Why I'm Happy the IDW Transformers Universe is Ending

Why I'm Happy the IDW Transformers Universe is Ending

Sunday, July 29th, 2018 8:00am CDT

Categories: Comic Book News, Site Articles, Editorials
Posted by: Va'al   Views: 35,771

Topic Options: View Discussion · Sign in or Join to reply

Well, 'happy' might not be the best word. But hear me out.


The IDW Transformers and Hasbro universe, their comics continuity, has been running for the past 13 years, and was announced - for lack of a better term - to reach its conclusion by the time the Unicron mini-series came to its own end, taking Lost Light and Optimus Prime with it (alongside Rom, Micronauts, GI Joe, MASK, and all the various casts and stories within).

As of this week, and after an initial showing at the San Diego Comic Con 2018 IDW panel, we have finally seen the final covers for the last issues of each of the three series - but most importantly for Lost Light and Optimus Prime.

Transformers News: Why I'm Happy the IDW Transformers Universe is Ending


Let's go a little into the background first, though: in October 2005, Simon Furman and EJ Su brought to the stage Infiltration #0, the revelation that Cybertronians had been on Earth for a while, Verity Carlo and Hunter O'Nion, and a new Marvel Ultimates-influenced 'Generation One' continuity - its Phase One - began.

A year later, in September 2006, Nick Roche and Simon Furman went back a little further in Spotlight: Shockwave, an issue that will become more and more relevant to everything happening in this universe up to its very end.

Some of those stories were cut short in 2008 (and concluded in Maximum Dinobots - until we came back to it all in Lost Light), as Shane McCarthy's All Hail Megatron saw the triumph of the Decepticons on Earth and the creation and arrival of Drift, some initial but vocal fan complaints (not all was bad!), which only got louder for the most part with what followed from 2009 to 2011, and Mike Costa's ongoing series. Then Optimus Prime was killed, again, and Orion Pax returned - the comics split in two parallel series: More Than Meets the Eye, and Robots in Disguise. Phase Two begins.

Transformers News: Why I'm Happy the IDW Transformers Universe is Ending


Part of the Phase Two stories, alongside the ongoings, were the Wreckers' Saga (now collected in one volume), the Autocracy trilogy (which we re-covered here), and the first proper crossover event in Dark Cybertron - which brought with it a much wider universe, and the arrival of Windblade (among others).

Transformers News: Why I'm Happy the IDW Transformers Universe is Ending


Since then, the ongoing series saw a third companion, in Windblade, and eventually Till All Are One. Dawn of the Autobots led into Days of Deception, then its second crossover Combiner Wars up to Titans Return, and opening the universe even further and wider in Revolution, Reconstruction and the final big event, First Strike, which ushered in the end of the Hasbro Universe through the unfortunate Transformers vs Visionaries miniseries, and the resulting summoning of Unicron.

Transformers News: Why I'm Happy the IDW Transformers Universe is Ending

So here we are, at the brink of it all. The universe is about to end, and I just told you I'm happy for it. Let me explain why, exactly:

  • Continuity - This is the bane of comics everywhere, I have said so before and I will keep on saying so until we stop considering 'canon' as something monolithic and impervious to change and modification. Continuity can be a useful tool, but taken to its extreme it's just silly, harmless, and a source of headaches - and unnecessary gatekeeping for readers who do not want to or cannot keep track of everything that happened ten years prior to the book they're reading right now. An entirely new, actually fresh start will clear everything before it - and a new continuity can be established, free from the self-imposed shackles that prevent potential fans to fully enjoy the books coming out. Hopefully, something looser, that will allow for further development as it continues.

  • IDW Publishing - The IDW staff have proven themselves extremely capable of creating good Transformers fiction (other fiction too, but this is the focus here of course). Sure, there have been pitfalls along the way, mostly down to the strained relationship between licensor and licensee, and how that affected the creators in their storytelling. But they have never entirely destroyed the Transformers story that was being told. With John Barber as EIC, I have the confidence that this will continue, strongly, into whatever new venture we will see the comics embark.

  • Timing - I said something very similar in a piece about the Transformers Bumblebee Movie, but it's worth repeating at this point: the entire Hasbro universe, outside of the fiction, is being reshaped. The live action movies have shifted tone and possible storytelling, with Paramount looking to start afresh; the comics are all being ended together, with stories having been developed for a long time already, by admission of the writers themselves (and TAAO and Wreckers also had their excellent farewells), and reaching a almost entirely organic conclusion; a new toyline, with some heavy fiction behind it, is being launched in Fall 2018; it's been 13 years. That's a new fan's entire life, and one now ripe for the seeding of a new story.

  • New talent - A lot of the creators, with the exclusion of editor John Barber, have already stated that they are not currently planning on returning to the books. Be it artists, or writers, or colourists, or anyone else involved in the creation of the books, we currently have no idea of who will be involved, and this opens doors to infinite potential: to name but a couple of fan favourites, Sarah Stone came into the books from fan-art work; Alex Milne had a similar trajectory from deviantArt, though with previous engagements at Dreamwave; Kei Zama was extremely popular on Tumblr before doing covers and eventually interiors; most current professional creators have been fans of the franchise since they started doing art or writing of any kind; we've seen several fan creators spotlighted in comics covers across the series and the years, and the prospect of entirely new talent is tantalisingly exciting. I am ready for all of it.

  • Comics precedent - This is a two-sided point, actually.

    Firstly, comics history has a well proven track record of having limited series among its most influential of all time: I'm thinking of The Sandman, Lucifer, The Wicked and The Divine (end forthcoming), even Saga will end at some point (once the current hiatus is over). The same can be said for book series, and even big and small screen ones - in spite of the recent wave of rebooting and forced continuation - I mean, Marvel Transformers itself is famously a 4 issue mini-series that lasted for 80 numbers. Having an ending is good. It does not cancel out a story, it allows it to sit and mature with time and with every revisitation.

    Secondly, the precedent set by the current IDW universe. The entirety of the creative teams involved have been working nothing short of miracles in establishing a seriously impressive layer of fertile ground for more stories to spring forth (not in the Botanica sense from ReGeneration One - sorry Simon). In an interview with the Twincast Podcast, Nick Roche spoke about 'a groove that was for everyone reading – and if that’s not for me, that’s fine' - starting with the inclusivity, diversity, and representation that the writers so far have established for the Transformers world, and carrying that into the next stories as a starting point. The precedent, the existing reality that made it into non-specialist media coverage, as well as triumphed within comics circles, is there, and it is a thing of wonder.

Transformers News: Why I'm Happy the IDW Transformers Universe is Ending



As I was working on the later stages of this comment, a similar piece from David Heslop was brought to my attention, and I wholeheartedly recommend heading over to read that too, as one phrase in particular jumped out at me: 'by giving us an ending, we get to experience the totality of this saga’s existence'.

Experiences can indeed be bittersweet, and provoke untold levels of emotion - be that good or bad - but we have all been witnesses to something unprecedented in a licensed comic property that started out way back when to sell toys and flesh out their packaging bios. Non-Anglophone readers are slowly gaining access to those stories too, with translations of MTMTE spearheading localised publishing pushes, and Japan receiving the full story from AHM onwards as we speak; the rest will hopefully follow too, even if much after the end of this particular era of stories.

And for that, for all of these thirteen (even just the number!) years, for all of these stories, yes - I am happy to see them come to an end. With an ending that the creators have meant and carefully planned. And an ending that I still hope will open to something bigger still in the years to come.


Transformers News: Why I'm Happy the IDW Transformers Universe is Ending


Thumbnail image by Alex Milne and Josh Perez


This article was last modified on Sunday, July 29th, 2018 7:36am CDT

News Search

Got Transformers News? Let us know here!

Re: Why I'm Happy the IDW Transformers Universe is Ending (1975032)
Posted by ZeroWolf on July 29th, 2018 @ 8:52am CDT
Great article Va'al with a lot to think about. I spouse what I'm most curious about is the fate of some of the concepts introduced, such as conjunx endura and the relationships that played out. It also took us to a phase rarely seen in TF fiction (at least rarely seen when it first happened) that of post-war and of the conflict that arose when the neutrals returned.
Re: Why I'm Happy the IDW Transformers Universe is Ending (1975039)
Posted by Sparkimus Prime on July 29th, 2018 @ 9:31am CDT
All the best to the writers and especially the animators of those stories. That being said, I'm optimistic that the politics and gender dysphoria will be removed like the cancers they are for the new comics. This is after all supposed to be children's toys and stories. Till all are one.
Re: Why I'm Happy the IDW Transformers Universe is Ending (1975043)
Posted by ZeroWolf on July 29th, 2018 @ 9:39am CDT
Children's toys? Yes but the comics are geared for older fans, teenagers at least. Thus more mature storytelling is encouraged.
Re: Why I'm Happy the IDW Transformers Universe is Ending (1975047)
Posted by Sparkimus Prime on July 29th, 2018 @ 9:52am CDT
ZeroWolf wrote:Children's toys? Yes but the comics are geared for older fans, teenagers at least. Thus more mature storytelling is encouraged.


IDW comics were included in a lot of the recent Generations toys. You can't really separate the two. My point was the comics are meant for all audiences.
Re: Why I'm Happy the IDW Transformers Universe is Ending (1975052)
Posted by Skritz on July 29th, 2018 @ 10:02am CDT
The worst of IDW Transformers has certainly been, in spite of everything else, the issue of continuity and the multiple titles and multiple writers. The sheer density of retcon, rewrites and continuity shifting so endemic to comics has simply made it an impossible to follow mess. The addition of the rest of the Hasbro properties has only made this worse. This simply is not the same creature that was Furman's original idea to reboot the franchise back in the early 2000 but rather turned into the pet abomination of fanboys canonizing their own silly ideas or, as people sometimes call it, inmates running the asylum. :roll:

IDW Transformers is a mess. I'm glad it is getting put out of it's misery.
Re: Why I'm Happy the IDW Transformers Universe is Ending (1975056)
Posted by Va'al on July 29th, 2018 @ 10:06am CDT
Sparkimus Prime wrote:
ZeroWolf wrote:Children's toys? Yes but the comics are geared for older fans, teenagers at least. Thus more mature storytelling is encouraged.


IDW comics were included in a lot of the recent Generations toys. You can't really separate the two. My point was the comics are meant for all audiences.


Image
Re: Why I'm Happy the IDW Transformers Universe is Ending (1975057)
Posted by Tommy T. on July 29th, 2018 @ 10:08am CDT
Yeah I 100% agree, idw transformers is a complete mess. Stories jumping around , politics, robots in love with each other holding hands and hugging. Good riddance.
Re: Why I'm Happy the IDW Transformers Universe is Ending (1975058)
Posted by Va'al on July 29th, 2018 @ 10:08am CDT
Skritz wrote:The worst of IDW Transformers has certainly been, in spite of everything else, the issue of continuity and the multiple titles and multiple writers. The sheer density of retcon, rewrites and continuity shifting so endemic to comics has simply made it an impossible to follow mess. The addition of the rest of the Hasbro properties has only made this worse. This simply is not the same creature that was Furman's original idea to reboot the franchise back in the early 2000 but rather turned into the pet abomination of fanboys canonizing their own silly ideas or, as people sometimes call it, inmates running the asylum. :roll:

IDW Transformers is a mess. I'm glad it is getting put out of it's misery.


I don't think it's in a dire state, at all, and I think the work done to the stories that started with Furman - especially after Costa did whatever happened in those years - has been pretty good, if convoluted and unwelcoming to anyone who wasn't a devoted reader.

In that last respect, I mostly agree with you, as I pointed out above.
Re: Why I'm Happy the IDW Transformers Universe is Ending (1975059)
Posted by ZeroWolf on July 29th, 2018 @ 10:10am CDT
Yet that also stopped not long after it started with only the thrilling 30 and combiner wars deluxes doing it (only American editions at that). So I don't think kids will be reading them now...not that they would have then as it really wasn't wise plonking people right in the middle of an arc, or with the case of combiner wars, splitting the story up in waves that a collector may not even see them all at retail.

All that aside though, I don't think kids are that bother by tf comics, so we shouldn't force the comics to be all ages when it can tackle darker themes and more complex issues.
Re: Why I'm Happy the IDW Transformers Universe is Ending (1975062)
Posted by Va'al on July 29th, 2018 @ 10:13am CDT
ZeroWolf wrote:Yet that also stopped not long after it started with only the thrilling 30 and combiner wars deluxes doing it (only American editions at that). So I don't think kids will be reading them now...not that they would have then as it really wasn't wise plonking people right in the middle of an arc, or with the case of combiner wars, splitting the story up in waves that a collector may not even see them all at retail.

All that aside though, I don't think kids are that bother by tf comics, so we shouldn't force the comics to be all ages when it can tackle darker themes and more complex issues.


Thing is though, children's media already tackles all of those 'more complex' issues.

Look at anything Disney and Pixar have put out in past 10 years. Or Laika. Or any YA book. If people are willing to complain about 'simple' toys taking kids for dumb when they're not, then we should also stop taking kids for dumb when providing them with potentially challenging media!
Re: Why I'm Happy the IDW Transformers Universe is Ending (1975066)
Posted by Sparkimus Prime on July 29th, 2018 @ 10:17am CDT
Va'al wrote:
Sparkimus Prime wrote:
ZeroWolf wrote:Children's toys? Yes but the comics are geared for older fans, teenagers at least. Thus more mature storytelling is encouraged.


IDW comics were included in a lot of the recent Generations toys. You can't really separate the two. My point was the comics are meant for all audiences.


Image


If that was meant to be a joke, maybe take your job a little more seriously. If that was meant to be serious, I feel bad for you.
Re: Why I'm Happy the IDW Transformers Universe is Ending (1975068)
Posted by ZeroWolf on July 29th, 2018 @ 10:18am CDT
Va'al wrote:
ZeroWolf wrote:Yet that also stopped not long after it started with only the thrilling 30 and combiner wars deluxes doing it (only American editions at that). So I don't think kids will be reading them now...not that they would have then as it really wasn't wise plonking people right in the middle of an arc, or with the case of combiner wars, splitting the story up in waves that a collector may not even see them all at retail.

All that aside though, I don't think kids are that bother by tf comics, so we shouldn't force the comics to be all ages when it can tackle darker themes and more complex issues.


Thing is though, children's media already tackles all of those 'more complex' issues.

Look at anything Disney and Pixar have put out in past 10 years. Or Laika. Or any YA book. If people are willing to complain about 'simple' toys taking kids for dumb when they're not, then we should also stop taking kids for dumb when providing them with potentially challenging media!

Point taken, though I'm always weary because as soon as certain people get wind of developments like that in kids media, then suddenly it's "think of the children!" I've had arguments like this in my own circles so i just err on the side of caution.

I know it's not great :-(
Re: Why I'm Happy the IDW Transformers Universe is Ending (1975069)
Posted by Va'al on July 29th, 2018 @ 10:22am CDT
Sparkimus Prime wrote:
Va'al wrote:
Sparkimus Prime wrote:
ZeroWolf wrote:Children's toys? Yes but the comics are geared for older fans, teenagers at least. Thus more mature storytelling is encouraged.


IDW comics were included in a lot of the recent Generations toys. You can't really separate the two. My point was the comics are meant for all audiences.


Image


If that was meant to be a joke, maybe take your job a little more seriously. If that was meant to be serious, I feel bad for you.


I am totally serious when talking about toy robots and their fictional boyfriends in space.
Re: Why I'm Happy the IDW Transformers Universe is Ending (1975076)
Posted by Moonshot on July 29th, 2018 @ 11:05am CDT
IDW Transformers universe has been my favorite so far. Thats coming from someone who was 6 in 1984 and started as a kid with Transformers from the very beginning. I also love Sunbow G1, Marvel, Marvel UK, Beast Wars, Animated etc. But IDW is something more and adult me plus the kid inside can relate and be highly entertained. Although I do agree some of the more annoying SJW stuff and politics needs to be toned down. I could just do without it in my Transformers comics, its already everywhere else. As it has been, its not that bad, I just dont want even more. This IDW Transformers ride has been awesome since the start and I also cant wait for it to end. Closure on a story is important, plus I am imagining all the cool story, world, characters that will come out of it into the new IDW continuity.
Re: Why I'm Happy the IDW Transformers Universe is Ending (1975077)
Posted by TulioDude on July 29th, 2018 @ 11:29am CDT
Sparkimus Prime wrote:
ZeroWolf wrote:Children's toys? Yes but the comics are geared for older fans, teenagers at least. Thus more mature storytelling is encouraged.


IDW comics were included in a lot of the recent Generations toys. You can't really separate the two. My point was the comics are meant for all audiences.


Still worth remembering that up untill the Dark Cybertron arc,most of the stories and designs were based on variations of the G1 version,with no toyline to accompany it.
Re: Why I'm Happy the IDW Transformers Universe is Ending (1975081)
Posted by Skritz on July 29th, 2018 @ 12:06pm CDT
The thing is, to me, IDW Transformers was on a downward slope before even politics reared their ugly head simple because of the aforementioned issue of continuity and fanboys running the asylum. It's not to say fan-pandering is inherently bad but with a 13-years old continuity it run the risk of becoming (and did become) an inapproachable mess of self-referential continuity and fan-pandering. A story need to be able to be relatively self contained with a beginning/middle/end and comics with their ongoing nature and often drastic changes in writers are terrible at wrapping stories up compared to cartoons. By the very nature of the medium, it's function and desire you WANT to keep things running whereas a TV show usually knows it only has a few seasons.

I'm glad it's ending with a bang but I still abide by my point that it's dragged on for way too long.
Re: Why I'm Happy the IDW Transformers Universe is Ending (1975083)
Posted by ZeroWolf on July 29th, 2018 @ 12:38pm CDT
Skritz wrote:The thing is, to me, IDW Transformers was on a downward slope before even politics reared their ugly head simple because of the aforementioned issue of continuity and fanboys running the asylum. It's not to say fan-pandering is inherently bad but with a 13-years old continuity it run the risk of becoming (and did become) an inapproachable mess of self-referential continuity and fan-pandering. A story need to be able to be relatively self contained with a beginning/middle/end and comics with their ongoing nature and often drastic changes in writers are terrible at wrapping stories up compared to cartoons. By the very nature of the medium, it's function and desire you WANT to keep things running whereas a TV show usually knows it only has a few seasons.

I'm glad it's ending with a bang but I still abide by my point that it's dragged on for way too long.

Try telling that to the big two comic makers ;-)

Also thirteen years is quite ironic don't you think considering the franchise :lol:
Re: Why I'm Happy the IDW Transformers Universe is Ending (1975085)
Posted by Skritz on July 29th, 2018 @ 12:41pm CDT
ZeroWolf wrote:
Skritz wrote:The thing is, to me, IDW Transformers was on a downward slope before even politics reared their ugly head simple because of the aforementioned issue of continuity and fanboys running the asylum. It's not to say fan-pandering is inherently bad but with a 13-years old continuity it run the risk of becoming (and did become) an inapproachable mess of self-referential continuity and fan-pandering. A story need to be able to be relatively self contained with a beginning/middle/end and comics with their ongoing nature and often drastic changes in writers are terrible at wrapping stories up compared to cartoons. By the very nature of the medium, it's function and desire you WANT to keep things running whereas a TV show usually knows it only has a few seasons.

I'm glad it's ending with a bang but I still abide by my point that it's dragged on for way too long.

Try telling that to the big two comic makers ;-)

Also thirteen years is quite ironic don't you think considering the franchise :lol:


Yes and the DC/Marvel are both struggling and anyone familiar with comic history will know how much of a continuity headache it can be. The number of times they've rebooted a classic character can be staggering.
Re: Why I'm Happy the IDW Transformers Universe is Ending (1975098)
Posted by dragons on July 29th, 2018 @ 1:39pm CDT
For people complaining about IDW Transformers stories jumping they never read any marvel comic series X-Men, xfactor, Spider-Man , deadpool, avengers books I named off inter twine with other comic series such as wolverine black panther punisher still don’t know what I’m talking about xmen onslaught series, Phoenix saga resurrection , Spider-Man death or rebirth , death of superman, superman returns, Batman Gotham City earthquake series, , and many others plus over constant use of time travel and clones in marvel comics,.

Welcome to world of comic books transformers people that’s normal for me I’m use to it where stories get mixed up in other series I will miss idw series having megatron as autobot, starscream ruler of cybertron, new transformers series better not have death Optimus prime again every transformer comic series prime dies gets reborn again,.

I like look of IDW Transformers until artists starting drawing transformers based on toys of combiner wars and power primes then it went away idw series Glad comedy will be gone autobot shoots himself, another autobot juggling, autobot doing impression of hudini being chained up from ceiling upside trying to escape, if I want comedy in transformers I will watch beast wars, rid, armada, energon, cybertron, transformers animated with annoying Siri ,
Re: Why I'm Happy the IDW Transformers Universe is Ending (1975104)
Posted by ZeroWolf on July 29th, 2018 @ 2:07pm CDT
Doesn't that kind of point to comedy being a fundamental strand in the franchises dna? You also forgot Prime (it had comedic elements just as all tf shows have had)

Also you may not have liked more than meets the eye but there was robots in disguise as well ;-)

Featured Products on Amazon.com

Buy "Transformers Generations Exclusive Cyber Battalion Class Shockwave Figure" on AMAZON
Buy "Transformers Authentics Grimlock Action Figure" on AMAZON
Buy "Transformers Toys Megatron Cyberverse Ultimate Class Action Figure - Repeatable Fusion Mega Shot Action Attack Move - Toys for Kids 6 and Up, 11.5-inch" on AMAZON
Buy "Transformers: Generations Power of The Primes Legends Class Autobot Outback" on AMAZON
Buy "Transformers: Generations Power of The Primes Leader Evolution Optimus Prime" on AMAZON
Buy "Transformers Generations Combiner Wars Computron Collection Pack" on AMAZON
Buy "Transformers: Generations Power of The Primes Solus Prime Prime Master" on AMAZON
Buy "Cyberverse Warrior Class Acid Storm" on AMAZON
Buy "Transformers MV5 Turbo Changer Super Nova Action Figure" on AMAZON
Buy "Transformers Generations Titans Return Deluxe Autobot Topspin and Freezeout" on AMAZON
Buy "Transformers Generations Combiner Wars Legends Class Decepticon Viper Figure" on AMAZON
Buy "Transformers Tra Rid Warrior Soundwave Action Figure" on AMAZON
Transformers Podcast: Twincast / Podcast #287 - Pulse Con 2021
Twincast / Podcast #287:
"Pulse Con 2021"
MP3 · iTunes · RSS · View · Discuss · Ask
Posted: Monday, October 25th, 2021

New Items on eBay

Buy "Transformers DOUBLE PUNCH Botcon Japan Exclusive The Evil Predacon Limited" on EBAY
Buy "Transformers War For Cybertron Soundblaster Black 35th Anniversary Hasbro WFC" on EBAY
Buy "Transformers Rescue Bots SALVAGE Garbage Truck Figure Hasbro Playskool Heroes" on EBAY
Buy "Transformers 2005 BotCon Decent Into Darkness Ricochet" on EBAY
Buy "TRANSFORMERS RESCUE BOTS BLADES (Shark Sub Variant), Rare Shark Sub Capture 2015" on EBAY
Buy "Transformers Titans Return Wheelie" on EBAY
Buy "Transformers Titans Return SLUGSLINGER w/ Caliburst 2017 Figure MOSC in USA G1" on EBAY
Buy "Gigapower GP HQ-04 Graviter (METALLIC) Transformers Sludge Complete, Re-boxed" on EBAY