IDW Star Saber Designs
Posted by Va'al
Apr 21, 2013 at 5:43pm CDT
47,463 views
View Discussion
Sign in
or
Join
to reply
More Bots. More News. More Awesome.
Re: IDW Star Saber Designs
(view post)
Comment by Super Megatron
Apr 21, 2013
Best.Autobot.Leader.EVER.
Re: IDW Star Saber Designs
(view post)
Comment by Mindmaster
Apr 21, 2013
Oh, you better believe he will get a toy in the Thrilling 30 toyline.
Re: IDW Star Saber Designs
(view post)
Comment by Bumblevivisector
Apr 21, 2013
And just hours ago, I happened to read that MSTF script with the "Victory with ball-joints" joke. Damn, that's a weird coincidence.
Actually, here's hoping he doesn't get a toy rushed into production until an IDW Victory Leo design that he can combine with is finalized. Then we're talkin'!
Actually, here's hoping he doesn't get a toy rushed into production until an IDW Victory Leo design that he can combine with is finalized. Then we're talkin'!
Re: IDW Star Saber Designs
(view post)
You know they will/won't (pick your favorite).
Comment by Mindmaster
Apr 21, 2013
Bumblevivisector wrote:Actually, here's hoping he doesn't get a toy rushed into production until an IDW Victory Leo design that he can combine with is finalized. Then we're talkin'!
You know they will/won't (pick your favorite).
Re: IDW Star Saber Designs
(view post)
Comment by Manterax Prime
Apr 21, 2013
He had better get toy sometime this year! The G1 figure and Energon Wing Saber just doesn't cut it for me as a sufficient Star Saber.
So, what size class? Leader? Supreme? Titan?
So, what size class? Leader? Supreme? Titan?
Re: IDW Star Saber Designs
(view post)
Okay, I wouldn't say any of those. He would feel way too big. I'd wager either Deluxe or Voyager. If they were to make a Victory Leo toy that can combine with Star Saber into Victory Saber, I would go with Deluxe. No combination, Voyager.
Comment by Mindmaster
Apr 21, 2013
Manterax Prime wrote:So, what size class? Leader? Supreme? Titan?
Okay, I wouldn't say any of those. He would feel way too big. I'd wager either Deluxe or Voyager. If they were to make a Victory Leo toy that can combine with Star Saber into Victory Saber, I would go with Deluxe. No combination, Voyager.
Re: IDW Star Saber Designs
(view post)
Comment by MasterSoundBlaster
Apr 21, 2013
Voyager Tarn, Voyager Star Saber, Deluxe Chromedome...
Oh please Hasbro? PLEASE???
Oh please Hasbro? PLEASE???
Re: IDW Star Saber Designs
(view post)
Voyager Tarn with a Scout-sized Vos as a Targetmaster. Yeah, think on that for a while.
Comment by Mindmaster
Apr 21, 2013
MasterSoundBlaster wrote:Voyager Tarn, Voyager Star Saber, Deluxe Chromedome...
Oh please Hasbro? PLEASE???
Voyager Tarn with a Scout-sized Vos as a Targetmaster. Yeah, think on that for a while.
Re: IDW Star Saber Designs
(view post)
Comment by Manterax Prime
Apr 21, 2013
Voyager IDW Sentinel Prime as well.
Re: IDW Star Saber Designs
(view post)
Comment by Down_Shift
Apr 21, 2013
Looks pretty good. Milne is at his best when he doesn't have to draw a face. Alt mode looks a little naff though.
Oh well, ya win some ya lose some.
Oh well, ya win some ya lose some.
Re: IDW Star Saber Designs
(view post)
Comment by Ultra Markus
Apr 21, 2013
i'm all for making new toys out of this or any victory character but i think i would like a reissue of the original for the nostalgia, theres just something about those brick-formers
Re: IDW Star Saber Designs
(view post)
Comment by RAcast
Apr 21, 2013
DAMN Saber, you're lookin' good!
Re: IDW Star Saber Designs
(view post)
Comment by jamarmiller
Apr 22, 2013
God I hate these idw designs , what was wrong with his original design?
Re: IDW Star Saber Designs
(view post)
Comment by Deathsanras
Apr 22, 2013
What's missing from the design is the Mary Jane shoes to fit the Mary Sue character.
Even a giant gestalt is no match for the burning justice of the incomparable, exalted Star Saber, who swoops in and saves both the day and the ineffectual non-Star Saber Cybertrons, each and (almost) every episode.
If you were really a purist railing against change, you'd insist that he continue to speak Japanese. If you can handle the concept of an English-speaking Star Saber, you can adapt.
Even a giant gestalt is no match for the burning justice of the incomparable, exalted Star Saber, who swoops in and saves both the day and the ineffectual non-Star Saber Cybertrons, each and (almost) every episode.
jamarmiller wrote:God I hate these idw designs , what was wrong with his original design?
If you were really a purist railing against change, you'd insist that he continue to speak Japanese. If you can handle the concept of an English-speaking Star Saber, you can adapt.
Re: IDW Star Saber Designs
(view post)
Other than the fact that though his original design was cool, it still made him, and almost every other brick bot look like a generic super sentai mecha, nothing.
The IDW designs are a well needed and well received improvement as they make the robots look like robots.
Comment by Manterax Prime
Apr 22, 2013
jamarmiller wrote:God I hate these idw designs , what was wrong with his original design?
Other than the fact that though his original design was cool, it still made him, and almost every other brick bot look like a generic super sentai mecha, nothing.
The IDW designs are a well needed and well received improvement as they make the robots look like robots.
Re: IDW Star Saber Designs
(view post)
YES.
That is one sexy bot mode. Looking forward to his appearance!
Comment by kirbenvost
Apr 22, 2013
MasterSoundBlaster wrote:Voyager Tarn, Voyager Star Saber, Deluxe Chromedome...
Oh please Hasbro? PLEASE???
YES.
That is one sexy bot mode. Looking forward to his appearance!
Re: IDW Star Saber Designs
(view post)
OMG, holier than though posters, God I forgot why I dont post on TF boards anymore, thank you for reminding me !
Comment by jamarmiller
Apr 22, 2013
Manterax Prime wrote:jamarmiller wrote:God I hate these idw designs , what was wrong with his original design?
Other than the fact that though his original design was cool, it still made him, and almost every other brick bot look like a generic super sentai mecha, nothing.
The IDW designs are a well needed and well received improvement as they make the robots look like robots.
Deathsanras wrote:What's missing from the design is the Mary Jane shoes to fit the Mary Sue character.
Even a giant gestalt is no match for the burning justice of the incomparable, exalted Star Saber, who swoops in and saves both the day and the ineffectual non-Star Saber Cybertrons, each and (almost) every episode.jamarmiller wrote:God I hate these idw designs , what was wrong with his original design?
If you were really a purist railing against change, you'd insist that he continue to speak Japanese. If you can handle the concept of an English-speaking Star Saber, you can adapt.
OMG, holier than though posters, God I forgot why I dont post on TF boards anymore, thank you for reminding me !
Re: IDW Star Saber Designs
(view post)
My 2 cents: nothing per se. But times have changed since the 80's, so in order to appeal to the masses, the designs have to be changed/updated as well. By today's standards, the designs would be blocky, bland, in other words boring.Thundercats, He-Man, and Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles have gone the updating route too, so why not Transformers?
If you prefer the original designs to remain as they were, nothing wrong with that (everybody got that?). I, for one, welcome the update, but a little less detail can go a long way.
Comment by Jelze Bunnycat
Apr 22, 2013
jamarmiller wrote:God I hate these idw designs , what was wrong with his original design?
My 2 cents: nothing per se. But times have changed since the 80's, so in order to appeal to the masses, the designs have to be changed/updated as well. By today's standards, the designs would be blocky, bland, in other words boring.Thundercats, He-Man, and Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles have gone the updating route too, so why not Transformers?
If you prefer the original designs to remain as they were, nothing wrong with that (everybody got that?). I, for one, welcome the update, but a little less detail can go a long way.
Re: IDW Star Saber Designs
(view post)
The level of sarcasm is strong with this one, though I do approve.
Frankly, I'll never understand people who are -that- kind of "purist" (see: stuck in the past). It's not like this is a new design, it's a great update/combination of G1/Energon Star/Wing Saber, and it looks fantastic. His head's even the same as the G1 character, and that's the part that matters!
Comment by RAcast
Apr 22, 2013
Deathsanras wrote:What's missing from the design is the Mary Jane shoes to fit the Mary Sue character.
Even a giant gestalt is no match for the burning justice of the incomparable, exalted Star Saber, who swoops in and saves both the day and the ineffectual non-Star Saber Cybertrons, each and (almost) every episode.jamarmiller wrote:God I hate these idw designs , what was wrong with his original design?
If you were really a purist railing against change, you'd insist that he continue to speak Japanese. If you can handle the concept of an English-speaking Star Saber, you can adapt.
The level of sarcasm is strong with this one, though I do approve. Frankly, I'll never understand people who are -that- kind of "purist" (see: stuck in the past). It's not like this is a new design, it's a great update/combination of G1/Energon Star/Wing Saber, and it looks fantastic. His head's even the same as the G1 character, and that's the part that matters!
