Counterpunch Reviews 2008's Toys and Trends

Counterpunch Reviews 2008's Toys and Trends

Wednesday, December 31st, 2008 3:05pm CST

Category: Site Articles
Posted by: Counterpunch   Views: 102,150

Topic Options: View Discussion · Sign in or Join to reply

I have to start off with something of an apology; it’s been sometime since I was able to put pen to paper and through coffee induced wizardry, draft up something worth either my time to write or, and more importantly, your time to read. Most of the time, writing about the hobby is something that I find to be fun and relaxing, but for the past few months, I have found it to be dreadfully uninspiring. There just did not seem to be anything worth commenting on.

I know, I know that there will be those who disagree with that last statement, but in comparison to last year where there was the magical mixture of new fans plus controversy, 2008 was seemingly rather ‘blah’. Taking task to sit down and drum up the highlights of the year in review, it began to dawn on me just how incorrect that assessment was.

2008 was something of a different game for me and I am going to have to assume a good number of other collectors out there. First off, the 2007 Movie changed, well, everything. For the first time in twenty years, Transformers was getting Star Wars level of attention in terms of media and toy aisle space. The brand moved to something new and different with the Movie look. The Transformers we knew were now distinctly alien to many. When it was all said and done, there was no return to normalcy. Transformers Animated picked up the reins and took the brand back to the other end of the extreme with a softer, cartoon based, and fresh look at both the media and toys.

I can admit it, for the first time since before Robots in Disguise, I did not find any real enjoyment of the main line Transformers being offered. I was not in ‘the thick’ of the hobby and this was entirely new to me. Now before you either 1) Attempt to hang me or 2) Try to defend either the Movie or Animated, understand that I do not dislike either one. I just don’t prefer them. Like choosing coffee over tea, it is just a matter of preference.

Why am I telling you all this? Why the big preface? Because I know, I am not the only one in a similar circumstance. To properly review 2008, I have to start with the things that were important everyone, not only my view on the matter.


As someone who has been around for a while in the hobby, I feel like I have a unique perspective on this matter and I am prepared to lay it all out straight, the good and the bad. Interestingly enough, Animated, it’s success, and the fan reaction reminds me, to the point of acid induced flashback, of Armada. The vivid colors, rounded designs, and orientation towards a younger audience all harkens back to those days. To a point, so does the very divided fan reaction to Animated’s arrival. While many find the designs to be refreshing and the direct representation of on screen characters to toys as the line’s most positive attributes, others decry the line’s lack of details and cartoon representations to lack a degree of “maturity”. I think if I looked hard enough, I could go back a few years and find the exact same thing said about Armada.

Now, no matter how you feel about the style of Animated, the designs are well, revolutionary. For the first time in a few years, the engineering has leaped forward. The transformations maintain the style of the brand in both vehicle and bot modes. The robots are near perfect representations of the on-screen characters and unlike Armada, Animated is able to fully articulate the toys and sacrifice next to nothing in regards to the character. Brilliant releases where the toys are pretty much marvels of modern engineering include Prowl, Ultra Magnus, and Bulkhead.

One interesting side effect of Animated (and its now forgotten about delays in coming to market), was the rise of prototype and test shot figure sales. This had a small start with the Movie line, but 2008 saw an almost rabid competition among collectors to gather these protos up from China and be the first to have and/or review them to their collecting brethren, bringing us to…

For a time, there was a grand standard upheld by many collecting veterans of relying upon our friends in Japan and Hong Kong to provide detailed reviews with pictures. The East simply got everything first and like clockwork, you could count on your neighbors half a world away to review and provide pictures of toys that you wouldn’t see for months. Whether a simple attempt to gather up internet fame or a more substantial desire to provide a ‘first look’, YouTube has become the market place for video reviews, commentary, and all manner of fan-based interaction. Many of these online reviewers were, well, simply not all that good at first. Lighting, sound, charm…well, all those things require a degree of practice and it took time, but there are now, numerous means of seeing your favorite toy (that you don’t own yet) on the small screen well before you find him in the store. Some of them are even quite good. I have to admit to missing the days of pictorial review. Maybe I’m old fashioned, but I suppose I prefer to see the pictures without all that pesky sound…

That being said, all those out there who are devoting time, effort, and money to spreading knowledge about our hobby are to be commended. Efforts like these are at the heart of making a fan community grow and are ahead of the curve compared to old goats like me who just punch keyboards until something mildly intelligent comes out of it.

G1 and the Expense Report

2008 was without a doubt, an amazing year for G1 collectors and fans. 2008 was a vicious wallet destroying plague for G1 collectors and fans. I simply can not remember when we have had so many significant, large, and otherwise expensive G1 releases in one year. I do not, as a habit, complain about prices as this is a hobby where I have said on numerous occasions, “pay to play”. I still support that statement, however, please consider: Encore Skylynx $75, Encore Omega $85, Encore Metroplex $85, eHobby City Guardian Omega Supreme (Omega Sentinel) $200+, Masterpiece Thundercracker $105… So, around $550 in large reissue figures all in one year. Takara, Tomy…whatever it is now,…I am at the very least impressed with your faith in the fandom’s ability to absorb all that in one year.

Now, consider this, two of those figures (and kind of three) were thought to be strict no-no releases. Everyone including myself thought that Sky Lynx and Omega Supreme were just off limits. Takara…er, Tomy, whatever, has done an excellent job of kicking collector’s expectations of what they can and can’t do right in the balls this year. Roshambo Takara, Roshambo indeed…

For a long time, knock-offs and bootlegged transformers were something of a spectacle or slight amusement to many collectors. They were of poor quality, odd sizes, and radical colors. When they were not those things, they were clear, black, or vac-metaled to hell and back.

Now, we have bootlegged Transformers that are almost indistinguishable from vintage items. Mirage, Gnaw, Slag, Wheeljack, Metroplex and several other difficult to obtain G1 toys have become forever wrapped up in a set of events which will drive vintage collectors to the deepest catacombs of the internet to document the differences between the originals. With the dawn of this new collecting challenge, there has also been a significant number of people ready and willing to support this new market. The battle lines on the matter are clearly drawn, those in favor of the bootlegged Transformers see this as an opportunity to own formerly impossibly expensive and difficult to find pieces. They feel strongly that these releases have no effect on the collecting market. The other side finds these bootlegs to be a real problem which tarnishes the vintage market. Recent news of Encore Reissue Metroplexes having been replaced with Chinese bootlegs and the subsequent vomit reflex most collectors encountered in regards to this all indicates that the Almighty himself has sided with the anti-KO/Bootleg crowd.

Garage Companies

In other somewhat related news, the City Commander Upgrade Armor set for Classics Ultra Magnus descended from Heaven in October of this year to rowdy applause and a flurry of adulation. A handful of people claimed to either not like, or have no interest in the armor, but it is assumed that they are taking this stand on things to simply up their ‘street-cred’.

Where as years past have seen similar attempts at home-brewed Transformers merchandise and add on sets, most of those attempts where borderline disastrous or otherwise quickly forgotten. The City Commander set marks a turning point by doing two very crucial things for these garage companies. 1) It’s garnered attention from the community and established a critical mass of people who are willing to pay and eager to be amazed. 2) It’s brought about an element of trust between the community at large and these smaller businesses. We aren’t talking about fragile or poorly made materials here, this new wave of DIY Transformers products are just a shade off of what Takara/Tomy and Hasbro are providing in terms of quality. Most interesting, is that the level of engineering is already equal to the Official Transformers product and is in many ways more responsive to what collectors want to see. Where Takara/Tomy and Hasbro come up short due to cost concerns, fans now have a slight hope that this alternative product will provide.

Henkei-a-go-go and the return of Classics aka Universe

Takara/Tomy really gets a bit more credit than they deserve…in a way. Hindsight is always 20/20 and with the release of Henkei Transformers, the Japanese counterpart to US based Classics, Takara/Tomy is able to spend a good deal more on paint apps and reconfigure colors and decos to give fans an even more G1-y experience than before. Henkei has been somewhat of an incredible and yet overpaid 6th man, leaping up from the bench to perform on-court miracles when the home team is just not delivering. Henkei gave collectors another shot at each of the Classics toys, with an alternate deco, and a price tag with 100% mark-up. Where it is great, it is incredible, where it fails, it gets ugly.

Henkei Megatron and Astrotrain provided beautiful alternatives to the somewhat garish US releases of those toys while Bumblebee and Mirage really only provided inflated price tags. Speaking of inflate price tags, USA editions of Powerglide, Silverbolt, and Onslaught were available on the Japanese market, each of the three sporting a very G1 look in comparison to the US releases, each one also carrying a hefty price tag.

Henkei went and did something that for a while, we thought would never happen based upon everything told to collectors at various BotCons and from various panels over the years. Henkei provided collectors a second bite at the apple with the release of a Japanese exclusive Thundercracker. In comparison to the pure outrage that struck many collectors when Thundercracker was released as part of the very limited BotCon set, the fan response to the Henkei release of Thundercracker was quite mild. It was not the kind of victory that those who had been clamoring for Thundercracker’s general release were hoping for, the $75-80 price tag saw to that. Then again, dispelling the force behind what ‘BotCon Exclusive’ meant took the wind out of several collectors, this one included. The interesting thing that became evident to anyone who kept on top of the information, was the revelation of exactly how and to what extent, the term ‘exclusive’ applied to the collector’s market.

Completing the trend, Classics came back to the US and Western markets with the advent of the Universe line. G1 fan favorites Sunstreaker, Prowl, and Octane ushered in the new line in July of this year followed by the Ultra Class Powerglide, Onslaught, and Silverbolt. As with Animated’s release earlier in the year, quality control issues were prevalent much to the aggravation of fans everywhere. Hope for classic characters like Ironhide and Hound have finally come around and those who managed to keep faith in the idea that Classics would return were rewarded with some outstanding as well as mediocre figures.

So, perhaps 2008 was really not all that boring when I reconsider it. It was a different year in almost every regard. New toys, new designs, new lines, yet still some of the old favorites continued. Somehow I managed to sit out a lot of the year in terms of buying things as a result of being uninterested in Animated, but all the same I managed to buy a lot, and I mean a lot of toys. This strikes me as being very cool, if I may use that sacred term so loosely. 2008 was indeed a good year because even if it did not beat us over the head with the Movie’s release, heated arguments, or expensive toys…wait, it definitely did do that last one, it gave us a range of options and a selection of awesome that was quite wide.

Here’s hoping for a great 2009, a continuation of interesting and surprising releases from Hasbro & Takara/Tomy, and hopefully a raise or two so that we can all afford it.

Please refrain from responding until you're positive you've had enough to drink tonight to make your post interesting. :wink:

Credit(s): Counterpunch

News Search

Got Transformers News? Let us know here!

Re: Counterpunch Reviews 2008's Toys and Trends (859271)
Posted by neliz on December 31st, 2008 @ 3:13pm CST
burp, good article PCP!

and happy new year!

Drinking Tsingtao beer.
Re: Counterpunch Reviews 2008's Toys and Trends (859280)
Posted by Narc on December 31st, 2008 @ 3:39pm CST
Well said. We had a good year in 2008.

Happy New Year!!! Here's to 2009 (drinks Chivas on the rocks)!!! :D
Re: Counterpunch Reviews 2008's Toys and Trends (859287)
Posted by frogbat on December 31st, 2008 @ 3:53pm CST
good article - I can relate as i limit myself to g1 related purchases and it's been an expensive year and i held back a lot. And though I don't collect the new lines except for the token representative, I enjoyed all the TF universe in 2007 and 8

here's to an even more expensive 2009!
Re: Counterpunch Reviews 2008's Toys and Trends (859297)
Posted by ultra_magus on December 31st, 2008 @ 4:13pm CST
Counterpunch, I salute you! That's a great wrap-up of the year-that-was. :APPLAUSE: :APPLAUSE:
Also, thanks for the pic of you collection. I'm gonna show my wife that my collection has a LONG way to go yet! :grin:
Re: Counterpunch Reviews 2008's Toys and Trends (859325)
Posted by Geekee1 on December 31st, 2008 @ 4:55pm CST
ultra_magus wrote:Counterpunch, I salute you! That's a great wrap-up of the year-that-was. :APPLAUSE: :APPLAUSE:
Also, thanks for the pic of you collection. I'm gonna show my wife that my collection has a LONG way to go yet! :grin:

And that's not even the whole thing!

Great article man, best read I've had in awhile.
Re: Counterpunch Reviews 2008's Toys and Trends (859334)
Posted by ReinaHW on December 31st, 2008 @ 5:17pm CST
I don't drink, so I'm sober as usual. Good review there and I agree with it all. 2008 has been a somewhat humdrum year in terms of TF's, the Classics have been good, but hard to find beyond the US and Japan, Animated is so-so, the cartoon was alright aside from the terrible art style, the rest wasn't bad.
Maybe next year things will be better.

Re: Counterpunch Reviews 2008's Toys and Trends (859342)
Posted by dragons on December 31st, 2008 @ 5:28pm CST
i completly 1000% agree with you ecpecialy with the g1 figures i dont understadn why the g1 figures are so expensive even the encore, & reissues the encore & re issues should be cheaper to get even on ebay sometimes but there not depends who your looking for i guess that the price is right & sopme master piece figures well.

no matter where get utlramagns mp version hes the expensive ther is while megatron hes the one thats surprises me & continues to shock me still megatron mp is cheaper than mp ultramagnus no matter what store you get him from whats the connection megatron i expected to be more since hes all metal but magnus 90% metal & 10% plastic same as prime differnt color, name and maybe bio connection somewhere i dont get it?
Re: Counterpunch Reviews 2008's Toys and Trends (859352)
Posted by Archanubis on December 31st, 2008 @ 5:35pm CST
I have to say that the City Commander Upgrade was the best release this year. As for YouTube reviews... eh, I prefer to read toy reviews rather than listen to 'em, but to each their own.
Re: Counterpunch Reviews 2008's Toys and Trends (859435)
Posted by coolpop on December 31st, 2008 @ 8:48pm CST
Thanks for sharing CP, great article indeed.
Re: Counterpunch Reviews 2008's Toys and Trends (859474)
Posted by Forgotten on December 31st, 2008 @ 10:19pm CST
:APPLAUSE: :APPLAUSE: :APPLAUSE: excellent summary. I hope that all of us are lucky enough in 2009 to be able to continue doing the thing that makes us all so happy and helps us stay young at heart if not in life. (Raises glass of Woodford Reserve)Here's to 2009 may it be the best for us yet.
Re: Counterpunch Reviews 2008's Toys and Trends (859490)
Posted by Nickolai on December 31st, 2008 @ 11:38pm CST
Excellent work, CP. I spent most of this year catching up with old releases, so I was unable to appreciate most of the goodness for what it was. I look forward to catching up again this year, but with the 2008 stuff.
Re: Counterpunch Reviews 2008's Toys and Trends (859505)
Posted by WolfDawg on January 1st, 2009 @ 2:37am CST
Great article, and I've been drinking all night so my post may or may not be interesting. Anyways, I agree with most of what you said, but I have to defend the Movie toys like Landmine and Stockade from the 08 part of the movie line. Those guys were great...Landmine being one of my favorite TF's period.

I also love the animated line and it's quickly surpassing RID and Beast Wars as my favorite TF toy line. The designs and variety of characters is very refreshing. I'm looking to an awesome new year of TF's (ROTF and Alternity the most). Let's keep the plastic crack coming!
Re: Counterpunch Reviews 2008's Toys and Trends (859537)
Posted by Tigertrack on January 1st, 2009 @ 7:25am CST
Excellent write up, and sum up of the year that has now passed.

I quite agree that the Transformers fans were treated to a huge amount of choice, and awesome-ness. I wish 2009 looked more optimistic, but with the impending movie, we lose some choices.

Still Masterpiece Grimlock, Alternity Prime and Megatron, and the rest of the 25th line may make the beginning of it memorable for me.
Re: Counterpunch Reviews 2008's Toys and Trends (859666)
Posted by Oilspill on January 1st, 2009 @ 11:26am CST
Great end-of-year wrap-up CP. I definitely enjoyed the Animated line, it is now one of my favourite lines and the show managed to get my GF watching.. so now she is involved with my favourite hobby :)

2009 should be cheaper for me, since I will probably not buy any movie toys (unless *spoiler*Devastator is really really cool).

But there is Masterpiece, and the rest of Universe and Animated to get (and one hopes they will release Animated season 3 toys).
Re: Counterpunch Reviews 2008's Toys and Trends (859671)
Posted by Nekoman on January 1st, 2009 @ 11:36am CST
tigertracks 24 wrote:I quite agree that the Transformers fans were treated to a huge amount of choice, and awesome-ness. I wish 2009 looked more optimistic, but with the impending movie, we lose some choices.

I don't see how 09 could be any less fun than 08. If you don't like movie, you're still going to have the Animated toys (plus a new season of episodes!) AND some Classics figures in the early parts of 09. then who knows what TT might give us...

Excellent article Ccounterpunch! 08 has been a heck of a lot more fun than I thought it'd be. Somehow I didn't think we'd be getting this much to enjoy, but I guess we sure did.
Re: Counterpunch Reviews 2008's Toys and Trends (859694)
Posted by 8 bit on January 1st, 2009 @ 12:16pm CST
In terms of collecting TFs, 2008 was a fun year for meā€”even though I traded my hunting ways for online shopping. The Target exclusives were awesome, Cyclonus is perfection, looking forward to TRU Countdown in 09!
Re: Counterpunch Reviews 2008's Toys and Trends (859705)
Posted by starfish on January 1st, 2009 @ 12:34pm CST
A bit of a mixed review, then.

Personally, I think we were spoiled this year, in that there was something for everyone. Even those who weren't hot on the Movie or Animated lines still got the Classics and Encore lines to fall back on.

Compare this to the 1990s, where you were kinda screwed if you didn't like Beast Wars or Animorphs!

So yeah, I think that it's a little harsh to say this was anything other than one of the best years for TFs ever, in terms of both variety and engineering.

There is one other point I'd like to add as a UK collector - the economic climate in the latter half of the year is such that the Pound has become horribly devalued, and as a result the cost of imports are ever rising. Nothing to do with Hasbro or Takara I know, but it stands as the one really black mark on what's otherwise been a good year for those of us across the pond.
Re: Counterpunch Reviews 2008's Toys and Trends (859767)
Posted by Iron Prime on January 1st, 2009 @ 1:57pm CST
Great work as always CP! Makes me look forward to your review of 2009 already... :grin:
Re: Counterpunch Reviews 2008's Toys and Trends (859852)
Posted by mmcfacialhair on January 1st, 2009 @ 4:12pm CST
Great review Counterpunch, it shed a lot of perspective light on 2008! I just have to say, in defense of the Henkei line, yes there was a 100% markup from the initial classics release back in '06, but you have to take into account the inflation classics gets in the aftermarket. For us newbie collectors, Henkei was a godsend; I bought my Henkei Bumblebee and Hot Rodimus about two months ago on clearance at BBTS for $16 apiece, when the classics versions were selling on Amazon for $50 each. Heck, classics Jetfire is going for over $100 at the moment on Amazon, and the Henkei version is going for $39.

Aside from that, though, great review.
Re: Counterpunch Reviews 2008's Toys and Trends (860231)
Posted by Optimist_Prime on January 2nd, 2009 @ 9:50am CST
I'm always impressed by your writings CP. Did you major in journalism? I'm not sure I have any thing terribly interesting to say on the matter. 2008 was definitely a pricey one for me as well, and I'm not collecting Encore or Animated. I think I also may have had a small panic attack in Nov. as my dad knocked my City Commander off a shelf, but it didn't break.

Anyway great article CP. Happy New Year to ya.

Featured Products on

Buy "Transformers Authentics Grimlock Action Figure" on AMAZON
Buy "Transformers: Bumblebee -- Energon Igniters Nitro Series Barricade" on AMAZON
Buy "Transformers: Generations Power of The Primes Legends Class Roadtrap" on AMAZON
Buy "Transformers Studio Series 13 Voyager Class Movie 2 Megatron" on AMAZON
Buy "Transformers Toys Megatron Cyberverse Ultimate Class Action Figure - Repeatable Fusion Mega Shot Action Attack Move - Toys for Kids 6 and Up, 11.5-inch" on AMAZON
Buy "Transformers: Generations Power of The Primes Evolution Optimal Optimus" on AMAZON
Buy "Transformers Masterpiece Movie Series Barricade MPM-5" on AMAZON
Buy "Transformers: Generations Power of The Primes Voyager Terrorcon Hun-Gurrr" on AMAZON
Buy "Transformers Studio Series 01 Deluxe Class Movie 1 Bumblebee" on AMAZON
Buy "Transformers Generations Combiner Wars Victorion Collection Pack" on AMAZON
Buy "Transformers Generations Titans Return Legends Class Laserbeak" on AMAZON
Buy "Transformers Playskool Heroes Rescue Bots Optimus Prime Figure" on AMAZON
Transformers Podcast: Twincast / Podcast #274 - Pulse Fan Fest 2021
Twincast / Podcast #274:
"Pulse Fan Fest 2021"
MP3 · iTunes · RSS · View · Discuss · Ask
Posted: Sunday, April 18th, 2021

New Items on eBay

Buy "Transformers BLAST OFF and MEGATRONUS Amazon Exclusive Combiner Wars Prime" on EBAY
Buy "TRANSFORMERS Titans Return Wheelie Generations Legends Rare Complete" on EBAY
Buy "Transformers Onslaught Combaticons Leader Combiner Wars In Box" on EBAY
Buy "?? Transformers Titans Return Legends COSMOS & SEASPRAY figure Lot Authentic" on EBAY
Buy "Transformers Titans Return TRYPTICON Factory Sealed MISB HASBRO" on EBAY
Buy "New Transformers Takara Legends LG36 Soundwave" on EBAY
Buy "Transformers Optimus Prime Battle Call Figure Bumblebee Cyberverse Adventures" on EBAY