The Energon Pub

I usually hate posting negative things... but what a truly awful episode

Indeed it is... Surely only the most foolish of fools would be foolhardy enough to defend this foolish episode.

Still better than B.O.T.

RK_Striker_JK_5 wrote:Still better than B.O.T.

I actually just watched both for the first time. B.O.T. was pretty bad, and reminded me of some episodes from TFA, in the way that it was mildly pointless. Nothing to be gained from having watched it...

Carnage in C-Minor is the worst piece of animation ever. Ever. I will admit it was worse than anything from Animated, and Animated had some pretty bad animation.

Though, interestingly enough the entire episode was animated by AKOM, a South Korean studio, not Toei. AKOM seems not to be very good at what they do judging by their portfolio...

Imagine everything written in this thread to be spoken in a singing voice.

Both are horrible. any debate about which is worse, does nothing as neither episode gains any benefit from being better than the other.

both are filed with stupid animation errors and plotlines that should have been shot down before they were approved.

Nekoman wrote:Imagine everything written in this thread to be spoken in a singing voice.

CANNOT UNHEAR IT

Editor wrote:Both are horrible. any debate about which is worse, does nothing as neither episode gains any benefit from being better than the other.

both are filed with stupid animation errors and plotlines that should have been shot down before they were approved.

Roland is ashamed of what you said about his episode!

Nekoman wrote:
Roland is ashamed of what you said about his episode!

Roland should be more concerned with Shuttles that fit in car lanes, military grade computers in his school, the Jem wannabes in his class, and possible abuse charges then any abuse i can verbally commit against B.O.T.

And charges of assault filed against him and his criminal cronie by Miss Pressman... soon as she gets the tape off her mouth.

BOT is just bad, going to watch Carnage now.

WOW that was almost too painful to watch, at least they had soundwave in that episode. figures theyd feature him in a trash episode

RK_Striker_JK_5 wrote:Still better than B.O.T.

Oh yeah? Well, I just watched B.O.T last night, and it was, and remains as, a terrible episode! So, now what? Huh?

No, but really. Both of these episodes suck. Suck hard. Does anyone think that when people jump up and down your ass for being a fan of G1, that these are the episodes that fuel their pointless rages? Cause, as a G1 fan, I can completely understand why these two episodes would infuriate people who like other series better.

I agree if there were more episodes like BOT and Carnage in C-Minor everyone would hate G1

NormT81 wrote:I agree if there were more episodes like BOT and Carnage in C-Minor everyone would hate G1

Hate... maybe not. But it wouldn't have as much appeal as it does.

Yeah. More of those episodes, and maybe TF might not have been revived.

Oh God, what a terrible episode! I've been rewatching all the G1 episodes, but when I came back across this one, I couldn't even stomach it enough to sit through it. AGGGH, those friggin' sing-song voices are SO BAD!

RK_Striker_JK_5 wrote:Yeah. More of those episodes, and maybe TF might not have been revived.

Well, Transformers never really went away. True, it didn't have a multi-million dollar big studio movie made for it yet, but it never went away.

Dagon wrote:

RK_Striker_JK_5 wrote:Yeah. More of those episodes, and maybe TF might not have been revived.

Well, Transformers never really went away. True, it didn't have a multi-million dollar big studio movie made for it yet, but it never went away.

I think it is more of if we had most episodes like that, the franchise could have died completely after G1, rather than sleeping thru G2, and slumbering until Beast Wars took off.

Editor wrote:

Dagon wrote:

RK_Striker_JK_5 wrote:Yeah. More of those episodes, and maybe TF might not have been revived.

Well, Transformers never really went away. True, it didn't have a multi-million dollar big studio movie made for it yet, but it never went away.

I think it is more of if we had most episodes like that, the franchise could have died completely after G1, rather than sleeping thru G2, and slumbering until Beast Wars took off.

Yeah, pretty much. More episodes like those two and there might've been a final fading.