Page 1 of 1

Which comic should I read?!?!

PostPosted: Wed Sep 29, 2010 10:19 am
by ubertenorman
Hey all.

So, I was considering getting into reading some Transformers comics. However, I have no idea where to start. Do you have any suggestions. I'm pretty open in terms of subjects (movie universe, G1, Beast era, etc) but I'd like something newer so I can get a hold of it more easily.

Thanks!

Re: Which comic should I read?!?!

PostPosted: Wed Sep 29, 2010 2:43 pm
by JetOptimus23
Movie: Try Nefarious or Defiance, great ones.
G1: Ironhide, Bumblebee, Stormbringer, Spotlight.

Re: Which comic should I read?!?!

PostPosted: Wed Sep 29, 2010 4:50 pm
by Bobton03
Someone asked a similar question a few weeks ago in this forum -- try to look for the posting and, once found, your question will be answered.


- Bob

Re: Which comic should I read?!?!

PostPosted: Thu Sep 30, 2010 5:56 am
by Bobton03
If you could not find the original posting (19 Sep 10), here are my inputs:

Here are my recommendations:

1.) Last Stand of the Wreckers
2.) Megatron Origin
3.) Stormbringer
4.) Maximum Dinobots
5.) Spotlight: Revelation
6.) All Hail Megatron


If you want to stray outside of the IDW continuity, then I would definitely recommend all three of Dreamwave's "War Within" story-arcs.


- Bob

Re: Which comic should I read?!?!

PostPosted: Sun Oct 03, 2010 7:38 am
by ComicBookBoo
Okay this is a COMPLEX question, but it can be made simple :)

If you want the best Transformers book EVER drawn and created, then get - Transformers animated The Arrival
(yeah i have to say it's the best because i drew alot of it haha)

If you want a fantastic TF story with good characters, artwork, action and plotting read - Worlds Collide by Furrman and Don
published by DW

If you want something more offworld in space and your not botherd about transforming - Stormbringer by Furrman and Don
published by IDW

If you want the origin of it all with great story, art and TF's before they go to earth - WarWithin Volume 1
published by DW

If you want the current continuity published by IDW you have to be picky because they relaunch often - Transformers Ongoing in shops every month

hope that helps

Re: Which comic should I read?!?!

PostPosted: Sun Oct 03, 2010 1:31 pm
by Stormer
When I started getting back into Transformers (previously my last encounter was Marvel's Generation 2 - when that ended, life took over and it took until 2007 to spark my interest again), I purchased The Reign of Starscream, All Hail Megatron, Stormbringer and Spotlight: Revelations. Of coarse, that just whet my whistle for more. I don't think it matters where you start out. Once you're hooked, you're going to be hungry for more.

My favorite is still Last Stand of the Wreckers, followed by AHM, Spotlights Drift and Blurr, and I'm really enjoying the Drift mini-series.

I've yet to get the Animated stuff (sorry TheBoo - I'll get around to it!), so I don't have an opinion on that continuity. Lots of fans seem to like it tho!

Re: Which comic should I read?!?!

PostPosted: Sun Oct 03, 2010 2:08 pm
by ComicBookBoo
Stormer wrote:When I started getting back into Transformers (previously my last encounter was Marvel's Generation 2 - when that ended, life took over and it took until 2007 to spark my interest again), I purchased The Reign of Starscream, All Hail Megatron, Stormbringer and Spotlight: Revelations. Of coarse, that just whet my whistle for more. I don't think it matters where you start out. Once you're hooked, you're going to be hungry for more.

My favorite is still Last Stand of the Wreckers, followed by AHM, Spotlights Drift and Blurr, and I'm really enjoying the Drift mini-series.

I've yet to get the Animated stuff (sorry TheBoo - I'll get around to it!), so I don't have an opinion on that continuity. Lots of fans seem to like it tho!


Okay I'll TRY to not be biased lol
alot of people fall in love with TFA, it has really good character writing and iconic designs, also more girls prefer TFA which makes me happy :grin:

the IDW TFA Arrival books are actually part of the cartoons continuity because Marty Isenberg wrote them... for example, i drew the first official appearance of Oilslick in TFAArrival #3 before he even appeared in the cartoon lol.

But TFA is like Marmite, some love it and some hate it

Re: Which comic should I read?!?!

PostPosted: Sun Oct 03, 2010 4:04 pm
by Stormer
TheBoo wrote:If you want the best Transformers book EVER drawn and created, then get - Transformers animated The Arrival
(yeah i have to say it's the best because i drew alot of it haha)


How freakin' awesome is that to actually get to work on this stuff! You are in quite the enviable position! I just think that's totally cool that you get to work on something you enjoy so much!

I don't know that I honestly had much interest in Animated until now...I'll check it out ASAP!

Re: Which comic should I read?!?!

PostPosted: Sun Oct 03, 2010 4:06 pm
by Stormer
TheBoo wrote:If you want the best Transformers book EVER drawn and created, then get - Transformers animated The Arrival
(yeah i have to say it's the best because i drew alot of it haha)


How freakin' awesome is that to actually get to work on this stuff! You are in quite the enviable position! I just think that's totally cool that you get to work on something you enjoy so much!

I don't know that I honestly had much interest in Animated until now...I'll check it out ASAP!


Whooops! I sent this twice - my apologies! Dang slow old computer anyway...

Re: Which comic should I read?!?!

PostPosted: Tue Oct 05, 2010 3:39 am
by ComicBookBoo
Stormer wrote:
TheBoo wrote:If you want the best Transformers book EVER drawn and created, then get - Transformers animated The Arrival
(yeah i have to say it's the best because i drew alot of it haha)


How freakin' awesome is that to actually get to work on this stuff! You are in quite the enviable position! I just think that's totally cool that you get to work on something you enjoy so much!

I don't know that I honestly had much interest in Animated until now...I'll check it out ASAP!


Whooops! I sent this twice - my apologies! Dang slow old computer anyway...


Thanxx, i started off a TF fan in the 80's and now i am proud that i've contributed to the Legand that is Transformers :D
What really gets me excited tho is when i get emails and messages on DA from kids (and adults who are still kids like me) who have just gotten into TF and really enjoyed my work, it's very touching

Re: Which comic should I read?!?!

PostPosted: Tue Oct 05, 2010 8:24 am
by Rodimus Prime
I'd say start with either War Within 1 from DreamWave or the G1 stories (either volume 1 or 2) from DreamWave. I never read the IDW stuff because when they first started out, they were horrible. The TFA stuff I've never even heard of, of course I never got into the cartoon either, and the toys are stupid, except for maybe Jazz and Soundwave w/Ratbat. But sometime you mUST read the original Marvel G1 and G2 comics, if you're a fan worth your salt. Be reminded that it is from the 80s, but it gave Simon Furman his entry into the TF Universe, and the last 25 US issues of Marvel and the entire G2 series is just f**king awesome. And yes, the final 5 issues of the Armada comics, Worlds Collide. If anything can come close to the end of G1 and G2, that story arc did.

Re: Which comic should I read?!?!

PostPosted: Tue Oct 05, 2010 11:56 am
by Cyberstrike
IDW's GREAT series All Hail Megatron and the excellant ongoing series. That would be the best place to start. And pay no attention to the haters here they can't stand the fact that McCarthy and Costa have written better stories than Furman.

Re: Which comic should I read?!?!

PostPosted: Tue Oct 05, 2010 6:11 pm
by Stormer
Cyberstrike wrote:IDW's GREAT series All Hail Megatron and the excellant ongoing series. That would be the best place to start. And pay no attention to the haters here they can't stand the fact that McCarthy and Costa have written better stories than Furman.


They definitely are starting to get it going in a good direction, for sure!

Re: Which comic should I read?!?!

PostPosted: Tue Oct 05, 2010 8:35 pm
by Darth Bombshell
Cyberstrike wrote:And pay no attention to the haters here they can't stand the fact that McCarthy and Costa have written better stories than Furman.


Please point me in the direction of one of those either of those people have done.

Re: Which comic should I read?!?!

PostPosted: Tue Oct 05, 2010 8:47 pm
by TulioDude
Image

Re: Which comic should I read?!?!

PostPosted: Wed Oct 06, 2010 8:25 am
by ComicBookBoo
TulioDude wrote:Image


Thats the best Transformers comic ever...but what happens when Unicron comes for some Jam!!!

Re: Which comic should I read?!?!

PostPosted: Mon Oct 11, 2010 9:46 am
by transformers<3<3
[quote="ubertenorman"]Hey all.

So, I was considering getting into reading some Transformers comics. However, I have no idea where to start. Do you have any suggestions. I'm pretty open in terms of subjects (movie universe, G1, Beast era, etc) but I'd like something newer so I can get a hold of it more easily.

Thanks![/quote)

O MATE YOUR INTRESTED IN TRANSFORMERS COMICS? SO AM I!! FOUND SOMETHING REALLY COOL U MIGHT BE INTRESTED IN ! THE COMPLETE COLLECTION OF TRANSFORMERS COMICS FROM THE YEARS 1984-91 !! CHEAP ASWELL! HERES THE LINK : http://cgi.ebay.co.uk/transformers-comi ... 500wt_1156

Re: Which comic should I read?!?!

PostPosted: Tue Oct 19, 2010 12:34 pm
by MidAge
My suggestion: Maximum Dinobots