Page 1 of 1

What size would you like for a MP Galvatron, for 3rd party or HasTak.

PostPosted: Wed Dec 24, 2014 5:14 am
by Tsutsukakushi
Please lets not discuss classics desired scale, This is a MP discussion thread.

Wouldn't be opposed to a 3rd party or HasTak MP Galvatron being a head taller than MP-09 and MP-10. Reasoning, it's the upgrade Megatron, so it should be taller than X-T Appollon and a rumored HasTak MP Smaller scale Megatron. Plus it would be kinda cool to have a MP Galvatron the same height as MP-22 and MP-24.

As a last resort, I'd be willing to settle for a 3rd party or HasTak MP Galvatron toy The same robot height as MP-09.

Don't want any MP Galvatron to be a head shorter or heads shorter than MP-09.

As far as design goes, I'd be up for buying that current IDW TF G-1 Galvatron late 2014 comics art design for a 3rd party MP Galvatron toy. For HasTak, Have to have a MP Galvatron that resembles the 1986 Cartoon designs.

Re: What size would you like for a MP Galvatron, for 3rd party or HasTak.

PostPosted: Wed Dec 24, 2014 5:46 am
by guarayakha
I never see Galvy as being a big bot, so having him at the same height as MP22 makes no sense to me, so I expect him to be at least be the same height as Rodimus Prime.

Having no personal attachment to the character, I'll just wait for the official MP

Re: What size would you like for a MP Galvatron, for 3rd party or HasTak.

PostPosted: Wed Dec 24, 2014 8:58 am
by Gauntlet101010
This is the easiest answer of them all considering we have an MP Rodimus. WHy would Galvarton be much larger (or worse, smaller) than Roddy?

Re: What size would you like for a MP Galvatron, for 3rd party or HasTak.

PostPosted: Wed Dec 24, 2014 9:44 am
by rpetras
Gauntlet101010 wrote:This is the easiest answer of them all considering we have an MP Rodimus. WHy would Galvarton be much larger (or worse, smaller) than Roddy?


Agreed, he should stand eye to eye with Optimus.

That would put him a hair taller than Rodimus, which is fine.

Re: What size would you like for a MP Galvatron, for 3rd party or HasTak.

PostPosted: Wed Dec 24, 2014 11:35 am
by Tsutsukakushi
rpetras wrote:
Gauntlet101010 wrote:This is the easiest answer of them all considering we have an MP Rodimus. WHy would Galvarton be much larger (or worse, smaller) than Roddy?


Agreed, he should stand eye to eye with Optimus.

That would put him a hair taller than Rodimus, which is fine.


Except MP-10 is a half of a head shorter than MP-09. So any MP Galvatron would need to be at least MP-09 Height.

Re: What size would you like for a MP Galvatron, for 3rd party or HasTak.

PostPosted: Wed Dec 24, 2014 12:30 pm
by mooncake623
I want him to be exactly 10.567 inches tall.

Re: What size would you like for a MP Galvatron, for 3rd party or HasTak.

PostPosted: Wed Dec 24, 2014 3:41 pm
by Evil Eye
Ideally Galvatron should be MP-10 height. Regarding Rodimus's height, I think they really need to do an MP Hot Rod/Rodimus 2.0, although I for one would prefer it if they did the 2 versions separately, with Hot Rod being MP car sized (Sideswipe, Prowl and his moldmates, etc) whilst Rodimus Prime should be MP-10/Galvatron height. Having them as separate figures would not only allow for better height changing and for the colour change between Hot Rod and RP to be properly realized, but also should avoid having to pack the figure full of fragile hinges and breakable bits.

On a completely unrelated note, it would be cool if they did Galvatron in toy colours too.

Re: What size would you like for a MP Galvatron, for 3rd party or HasTak.

PostPosted: Wed Dec 24, 2014 7:17 pm
by Tsutsukakushi
Delta Magnus wrote:Ideally Galvatron should be MP-10 height. Regarding Rodimus's height, I think they really need to do an MP Hot Rod/Rodimus 2.0, although I for one would prefer it if they did the 2 versions separately, with Hot Rod being MP car sized (Sideswipe, Prowl and his moldmates, etc) whilst Rodimus Prime should be MP-10/Galvatron height. Having them as separate figures would not only allow for better height changing and for the colour change between Hot Rod and RP to be properly realized, but also should avoid having to pack the figure full of fragile hinges and breakable bits.

On a completely unrelated note, it would be cool if they did Galvatron in toy colours too.


Doing a Voyager-Ultra Scale MP Hotrod is something I'd also like to see happen from HasTak or a 3rd party.

Would also love it if a 3rd party company could build a Protector type trailer for Voyager-Ultra MP Hotrod that broke up into armor parts for the robot to wear. So that the combined Rodimus Prime forms in both modes could be MP Leader scale.

Re: What size would you like for a MP Galvatron, for 3rd party or HasTak.

PostPosted: Thu Dec 25, 2014 8:30 pm
by craggy
I'd need mine to be taller than a piece of string, but not as tall as a fish.

Re: What size would you like for a MP Galvatron, for 3rd party or HasTak.

PostPosted: Fri Dec 26, 2014 11:26 am
by fenrir72
Same as MP UM.

Re: What size would you like for a MP Galvatron, for 3rd party or HasTak.

PostPosted: Sun Dec 28, 2014 8:59 pm
by Forgotten
π² inches.

Re: What size would you like for a MP Galvatron, for 3rd party or HasTak.

PostPosted: Sun Dec 28, 2014 9:11 pm
by ScottyP
MP-9 sized, please. Makes the most sense to me.

Re: What size would you like for a MP Galvatron, for 3rd party or HasTak.

PostPosted: Sun Jan 11, 2015 9:15 pm
by Blasphemous Prime
I think a half head taller than MP-09 would be just about right for Galvatron. And he should be proportionate to MP-09 as well.

Nothing pissed me off more as a kid with these characters than having Magnus end up not being the leader instead we ended up with Rodimus who as a figure was about half the height of Galvatron. #-o

I always wanted either a taller Rodimus or a smaller Galvatron.

Re: What size would you like for a MP Galvatron, for 3rd party or HasTak.

PostPosted: Sun Jan 11, 2015 9:32 pm
by Blasphemous Prime
mooncake623 wrote:I want him to be exactly 10.567 inches tall.


Do you have that in metric? :lol:

I have to ask, why that precise height?

Re: What size would you like for a MP Galvatron, for 3rd party or HasTak.

PostPosted: Sun Jan 11, 2015 9:42 pm
by Blasphemous Prime
Delta Magnus wrote:Ideally Galvatron should be MP-10 height. Regarding Rodimus's height, I think they really need to do an MP Hot Rod/Rodimus 2.0, although I for one would prefer it if they did the 2 versions separately, with Hot Rod being MP car sized (Sideswipe, Prowl and his moldmates, etc) whilst Rodimus Prime should be MP-10/Galvatron height. Having them as separate figures would not only allow for better height changing and for the colour change between Hot Rod and RP to be properly realized, but also should avoid having to pack the figure full of fragile hinges and breakable bits.

On a completely unrelated note, it would be cool if they did Galvatron in toy colours too.


Personally, I don't think we need a new Rodimus, but I do agree we need a scaled down HotRod to match the size of other MP cars. If they would just extrapolate the existing HotRod down to scale and then strengthen the weaknesses, that would be ideal. I look at MP-09 as just Rodimus, except for the face gimmick. The reason being, a Prime should be able to detach from his trailer without people saying "Wtf is that?" when they see the smaller alt mode. I always thought if RP detached from his trailer, he would just look like HotRod's alt mode, only bigger.

I agree with you on a toy accurate color scheme on Galvatron. It would give fans a choice and because some collectors collect everything, this would allow the company to reap extra use from the mold.

Re: What size would you like for a MP Galvatron, for 3rd party or HasTak.

PostPosted: Mon Jan 12, 2015 3:02 pm
by Evil Eye
Well the reason we need a new Rodimus is less because of the (pretty decent) aesthetics or size and more because the Japanese version is reeeeeeaaaaally fragile and the Hasbro version has no trailer and has EXPLODING SHOULDERS.

Did Michaell Bay engineer this figure I wonder? :lol:

Re: What size would you like for a MP Galvatron, for 3rd party or HasTak.

PostPosted: Mon Jan 12, 2015 6:02 pm
by Genocide G2.0
I would like a new rodimus prime as he doesnt scale right imo

As for galvatron no bigger than mp10

Re: What size would you like for a MP Galvatron, for 3rd party or HasTak.

PostPosted: Mon Jan 12, 2015 6:59 pm
by Tsutsukakushi
Delta Magnus wrote:Well the reason we need a new Rodimus is less because of the (pretty decent) aesthetics or size and more because the Japanese version is reeeeeeaaaaally fragile and the Hasbro version has no trailer and has EXPLODING SHOULDERS.

Did Michaell Bay engineer this figure I wonder? :lol:


In agreeance with everything you wrote


Like Two different MP toys for this character. With a less complicated Transformation and more durable stronger less fragile parts.

One, MP toy for Hotrod that is voyager scale and matches the size of the current MP TF cars-bots. Thinking later on a 3rd party company can step in and created a FP styled armor trailer to turn the toy into a Ultra-Leader scale Rodimus Prime in both modes.

2nd, MP TF toy just for Rodimus Prime. That is less fragile and less thin than the MP-09 toy was. Envision a thick plastic, Bulky toy like MP-08 was. Want it to be a huge one piece truck bot that transforms into a big robot mode like mp-22 does and Titanium 6 Rodimus Prime does.

Re: What size would you like for a MP Galvatron, for 3rd party or HasTak.

PostPosted: Mon Jan 12, 2015 11:43 pm
by megatronus
I'd prefer an MP Galvatron to be eye to eye with MP10. Galvatron may have been an upgraded (or rather, reformatted) Megatron, but Galvatron was the same height as Megatron, and Megatron was the same height as Prime. I don't see why that height would be undesirable - at least for me, the trope of characterizing the challenge of the protagonists by the over-sized nature of the antagonists has grown tiresome. Galvatron doesn't have to be over-sized to be threatening.

Making an MP Galvatron eye to eye with Prime would place him just a tad larger than Soundwave and the Seekers to assert his dominance over the Decepticons, but would also properly place him as a suitable adversary for his Autobot opponents. (In my opinion.)

Besides, putting Galvatron at MP10's height means he'll be about the same height as MP09, too:

Image




Blasphemous Prime wrote:
mooncake623 wrote:I want him to be exactly 10.567 inches tall.


Do you have that in metric? :lol:

I have to ask, why that precise height?

He's goofing on Tsu. Let's just call it a running gag.

Re: What size would you like for a MP Galvatron, for 3rd party or HasTak.

PostPosted: Mon Jan 12, 2015 11:51 pm
by Tsutsukakushi
Don't want a MP Galvatron to be MP-10 robot height as Prime is half a head shorter than MP-09.

At the very least I need a MP Galvatron and MP-09 to be the same robot height. Would love it if MP Galvatron was a Half of a head or Head taller than MP-09. Because I feel Megatron was taller than Prime in the G-1 cartoon. So Galvatron should be slightly taller than Rodimus Prime.

Image

Like this height comparisons pics between MP-09 and MP-10 so much, I just saved it on my computer.

Re: What size would you like for a MP Galvatron, for 3rd party or HasTak.

PostPosted: Tue Jan 13, 2015 12:07 am
by megatronus
Tsutsukakushi wrote:Because I feel Megatron was taller than Prime in the G-1 cartoon.

Just cuz you feel it, don't make it so.

Re: What size would you like for a MP Galvatron, for 3rd party or HasTak.

PostPosted: Tue Jan 13, 2015 12:15 am
by Tsutsukakushi
Perhaps a simple fix solution would be for Takara or a 3rd party to make a MP Galvatron MP-09 robot height. Then include One inch height boots to make others who want it to be slightly taller happy.