Seibertron.com Energon Pub Forums

[steals_your_goats]

Meh not a huge fan of beast wars so this is an easy pass. I agree with Will that this looks more like a generations figure than a masterpiece.

[wilcosu35]

They could have hidden the elbow hinges in ape mode better, but as for robot mode accuracy, i think he's pretty much perfect



I'd also say that the already released MP figures aren't perfectly accurate eiter, taking liberties in bot mode, alt mode, or both.
In that sense, Primal is just as much a Masterpiece as the other ones.

[megatronus]

They could have hidden the elbow hinges in ape mode better, but as for robot mode accuracy, i think he's pretty much perfect



I'd also say that the already released MP figures aren't perfectly accurate eiter, taking liberties in bot mode, alt mode, or both.
In that sense, Primal is just as much a Masterpiece as the other ones.

This all gets to the question of 'what's an MP?' or 'what characteristics define an MP?' or even 'what's the platonic ideal?'

For characters with licensed vehicle modes, the answer is easier - slavish vehicle modes, compromises in bot mode where needed. With Optimus Primal, the compromise is in the alt mode... which is a weird inversion of our normal expectations when it comes to Masterpiece figures.

Either way, I think it's way too early to pass judgment on this one.

[Cobotron]

Early indeed.

First reaction is, this cartoon accuracy rampage is driving me nuts. The ape mode looks bad. He's an animal, not a computer model from 1994. He should have fur! Not this smooth CG rendered finish.

The bot mode looks great though! I will anxiously await more information.

[D-Maximal_Primal]

I can hop onboard the Primal bandwagon. Nice looking render. Cannot wait to see some more stuff down the line!

[Hero Alpha]

He looks pretty good for an early render. The one shown at the toy show was just a statue not an actual working figure. Wonder how they will scale him? If he is kept in scale with the rest of the masterpiece figures then he would be about the same size as the LG-02 Primal figure. If thats the case then why make him in masterpiece as that, Gen. Rattrap and Rhinox are already fairly in scale with masterpiece. When Primal took Prime's spark and held it, he was about shin height to him.

[Munkky]

For an early render this doesn't look too bad. The gorilla does look a bit awkward, the feet were the first thing I noticed as off, but most of the Beast Wars toys had robot kibble showing somewhere so it doesn't bother me that much. This could very well be my first Masterpiece figure, I kind of hope it's around the same height as a Generations Voyager (something close to Combiner Wars Optimus/Motormaster, a little bit taller than Masterpiece Bumblebee would be perfect), but I get the feeling it will be closer in height to Masterpiece Prowl or Wheeljack.

[Hellscream9999]

Early indeed.

First reaction is, this cartoon accuracy rampage is driving me nuts. The ape mode looks bad. He's an animal, not a computer model from 1994. He should have fur! Not this smooth CG rendered finish.

The bot mode looks great though! I will anxiously await more information.

Why? That's what's driven me away from all of his releases thus far, is that the beast mode head never looked like the character I grew up loving... the MP line has always been about cartoon accuracy where needed, and where else would it be needed than in giving him his iconic cartoon head model. If you want a 'realistic' o/p get any of the standard releases, as they probably fit the bill better

[Sabrblade]

It looks like they're trying to make this toy's Beast Mode able to both realistically bend over on all fours (as Primal did in the show when he wanted to walk or run) and unrealistically stand upright (as Primal also did in the show went he was just standing around).

[Hellscream9999]

It looks like they're trying to make this toy's Beast Mode able to both realistically bend over on all fours (as Primal did in the show when he wanted to walk or run) and unrealistically stand upright (as Primal also did in the show went he was just standing around).

Just like they did for rattrap; which is fair, as that's how they spent the bulk of their time in beast mode; imagine if they tried to do terrorsaur, what an engineering mess he would yield

[Cobotron]

Early indeed.

First reaction is, this cartoon accuracy rampage is driving me nuts. The ape mode looks bad. He's an animal, not a computer model from 1994. He should have fur! Not this smooth CG rendered finish.

The bot mode looks great though! I will anxiously await more information.

Why? That's what's driven me away from all of his releases thus far, is that the beast mode head never looked like the character I grew up loving... the MP line has always been about cartoon accuracy where needed, and where else would it be needed than in giving him his iconic cartoon head model. If you want a 'realistic' o/p get any of the standard releases, as they probably fit the bill better

I "grew up" ( ) loving the toy more than the show model. One of my all time favorite toys I've ever owned. That's just me. I get the whole Toon Acc thing, but I feel like Masterpiece should mean a better toy than it's predecessors. IMO a better toy would mean a more realistic beast mode. Not a gorilla with an inter tube stretched over his bones.
Maybe this rendering hasn't hit the texturing phase. I don't know. Plus I don't mind that his sculpt looks like the cartoon. I just think he needs some depth.

Trust me. I REALLY want to love this thing. And so like I said, I will anxiously wait to see what happens and keep a positive outlook.

Oh, and congrats on your promotion Newsie!

[Hellscream9999]

Early indeed.

First reaction is, this cartoon accuracy rampage is driving me nuts. The ape mode looks bad. He's an animal, not a computer model from 1994. He should have fur! Not this smooth CG rendered finish.

The bot mode looks great though! I will anxiously await more information.

Why? That's what's driven me away from all of his releases thus far, is that the beast mode head never looked like the character I grew up loving... the MP line has always been about cartoon accuracy where needed, and where else would it be needed than in giving him his iconic cartoon head model. If you want a 'realistic' o/p get any of the standard releases, as they probably fit the bill better

I "grew up" ( ) loving the toy more than the show model. One of my all time favorite toys I've ever owned. That's just me. I get the whole Toon Acc thing, but I feel like Masterpiece should mean a better toy than it's predecessors. IMO a better toy would mean a more realistic beast mode. Not a gorilla with an inter tube stretched over his bones.
Maybe this rendering hasn't hit the texturing phase. I don't know. Plus I don't mind that his sculpt looks like the cartoon. I just think he needs some depth.

Trust me. I REALLY want to love this thing. And so like I said, I will anxiously wait to see what happens and keep a positive outlook.

I mentioned this before, but they can't 'improve' the figure; he and megs were perfect (nearly in megs' case - need that hand); I never had a chance to gt o/p toy as a kid, so all I had was the show...

Besides, TT is being cartoon accurate, just as the mp line does, buttflaps, aprons, and all...

Wonder if he'll have a flip-up mouthplate

Oh, and congrats on your promotion Newsie!

Thanks I can edit posts now, this is amazing

[Cobotron]

he and megs were perfect

INDEED!

Besides, TT is being cartoon accurate, just as the mp line does, buttflaps, aprons, and all...

Yes. and it's starting to drive me away from the line. Just me, but I prefer toy accuracy over toon.

Wonder if he'll have a flip-up mouthplate

That would be DOPE! Did you notice the panels on his forearms? Maybe he has the weapons gimmicks. I would like that very much.

[Sabrblade]

Yeah, the engineering seems more like an update than really a Masterpiece figure. I dont see how RHinox is generations and this is an MP, aside from size.

Because Rhinox had a ton of things about his toy that were completely inaccurate to the cartoon model, chief among them being his beast mode looking more like a real rhinoceros than the more cartoony look of the CG model, along with several aspects of his robot mode being inaccurate to the CG model's robot mode.

Gen. Rattrap and Rhinox are already fairly in scale with masterpiece.

Aside from the original 1996 Ultra class Optimus Primal mold, Generations Rattrap is in scale with no one.

[Hellscream9999]

Besides, TT is being cartoon accurate, just as the mp line does, buttflaps, aprons, and all...

Yes. and it's starting to drive me away from the line. Just me, but I prefer toy accuracy over toon.

Well, just stick with the original, or any of the 10 updates TT has pushed out since then and you should be fine...

[Sabrblade]

In regards to texture/smoothness, the CGI model did have a furry texture:



It was just that his fur happened to always be extremely well-groomed.

[Cobotron]

Besides, TT is being cartoon accurate, just as the mp line does, buttflaps, aprons, and all...

Yes. and it's starting to drive me away from the line. Just me, but I prefer toy accuracy over toon.

Well, just stick with the original, or any of the 10 updates TT has pushed out since then and you should be fine...

The OG has been on my desk for the past week.

[hinomars19]

Early indeed.

First reaction is, this cartoon accuracy rampage is driving me nuts. The ape mode looks bad. He's an animal, not a computer model from 1994. He should have fur! Not this smooth CG rendered finish.

The bot mode looks great though! I will anxiously await more information.

The fur may be a manufacturing/ cost thing. It's a high end collectible yes, but still mass produced

[Hellscream9999]

In regards to texture/smoothness, the CGI model did have a furry texture:



It was just that his fur happened to always be extremely well-groomed.

That's a weak excuse, they could mold more fur on the mp figure, the show version only had that because of cg constraints...

[Hellscream9999]

Besides, TT is being cartoon accurate, just as the mp line does, buttflaps, aprons, and all...

Yes. and it's starting to drive me away from the line. Just me, but I prefer toy accuracy over toon.

Well, just stick with the original, or any of the 10 updates TT has pushed out since then and you should be fine...

The OG has been on my desk for the past week.

Lucky

[Cobotron]

In regards to texture/smoothness, the CGI model did have a furry texture:



It was just that his fur happened to always be extremely well-groomed.

Ya, I'm just hoping we see some on the toy. That's all.
What a handsome devil in that GQ pose.

[Sabrblade]

In regards to texture/smoothness, the CGI model did have a furry texture:



It was just that his fur happened to always be extremely well-groomed.

Ya, I'm just hoping we see some on the toy. That's all.
What a handsome devil in that GQ pose.

The smoothness seen on the magazine scan CG render is what makes it an unfinished render, much like this very early unfinished render from Mainframe:

[Cobotron]

The smoothness seen on the magazine scan CG render is what makes it an unfinished render, much like this very early unfinished render from Mainframe:

Ya, I mentioned that a few posts back. Fingers crossed.

For the record guys. I may be an "Old Timer", but I love Beast wars above all things TFs.
That's why I really really want this thing to knock my socks off!

[Hellscream9999]

The smoothness seen on the magazine scan CG render is what makes it an unfinished render, much like this very early unfinished render from Mainframe:

Ya, I mentioned that a few posts back. Fingers crossed.

For the record guys. I may be an "Old Timer", but I love Beast wars above all things TFs.
That's why I really really want this thing to knock my socks off!

If you can get past the head (I love, you kinda don't, but, we did need a figure to have an accurate head) I think this will blow you away once some of the features/accesories are revealed

[Sabrblade]

In regards to texture/smoothness, the CGI model did have a furry texture:



It was just that his fur happened to always be extremely well-groomed.

That's a weak excuse, they could mold more fur on the mp figure, the show version only had that because of cg constraints...

My point is that the show model did have fur and wasn't as solidly smooth-surfaced as this unfinished render looks.