HoosierDaddy wrote:The Chaos Bringer wrote:The Jedi order is all about beliefs and morals. It is a way of life that emphasizes peace and justice. A government run by self proclaimed "Jedi" would be one that avoids war at all costs;
But the Jedis did not avoid war at all costs. When negotiations fail, Jedis fight and *gasp* kill their enemies.
Not entirely. The Jedi (The plural of Jedi is Jedi) DID fight wars, and fought in just about every major conflict in the history of the Force. But it wasn't encouraged. The Council forbid fighting in the Mandalorian Wars. (Which, in turn, led to the Jedi Civil War)
And, as a rule, enemies are ONLY to be killed if the Jedi has no other choice. Otherwise, they're taken prisoner. (At the same time, the Jedi don't believe in Capital Punishment. Rogue Jedi and Sith are either detained indefinitely, or have their connection to the Force severed.
HoosierDaddy wrote: demands that criminals be brought to justice, but humanely;
By slicing said enemy in half with a lightsaber. Mace Winu was ready to kill Palpatine if Anakin hadn't intervened. Obi Wan cut off Anakins legs and left him by the lava on fire to die. Basically, I see that you are trying to say that war is avoidable and there are other ways to do things but even the most peaceful and reasonable beings in the universe, the Jedi, use war as a tactic. Evil is evil and it needs to be stopped at all costs.
Like I said, no other choice. Windu knew Sidious would manipulate anyone he needed to to win a trial. (Which is how the Clone Wars ended, and the Empire began)
HoosierDaddy wrote: demands that law enforcement not be so quick to pull the trigger and always try to negotiate; and would not let anyone out of prison without serious rehabilitation, due to the belief that it is nearly impossible to return to light after choosing a dark path (which is apparently true, since a staggering percentage of criminals continue to commit crimes after being released from jail.)
Even science fiction can be a respectable religion, but only if it is based on beliefs and morals. Scientology, is not. Don't waste any money on it.
This part I can agree on.

Me as well.