Deadput wrote:Why is this absolutely dumb argument even happening?
WHY?!
Because not everyone takes everything at face value. I mean, they just swerved us with Galvatron actually being Galvatron II.
Emerje
Deadput wrote:Why is this absolutely dumb argument even happening?
WHY?!
Emerje wrote:Deadput wrote:Why is this absolutely dumb argument even happening?
WHY?!
Because not everyone takes everything at face value. I mean, they just swerved us with Galvatron actually being Galvatron II.
Emerje
o.supreme wrote:william-james88 wrote: These are still the same people who haven't explained how Ratchet is alive and well.
Yeah that's a tough one. I used to think, with respect specifically to Wheeljack's appearance in Victory that perhaps *somehow* he wasn't fully dead in TFTM, and he survived somehow, or the Autobots resurrected him. But the fact that in Dark Awakening, all the Autobots who supposedly died in the events of the movie, their bodies were sent into a star in that tomb ship...kind of hard to come back from that.
Maybe here on Seibertron, but in other places, back when the Grand Galvatron set was revealed, others were going "Hey, it's IDW Roller!" almost immediately after the reveal happened. Even here on this board did we have such folks as Mindmaster and SW's SilverHammer who were quick to recognize him as IDW Roller.o.supreme wrote:I just think it speaks volumes that so many of us fans assumed Wandering Roller was Roller from the original series.
Takara was simply looking to release the Rook mold as-is in Japan without any remolding. Sakamoto worked on MTMTE, was familiar with the character, and evidently felt that IDW Roller was a good enough fit to redeco the Rook mold into. I mean, since when is MTMTE considered "obscure" by this fandom in this day and age? It's arguably the most popular English-language Transformers fiction in the whole fandom at this present time.o.supreme wrote:I'm not trying to knock IDW here. I own, and have read every issue, but obviously the memories of these events are just not sticking, or are just not well known for so many people to assume differently. They go with what's familiar, what they know. Though WR may in fact be IDW Roller, this begs the question, why make such an obscure choice? All the other members of Grand Galvatron are based on characters from various animated series that are arguably much more well known.
Preach it!Kurona wrote:Well... why not?
We don't really need to know the reason behind the choice. I just find it bizarre that this argument is happening at all; every single piece of evidence points towards this being a version of the IDW Roller rather than the drone. If you want to imagine it's the drone, then cool, all the power to you. These are at the end of the day toys and you can do with them what you like and headcanon what you like; imagination's one of the best things Transformers has inspired in my opinion.
But in terms of facts and what this is supposed to be, it's very clearly supposed to be IDW Roller. Again, everything points towards it and I just don't see why there's any doubt about it.
I'm thinking (and hoping) it's the latter. Unicron summoned Grand Scourge to deal with Baldigus and the guy is tricking Baldigus into thinking Grand Scourge is Black Convoy, all so that Grand Scourge can catch the combiner with his guard down.Coptur wrote:Autobot N wrote:http://imgur.com/a/tm4Gn
Thank you Autobot N
So if i'm reading this correctly Grand Scourge is Black Convoy/Scourge?? or....is he deceiving Ruination to gain his trust??
The Galvatron II reveal doesn't even make any sense. That guy isn't suppose to show up in this universe until after G-2, and the Grand Galvatron comic has the Galvatron in that comic possessing knowledge/memories that Galvatron II isn't supposed to have, but which Cartoon Galvatron is supposed to have.Coptur wrote:I Wonder why Galvatron II's ghost appeared above G1-JapToon Galvatron's body..ah man i need to read up on Galvatron II again from the old G1-Comic.
But the story doesn't call him "Breakdown", it calls him "War Breakdown". Breakdown was renamed "War Breakdown" in the Japanese dub of the Prime cartoon. Plus, multiple characters can have the same name. This Baldigus comic alone contains a team called the Combatrons who Megatronia even remarks as a different set of Combatrons from those who form Bruticus. IDW's even made a whole deal about two guys both named "Tankor".Emerje wrote:Sabrblade wrote:And yet, modern fictions have gone and transplanted originally non-G1 characters into G1-set stories as new G1 versions of those characters who look exactly the same as their original non-G1 counterparts. Both IDW and Fun Pub have been extremely guilty of this lately, so what makes that Thrust and that Breakdown stand out as obviously being the original non-G1 versions of those two instead of the same kind of G1-transplanted versions that IDW and Fun Pub have done and which you're suggesting has been done for Roller?
Well that's easy, it's because the story tells us so. G1 Breakdown has never been portrayed as being a zombie, but the Breadown in the comic that looks just like Prime Breakdown has.
Being a G1 version of Armada Thrust wouldn't make a G1-transplanted Armada Thrust analogue automatically be the same guy as G1 Thrust. It would just make him yet another guy named "Thrust" in a G1 setting.Emerje wrote:Likewise G1 Thrust never dealt directly with Unicron, but the guy in the comic that looks just like Micron Legends Thrust sure has.
Oh really? Well, how about all of those originally non-G1 characters whom Fun Pub, and IDW (and even Hasbro via their Legends mobile game), have just straight up put into G1 settings with their original non-G1 designs carried over wholecloth? Knock Out. "Breakdown". Thunderhoof. Synapse (top-right Armada Sparkplug-looking dude). Twirl. Overrun/Surge. Wind Sheer. Skyfire. Bulkhead. Hot Shot. Heavy Barrel (based on an Armada Mini-Con). All of them are G1 characters based on non-G1 characters and whose designs look exactly like those of the non-G1 chracters they're based on, rather than their designs having been changed to look like any G1 characters who may or may not happen to share their names.Emerje wrote:And really, when Fun Pub uses an unrelated design to represent the G1 version of another character they at least to make them look a little like the character they're supposed to represent.
But doesn't a character's robot mode matter more than its altmode when it comes to the character's personal identity? After all, we're talking about a race of robotic people that turn into objects, not a race of sentient objects that turn into humanoid robots. They're robots in disguise, meaning the altmode is a disguise, as in a falsehood that hides the character's true nature. Thus, shouldn't we be looking to the robot mode, rather than the altmode, for determining "who", rather than "what", a character personally is?Emerje wrote:But if Sakamoto wanted it to be the G1 Cartoon Roller, why wouldn't he have just drawn the original drone vehicle instead of drawing the IDW character at all? Why would the G1 Cartoon Roller need to be represented by a robot mode it never had before and which the average Japanese fan wouldn't recognize as much as they would the little car form that that Roller always had? It doesn't make sense for Sakamoto to have presented IDW Roller's robot mode as G1 Cartoon Roller for an audience that isn't that familiar with the IDW character or his name affiliation with the little drone buggy that they do know of.
Don't forget, the whole point of this combiner was for Takara Tomy to use figures and head sculpts they hadn't used yet. The Rook mold would have been locked in already, but who else are you going to use to represent a six-wheeled vehicle like that? You talk about dual homages, well I think G1 Roller was the original intent for the character and the bot mode color scheme was chosen as a homage to the IDW version, but not representative of him. You spoke before about non-G1 characters being used to represent G1 characters, well that's what I think is happening here. I think he shadowed his image so we wouldn't think it was the same IDW character.
But there are Japanese fans of the IDW comics. Just last BotCon there were a bunch of Japanese people coming up to Sakamoto's Artist Alley booth asking him to draw IDW-original characters like Nickel and Sunder.Emerje wrote:And it's not like Roller's so completely shadowed as to be unrecognizable to those who do know of him. His blue, orange, and gray colors are all quite visible on my screen.
"Those who do" being what tiny sliver of a fraction of the Japanese fan base? Seems like if he wanted it to be IDW Roller he'd have just drawn IDW roller and be done with it. I'm sure he didn't do it for the slightly larger sliver of a fraction of English speaking fans that know about IDW Roller.
Emerje
Kurona wrote:
Well, it is just Roller talking there. Doesn't give Optimus a chance to say anything more than his name. Maybe he's just a bit delusional
Indeed!D-Maximus_Prime wrote:Well I mean, the only thing Optimus says is "Roller!", and it looks like Roller is implying they can talk later and maybe not know that this Prime isn't his. Plus, Prime could have been informed by either the Oracle or by combination with the others that this guy was Roller and he was angry.
And yet, you do so for Thrust and Breakdown. Why accept them at face value but seek something deeper beneath the surface for Roller when all three are presented by their bios and the comic in equal fashions?Emerje wrote:Deadput wrote:Why is this absolutely dumb argument even happening?
WHY?!
Because not everyone takes everything at face value.
Which makes no sense given the reasons I mentioned above in this post.Emerje wrote:I mean, they just swerved us with Galvatron actually being Galvatron II.
While it does help explain how Cartoon Galvatron gets reborn later as Super Megatron, it also conflicts with how the Galvatron seen in the Grand Galvatron comic was portrayed, as that Galvatron reads more as Cartoon Galvatron rather than Galvatron II.fenrir72 wrote:That was what was bugging me and I thought that just by possessing Cyclonus, anime Galvatron colors turns into G1 toy color Galvatron
(a side effect) then now he is Galvatron II. But this makes sense as anime Galvatron would later be resurrected as Super Megatron in Return of Convoy/Battlestars there bye not affecting the time stream
Shadowman wrote:This is Sabrblade we're talking about. His ability to store trivial information about TV shows is downright superhuman.
Caelus wrote:My wife pointed out something interesting about the prehistoric Predacons. I said that everyone was complaining because transforming for them mostly consisted of them just standing up-right. She essentially said, 'So? That's what our ancestors did.'
Windsweeper wrote:Always love the artwork in these Japanese comics.
Always love to see other continuity Transformers introduced into G1.
Deadput wrote:Why is this absolutely dumb argument even happening?
WHY?!
Takara evidently wanted to release those hands and feet into their market somehow, so this is their way of doing that. And it's a good way too since those feet better resemble how Bladigus's feet looked in the cartoon than the CW HFGs as feet do.Black Hat wrote:Damn, he looks good. Shame the hands and feet kinda suck (though the feet LOOK cool) because they're the only bitter nugget in an otherwise delicious stew of toy goodness.
Shadowman wrote:This is Sabrblade we're talking about. His ability to store trivial information about TV shows is downright superhuman.
Caelus wrote:My wife pointed out something interesting about the prehistoric Predacons. I said that everyone was complaining because transforming for them mostly consisted of them just standing up-right. She essentially said, 'So? That's what our ancestors did.'
Sabrblade wrote:Takara evidently wanted to release those hands and feet into their market somehow, so this is their way of doing that. And it's a good way too since those feet better resemble how Bladigus's feet looked in the cartoon than the CW HFGs as feet do.Black Hat wrote:Damn, he looks good. Shame the hands and feet kinda suck (though the feet LOOK cool) because they're the only bitter nugget in an otherwise delicious stew of toy goodness.
D-Maximus_Prime wrote:He's being released in 9 days?! wow, that was a quick turnaround from his reveal
To be fair, though, the HFGs as feet have zero ankle articulation, so the CW computron feet at least offer some diversity in posable stances. And all we really need the hands to do is hold each gun in its grip. Otherwise, as long as the hands can each make a fist for Baldigus to punch his foes, I'd say they serve their purpose decently enough. It's not like Baldigus is gonna need open palms to hive-five, wave to, or slap somebody.Black Hat wrote:Sabrblade wrote:Takara evidently wanted to release those hands and feet into their market somehow, so this is their way of doing that. And it's a good way too since those feet better resemble how Bladigus's feet looked in the cartoon than the CW HFGs as feet do.Black Hat wrote:Damn, he looks good. Shame the hands and feet kinda suck (though the feet LOOK cool) because they're the only bitter nugget in an otherwise delicious stew of toy goodness.
Oh I totally understand why they used them, I just don't like them. The hands are completely inarticulate, which sucks, and the feet have no forward-and-backward motion and are hollow shells, which also sucks. I think the feet at least LOOK the part, but compared to other hand options available, and even other hands HasTak has made (like Unicron's gorgeous grabbers) the single-cast fist lumps seem a bit feeble.
Shadowman wrote:This is Sabrblade we're talking about. His ability to store trivial information about TV shows is downright superhuman.
Caelus wrote:My wife pointed out something interesting about the prehistoric Predacons. I said that everyone was complaining because transforming for them mostly consisted of them just standing up-right. She essentially said, 'So? That's what our ancestors did.'
william-james88 wrote:D-Maximus_Prime wrote:He's being released in 9 days?! wow, that was a quick turnaround from his reveal
He's up for preorder in Japan in 9 days
Sabrblade wrote:To be fair, though, the HFGs as feet have zero ankle articulation, so the CW computron feet at least offer some diversity in posable stances. And all we really need the hands to do is hold each gun in its grip. Otherwise, as long as the hands can each make a fist for Baldigus to punch his foes, I'd say they serve their purpose decently enough. It's not like Baldigus is gonna need open palms to hive-five, wave to, or slap somebody.Black Hat wrote:Sabrblade wrote:Takara evidently wanted to release those hands and feet into their market somehow, so this is their way of doing that. And it's a good way too since those feet better resemble how Bladigus's feet looked in the cartoon than the CW HFGs as feet do.Black Hat wrote:Damn, he looks good. Shame the hands and feet kinda suck (though the feet LOOK cool) because they're the only bitter nugget in an otherwise delicious stew of toy goodness.
Oh I totally understand why they used them, I just don't like them. The hands are completely inarticulate, which sucks, and the feet have no forward-and-backward motion and are hollow shells, which also sucks. I think the feet at least LOOK the part, but compared to other hand options available, and even other hands HasTak has made (like Unicron's gorgeous grabbers) the single-cast fist lumps seem a bit feeble.
At the very least, the hands aren't like the original toy's G1-molded fists, which were solid pieces of hollowed-out plastic:Black Hat wrote:Yeah I suppose, I'm just a big fan of articulated hands in general. They're fun. And I must be honest, whilst they SUCKED as feet, HFGs made pretty good hands and surprisingly good weapons.
Shadowman wrote:This is Sabrblade we're talking about. His ability to store trivial information about TV shows is downright superhuman.
Caelus wrote:My wife pointed out something interesting about the prehistoric Predacons. I said that everyone was complaining because transforming for them mostly consisted of them just standing up-right. She essentially said, 'So? That's what our ancestors did.'
Sabrblade wrote:At the very least, the hands aren't like the original toy's G1-molded fists, which were solid pieces of hollowed-out plastic:Black Hat wrote:Yeah I suppose, I'm just a big fan of articulated hands in general. They're fun. And I must be honest, whilst they SUCKED as feet, HFGs made pretty good hands and surprisingly good weapons.
To be fair to Dangar/Armorhide, he only wore and used his tank mode's double cannons once in a single episode, and without fanfare or even a name for his attack that used them (his use of them was part of a group attack by all five combining Combatrons/Commandos firing all of their guns on Scourge's/Black Convoy's order to fire). Every other appearance of his tank mode in the series featured it without the extra cannons.Kurona wrote:Admittedly if the HFGs had to be forgone for any set, it's a shame it had to be forgone on a set with the tank mold. While said mold has so many negatives, it's HFG integration with the twin cannons sitting on the back to replicate the original toy's weapon is really neat and I love posing Brawl's vehicle mode like that.
Shadowman wrote:This is Sabrblade we're talking about. His ability to store trivial information about TV shows is downright superhuman.
Caelus wrote:My wife pointed out something interesting about the prehistoric Predacons. I said that everyone was complaining because transforming for them mostly consisted of them just standing up-right. She essentially said, 'So? That's what our ancestors did.'
Sabrblade wrote:To be fair to Dangar/Armorhide, he only wore and used his tank mode's double cannons once in a single episode, and without fanfare or even a name for his attack that used them (his use of them was part of a group attack by all five combining Combatrons/Commandos firing all of their guns on Scourge's/Black Convoy's order to fire). Every other appearance of his tank mode in the series featured it without the extra cannons.Kurona wrote:Admittedly if the HFGs had to be forgone for any set, it's a shame it had to be forgone on a set with the tank mold. While said mold has so many negatives, it's HFG integration with the twin cannons sitting on the back to replicate the original toy's weapon is really neat and I love posing Brawl's vehicle mode like that.
It would have been nice for this toy to have included something to represent those extra twin cannons, but I am glad that they at least included an extra handgun to represent the original's handgun ("Dangar Gun") that was a different weapon from his tank gun ("Dangar Cannon").
If need be, finding another extra HFG on the secondary market shouldn't be much of a task.
Sabrblade wrote:Maybe here on Seibertron, but in other places, back when the Grand Galvatron set was revealed, others were going "Hey, it's IDW Roller!" almost immediately after the reveal happened. Even here on this board did we have such folks as Mindmaster and SW's SilverHammer who were quick to recognize him as IDW Roller.o.supreme wrote:I just think it speaks volumes that so many of us fans assumed Wandering Roller was Roller from the original series.
I mean, since when is MTMTE considered "obscure" by this fandom in this day and age? It's arguably the most popular English-language Transformers fiction in the whole fandom at this present time.
But the story doesn't call him "Breakdown", it calls him "War Breakdown". Breakdown was renamed "War Breakdown" in the Japanese dub of the Prime cartoon. Plus, multiple characters can have the same name. This Baldigus comic alone contains a team called the Combatrons who Megatronia even remarks as a different set of Combatrons from those who form Bruticus. IDW's even made a whole deal about two guys both named "Tankor".
Being a G1 version of Armada Thrust wouldn't make a G1-transplanted Armada Thrust analogue automatically be the same guy as G1 Thrust. It would just make him yet another guy named "Thrust" in a G1 setting.
Though, you're accepting what is said about that Thrust having dealt with Unicron at "face value" (which you use later), so why is there some sort of double-standard for when it comes to Roller?
Oh really? Well, how about all of those originally non-G1 characters whom Fun Pub, and IDW (and even Hasbro via their Legends mobile game), have just straight up put into G1 settings with their original non-G1 designs carried over wholecloth? Knock Out. "Breakdown". Thunderhoof. Synapse (top-right Armada Sparkplug-looking dude). Twirl. Overrun/Surge. Wind Sheer. Skyfire. Bulkhead. Hot Shot. Heavy Barrel (based on an Armada Mini-Con). All of them are G1 characters based on non-G1 characters and whose designs look exactly like those of the non-G1 chracters they're based on, rather than their designs having been changed to look like any G1 characters who may or may not happen to share their names.
Or what of those whose designs Fun Pub/IDW/etc. only changed a little but still look like their non-G1 counterparts? Override. Lightbright. Sky-Byte. Skidmark (based on an Armada Mini-Con). Treadshot. Ransack. Crumplezone. Ser-Ket (bottom-right winged one).
But doesn't a character's robot mode matter more than its altmode when it comes to the character's personal identity? After all, we're talking about a race of robotic people that turn into objects, not a race of sentient objects that turn into humanoid robots. They're robots in disguise, meaning the altmode is a disguise, as in a falsehood that hides the character's true nature. Thus, shouldn't we be looking to the robot mode, rather than the altmode, for determining "who", rather than "what", a character personally is?
But there are Japanese fans of the IDW comics. Just last BotCon there were a bunch of Japanese people coming up to Sakamoto's Artist Alley booth asking him to draw IDW-original characters like Nickel and Sunder.
The Japanese IDW fandom may not be huge, but that there is one shows that there are Japanese fans hardcore enough to be into those comics, and it's those kinds of hardcore Transformers fans (of any country) that Sakamoto likes to throw bones to with his hardcore brand of continuity fanwank.
Shadowman wrote:This is Sabrblade we're talking about. His ability to store trivial information about TV shows is downright superhuman.
Caelus wrote:My wife pointed out something interesting about the prehistoric Predacons. I said that everyone was complaining because transforming for them mostly consisted of them just standing up-right. She essentially said, 'So? That's what our ancestors did.'
Return to Transformers Toys Discussion
Registered users: Bing [Bot], Google [Bot], Google Adsense [Bot], Google Feedfetcher, kryslarry, LE0KING, Majestic-12 [Bot], megatronus, MSN [Bot], MSNbot Media, Whifflefire