Page 1 of 1
Universe Boxart on deviantART

Posted:
Sat Apr 05, 2008 5:44 am
by Down_Shift
Marcelo Matere has updated his page to include the boxart for the new Universe line. We've seen these pictures on the packages, but now you can see them stand alone.
PowerglideTankorProwlSunstreakerIf you're wondering why these four looks so stiff, it was at the request of Hasbro. Do you think it makes them more iconic or do you think it holds back the artists creativity?
Discussion as always is welcome.
Re: Universe Boxart on deviantART

Posted:
Sat Apr 05, 2008 6:17 am
by Deadpool.
I think that the artstyle is pretty good, but the stiff poses kinda suck....
And Prowl looks... plump.
Re: Universe Boxart on deviantART

Posted:
Sat Apr 05, 2008 6:40 am
by Glackie
Iconic? Angels are icons and they don't stand stiff. They should be in some sort of pose. Standing stiff like that takes away from the character of the character and the artist.
Other than that they're very nice.

Re: Universe Boxart on deviantART

Posted:
Sat Apr 05, 2008 7:28 am
by Zeds
I agree with the posters on the deviantART website. The poses should show more action. They look a little boring just standing there.
Re: Universe Boxart on deviantART

Posted:
Sat Apr 05, 2008 7:41 am
by Tigertrack
Sunstreaker looks the best in that quite boring pose, Prowl is looking chunky, Octanor is skinny, and Powerglide looks like he's on the 'roids and supplements a bit too much since G1...
But if that's what they wanted...
(Please refer to my previous statements about the state of packaging and boxart...)
Re: Universe Boxart on deviantART

Posted:
Sat Apr 05, 2008 7:56 am
by metalformer
They are all nice. But I would love to see more action in them (yes! I'm a purist!)... though I understand why would Hasbro want them like that. Today's packages shows very little of the figure's art so why bother drawing a pose anyway? Though I would use the whole art on the instructions or on the back or somewhere (Now I am talking trully puritan).
Re: Universe Boxart on deviantART

Posted:
Sat Apr 05, 2008 8:19 am
by Tigertrack
They kind of look like they are ill, or sick (faces)...

Re: Universe Boxart on deviantART

Posted:
Sat Apr 05, 2008 10:12 am
by PhantomPrime
Cool, but if they had action poses it would be cooler
Re: Universe Boxart on deviantART

Posted:
Sat Apr 05, 2008 11:40 am
by Dr. Caelus
Having them stand at attention doesn't really bother me, but the expressions on Octane, Prowl, and Sunstreaker are all identical, and all of them look like they just found out that someone peed in their last energon cube.
Re: Universe Boxart on deviantART

Posted:
Sat Apr 05, 2008 11:44 am
by Autobot032
Down_Shift wrote:If you're wondering why these four looks so stiff, it was at the request of Hasbro. Do you think it makes them more iconic or do you think it holds back the artists creativity?
Discussion as always is welcome.
I like it. They look far better in an "At attention" pose, than the out of proportion, goofy, cominatcha of the previous lines. (G1 was notorious for this ridiculous practice.)
I really like it. At first I was put off because they were all in the same pose and I thought "Well, this is boring concept art."
But now that I know that it was Hasbro's idea and the way the figures are packaged, it's like a showcase in a box.
It works.
Re: Universe Boxart on deviantART

Posted:
Sat Apr 05, 2008 11:51 am
by Tigertrack
Autobot032 wrote:Down_Shift wrote:If you're wondering why these four looks so stiff, it was at the request of Hasbro. Do you think it makes them more iconic or do you think it holds back the artists creativity?
Discussion as always is welcome.
I like it. They look far better in an "At attention" pose, than the out of proportion, goofy, cominatcha of the previous lines. (G1 was notorious for this ridiculous practice.)
I really like it. At first I was put off because they were all in the same pose and I thought "Well, this is boring concept art."
But now that I know that it was Hasbro's idea and the way the figures are packaged, it's like a showcase in a box.
It works.
Why is action/coming at you box art goofy? I thought it gave the imagination something to build on as to the characters personality, and/or abilities. I think the G1 designs are for the most part very attractive to the consumer and collector, but there are a few stinkers here and there.
It works to let us know what part of the robot mode is (which also displayed fully on the back). Ironically the toy picture on the back gives us more movement and character than the actual boxart, which may have been their point...doing the opposite of what they did with G1 where the toy poses were so static they needed the artwork to really sell the character, and thus the toy.
Re: Universe Boxart on deviantART

Posted:
Sat Apr 05, 2008 12:10 pm
by UltraPrimal
Iconic.
Re: Universe Boxart on deviantART

Posted:
Sat Apr 05, 2008 1:01 pm
by 8 bit
I think this all has to do with marketing and the cost of printing/finishing. What I mean is, by having similar poses, Hasbro will probably be able to save design time and might even have all the boxes cut out with the same die-cut instead of one that goes around each figure differently. And if they are all printed in the same area on the packaging, they can be enlarged to an optimal size with the poses they are in. I haven't seen the Universe packaging yet, so I may be totally off base.
Anyway, it looks like Hasbro is taking the Universe line seriously. That is some pretty good artwork.
Re: Universe Boxart on deviantART

Posted:
Sat Apr 05, 2008 4:41 pm
by Bumblethumper
I like.
They're imposing and iconic. The robust posing makes them look like towering robotic monoliths.
Sunstreaker is somehow a lot better than the others. Powerglide has droopy manboobs.
Re: Universe Boxart on deviantART

Posted:
Sat Apr 05, 2008 5:29 pm
by Down_Shift
To be honest, I liked Energons Box-art the best. It gave a little something else. I still like this work, but I'm afraid I'll get very bored with it fast. Almost anti-climactic.
Re: Universe Boxart on deviantART

Posted:
Sat Apr 05, 2008 7:00 pm
by [JRX]
Caelus wrote:Having them stand at attention doesn't really bother me, but the expressions on Octane, Prowl, and Sunstreaker are all identical, and all of them look like they just found out that someone peed in their last energon cube.
Agreed. The expressions are a bit odd... almost reminiscent of Pat Lee's trademarked "Dull Surprise."

Re: Universe Boxart on deviantART

Posted:
Sat Apr 05, 2008 8:20 pm
by Stormrider
They all look like a bunch of fatties.
Re: Universe Boxart on deviantART

Posted:
Sat Apr 05, 2008 8:43 pm
by Smokescreen85
The artwork looks good overall IMO. The lack of action in their poses doesn't bother me so much as their slack jaws. It's like they're surprised by something and their mouths are just hanging open in amazement. Oh, well. Still looking forward to picking up the figures themselves.
Re: Universe Boxart on deviantART

Posted:
Sat Apr 05, 2008 9:01 pm
by Cascadia
Smokescreen GT wrote:The artwork looks good overall IMO. The lack of action in their poses doesn't bother me so much as their slack jaws. It's like they're surprised by something and their mouths are just hanging open in amazement. Oh, well. Still looking forward to picking up the figures themselves.
They are not half bad. I am still looking forward to picking them up in August.
Re: Universe Boxart on deviantART

Posted:
Sat Apr 05, 2008 10:02 pm
by polystyleneman
Yeah, those stiff poses aren't doing anybody any favors.
Re: Universe Boxart on deviantART

Posted:
Mon Apr 07, 2008 4:01 am
by TaiPoh
Depending on what the final packaging design will look like, their poses can either make or break it. I would rather have dynamic poses, but that's just me. Expressions could be better, if they are at that pose, wouldn't they look more focused rather than relaxed and slack? Finishing and style looks nice though, can't wait to see more.