IDW Transformers #14 Review
Wednesday, November 6th, 2019 7:38PM CST
Categories: Comic Book News, Site ArticlesPosted by: D-Maximal_Primal Views: 34,650
Topic Options: View Discussion · Sign in or Join to reply
A Seibertron.com Semi-Spoilerish Review of IDW Transformers #14
Synopsis
Now shipping monthly! The Ascenticon Guard, Security Operations, and The Rise are caught in a three-way faceoff. Cybertron is teetering on the brink of chaos, but there is still hope for peace. And leading the way to restore that peace are the only bots that make sense: Megatron, Soundwave, and Starscream!
Story
After a bit of a hiatus, we return to you with a review for the just released IDW Transformers #14, part of the Bold New Era. And as for how that Bold New Era is doing, keep reading below! And for more information on this issue, you can check out our database entry!
So far, the Bold New Era has been heavy on the dialogue, but not so heavy on the story or intrigue. If anything, that has been the weakness of the Bold New Era to date, not a lot happening for the page space. The story has been slow going, and every time we get something that seems intriguing, it stalls out.
But after the Rubble of issue 5 and the return of Sentinel Prime to Cybertron, it seems the story might finally be making some ground. While it still wasn't very deep, there was some excitement to the story, it felt like there were more risks and consequences. We also learned some things about a few characters and also got to see some new ones. Motivations that were seemingly not there or unclear have focused in some, and we got some more character development, though we still don't really have many highly intriguing characters.
I liked the inclusion of Starscream in this issue, and he proved to be a welcome addition, bringing to the table some of the traits described in the paragraph above. I also think it was important for Orion Pax to be entirely absent and Megatron to only briefly show up. Both characters are very important Transformers characters, but so far have proven to be more attention vacuums than intriguing characters. It was good to have a good sized cast represented here without them with a chance to shine on their own, and Starscream, Soundwave, and to a lesser extent Sideswipe, Kup, Landmine, and Geomotus.
On another note, the inclusion of Strongarm alongside Sideswipe in this issue is a continued sign of the thing I so far like most in this comic: the variety of the characters showing up. Sure it has a lot of G1/Siege going on, but non-G1 characters showing up and referencing things outside of previous G1 stories is refreshing. I enjoy inclusions such as this, and want a little bit more of those characters and story too. The comic has showed a cast with variety, it just needs to flex that diversity a bit more.
Art
Art for this issue is split between Anna Malkova and Bethany Mcguire-Smith on lines, Joana Lafuente on colors, and Tom B. Long on letters. The art for the series so far has been a bit loose and all over the place in terms of quality, but outside of issue 13, I feel this is the best comic issue in terms of artistic consistency. While there were some questionable shapes thrown during this issue (Nautica being a primary offender compared to her prior appearances), the art overall was good quality, the two line artists had similar styles that allowed for a smooth transition between the artists, and the facial expressions were very well done in this issue.
The colors matched up with the line art pretty dang good as well, giving you a good sense of what time it is on Cybertron, and it also helped give the book some depth, showing shadows and sun glistening off of the lined surfaces. It was very pleasing to look at. The glowing optics were also a highlight in terms of colors.
The lettering is once more of good quality, and helps compliment the art while not getting in the way. I also enjoyed the word effects for all the different types of action happening throughout the issue, it helped augment the lines and colors of the different panels.
Conclusion
Overall, I would argue that this is the best overall chapter of the Bold New Era so far. We had a good first issue that helped set things up, but after that, there haven't been many highlights, and the ones that have happened have had a bit too much dead space between them to truly have a impact. If issue 14 had come earlier, such as being issue 8 instead of 14, I feel like the story would be progressing better and more coherently. The story needs better pacing and some more intrigue to it. We don't necessarily need to be told everything, let stuff happen in the background. Speech and walking heads can get in the way.
On those notes, issue 14 seems to be a step in the right direction. No real depth, nothing really to pick up with a 2nd read, but it was intriguing, it had some depth to it, and it made you want to actually read through it again. If we can actually keep this tempo up, the story will progress and we will start having some more depth and more enjoyment for the readers.
News Search
Got Transformers News? Let us know here!
Most Popular Transformers News
ROTB Optimus Prime Lead Designer Discusses Why the Face Looks Similar to the 2007 Movie
56,964 viewsMost Recent Transformers News
Posted by ScottyP on November 7th, 2019 @ 10:12am CST
If I put this issue in a vaccuum it was pretty entertaining. Overall it isn't in a vaccuum though, so my confusion on why this is all happening to this degree dampens the experience. This is turning into Char's Counterattack where the motivations are all explained but the actions based on them take such a leap that I have a hard time believing the characters.
Also still find the dialogue too stiff and not character driven, for the most part. The Nautica, Prowl and Road Rage scene would be an exception where that was done better.
Posted by Rodimus Prime on November 7th, 2019 @ 12:36pm CST
I pretty much gave up on this book, but I still read the reviews out of morbid curiosity. Maybe eventually it'll pick up.
Posted by ZeroWolf on November 12th, 2019 @ 2:09pm CST
Transformers #15 RI Cover by Luca Pizzari
Transformers: Galaxies #3 RI Cover by Angel Hernandez
Transformers: Galaxies #4 RI Cover by Christina-Antoinette Neofotistou
What do you think of these covers? How are you liking the series so far? Let us know in the Energon Pub and stay tuned to Seibertron for all the latest news and reviews!
Posted by Big Grim on November 14th, 2019 @ 4:04am CST
Strangely the 2 issues of Galaxies thus far I've enjoyed. Interested to see where that's going, unlike the ongoing.
Posted by ScottyP on November 15th, 2019 @ 10:58am CST
Not strange at all! Galaxies has Transformers doing Transformers things, has a tight cast, is developing its characters and has some great hooks (no pun intended) for its plot which has just enough layers and connections to the outside universe to be intriguing.Big Grim wrote:I've stuck with the ongoing this long but it's really starting to test me. I'd like something to happen please.
Strangely the 2 issues of Galaxies thus far I've enjoyed. Interested to see where that's going, unlike the ongoing.
The ongoing has robots cosplaying as Transformers speaking in platitudes while walking up and down stairs. Sometimes they shoot at one another now.
Posted by Big Grim on November 15th, 2019 @ 11:36am CST
ScottyP wrote:Not strange at all! Galaxies has Transformers doing Transformers things, has a tight cast, is developing its characters and has some great hooks (no pun intended) for its plot which has just enough layers and connections to the outside universe to be intriguing.
The ongoing has robots cosplaying as Transformers speaking in platitudes while walking up and down stairs. Sometimes they shoot at one another now.
Wow. You are bang on the money mate! The ongoing is boring with extra helpings of dull.
We're getting interesting character development of the Constructicons AND Insecticons and we're only 2 issues in.
Posted by ScottyP on January 29th, 2020 @ 10:00am CST
Also, really really hoping Vigilem isn't another exciting last page reveal that goes nowhere for several issues.
Posted by D-Maximal_Primal on January 29th, 2020 @ 6:00pm CST
Posted by ScottyP on January 30th, 2020 @ 8:10am CST
It looks like it will not. Why am I not surprised https://twitter.com/Brian_Ruckley/statu ... 82113?s=19D-Maximal_Primal wrote:I agree with your assessment Scotty, The character point was the highlight, and I hope that last page reveal goes somewhere quickly too
Posted by D-Maximal_Primal on January 30th, 2020 @ 8:01pm CST
ScottyP wrote:It looks like it will not. Why am I not surprised https://twitter.com/Brian_Ruckley/statu ... 82113?s=19D-Maximal_Primal wrote:I agree with your assessment Scotty, The character point was the highlight, and I hope that last page reveal goes somewhere quickly too
I really hope that doesn't mean what I think it means.
This book has accomplished so little. There are parts i like, but they are not consecutive and are so spread out! I really hate to say it, but look at what other continuities did in a 16 issue time frame. This book is slow, meandering, and all over the map. It needs focus
Posted by Big Grim on January 31st, 2020 @ 9:39am CST
Posted by Bounti76 on February 3rd, 2020 @ 6:54pm CST
As we can see, Pitre-Durocher knocks it out of the park again, with a gorgeous cover featuring Blast Off and Cosmos set against a backdrop of Cybertron in orbit.
Set to be released on February 12th, this cover can be picked up at your local comic shop, providing they've ordered enough copies to have this cover shipped to them (that's where the incentive part comes in). What do you think about this cover? Click on either of the pictures above to be taken to Ms. Pitre-Durocher's Twitter announcement, and let us know your thoughts below!
Posted by notsoalex on February 3rd, 2020 @ 7:20pm CST
providing they've ordered enough copies to have this cover shipped to them
legit when i skimmed through this i thought that shipped referred to shipping cosmos and blast off
which i mean, will prolly come to life in the comic itself but ya know
Posted by DedicatedGhostArt on February 3rd, 2020 @ 10:43pm CST
Posted by steve2275 on February 4th, 2020 @ 12:36am CST
Posted by Jeddostotle7 on February 4th, 2020 @ 3:17am CST
UnderYourCloset wrote:This is cursed.
...wh?
How so?
Posted by ZeroWolf on February 4th, 2020 @ 4:07am CST
Jeddostotle7 wrote:UnderYourCloset wrote:This is cursed.
...wh?
How so?
I'm now picturing the scene from Mummy Returns where one of the soon to be dead henchmen says it constantly
Posted by TreyTable on February 4th, 2020 @ 8:02am CST
Posted by ScottyP on February 4th, 2020 @ 10:17am CST
We do need to catch up a bit, no reviews for the past few has a lot to do with my schedule (see: real job, this is a volunteer gig) and if it's down to time for a Twincast episode or a comics review, the podcast wins. They'll resume for the "main" ongoing hopefully soon, or when we get some more volunteers for site staff that would like to give it a shot.Big Grim wrote:I quit it a couple of issues ago. Forgot it existed, I've seen so little news on it. I assume the reviews stopped?
Reviews for one-shots, Galaxies and other misc stuff may be expected on a more-or-less normal schedule, the releases have just been very sparse lately.
Posted by D-Maximal_Primal on February 4th, 2020 @ 5:48pm CST
Posted by Evil Eye on February 5th, 2020 @ 4:21am CST
Posted by Big Grim on February 5th, 2020 @ 4:34am CST
ScottyP wrote:We do need to catch up a bit, no reviews for the past few has a lot to do with my schedule (see: real job, this is a volunteer gig).
Oh, I totally get that Dude. No dig at you guys.
Posted by Jeddostotle7 on February 5th, 2020 @ 5:33am CST
Black Hat wrote:The cover's pretty, but Cosmos X Blastoff seems an odd choice. They're both space vehicles, but that aside do they have anything in common?
Feeling lonely up in space?
Posted by Stormtalon on February 5th, 2020 @ 5:59am CST
Posted by ScottyP on February 5th, 2020 @ 8:29am CST
No worries, wasn't taken that way!Big Grim wrote:ScottyP wrote:We do need to catch up a bit, no reviews for the past few has a lot to do with my schedule (see: real job, this is a volunteer gig).
Oh, I totally get that Dude. No dig at you guys.
Posted by Cyberstrike on February 6th, 2020 @ 8:30am CST
Stormtalon wrote:Talk about 'Starcrossed'.
Posted by ZeroWolf on February 7th, 2020 @ 1:51pm CST
Here's the publishers description for this issue:
Megatron is faced with the ultimate decision. He can forge ahead on the path he’s started down, or he can take the last chance at doing things by the book. Either way, Cybertron is on the verge of change, and after this, nothing will ever be the same.
Transformers #17 is written by Brian Ruckley, with art duties shared between Anna Malkova, Beth McGuire-Smith and cover art by Livio Ramondelli.
You looking forward to this issue? Let us know in the Energon Pub and stay tuned to Seibertron for all the latest news and reviews!
Posted by D-Maximal_Primal on February 7th, 2020 @ 5:00pm CST
Posted by Mr.MicroMaster on February 7th, 2020 @ 9:15pm CST
D-Maximal_Primal wrote:cyclonus continues to be the best thing about this ongoing
I hundred percent agree with you.
Posted by Rodimus Prime on February 21st, 2020 @ 12:01am CST
Posted by D-Maximal_Primal on February 22nd, 2020 @ 8:55am CST
Rodimus Prime wrote:I gave up on this series a while ago, but I'm curious about something. Since Prime is the Siege version, does he get the galaxy upgrade in this book?
Not yet. Probably will, but with the pacing, it'll probably be around issue 45
Posted by Tigertrack on February 24th, 2020 @ 8:48am CST
Vigilem quoting Codexa,‘The Way We Were, By One Who Saw It.’
The Change in Your Nature - Part Five - A late review without too many spoilers, even though the issue came out last Wednesday.
Written by Brian Ruckley with Art by Anna Malkova and Bethany McGuire, colors by Joana LaFuente and John-Paul Bove, with letters by Jake M. Wood and Neil Uyetake. Edited by David Mariotte and Tom Waltz.
The Rise is pushing even more boundaries and their next step is in motion. Skystalker has awoken Vigilem… What is the next step for Cybertron’s many factions? Vigiliem’s awakening cannot mean good things can it? The fact that the rise want to awaken him, based on their prior motivations does not seem like a positive step for the planet. But, many readers will be relying on their previous experience with the very large, very powerful, and very dangerous Titan (see 'Til All Are One') to better inform their prediction for what the outcome most likely involves.
Vigilem is the focus this issue, which as you can imagine, is not a small thing.
The first few pages take us right back where the last issue left off and speaking of not small things, check out Astrotrain's size in the image below. Our glorious gaggle of Risers is itching for more trouble, especially the XXXL-sized train bot. History will mark their deeds and judge what they have done as being right, wrong…or possibly something even more defining.
I choo-choo choose...WAR!
Cyclonus is physically healed up, but is also still dealing with his mental illness which might be PTSD or something else entirely, and is now growing angry with a new inner fire being sparked because of the Rise's destruction of one of his favorite places. Is there a reason for us to care about Cyclonus’ backstory right now? What bigger role will he and his memories play?
The Winged Moon, a consistent hangout of Wheeljack and his mentee Gears, is our main setting though...and space. Gears follows through with his difficulties with 0 gravity mentioned by Cosmos in the Transformers Valentine’s Day Special. More importantly, we learn of Vigiliem’s target…
Cue the alarms and the 2nd part of the Rise’s plan. Big bad rockin’ communicator bot and his communication friends not named Steeljaw, Ramhorn, Eject, Rewind, Raindance, or Grand Slam, work very hard to try to undo the virus that has taken down the Titan network. This is a bad thing, of course, because apparently there is no response to be had to re-route Vigilem by communication or by force (apparently).
BUT WAIT! Old friend Lightbright is ready to intervene with Titan Lodestar, results to be determined (and not spoiled entirely)…
Artwork duties are once again shared by Anna Malkova and Bethany McGuire. Both are adept at showing action and expression in their work. This issue has plenty of both to go around. There are some really large almost splash pages (you can imagine with showing characters the scale of Titans with regular bots). I’m not particularly fond of Vigilem’s ship-mode design, but that’s a small gripe, right? I feel like being the large scale that he is, there could be more detail in trying to show that MONSTROUS scale. But the artwork certainly helps tell our story, and certainly has some amazing shining moments of expression; especially AWE and FEAR…
Coloring duties fall to the duo of LaFuente and Bove, two worthy and capable individuals with plenty of Transformers and other comic experience to bring. The color work with Lightbright in Lodestar is a nice bit of work using Lodestar’s palette as inspiration for other interiors on the Titan.
I was most impressed by the art team’s panel below. This immediately caught my eye and I smiled to myself as I thought, ‘Wow, they nailed that shot…I really love it.’ The potential for even more is there.
And there are a few cover options, Livio's standard, Brendan Cahill, and Marcelo Matere in the thumbnail.
The story moves along well, with a lot of action- broken up with some moments of levity and build up for another part of the plot to pay off later via Cyclonus. There's a lot of history that is being introduced and some somewhat assumed for the reader, but not much built on yet.
All-in-all, I thought this was a good issue, and I look forward to the follow up -that ending-. Lots of IDW Transformers version 2 Titan lore came out, as well as, more information as to how Titans function, and are supported, some we were mostly aware of from prior experience, some brand new. We have mentions of knights, and plenty of Titan names that we have no idea who or what they fully did. And we get much of this from the memories of a Titan who has read works by Codexa (or downloaded them) and uses her words to express his/the mood. I did miss the Titan voice ballon work that we have seen in the past (and even in this issue). I think it helps to set apart the Titan's from the 'regular' bot and I'd love to see it consistently used again.
I thought that there were some possible missed opportunities with some somewhat bland panels of spaceship flying in space at many different angles, it does allow for Vigilem's exposition to be broken up, but otherwise, a solid issue with some new Cybertronian faces showing up to the party and many panels of pretty amazing artwork.
“Titans built our colonies, they fought for us, they WERE us.”
out of
Team Gears is blasting off again!!!
Posted by sol magnus on March 10th, 2020 @ 2:20pm CDT
http://majorspoilers.com/2020/03/10/pre ... rettyPhoto
I'd like credit.
Posted by D-Maximal_Primal on March 10th, 2020 @ 7:27pm CDT
The issue is due out tomorrow and will be available for $3.99. Check out the preview below, and let us know what you think in the comments section below!
Posted by snavej on March 11th, 2020 @ 9:28am CDT
I read a book once called 'Red Mars' by Kim Stanley Robinson. In that, an orbital tether falls back onto Mars. Death and destruction ensue, naturally.
Posted by Rodimus Knight on March 11th, 2020 @ 10:42am CDT
Posted by Big Grim on March 11th, 2020 @ 12:33pm CDT
Posted by D-Maximal_Primal on March 11th, 2020 @ 6:38pm CDT
Big Grim wrote:Is anything actually happening in this book yet?
Sort of? It has improved, but it's still not really flowing
Posted by Rodimus Prime on March 12th, 2020 @ 10:35am CDT
Posted by Lore Keeper on March 12th, 2020 @ 3:22pm CDT
Posted by william-james88 on March 12th, 2020 @ 9:57pm CDT
I liked this issue. It is actually my favourite issue of the ones I have reviewed for the site. Of course that doesn't mean much, all I needed was an issue with less stairs and talking. And funny enough, I don't recall any prominent stairs here, instead it was more star wars type walkways and ramps. Now that i think of it, for a species that turns into cars, don't ramps make more sense than stairs? Why even have stairs? Eh, moving on.
This issue feels like a breath of fresh air compared to previous ones in the sense that it feels more like a spotlight issue. There is definitely still some world building, like the logic behind new bots being created, but no one is sitting around talking about it. Instead we see it through actions and other fun interactions. While she isn't spotlit on this issue's two main covers, the spotlight is really on Arcee. I do like how the idea of her being a hardened warrior is kept from the previous continuity, without being too world weary either. And we get more Greenlight here than we've ever gotten in G1 so hurray for that too.
It is a very simple story, just getting from point A to point B while kicking ass and taking names, ala Escape from New York, which works very well for these other characters born of the 80s. I did like the action, it was very well framed by the artists, though I did wonder the effectiveness of some moves. There is a really prominent shot of an antagonist throwing energon cubes at Arcee and you get the sense that he is skilled at this, but the next shot is just them bumping off her like they were empty cardboard boxes. It would have been more impressive to see her dodge them acrobatically, unless I was supposed to know that Arcee now has wonder woman gauntlets. It just felt a tad underwhelming after the emphasis on the battle.
Speaking of the artists, this issue had 2, Bethany McGuire-Smith and Umi Miyao, and I felt both their styles worked well with this issue. The change in artist never felt jarring, I wouldn't even have known if I wasn't told. It is of course helped a lot by Josh Burcham being the only colourist on this issue and giving it a very even feel. The art itself was fine, a bit reminiscent of Nick Roche (especially when coloured by Josh Burcham) but I did have some issue with the faces. Arcee especially is given a Jay leno chin and there are some shots in the issue where her Lea bunns helmet is cut off from the frame and it was not obvious it was her. Also, I never thought of Transformers sweating, but the artists give it a shot in this issue and it instead comes off as Arcee having a bad case of acnee.
The covers available feature Umi Miyao as the main cover artist and Beth Mcguire-Smith as the artist for cover B. I will say none really do it for me, especially the main cover where I couldn't even tell that was Greenlight. My favourite cover of the bunch is Kei Zama's retailer incentive which looks incredible, and does have Arcee in the spotlight. Regardless of my personal tastes, I do find it incredible that we all these covers are by talented women. It's a nice touch for international women's day, whether intentional or not, and it's nice to highlight diversity in this field which has been dominated by men since inception.
As always, you can also find images of all of the book's covers along with full credits for the issue in our Vector Sigma Database page for Transformers #18.
Straight and to the point, just like I like em. Nothing too fancy, but it hit the spot for some Transformers fiction and I definitely wouldn't mind reading more from these characters, which is something I thought I would never say about this series.
. and a half
out of
Posted by william-james88 on March 12th, 2020 @ 10:01pm CDT
Rodimus Knight wrote:I looked at this cover and I had no Idea who the characters on it were.
Same here, I adress it in my review. Along with the robo sweat.
Posted by Rodimus Prime on March 13th, 2020 @ 12:14am CDT
Posted by ZeroWolf on March 13th, 2020 @ 3:22am CDT
Rodimus Prime wrote:Yeah the sweat was the 1st thing that caught my eye. Any idea how and when this series will be released in trades? And will Galaxies really be put together with it?
I think there has been a, listing for the first TPB on Amazon
, and so far, yes Galaxies will be contained within the mainline TPB.
What I found amusing looking at the cover was that I was trying to figure out why Greenlight had been paired with Arcee, then I remembered that we got Greenlight as part of the Selects line (under Siege) and of course, Arcee is coming out in Earthrise. Coincidence?
Probably I haven't even checked to see if this Arcee looks anything like the Earthrise release
Posted by Dannshinigami on March 13th, 2020 @ 3:40am CDT
Loved this issue the Arcee transforming and catching Gauge sequence was a highlight panel as was the whole Arcee takes no prisoners scene.
Posted by Bounti76 on March 13th, 2020 @ 5:41am CDT
ZeroWolf wrote:Rodimus Prime wrote:Yeah the sweat was the 1st thing that caught my eye. Any idea how and when this series will be released in trades? And will Galaxies really be put together with it?
I think there has been a, listing for the first TPB on Amazon
, and so far, yes Galaxies will be contained within the mainline TPB.
What I found amusing looking at the cover was that I was trying to figure out why Greenlight had been paired with Arcee, then I remembered that we got Greenlight as part of the Selects line (under Siege) and of course, Arcee is coming out in Earthrise. Coincidence?
Probably I haven't even checked to see if this Arcee looks anything like the Earthrise release
Technically, Greenlight was part of the regular Siege line, just exclusive to Amazon. Her retool, Lancer, was part of Selects, though. As I recall, Earthrise Arcee is straight up her G1 cartoon design. This looks more IDW Arcee to me.
Posted by Flashwave on March 13th, 2020 @ 11:26pm CDT
The problem is not so much that they can turn into vehicles, even for a species who can do that, you sren't going to turn into a car in the middle of your Hotel just go up to the nect level. The question is that unlike Humans, there is a VERY large range of heights and builds with no consistancy. Unlike Humans where most adults are in the 4-6ft range, we have seen Cybertronians deviate from 4-8feet to over 40, and thats just the normal guys, not counting Combiners or dudes like Omega Supreme. And on top of that, legs are not as consistantly proportionate either, so you have guys like Ultra Magnus and Bulkhead who are close to the same height, but Bulkhead's legs are half as long. And someone like Override who turns into a Motorcycle and comes up to Bulkhead's WAIST has to use the same flight of steps. So whom do you size the steps for?
A Ramp, meanwhile, is more versatile, but comes with the inherent steepness issue.
Posted by aronjlove on July 22nd, 2020 @ 3:45pm CDT
Posted by D-Maximal_Primal on August 11th, 2020 @ 6:55pm CDT
Check out the preview below, and let us know what you think in the comments section below.