This page contains affiliate links. We may earn commissions when readers interact with or purchase items through these links. For more information, see our affiliate disclosures here.

Optimus Prime will indeed have a mouth under his "battle" shield

Transformers News: Optimus Prime will indeed have a mouth under his "battle" shield

Saturday, May 5th, 2007 2:27AM CDT

Category: Movie Related News
Posted by: Seibertron   Views: 34,208

Topic Options: View Discussion · Sign in or Join to reply

Read it and weep, fellow Seibertronians, the Movie camp has spoken: http://www.shootfortheedit.com/forums/viewtopic.php?t=1744

Optimus Prime will indeed have a mouth under his

Nelson @ MichaelBay.com :
Exactly 2 months form now, most of you will be wathcing Transformers and posting your opinions on these and other forums.

This movie is about 3-4 weeks from being locked (locked means that no more changes can be made to a film so that it could be release for masive reel duplication).

At this point, there are few mods left. Mike is tweaking the ending and maybe shaving off some minutes here and there. He's waiting for some final renders from ILM and that's it.

The photo of OP in the LA Times should tell you what the final decision is on the mouth/faceplate/battle mask is.

He and others then start the international press tour in early June.

So for now, could we stop and relax on the whining?

Nothing you say, post, scream will have an impact at this point.

If you don't like the choices, fine. And if you do, good for you.

Take a rest, and come back in 2 months all ready for more debating.
Credit(s): Conceptron

News Search

Got Transformers News? Let us know here!

Re: Optimus Prime will indeed have a mouth under his "battle" shield (110435)
Posted by Seibertron on May 5th, 2007 @ 2:53am CDT
This really pisses me off. It's Optimus-f'in-Prime for crying out loud. Can we at least have ONE thing in this movie not be changed for the sake of changing? I can't believe how passive so many people are being about this decision. And don't bring up the whole Optimus Primal thing. I would have been fine if they did the Beast Wars or Cybertron approach with movie Prime. This just looks ridiculous. How anyone at ILM or Dreamworks or even at Hasbro thought this looked even remotely good or "cool" seriously needs to get their eyes checked.

Please keep the entire design staff as far away as possible from G.I.Joe and any future Super Hero movies. Next thing you know we'll have a yellow Spider-Man with a visor and pinchers on his face as well as the Blue Lantern, a red Batman, a green Superman and a pink Wolverine. After seeing Spider-Man tonight and seeing how faithful they are to his costume, it helped me realize how disappointed I am to this day in the robot designs in this movie. I don't care what the reasons are for it, these design changes were poor decisions from the get-go and are completely unnecessary regardless of what mumbo-jumbo they want to make up to spin these changes to the public.

Don't get me wrong ... I'm extremely excited about the movie. But I feel a strong sense of Deja Vu. Beast Machines comes to mind. Great story. Absolutely horrible designs.
Re: Optimus Prime will indeed have a mouth under his "battle" shield (110438)
Posted by Fireblast on May 5th, 2007 @ 3:20am CDT
Seibertron wrote:This really pisses me off. It's Optimus-f'in-Prime for crying out loud. Can we at least have ONE thing in this movie not be changed for the sake of changing? I can't believe how passive so many people are being about this decision. And don't bring up the whole Optimus Primal thing. I would have been fine if they did the Beast Wars or Cybertron approach with movie Prime. This just looks ridiculous. How anyone at ILM or Dreamworks or even at Hasbro thought this looked even remotely good or "cool" seriously needs to get their eyes checked.

Please keep the entire design staff as far away as possible from G.I.Joe and any future Super Hero movies. Next thing you know we'll have a yellow Spider-Man with a visor and pinchers on his face as well as the Blue Lantern, a red Batman, a green Superman and a pink Wolverine. After seeing Spider-Man tonight and seeing how faithful they are to his costume, it helped me realize how disappointed I am to this day in the robot designs in this movie. I don't care what the reasons are for it, these design changes were poor decisions from the get-go and are completely unnecessary regardless of what mumbo-jumbo they want to make up to spin these changes to the public.

Don't get me wrong ... I'm extremely excited about the movie. But I feel a strong sense of Deja Vu. Beast Machines comes to mind. Great story. Absolutely horrible designs.
I saw it too tonight. If you've noticed Venom is exactly the same as he is in the comics with the webbing on the costume, and Sandman is picture perfect accurate from the comics as well. Of course some people are tearing Spidey 3 down on IMDB (then again, there is ALWAYS someone slamming a movie they saw). What's ironic is Spider-Man 3 gave fans their dreams come true with Venom and staying close to the classic designs and giving fans what they want. On the other hand the Transformers movie we are given what somebody else wants and the fans really don't have a say to well, anything. I find it quite sad about Starscream's design especially when the protoform looks better than his Earth mode. Plus I've notices Hasbro is slacking off in the quality of toys especially with the protoforms which frightens me on what Hasbro is doing and making me think we will get Beast Machines, no Animorphs quality Transformers. I also meant to say Hasbro is slacking off because Starscream's intelligence drops when he gains his Earth mode. Quite funny actually. :lol:
Re: Optimus Prime will indeed have a mouth under his "battle" shield (110444)
Posted by Quaternion on May 5th, 2007 @ 3:34am CDT
Fireblast wrote:Plus I've notices Hasbro is slacking off in the quality of toys especially with the protoforms...


Hasbro's QC has been getting worse but my protoforms were in perfect condition. In fact, I marveled at the awesome, non f'ed up paint jobs - especially on Op. I hoped that meant that their QC was finally getting better. Maybe I'm wrong. What was wrong with the protoforms?
Re: Optimus Prime will indeed have a mouth under his "battle" shield (110448)
Posted by Emperor Primacron the 1st on May 5th, 2007 @ 3:39am CDT
Why even have a mouth if one has a chin plate like Optimus, Onslaught and Soundwave has? Having a mouth seems redundent then.

Seibs, I watched the LOTR triliogy last week on extended DVD's, and was really moved as to how much Mr. Jackson put into the films and make them as close to the books as possible. Pity Bay feels that everything in TF lore needs to be changed in some way. Wish we could find a Peter Jackson equivilent to make this film.
Re: Optimus Prime will indeed have a mouth under his "battle" shield (110449)
Posted by InvaderJes on May 5th, 2007 @ 3:39am CDT
While I'd prefer he didn't have a mouth, I think it's a pretty minor point to get worked up about. The essence of the character really isn't based on the fact that we can't see his mouth.
But having said that- yeah- that picture... his face is ugly with a capital Ug.
Re: Optimus Prime will indeed have a mouth under his "battle" shield (110452)
Posted by the purifyer on May 5th, 2007 @ 3:43am CDT
If you want a child to stop whining you give them what they want.

Obviously most of us Transfans have loved the brand for 23 years. I think we know a little something when it comes to a film about Transformers, at the very least what the most iconic Transformer's face should look like.

People like what they like, hate what the hate if the movie staff can't hack that quite a large group of people are appalled at their efforts maybe they should have taken a step back and taken a look at the whole picture, or at very least came to terms with the fact that some of us just don't like it?

As long as they keep beating a dead horse, I will too, it's only fair.
Re: Optimus Prime will indeed have a mouth under his "battle" shield (110453)
Posted by zoso504 on May 5th, 2007 @ 3:46am CDT
Is anybody else worried that this big budgetted film will become, say, Peter Jackson's King Kong? I'm optimistic but there's a part of me that just says....
Re: Optimus Prime will indeed have a mouth under his "battle" shield (110466)
Posted by Ravage XK on May 5th, 2007 @ 4:15am CDT
I think Prime doesnt look half as heroic without his face plate. He actually looks a bit scary in that LA Times picture. I get the whole "these are aliens" thing but Prime was always able to emote perfectly well without a mouth thanks to skill of Mr Peter Cullen.
Re: Optimus Prime will indeed have a mouth under his "battle" shield (110469)
Posted by Blackstreak on May 5th, 2007 @ 4:24am CDT
I like that: "Could we stop and relax on the whining?" Whether Optimus has a 'mouth' or a 'battle shield' shouldn't matter. We are seeing our childhood heroes on the big screen and that is enough to be elated about. I can't wait to see it.
Re: Optimus Prime will indeed have a mouth under his "battle" shield (110479)
Posted by Gutsman Heavy on May 5th, 2007 @ 4:48am CDT
yeah I'm over complaining about the designs. No chance he wasn't having a face plate only.
Re: Optimus Prime will indeed have a mouth under his "battle" shield (110480)
Posted by Shin Optimus Prime on May 5th, 2007 @ 4:52am CDT
It's true, Prime is ICONIC as a Transformer. It really can't be said better than that. Although not everyone cares about Transformers the way we fans do, those who are even somewhat familiar with the brand know who Optimus Prime is, and would recognize him in no time. Not to say this movie Prime isn't recognizable as Prime, but if they didn't at least give him his trademark antennae and colors, I'm not even sure I'd know who I was looking at, and he's my all-time favorite character! It might seem small and strange to some, but Prime's faceplate does give him a certain character. I'm not even sure how I can put it to words, but it gives him a certain strength and authority, and it augments his position as leader. Actually, I'd say it gives him a certain powerful humility, like he is that caring and compassionate friend of man, but piss him off, and he'll bowl through Decepticons like they were nothing (see original Transformers animated movie). And even worse than taking away his faceplate, what they've left him with underneath is barely even recognizeable as a mouth. I hate to say anything negative about my beloved Autobot leader, but his lips make him look ape-like, and if I'm not mistaken, one of the things that makes the Transformers so likeable is there relative similarities to humans, despite being "alien". (Yeah, that's a card the guys behind this movie are playing WAY too much) Yes, the Transformers are alien, but if you want to make an alien lovable, give it a certain human quality. If you make it completely foreign, it's just plain scary, not interesting.

Sorry, Prime, I'll still support you, but I hope to God somehow the guys behind these live-action movies get some sense and rework you properly a little for the sequels.
Re: Optimus Prime will indeed have a mouth under his "battle" shield (110481)
Posted by Tigertrack on May 5th, 2007 @ 4:59am CDT
They've brow beat me enough with these designs...I'm a bit numb to things that would have been a big deal to me early on in production.

I just want to see it. Call it a fun movie, and go back to my IDW G1 stuff, and my Classics, and vintage items.

Collecting toys... Not planning on being a completist here, I am going to be very picky about what I buy, which is quite new for me...
Re: Optimus Prime will indeed have a mouth under his "battle" shield (110483)
Posted by † Sunstorm on May 5th, 2007 @ 5:16am CDT
this sucks balls, critics gonna ask themself if Ttransformers makes love with lips now, there is NO logical use for metal lips for a machine damed! this is just stupid, MB can no officially suck my G1 balls!
Re: Optimus Prime will indeed have a mouth under his "battle" shield (110484)
Posted by Sunstar on May 5th, 2007 @ 5:17am CDT
OH good, at least Prime looks odd. So that means the cons did not get all the bad luck. I couldn't care less if prime had a mouth or a flashing light like Shockwave. I never liked optimus Prime.

Anyway I've became used to the movie designs even if I don't like them.
Re: Optimus Prime will indeed have a mouth under his "battle" shield (110485)
Posted by † Sunstorm on May 5th, 2007 @ 5:21am CDT
oyeah, btw, i actually HOPE it wont come an sequal if this is the final desicion, cause i dont want to se other cool G1 heroes get blammed up as monsters, damed, megatron aint megatron, hes a fricking warhammer character!
Re: Optimus Prime will indeed have a mouth under his "battle" shield (110496)
Posted by City Commander on May 5th, 2007 @ 5:39am CDT
Who's complaining?

WHIIIIIIIIINE!

lol, not really ;)
Re: Optimus Prime will indeed have a mouth under his "battle" shield (110500)
Posted by Ataraxia on May 5th, 2007 @ 6:04am CDT
Stop being such whiny little bitches. who cares? i mean seriously. it's a film about giant transforming robots destroying things and eachother, that's the concept we all know and love and that hasn't changed. just be thankful you're getting a movie based on a toy franchise. and by-the-by spidey has more exposure than transformers so it'd be harder to change anything like that. plus a battle shield over the face tends to make it hard for a cgi character to emote...stupid funking fanboys...
Re: Optimus Prime will indeed have a mouth under his "battle" shield (110503)
Posted by caitlindevi on May 5th, 2007 @ 6:08am CDT
You know...a clever cgi artist would have done two versions of all primes head scenes...after all a mouth plate isn't as complex an element as a full mouth is...they may just need the rendering time.

DVD special edition anyone?
Re: Optimus Prime will indeed have a mouth under his "battle" shield (110505)
Posted by MYoung23 on May 5th, 2007 @ 6:11am CDT
Nelson remains a prick to the end
Re: Optimus Prime will indeed have a mouth under his "battle" shield (110511)
Posted by Khemical Prime on May 5th, 2007 @ 6:27am CDT
Someone needs to tell the a-holes associated with this film that this is still a free country and if you want to cry foul about something you can.

To me, this whole film production these guys have shown nothing but arrogance and talked down to the fans. I was actually leaning towards seeing this in the theatre but why line the pockets of people who treat fans like this. It's like they think we have no choice and must see this film.

Screw'em.
Re: Optimus Prime will indeed have a mouth under his "battle" shield (110520)
Posted by Phoenix_306 on May 5th, 2007 @ 6:41am CDT
I'm in total agreement with most of you over this faceplate issue - it's part of both Prime's image and character, and even though it obviously can't be changed now, how dare this Nelson p***k tell me what I can or can't complain about? Over the last twenty years or so I've invested a hell of a lot of money in this hobby that I love, just to be told I can't have an opinion on it? So Nelson, how about you crawl back up Bay's rear end where you came from and let the real Transformer's fans talk about the things they care about. Sorry if I've offended any of you guys with my ramblings...
Re: Optimus Prime will indeed have a mouth under his "battle" shield (110521)
Posted by First-Aid on May 5th, 2007 @ 6:41am CDT
If we look at this from a strictly logical standpoint, mouths allow for a much wider array of emotional display. The eyes are the other part; however with this movie design I doesn't look like the eyes will be able to widen or narrow much at all so if they wanted true emotional displays from the TF's they'd HAVE to have mouths. And who has more sentiment and compassion than Prime? And the reason he looks f'ed up in teh pic is because he IS f'ed up. This is obviously after the final battle or at least near the end of it. His head is tore up big time and he's laying on the ground...look at the huge battle scar above his right eye...
Re: Optimus Prime will indeed have a mouth under his "battle" shield (110536)
Posted by rad902 on May 5th, 2007 @ 7:19am CDT
Come on guys, Optimus will have a battle mask at some point in the movie! I think that given Op's major role, that we NEED to see full expressive faces i.e full face, without battle mask.

I think with the Battle Mask up all the time, it may not deliver the effect required in all cases...
Re: Optimus Prime will indeed have a mouth under his "battle" shield (110540)
Posted by shortround on May 5th, 2007 @ 7:23am CDT
Prime having a mouth doesn't bother me in the least. I guess I got used to him having it because of all the cybertron episodes. I look at this way over all movie is more important than if prime has mouth or he doesn't because one transformer doesn't make or break a movie. But you also have to understand that this is a still shot someone from pr department sent out to the papers. Who knows if during the film how his face will look.
Re: Optimus Prime will indeed have a mouth under his "battle" shield (110548)
Posted by LuckytheWonderLlama on May 5th, 2007 @ 7:34am CDT
OMG Prime has a mouth!!! They are not making the movie to my exact specifications!! I'm going to turn emo and cut myself and wear girl's jeans... Why? Why? Why does Prime have a mouth? Why can't everything be the way I want it!? Life has no meaning any more. Why? WHy? WH...uh?

6 VWs for under $17,000?

This movie is going to be great. It is different just like every incarnation of Transformers. Kudos to Bay and Speilberg for giving us their vision and actually entrtaining us with something new not spoonfeeding us the same old thing.

I say get over it and enjoy the movie.
Re: Optimus Prime will indeed have a mouth under his "battle" shield (110551)
Posted by jonusjaxon on May 5th, 2007 @ 7:38am CDT
I have respect for directors who do what they want and don't sweat over what the fans say.
Re: Optimus Prime will indeed have a mouth under his "battle" shield (110573)
Posted by Roadshadow on May 5th, 2007 @ 8:25am CDT
Damn you Michael Bay! You fucking suck for giving Prime a mouth!
Re: Optimus Prime will indeed have a mouth under his "battle" shield (110577)
Posted by Bender Prime on May 5th, 2007 @ 8:37am CDT
Flashbang wrote:I have respect for directors who do what they want and don't sweat over what the fans say.


Exactly. Talk about crying like a bunch of school girls. Waahhh the faceplate isn't on in all the scenes. Waahhh he has flames. Like who cares, it's a TINY DETAIL.

I can't believe reading these comments like 'the film will suck cos the face plate isn't on in all the scenes', what a load of baloney, go ask Sam Raimi how he feels about leaving his main characters in masks like the Green Goblin v Spidey fight in Spiderman 1 - he'll tell you it was a dumb move cos the scenes become flat cos you are just staring a darn inanimate plastic object. Prime has to EMOTE, he needs a flippin mouth to do that, it's not a cartoon, it's a $150 million dollar major motion picture so is it so damn hard for these people to understand that he has to be more expressive?

Here is a crazy idea, why not talk about the actual important things in the film like the story or the plot, or the characters (not their looks) instead of crapping on for what must be a year now about stuff that is completely irrelevant. It's like someone yapping on about what type of shades NEO wears in the Matrix, it's completely and utterly trivial!!!

No wonder Bay must get the impression a lot of fans are off the reservation.
Re: Optimus Prime will indeed have a mouth under his "battle" shield (110582)
Posted by DetectiveFork on May 5th, 2007 @ 8:44am CDT
I've already decided not to see this movie, so this is yet another reason for me not to regret it. I haven't liked the creative choices Bay & Co. have made all along and this is just another bad idea. The horrible look of the Transformers are the thing that bothers me the most and the script didn't impress me. I'll pass.

It's weird, though, how there's all this hype for the movie and people are getting excited about it (Even my girlfriend wants to see it!) but I'm just shrugging my shoulders and waiting for the next Transformers incarnation.
Re: Optimus Prime will indeed have a mouth under his "battle" shield (110609)
Posted by Noisemaze on May 5th, 2007 @ 9:28am CDT
Whatever!
Re: Optimus Prime will indeed have a mouth under his "battle" shield (110611)
Posted by Maldroth on May 5th, 2007 @ 9:31am CDT
Seibertron wrote:This really pisses me off. It's Optimus-f'in-Prime for crying out loud. Can we at least have ONE thing in this movie not be changed for the sake of changing? I can't believe how passive so many people are being about this decision. And don't bring up the whole Optimus Primal thing. I would have been fine if they did the Beast Wars or Cybertron approach with movie Prime. This just looks ridiculous. How anyone at ILM or Dreamworks or even at Hasbro thought this looked even remotely good or "cool" seriously needs to get their eyes checked.

Please keep the entire design staff as far away as possible from G.I.Joe and any future Super Hero movies. Next thing you know we'll have a yellow Spider-Man with a visor and pinchers on his face as well as the Blue Lantern, a red Batman, a green Superman and a pink Wolverine. After seeing Spider-Man tonight and seeing how faithful they are to his costume, it helped me realize how disappointed I am to this day in the robot designs in this movie. I don't care what the reasons are for it, these design changes were poor decisions from the get-go and are completely unnecessary regardless of what mumbo-jumbo they want to make up to spin these changes to the public.

Don't get me wrong ... I'm extremely excited about the movie. But I feel a strong sense of Deja Vu. Beast Machines comes to mind. Great story. Absolutely horrible designs.


Ryan I've seen you as a large supporter of the movie up until now and it surprises me you to take such a passionate stance against this now. Please realise this is not an attempt to be snarky, i'm just genuinely surpised.

Yeah you know when you take a major iconic character and nothing is more iconic than prime and make an alteration like this its going to look out of place. Even non Transformer fans know what Prime looks like. They see the design in all the promo material and what do you see? Prime with is "battle plate" on since that is the face of prime.

This will be the thing that will really impact the performance of the film as a whole. Too much artistic licence was taken and now it will suffer the same fate that all game/tv show movies that deviate too much from the baseline. Many will go but the following won't be there and the sequel (which we know there will be) will just look like grabing at more money than being as welcome as say the Spiderman franchise.

Many people will see the face and go, "Is that Optimus Prime? That looks silly." I'm really surpised their research department didn't realize what an impact changing a major iconic character would be. Shows that they really didn't care about being true to the franchise otherwise they would have come halfway on their visions and what is already set in the IP.
Re: Optimus Prime will indeed have a mouth under his "battle" shield (110625)
Posted by Blitzwing the warrior on May 5th, 2007 @ 9:40am CDT
Optimus had a mouth under his battle mask in G1 too. Im guessing he opens up the faceplate to speak, otherwise you'd probably hear this

Optimus: mmphm mmmmhphm mmphm!

Sam: WHAT!?

Optimus: MMPHMM MMMPHMMMMM!

*Megatron steps on Sam*
Re: Optimus Prime will indeed have a mouth under his "battle" shield (110629)
Posted by Kalon on May 5th, 2007 @ 9:43am CDT
And this is one of the many reason I will not pay to see this "film". I'll download it or get a bootleg copy. Bay and Co will not see a dime from me for this piece of crap disguised as a movie.
Re: Optimus Prime will indeed have a mouth under his "battle" shield (110650)
Posted by signalcore on May 5th, 2007 @ 10:04am CDT
Im going to be the wierdo and go out on a limb here. Perhaps its just the picture, more than likely it is. However I can see some resemblance to Peter Cullen in the face.

Dont know if that was intentional, but might be something to think about although it remains unmentioned.
Re: Optimus Prime will indeed have a mouth under his "battle" shield (110654)
Posted by Dr. Caelus on May 5th, 2007 @ 10:09am CDT
Well, the rest of his design only barely evokes the Optimus Prime image anyway - he could just as well be a mutilated Gundam - how much difference could the face plate have actually made at this point?

And at least the changing face plate is precedented - the only TF series since G1 that didn't have one is Armada, right? - Unlike Gorillascream and Scrapatron.

-------------------------------------------------------------

Maldroth wrote:Ryan I've seen you as a large supporter of the movie up until now and it surprises me you to take such a passionate stance against this now. Please realise this is not an attempt to be snarky, i'm just genuinely surpised.


Umm... Remember when the Starscream design came out? Or the Megatron design? I don't understand why you're surprised.

-------------------------------------------------------------

And is it absolutely necessary for those in favor of the design changes to ritually insult those who aren't?

I guess things really haven't changed in this forum afterall.
Re: Optimus Prime will indeed have a mouth under his "battle" shield (110656)
Posted by Sideshow Sideswipe on May 5th, 2007 @ 10:12am CDT
WHY THE MOUTH?????

:cries:
Re: Optimus Prime will indeed have a mouth under his "battle" shield (110658)
Posted by Skowl on May 5th, 2007 @ 10:13am CDT
Bender Prime wrote:
Exactly. Talk about crying like a bunch of school girls. Waahhh the faceplate isn't on in all the scenes. Waahhh he has flames. Like who cares, it's a TINY DETAIL.


Flames and a mouth on Optimus Prime are "tiny" details? I can't believe someone is even saying this! The flames were bad enough (Prime is such a noble, calm, collected, heroic leader, let's put flames on him wooooo! now he's X-Treme!) and let's give him a mouth so that our dumb audience can see how he's feeling all the time, and have his emotions spelt out in big, bold letters.

"Oh look, Prime has a sad face, he must be sad... duhhh... that girl is pretty, Og like explosions!"

If you think those are "tiny" details, I hate to see what you would consider to be a "big deal".

Bender Prime wrote:I can't believe reading these comments like 'the film will suck cos the face plate isn't on in all the scenes', what a load of baloney, go ask Sam Raimi how he feels about leaving his main characters in masks like the Green Goblin v Spidey fight in Spiderman 1 - he'll tell you it was a dumb move cos the scenes become flat cos you are just staring a darn inanimate plastic object. Prime has to EMOTE, he needs a flippin mouth to do that, it's not a cartoon, it's a $150 million dollar major motion picture so is it so damn hard for these people to understand that he has to be more expressive?


Now this... I don't really now how to answer other than it's just plain wrong. I don't know how many times I need to say this, but you do not need a mouth to project emotions! Good film makers will allow the audience to draw emotions out of a character given the context. You don't need to have sentiments spelt out for you. If you really needed a mouth to project emotions, well, wouldn't every novel ever written have to come with puppets or something, if not - oh no - the reader wouldn't know how the characters were feeling!

Just look at Darth Vader here, his helmet is, as you say, "a darn inanimate plastic object", but I guarantee he emotes better than most on-screen characters with the full range of facial features.

Because, yeah, if Darth Vader needs one thing to emote, it's a mouth...

Image
Image
Image
Image
Image
Image
Image[/i]
Re: Optimus Prime will indeed have a mouth under his "battle" shield (110660)
Posted by Spooner on May 5th, 2007 @ 10:13am CDT
Ravage XK wrote:I think Prime doesnt look half as heroic without his face plate. He actually looks a bit scary in that LA Times picture. I get the whole "these are aliens" thing but Prime was always able to emote perfectly well without a mouth thanks to skill of Mr Peter Cullen.


My sentiments exactly - Mr. Cullen, with that John Wayne "the-voice-alone-could-kick-your-a**" inflection, made the character. Praise God Mr. Bay had the wherewithal to bring him in - that's going to make this movie work, if nothing else.
Re: Optimus Prime will indeed have a mouth under his "battle" shield (110665)
Posted by Emperor Galvatron on May 5th, 2007 @ 10:17am CDT
I'm just loving the fact that Prime needs a mouth to emote, but apparently, none of the Decepticons do.

Oh, that's right, giant robotic bug aliens don't emote, silly rabbit. Just their good guy enemies do.

And I don't lay the blame squarely at Bay's feet, either. Aaron Archer has been pushing for a 'mouthed' Prime for years. (See Energon, Cybertron, TF Movie, etc.) It wouldn't suprise me if Archer pushed for this the whole time.
Re: Optimus Prime will indeed have a mouth under his "battle" shield (110676)
Posted by rad902 on May 5th, 2007 @ 10:28am CDT
Spidey shoots webbing out of his own hands instead of a contraption. Did that spoil the movie? NOOO!

Wolverine dons leather, instead of neon spandex. Did that spoil the movie? NOOO!

Ra's al Ghul is a mortal in Batman Begins, as opposed to the immortal character in comics and other continuities. Did that spoil the movie? NOOO!

He's still Prime. Lips or no lips... This is a pretty tiny issue!
Re: Optimus Prime will indeed have a mouth under his "battle" shield (110677)
Posted by Dr. Caelus on May 5th, 2007 @ 10:30am CDT
rad902 wrote:Ra's al Ghul is a mortal in Batman Begins, as opposed to the immortal character in comics and other continuities.


What makes you think that? :lol:
Re: Optimus Prime will indeed have a mouth under his "battle" shield (110681)
Posted by Omega Sentinel on May 5th, 2007 @ 10:35am CDT
Skowl wrote:I don't know how many times I need to say this, but you do not need a mouth to project emotions!
In a Michael Bay movie you do. He has never made a movie with deep characters.

Mouth, eyes, flipping the bird, or whatever. He needs to do whatever he can with Prime to project emotions because the story certainly won't.

PS...How come the bot that shouldn't have a mouth (Prime) does and the bots that should have a mouth (everyone else) don't? :-?
Re: Optimus Prime will indeed have a mouth under his "battle" shield (110682)
Posted by Nemesis Cyberplex on May 5th, 2007 @ 10:36am CDT
I agree that it was a stupid thing to do. Hell, take Energon Prime for example. They had to go back & take the mouth off of later productions of the toy because nobody liked it(the fact that Takara didn't even give him a mouth kinda helped, too).

I never liked the idea of Prime with a mouth. He never even needed one untill Mainframe got ahold of Primal. Why does a robot need a mouth? Surely it's not for eating.

Oh, & whoever said that about Spidey & the Green Goblin fight....IMHO, the reason that looked bad is for the same reason it looks bad in the Power Rangers shows: They try to make up for lack of facial features by waving their arms around too much(read:emoting through excess movement), which just looks silly. With Prime being all CG, emotion could be pulled off without having to use access movement. Hell, they could easily have him communicate through his eyes. They did in G1. I mean, when he was on his deathbed, his eyes made him look defeated & in pain, & you could tell exactly what he was feeling, & that was a frikin cartoon movie in the 80's. Surely they could do the same thing if not better with all the CG tech they have nowadays.

Oh, & BTW....Disagreeing with the directions these guys are going in with character designs is not whining. Most people I've seen on these boards, as well as others, have argues the points in a reasonable, mature manner, but the few "OMG Bay ButT-r4p3D My Ch1lDH00d!!!" comments apparently was all they heard...or wanted to hear so they could call the fandom as a whole a bunch of whining babies....

Spiderman 3 is a very good example of how this TF movie could have been made with respect to the previous designs & still been well-accepted. Even what they did change was not so far-fetched in design that it slapped the source material in the face(mainly talking about the New Goblin).

I call BS.
Re: Optimus Prime will indeed have a mouth under his "battle" shield (110685)
Posted by 1337W422102 on May 5th, 2007 @ 10:39am CDT
Make bad decisions, change things for no reason, ignore the fans, make fun of them for being fans... Yeah, I really like where this is going. By changing things only to try to appeal to everyone they only will end up appealing no one, except for maybe the Lowest-Common-Denominator "omg teh r0botz is el huug3 lol i lyk wen teh 5iht bl0wZZ up" crowd who haven't even heard of Transformers.

If you want to make a movie about the Transformers, make one about THE TRANSFORMERS. If you want to make a movie about generic shape-shift alien mechanoids who simply look cool and want to blow shit up, do that. But you CANNOT make a movie about both of them! And simply attributing the classic characters' names and personalities to the new Terminator-like droids does NOT make them the Transformers. Modifying timeless, iconic characters just for the sake of 'cooler CGI' is a big mistake and a bitch move.

Perhaps one day a movie about the Transformers, the real Transformers, will reach theatres. But that day is not July 4.
Re: Optimus Prime will indeed have a mouth under his "battle" shield (110687)
Posted by ZoneDaiatlas on May 5th, 2007 @ 10:40am CDT
Bender Prime wrote:Speak for yourself, I don't mind the on/off face plate, the benefits obviously outweigh the disadvantages given the scope and purpose of the film, something no one on here can comment on having not seen how these things actually look in motion.

And Bay is cool, there is no one I'd rather have directing my big robots movie, other than maybe Cameron.

I wanted Peter Jackson or Ridley Scott directing the Transformers movie. Those directors would schooled Michael Bay about directing a big budget film with a plot, script and acting... I was sadden that Paramount didn't hire Stan Winston since he's the best in the business in animatronics and robot designs.
Re: Optimus Prime will indeed have a mouth under his "battle" shield (110690)
Posted by ZoneDaiatlas on May 5th, 2007 @ 10:42am CDT
Seibertron wrote:This really pisses me off. It's Optimus-f'in-Prime for crying out loud. Can we at least have ONE thing in this movie not be changed for the sake of changing? I can't believe how passive so many people are being about this decision. And don't bring up the whole Optimus Primal thing. I would have been fine if they did the Beast Wars or Cybertron approach with movie Prime. This just looks ridiculous. How anyone at ILM or Dreamworks or even at Hasbro thought this looked even remotely good or "cool" seriously needs to get their eyes checked.

Please keep the entire design staff as far away as possible from G.I.Joe and any future Super Hero movies. Next thing you know we'll have a yellow Spider-Man with a visor and pinchers on his face as well as the Blue Lantern, a red Batman, a green Superman and a pink Wolverine. After seeing Spider-Man tonight and seeing how faithful they are to his costume, it helped me realize how disappointed I am to this day in the robot designs in this movie. I don't care what the reasons are for it, these design changes were poor decisions from the get-go and are completely unnecessary regardless of what mumbo-jumbo they want to make up to spin these changes to the public.

Don't get me wrong ... I'm extremely excited about the movie. But I feel a strong sense of Deja Vu. Beast Machines comes to mind. Great story. Absolutely horrible designs.

Seibertron, this Transformer movie has Godzilla (US 1998) written all over it...
Re: Optimus Prime will indeed have a mouth under his "battle" shield (110701)
Posted by Octavious Prime on May 5th, 2007 @ 11:01am CDT
I agree with most of you that Prime should have just had the faceplate on the whole time, and that many of the designs could of been much better but all I can say is what do you expect? They wanted to make an action-packed summer blockbuster and thats what they did.

It would have been impossible to use G1 designs in this movie, I mean you saw the type of crazy sh** those bots are doing. True, theres alot more they could of done (they could of atleast made starscream's head look like the newthundecracker toy that looks more like the orignal screamer), but thats hollywood for you.

Remember, this is not Spider-man, Batman, or Superman. Those movies are easy to stay true to the character designs, story, etc, but this is transformers, not exactly the easiest franchise to adapt into a live-action film. Changes HAD to be made, and though they might not have been the best decisions, I'm just going to except it as another encarnation of the series.

Anyone could go for days talking about what wasn't done right for the movie, but i just don't have the energy anymore. Come on people, it's live-action Transformers! you're not even a little excited?
Re: Optimus Prime will indeed have a mouth under his "battle" shield (110704)
Posted by Senor Hugo on May 5th, 2007 @ 11:06am CDT
Flashbang wrote:I have respect for directors who do what they want and don't sweat over what the fans say.


Yeah, I have respect for the directors who do that as well. Kevin Smith did that, and we got Jersey Girl, Joel Schumacher did that, and we got Bat Nipples. Steven E. de Souza did that, and we got Street Fighter. Annabel Jankin and Rocky Morton did that, and we got Super Mario Brothers, and the list goes on. MK:Annihilation, Blade: Trinity, AvP, Hulk.

Ataraxia wrote:Stop being such whiny little bitches. who cares? i mean seriously. it's a film about giant transforming robots destroying things and eachother, that's the concept we all know and love and that hasn't changed. just be thankful you're getting a movie based on a toy franchise. and by-the-by spidey has more exposure than transformers so it'd be harder to change anything like that. plus a battle shield over the face tends to make it hard for a cgi character to emote...stupid funking fanboys...


I love these replies. "ZOMG be grateful you're getting a movie!" Hm, we should be happy we're getting a movie that could very well ruin Transformers.

Also, since when was Transformers just about destroying each other? If that was the case, why even bother making a Transformers movie, they could just call it "Rock'em Sock'em Robots: The Movie."

Transformers is not just about robots destroying each other, it's about an alien race trying to not only protect humankind from their evil counterparts, but to gather energy to save their planet.

The whole "it's about giant robots and fighting" is just a huge excuse to cover for a poor movie script, and to cover up the fact that the person/people making the film really have no clue about the source material.

Also, Prime doesn't need a mouth to emote. Eyes say a hell of a lot more than seeing lips does.
Re: Optimus Prime will indeed have a mouth under his "battle" shield (110705)
Posted by zodconvoy on May 5th, 2007 @ 11:10am CDT
6 VWs for under $17,000?

Yeah, but the fact is Bumblebee isn't one. This is officially no longer the Transformers movie. It is now the Go-Bots, a $150,000,000.00 90 minute episode of the fire-trucking GOBOTS!
Re: Optimus Prime will indeed have a mouth under his "battle" shield (110706)
Posted by Seibertron on May 5th, 2007 @ 11:11am CDT
Ataraxia wrote:Stop being such whiny little bitches. who cares? i mean seriously. it's a film about giant transforming robots destroying things and eachother, that's the concept we all know and love and that hasn't changed. just be thankful you're getting a movie based on a toy franchise. and by-the-by spidey has more exposure than transformers so it'd be harder to change anything like that. plus a battle shield over the face tends to make it hard for a cgi character to emote...stupid funking fanboys...


It's OPTIMUS PRIME! Can't you at least appreciate that? And please don't call the fans who are complaining about this whiny bitches. Thanks.

Transformers and More @ The Seibertron Store

Visit our store on eBay
These are affiliate links. We may earn commissions when you purchase items or services through these links.
Visit shop.seibertron.com to buy "THUNDERCATS #2 Cvr ZH 1:15 FOC foil Dynamite Comics 2024 JAN247378 2ZH (CA) Tao"
NEW!
THUNDERCATS #2 Cvr ...
Visit shop.seibertron.com to buy "THUNDERCATS #1 Cvr L FOIL virgin Dynamite Comics 2024 DEC230215 1L (CA) Parrillo"
THUNDERCATS #1 Cvr ...
Visit shop.seibertron.com to buy "THUNDERCATS #2 Cvr O 1:20 Dynamite Comics 2024 JAN240119 2O (CA) Lee + Chung"
NEW!
THUNDERCATS #2 Cvr ...
Visit shop.seibertron.com to buy "SKELETOR vs HE-MAN Masters of the Universe Minis MOTU SDCC Comic-Con 2013 New"
SKELETOR vs HE-MAN ...
Visit shop.seibertron.com to buy "Masters Universe FORGE DESTINY #1 Cvr C Dark Horse Comics JUL231104 1C Rodriguez"
Masters Universe F ...
Visit shop.seibertron.com to buy "Masters Universe MASTERVERSE #1 Cvr C Dark Horse Comics DEC220423 1C Aragones"
Masters Universe M ...
Visit shop.seibertron.com to buy "Masters Universe FORGE DESTINY #1 Cvr B Dark Horse Comics JUL231103 1B Williams"
Masters Universe F ...
Visit shop.seibertron.com to buy "Masters Universe FORGE DESTINY #4 Cvr B Dark Horse Comics OCT231206 4B Fowler"
Masters Universe F ...
Visit shop.seibertron.com to buy "Masters Universe FORGE DESTINY #2 Cvr B Dark Horse Comics AUG231235 2B Seeley"
Masters Universe F ...
Visit shop.seibertron.com to buy "THUNDERCATS #1 3rd ptg Cvr A Dynamite Comics 2024 JAN249148 (CA) Nakayama"
NEW!
THUNDERCATS #1 3rd ...
Visit shop.seibertron.com to buy "HE-MAN AND MASTERS OF THE MULTIVERSE #5 DC Comics 2020 JAN200552 Universe MOTU"
HE-MAN AND MASTERS ...
Visit shop.seibertron.com to buy "THUNDERCATS #1 Cvr O LTD virgin Dynamite Comics 2024 DEC230218 1O (CA) Nakayama"
NEW!
THUNDERCATS #1 Cvr ...
Visit shop.seibertron.com to buy "THUNDERCATS #1 Cvr S 1:15 virgin Dynamite Comics DEC230222 1S (CA) Action Figure"
THUNDERCATS #1 Cvr ...
Visit shop.seibertron.com to buy "THUNDERCATS #1 Cvr E Dynamite Comics 2024 DEC230208 1E (CA) Tao (W) Shalvey"
THUNDERCATS #1 Cvr ...
* Price and quantities subject to change. Shipping costs, taxes and other fees not included in cost shown. Refer to listing for current price and availability.
Find the items above and thousands more at the Seibertron Store on eBay
Transformers Podcast: Twincast / Podcast #347 - Swooped In
Twincast / Podcast #347:
"Swooped In"
MP3 · iTunes · RSS · View · Discuss · Ask
Posted: Saturday, April 6th, 2024

Featured Products on Amazon.com

These are affiliate links. We may earn commissions when you purchase items or services through these links.
Buy "Transformers MPM04 Optimus Prime" on AMAZON
Buy "Transformers Titans Return Grotusque and Scorponok Deluxe Action Figure Exclusive Set" on AMAZON
Buy "Transformers: Generations Power of The Primes Legends Class Autobot Outback" on AMAZON
Buy "Transformers: Generations Power of the Primes Voyager Class Starscream" on AMAZON
Buy "Transformers: Generations Power of The Primes Deluxe Class Dinobot Slug" on AMAZON
Buy "Transformers Power of the Primes Punch-Counterpunch and Prima Prime" on AMAZON
Buy "Transformers: Bumblebee Movie Toys, Power Charge Bumblebee Action Figure - Spinning Core, Lights and Sounds - Toys for Kids 6 and Up, 10.5-inch" on AMAZON
Buy "Transformers Studio Series 12 Voyager Class Movie 1 Decepticon Brawl" on AMAZON
Buy "Transformers Generations Titans Return Legends Class Decepticon Ravage(Discontinued by manufacturer)" on AMAZON
Buy "Transformers Generations Titans Return Titan Master Hyperfire and Blurr" on AMAZON
Buy "Transformers Generations, Platinum Edition, One Shall Stand, One Shall Fall" on AMAZON
Buy "Transformers B1798AS0 Warpath Figure Combiner Wars" on AMAZON