Page 1 of 1

IDW's Classic Transformers collections

PostPosted: Sun Jul 05, 2009 6:59 pm
by Supreme Convoy
:BOT: Just curious since I haven't had a chance to flip through IDW's Classic Transformers Volume 1. Does it still include Spider-Man appearance? :CON:

Re: IDW's Classic Transformers Volume 1 - Spidey apperance?

PostPosted: Sun Jul 05, 2009 10:35 pm
by Darth Bombshell
Supreme Convoy wrote::BOT: Just curious since I haven't had a chance to flip through IDW's Classic Transformers Volume 1. Does it still include Spider-Man appearance? :CON:


No, it doesn't. The Classic Trades also don't include Circuit Breaker, which is why, in addition to #3, we also don't get #9, a page half blacked out of #21, #22, #23 or #45. It's also likely why we're not going to get another volume to collect the final eighteen issues, since she (and the Neo-Knights, also Marvel owned characters) appear in half of them.

Re: IDW's Classic Transformers Volume 1 - Spidey apperance?

PostPosted: Mon Jul 06, 2009 12:29 am
by Kenny28
Jeez...why did Marvel even bother? Most of those characters were either lame or just never used again, period.

Does this mean we won't be getting any of the UK stories with Death's Head?

Re: IDW's Classic Transformers Volume 1 - Spidey apperance?

PostPosted: Mon Jul 06, 2009 2:33 am
by Supreme Convoy
Darth Bombshell wrote:
Supreme Convoy wrote::BOT: Just curious since I haven't had a chance to flip through IDW's Classic Transformers Volume 1. Does it still include Spider-Man appearance? :CON:


No, it doesn't. The Classic Trades also don't include Circuit Breaker, which is why, in addition to #3, we also don't get #9, a page half blacked out of #21, #22, #23 or #45. It's also likely why we're not going to get another volume to collect the final eighteen issues, since she (and the Neo-Knights, also Marvel owned characters) appear in half of them.


:BOT: Wow. I hate to how #3 reads...

I just found it odd that the GI Joe collections remove all the Marvel logos yet the Greatest Battles of Optimus Prime and Megatron keep the Marvel logos. :CON:

Re: IDW's Classic Transformers Volume 1 - Spidey apperance?

PostPosted: Wed Jul 15, 2009 11:47 pm
by Hotrod
I just picked it up and I must say, I was dissappointed that they couldnt include issues 3 and 9 but I think I will pick up the whole series.

Re: IDW's Classic Transformers collections

PostPosted: Sat Mar 06, 2010 10:59 pm
by Supreme Convoy
Recently went on a spending spree and bought all the Classic Transformers volumes currently available. I noticed a few were out of print and I picked them up cheap while I can.

Seeing issue 3's omission obviously drive my nerd mind crazy. I can understand IDW's position but did Titan publish these issues with the Marvel content?

Though I will say that I love the quality of the books, the paper is great. The books feel like they'll last forever. Pretty stoked to read this stuff as I've only read the beginning and ending to the G1 comics.

Plus the price is pretty awesome.

Hopefully they'll do a G2 collection!

Image

Darth Bombshell wrote:It's also likely why we're not going to get another volume to collect the final eighteen issues, since she (and the Neo-Knights, also Marvel owned characters) appear in half of them.


I just remember she plays a big role in bringing down Unicron... that'd be interesting to read :shock:

I have a bad feeling I might buy the Titan edition of End of the Road just to make sure I get the complete story.

Re: IDW's Classic Transformers collections

PostPosted: Sun Mar 07, 2010 3:30 am
by Dead Metal
I think the titan stuff does include the Marvel characters, as I still have my 5 Pound voucher for the volume including Spider-Man and he's featured prominently on the cover.

Re: IDW's Classic Transformers collections

PostPosted: Sun Mar 07, 2010 4:26 am
by Supreme Convoy
I flipped through Volume 5 and Circuit Breaker and The Neo Knights appear in their entirety. So it looks like the last volume will not have any omissions.

It's a good thing. As with most people, I love the Furman run so it's nice that the reprints will be untouched.

Re: IDW's Classic Transformers collections

PostPosted: Sun Mar 07, 2010 8:06 am
by Darth Bombshell
Supreme Convoy wrote:I flipped through Volume 5 and Circuit Breaker and The Neo Knights appear in their entirety. So it looks like the last volume will not have any omissions.


They worked out some kind of deal before doing Volume 5. Obviously they had to, otherwise there wouldn't have been a Volume 5.

Re: IDW's Classic Transformers collections

PostPosted: Sun Mar 07, 2010 9:19 am
by RK_Striker_JK_5
Yeah, that'd be a big omission there.

Hate how they can't use Spidey, though. Glad I got some of the older collections.

Re: IDW's Classic Transformers collections

PostPosted: Thu Mar 11, 2010 12:03 pm
by Cyberstrike
Dead Metal wrote:I think the titan stuff does include the Marvel characters, as I still have my 5 Pound voucher for the volume including Spider-Man and he's featured prominently on the cover.



I have all the Titan US and UK TPBs (except for Transformers: Earthforce) and most of the hardcovers too.
So I can personally assure all of you that Spider-Man (and Nick Fury, who makes a very brief cameo in #3 as well) appears in full in Transformers #3 reprinted in the Titan Transformers: Beginings TPB and Hardcover. Circut Breaker and the Neo-Kinghts makes all of their full appearences through out the various Titan TPBs and Hardcovers of the Marvel US Transformers series too.