Saber Prime wrote: He was never "rebuilt" by Teletran 1, he was modified, there's a difference.
Considering the extent of the "Modifing" done to characters like Bumble Bee,Wheeljack,Jazz and the seekers it could very well be called rebuilding but I'll conseed that it was a poor choise of wording on my part.
But my point is that Optimus's modifecation could have rendered his "Prime" appearance to be his normal appearance and removing may not have had a effect on it.
Saber Prime wrote: True I don't, but considering in another argument you used the verry same argument to exsplain why Optimus Primal reverted to his original form in Beast Machines when that body never had that form.
What I said in that debate is that I believe that the Spark retain information on its host bodies appearance because it was the only explanation for what happened to Primal in Beast Machines.
None of the other possible explanations fited the issue.
Saber Prime wrote:If Primal can revert to his original form when he has an entirely new body, why not Optimus with just a few parts replaced?
Well Prime had more then a few replacment parts as you just pointed out.He was heavily modified.
Further more the properties of a G1 Spark are different then those of the Sparks of those from the Beast Era.
Maximal experimented on Sparks over the years and its safe to assume that their were improvements made over the years.
And there werent really "Sparks" in the G1 toon.....even the closest thing had different properties.
And I also said in that debate that it was the "Virus" that caused the change in Primals body not the info stored in the spark....but it was the stored info that allowed the change to take place.
So in Optimus Prime's case there would be no out side force causing a change in his body.
Removing the Matrix would have no effect because his body was modified and there was nothing causeing a revertion to his older body like Primal had when he was infected with the virus.
Saber Prime wrote:I may be mistaken but from what I've seen of Optronix/Optimus Prime he didn't even change forms, just his name. The pictures I've seen of Optronix he allready looks like Optimus Prime so there really isn't anything for him to revert back to.
You are mistaken.While I wont say the changes were great there was a phical change in his body when he was transformed by the Matrin from Optronix to Optimus.



Saber Prime wrote:Of course I've only seen the robot modes and even Hot Rod and Rodimus look verry much alike in robot mode so maybe the differences are too small that I just didn't notice.
The never showed the alt mode of Optronix.But since his robot mode had some differences in both appearance and size after h got the Matrix [which was commented on by some of the characters] then its safe to assume that Optronix's alt mode was smaller then that of his Optimus body.
Saber Prime wrote:On the other hand, sence he was Optronix not Orian Pax the comparison really can't be made with the cartoon counterpart.
When "the War Within" was announced it was also said that the name change from Orion to Optronix was done because Simon Furmen [writter of TWW] did not wasnt to thread over the writting done by David Wise [G1 cartoon writter and writter of the episode "War Dawn] but I believe that its because Furmen never liked the writtings of David Wise.
Furmen has also shown a dislike for many of myths from the cartoon.
The script for "The War Within" has mention that Optronix was his name but he was called Orion by his friends.
Regardless a fair comparison can be made to identify the character's origin but the events in both universes cant really be compaired to each other.
Its safe to assume that Optronix and Orion are counterparts of each other but the events that lead to both to becoming Optimus Prime were quite different.
Saber Prime wrote:It still might be possible, at least for the toon if not the comics, that the only reason Optimus Prime doesn't change back into Orian Pax is because he was rebuilt into Optimus by Alpha Trion not modified by the Matrix like Hot Rod/Rodimus Prime was.
Oh yes thats very possible.I never said it wasnt.But what I'm saying is that its equally possoble that the Matrix did modify him and that he doesnt change back because of other modificatuion done to his body in the years after getting the Matrix.
Or that after having it so long Optimus cant be reverted simply because the Matrix is removed.
Saber Prime wrote:You can allso look at it another way. Hot Rod really is the only KNOWN Transformer to be upgraded by the Matrix. The reason he was upgraded when no one else was could be exactly the oppisite, he IS the one destined to carrey the Matrix.
You are incorrect sir.The Decepticon Scourge was also changed by the power of the Matrix.I dont know if you can call it an upgrade but it made him bigger and stronger just like it did to Hot Rod.
Also Optimus Prime also said that the Matrix made him stronger when Hot Rod gave it back to him.
Both of those thing leed me to the conclusion that Hot Rod
IS Not the only one destined to carrey the Matrix and that there is a small fraction of the TF populance with an infinity with the Matrix and can be effected by it.
Saber Prime wrote:All of this, what you just said in the quote, and what I just said, is of course just speculation based on what we know about the Matrix, which isn't much.
Granted much of what we both said is open to debate but what is not is that Hot Rod was the only TF to be effected by the Matrix's power.
Optimus Prime and Scourge both reported a bost in power and Scourge was also physically change by the Matrix.
Saber Prime wrote:I've had that therie too and I still belive that may verry well be a possibility. Hey look, we actully agree on something.

We might be in an alternate universe
Saber Prime wrote:No idea what you just said there. That last part was kind of a run on sentence. (And I've probly been guilty of the same thing before.)
I weas trying to say that we really cant tell if the Matrix change Orion into Optimus or not.
And that we cant compair Rodimus's situation to that of Optimus's.
Saber Prime wrote:I could get a list off Wiki of all the known Matrix Bearers but there's really no point. The only thing I was trying to bring up is that it's not entirely nessisary for a Matrix Bearer to have an -imus Prime sufix on their name and that point has been made without listing everyone.
Agreed.