shamone wrote:By the title i mean, was there a scene in the movies which made you realise, yeah this is not for me
for me there were moments in both flicks
in transformers
- opening scene was fine, good introduction of serious threat, transforming sound was good, action seemed ok, could be good
however the next scene wiped all that out. I understand movie editing and pacing, and that you need to bring the audience down after a high tempo opening, but
- The logic in the class room scene. Sam is selling his GF's stuff to purchase a car. Cut to next scene he is buying said car, having not sold them, huh ?
- One more scene wiped me out then, Bunblebee upgrading to new model. His parents didnt note that sam had a crappy camaro, and suddenly its a brand new one. Yet no questions asked, huh ?
In ROTF it didnt take as long
- the opening scene in China, with the executionbots. At that point, I knew that the scriptwriters didnt know what autobots were or what their moral stance was.
Before Bays Fansformers go on the attack, these are my views, you can disagree fair enough, but try to limit the personal insults if you can, they are only movies.
No personal insults will come from me. Everyone is entitled to their opinion. I do, however, wish to address some of your post.
You're wrong about the selling stuff to buy the car. It was his intention to sell the items to make up the difference, because he knew his dad can be a hardass. Sam had the money, spoke to the teacher and pulled the "What would Jesus do?" line, and got the grade he needed. His dad paid the other half of his car. The sales of those items would be icing on the cake.
But, to be fair, the movie is convoluted as all get out in the first few viewings, both story wise, and visually, so I can't fault you for thinking "WTF?"
His parents never saw the reformatted Bumblebee until the events of the first film were over. There's no plot hole there.
As for the morality of the Autobots...you can't blame Orci & Kurtzman for that. There are plenty of things you can blame them for, when it comes to these movies, but that's not one of them.
The comics, both Marvel and now Dreamwave/IDW had some dark storylines and violent Autobots. O&K just carried on the tradition.
shamone wrote:difference between animated movie 9which had its flaws no doubt) was that the cons were on berserker kill mode, so prime was merely defending him.
In rotf, he executed an escaping con. and before that he used a quip

thats what seems off for me. Again as a geen wuner, thats not my prime. not the prime who sacrificed himself because he killed characters in a video game (crazy i know, but showed his respect for all life)
See, that's your first mistake. This is not G1. This is a reboot that merely shares the same characters and places, but not the situations or the personalities. This is a whole new TF universe and can't and shouldn't be compared to G1.
There is no comparison.
I fell in love with TransFormers through G1. Fan since '84. While the 'toon will always have a special place in my heart, I can see that it's not the end all, be all of the TF universe. It shouldn't be either.
toothdoc wrote:If you hated the movies so much why are you here posting? It just doesn't make sense to a sane person when someone supposedly hates something, but yet they try to partcipate in a discussion about that very thing they hate. I suggest you seek the guidance of a good shrink to find out what your issues are.
C'mon, this is just rude, man. He specifically asked people to be respectful, and you know what? He's right. It's not too much to ask.
Even if we don't agree, he is entitled to his opinion, and he most certainly has the right to discuss it, just like the rest of us.
I'm not trying to be a jerk here, but you're going a little overboard here.
SlyTF1 wrote:So, Shanghai, the forest battle, The Fallen's arrival, the Nemesis scene, the warehouse scene, Megatron's revival, the Well of Allsparks, Optimus's rebirth, Devastator's transformation, Optimus jumping out of a freaking airplane, Jetfire and Optimus combining, and I'm pretty sure there are ass loads more; never happened. Ok.
And the battles in the first movie did not give frame to the movie. Every fight scene with robots was either shaky as hell, or cut to humans running in the middle. At least in ROTF we got to see some robot ass kicking instead of blurry images of giant piles of car parts zooming past the camera, with people running in the foreground and explosions going off behind them.
All good points, especially the part about the battles in the first film.
Iamwarhorse wrote:^Yeah, it took the movie verse Transformers to make me into a fan. The cartoon was beyond cheesy for my tastes. I want bad ass robots. And, with Demolisher, Optimus was being merciful. He put the poor thing out of his misery!
I was already a fan when they came out, but I can certainly see the draw that the movies have. I'd be a fan if I hadn't been, thanks to the movies.
Capt.Failure wrote:Considering Demolisher just killed about a dozen NEST soldiers and who knows how many civilians when he plowed through Shanghai, I think a bullet to the brainbox was being a little too merciful.
And I agree, why post on these forums if you're just going to stirr up trouble about how much you hate the movies? You're either trying too hard to be a troll, or you're secretly in denial that you like them.
Two of you making personal insults? Why? I'm a big supporter of the movie verse as a whole, especially ROTF, but this isn't necessary. Not cool dude, not cool.

As for me, the movies are my thing, but they're not perfect.