inferno will be a winter release.

Well I'm excited. I wondered when we'd get around to the Inferno/Grapple mold. Here's hoping Trailbreaker and Hoist aren't far behind. Grapple and Hoist are bros!

http://www.seibertron.com/transformers/ ... ece/36317/

shajaki wrote:

Dear Takara,

Nobody cares.

Love,
Cobotron

I actually kind of care.

This release (in addition to the price for the MP Seekers) was a major factor in why I stopped collecting MP figures.

I'm not certain where or how many times we will go back to do an "Anime color edition," but I do not want to find out. I'm ok with updates of retail figures, but not for ones that are supposed to be the "definitive version."

Counterpunch wrote:This release (in addition to the price for the MP Seekers) was a major factor in why I stopped collecting MP figures.

I'm not certain where or how many times we will go back to do an "Anime color edition," but I do not want to find out. I'm ok with updates of retail figures, but not for ones that are supposed to be the "definitive version."

I agree. And the worst part is that there isstill something off on this one as to where the doors end up compared to hs cartoon model. So like the seekers they could do more definitive editions later. Its somethign I feel when collecting 3p and another 3p company does something even better than the toy you just got (ie Appolyon) but at least that makese sense since they are all competiting with oneanother. But here its the same damn company. The only thing I hope out of this (and i may sound like a douche) is that the mold has not moved from China yet (as was the case with BB) and thus Lena will get the leftovers and I can finally get a red alert for cheap

But that aside, I totally get what you mean Counterpunch, this hobby can become very exhausting.

Counterpunch wrote:I'm ok with updates of retail figures, but not for ones that are supposed to be the "definitive version."

I disagree with the premise of this part, though the stance makes sense. I think that for Takara, an MP figure being a "definitive" version was a ship that sailed far away as soon as MP-10 and MP-11 happened. Like I said though, if for you to have a place for them in your collection, you feel they should be definitive, then it definitely makes sense to back away.

I would speculate that this Red Alert, and any other "plus" figures that come later, are a result of the current MP designer trying to add his cartoon accuracy touch onto toys originally designed as hybrids of various concepts and appearances of the character.

ScottyP wrote:

Counterpunch wrote:I'm ok with updates of retail figures, but not for ones that are supposed to be the "definitive version."

I disagree with the premise of this part, though the stance makes sense. I think that for Takara, an MP figure being a "definitive" version was a ship that sailed far away as soon as MP-10 and MP-11 happened.

Well, it's not like MP-1 and MP-3 were exactly the best attempts at resembling the G1 cartoon versions the first time around.

MP-1 was admitted by its designer, Hinonori Kobayashi, to having at first been based on the Mainframe CGI model of Optimus Prime seen sleeping aboard the Ark in Beast Wars before being reworked and refined to steer the design back towards resembling the G1 cartoon model, and MP-3, well, that one is pretty self-explanatory.