Bombshell0001 wrote:How about the Transformers 86 movie line ?
ZeldaTheSwordsman wrote::roll:
The only reason to make the Insecticons Deluxe-class is accessories. And they all look reasonably detailed and accurate (well, aside from Shrapnel having proper bug legs instead of G1-accurate wheeled runners pretending to be bug legs ).
Matter of opinion. I like the 4 deluxe dinos, even if I agree that at least Snarl and Sludge should have been voyager sized. Swoop and Slag were smaller, so deluxe is good for them. But of course they had to accommodate that shitshow of a combiner, so they got ruined. Don't get me started on Grimlock (again).ZeldaTheSwordsman wrote:The PotP Dinobots are not horrible and nor is Volcanicus.
Ruined? I thought you said you liked them In any case, they didn't. Because the ONLY changes made to them to accommodate Volcanicus were the hand/foot sockets and replacing the Diaclone cockpits with combiner pegs. And Slag got a major upgrade to how his tail is dealt with in robot mode (For those unaware, on the G1 toy, Slag's tail is a contender for Clunkiest Piece of Kibble on a Transformer Ever; the best you can do is hide it under his hollow feet). Or were you talking about Grimlock with that "ruined" remark?Rodimus Prime wrote:Matter of opinion. I like the 4 deluxe dinos, even if I agree that at least Snarl and Sludge should have been voyager sized. Swoop and Slag were smaller, so deluxe is good for them. But of course they had to accommodate that shitshow of a combiner, so they got ruined.ZeldaTheSwordsman wrote:The PotP Dinobots are not horrible and nor is Volcanicus.
Aside from the combiner ports and integrating the tailtip into the legs, he's a fairly exacting articulation-improved upscale. Have you tried tightening his chest tabs so that you can use him as a standalone Grimlock?Rodimus Prime wrote:Don't get me started on Grimlock (again).
I like the deluxes as they are. I even use them as limbs for Sky Lynx sometimes. What I meant by 'ruined' was that they could have been good voyagers (at least Sludge and Snarl) if they weren't shoehorned in as limbs. Their potential as voyagers was ruined. As they are, they actually display well with G1 Grimlock.ZeldaTheSwordsman wrote:Ruined? I thought you said you liked them In any case, they didn't. Because the ONLY changes made to them to accommodate Volcanicus were the hand/foot sockets and replacing the Diaclone cockpits with combiner pegs. And Slag got a major upgrade to how his tail is dealt with in robot mode (For those unaware, on the G1 toy, Slag's tail is a contender for Clunkiest Piece of Kibble on a Transformer Ever; the best you can do is hide it under his hollow feet). Or were you talking about Grimlock with that "ruined" remark?Rodimus Prime wrote:Matter of opinion. I like the 4 deluxe dinos, even if I agree that at least Snarl and Sludge should have been voyager sized. Swoop and Slag were smaller, so deluxe is good for them. But of course they had to accommodate that shitshow of a combiner, so they got ruined.ZeldaTheSwordsman wrote:The PotP Dinobots are not horrible and nor is Volcanicus.
You will NEVER convince me that PoTP Grimlock is a good figure, so stop trying. He's 0-3. Struck out. Robot: mediocre. Dino: vomit. Torso: what's below mediocre?Aside from the combiner ports and integrating the tailtip into the legs, he's a fairly exacting articulation-improved upscale. Have you tried tightening his chest tabs so that you can use him as a standalone Grimlock?Rodimus Prime wrote:Don't get me started on Grimlock (again).
I didn't like Grimlock from the moment I saw him. The only reason I ever bought him in the 1st place is because I thought Volcanicus was passable in reviews I watched. Of course, in-hand is usually a different story, in this case for the worse. The loose chest is just an extra reason to be disappointed. I'm seriously thinking about gluing the shoulder tabs on Volcanicus into place so he can support the weight of the arm limb-bots. I don't have a problem with how he looks, he just doesn't stay together.ZeldaTheSwordsman wrote:Sludge and Snarl didn't have potential as Voyagers in that line in the first place. It was being limbs that got them slots at all.
You know what, perhaps I will stop trying to convince you on Grimlock. After all, one of your major complaints - the chest untabbing - is only due to bad luck at the QC roulette and has an easy fix... and you won't even give that a try to see if that improves things. I forget what your other complaints about the robot mode were; that's the one that stuck in my mind..
ZeldaTheSwordsman wrote:Gauntlet, I own all five G1 Dinobots and the PotP ones are hardly mediocre. The only knocks comparison-wise are Slag lacking wings the and reduced accessory count. But considering all the improvements in articulation and the fact that HasTak managed to do something about SLAG'S STUPID TRICERATOPS TAIL...
ZeroWolf wrote:I think the best way to get Voyager Dinobots is to space them out over a three year trilogy (like WfC) two Voyagers a year then a leader Class... Though that could be what they're planning regarding the 86 SS idea, get Grimlock this year, two Voyagers next year, then the last two the year after. Though does swoop really have to be a voyager? His alt isn't bulky, I could see him just being a tall deluxe
And what were these expectations of yours that they failed to live up to, hm? I was expecting new figures that painstakingly replicated the G1 toys' looks while improving articulation and integrating the combiner gimmick as tidily as possible (which they did, and fairly seamlessly on Slag et al). And minus Slag's kibble wings, that's exactly what we got. Oh, sure, their accessory arsenals are a tad lacking, but CHUG has always suffered on that front. Some of the G1 figures' weapons being 5mm compatible helps compensate in their case, as do Prime Master armors and Titan Master vehicles.Gauntlet101010 wrote:ZeldaTheSwordsman wrote:Gauntlet, I own all five G1 Dinobots and the PotP ones are hardly mediocre. The only knocks comparison-wise are Slag lacking wings the and reduced accessory count. But considering all the improvements in articulation and the fact that HasTak managed to do something about SLAG'S STUPID TRICERATOPS TAIL...
I own all the toys I mentioned, including the PotP Dinos, Platinum Dinos and, stupidly, the SDCC Dinos because I had an obsession with getting the "perfect" Classics set. I even own the G1 dinos and a stupid amount of G1 styled Grimlocks.
So, in my informed opinion owning many G1 dinobot toys, the PotP toys leave a lot to be desired
Well, they certainly wouldn't have wanted the Cybertronian modes and Earth modes sharing the shelves. Especially not the redeco-cow molds.Tuned Agent wrote:ZeroWolf wrote:I think the best way to get Voyager Dinobots is to space them out over a three year trilogy (like WfC) two Voyagers a year then a leader Class... Though that could be what they're planning regarding the 86 SS idea, get Grimlock this year, two Voyagers next year, then the last two the year after. Though does swoop really have to be a voyager? His alt isn't bulky, I could see him just being a tall deluxe
While this would definitely be the way to do it, I don't think this will happen given HasTak's current attitude of making all of a team in the same line (though they probably did that so everyone would buy all the Siege seekers and datsuns before the "better" ER ones were revealed, a hurdle the Dinobots wouldn't have to jump over).
ZeldaTheSwordsman wrote:And what were these expectations of yours that they failed to live up to, hm? I was expecting new figures that painstakingly replicated the G1 toys' looks while improving articulation and integrating the combiner gimmick as tidily as possible (which they did, and fairly seamlessly on Slag et al).
Tuned Agent wrote:ZeroWolf wrote:I think the best way to get Voyager Dinobots is to space them out over a three year trilogy (like WfC) two Voyagers a year then a leader Class... Though that could be what they're planning regarding the 86 SS idea, get Grimlock this year, two Voyagers next year, then the last two the year after. Though does swoop really have to be a voyager? His alt isn't bulky, I could see him just being a tall deluxe
While this would definitely be the way to do it, I don't think this will happen given HasTak's current attitude of making all of a team in the same line (though they probably did that so everyone would buy all the Siege seekers and datsuns before the "better" ER ones were revealed, a hurdle the Dinobots wouldn't have to jump over).
Personally, I don't think we'll ever get more than Grimlock in this scale, for numerous reasons.
As for Swoop, I'd really prefer him as a voyager. I think his wings would take up too much plastic for him to work as a tall deluxe, and even if the mass did work out he'd still only be as tall as Ironhide.
ZeldaTheSwordsman wrote:It is. Although if you were expecting the PotP Dinobots to have chrome, which is what you're making it sound like, then you're hardly fully informed.
Deluxes puts them at a smaller scale than they'd normally be. And since being Deluxes was the only way they were getting slots, I was ready, willing, and able to accept the size limits that imposed on them.
...
They deliver everything that could reasonably be asked for from retail Deluxe updates of the G1 designs, aside from Slag's kibble-wings being omitted.
You kept bringing up the fancy shiny G1-based redecoes as examples of "how it should be done", so I was starting to wonder if you really did expect the PotP figures to deliver the same quality of deco.Gauntlet101010 wrote:ZeldaTheSwordsman wrote:It is. Although if you were expecting the PotP Dinobots to have chrome, which is what you're making it sound like, then you're hardly fully informed.
This is just being obnoxious. You are purposefully missing the point.
Eh, it works out for those who like the combined mode, since it makes Volcanicus scale with the majority of combiners. And since it was the only way they were getting in and they'd been ignored by CHUG for over a decade despite their popularity..Gauntlet101010 wrote:Deluxes puts them at a smaller scale than they'd normally be. And since being Deluxes was the only way they were getting slots, I was ready, willing, and able to accept the size limits that imposed on them.
...
They deliver everything that could reasonably be asked for from retail Deluxe updates of the G1 designs, aside from Slag's kibble-wings being omitted.
Then deluxe sized G1 Dinobots are inherently just not that great of an idea.
*shrug* Depends who you compare them too. Yeah, they seem thin compared to, say, most SIEGE Deluxes (since on top of the height, everything not moldmated to/based on PotP Moonracer has fat arms and chests), or to TR and Universe figures.. but that's a bit like comparing DOTM Deluxe-class Ironhide to ROTF Leader-class Optimus Prime. They fare substantially better compared to fellow limb-bots and to pre-movie G1s. Or Legion-class figures.Gauntlet101010 wrote:The weird thing about opinions is that two people can have the same toy and yet judge it differently. You have the dinos and think they're really great because they handle their limits well. I think they're mediocre because their limits yielded a so-so toy for the designs and characters involved. I think the sculpts are just "meh." They are a small, thin, interpretation of the G1 designs in robot mode and it doesn't work for me with the exception of Swoop.
You're right, it's not. It's just.. your opinion bugged me because it seemed to come from expecting things retail Deluxes, especially CHUG retail Deluxes, were never going to be capable of in the first place... and then being disappointed that those expectations weren't met. It... touched a nerve. And I'm sorry.Gauntlet101010 wrote:Your opinion isn't the only valid one to have.
ZeroWolf wrote:Tuned Agent wrote:ZeroWolf wrote:I think the best way to get Voyager Dinobots is to space them out over a three year trilogy (like WfC) two Voyagers a year then a leader Class... Though that could be what they're planning regarding the 86 SS idea, get Grimlock this year, two Voyagers next year, then the last two the year after. Though does swoop really have to be a voyager? His alt isn't bulky, I could see him just being a tall deluxe
While this would definitely be the way to do it, I don't think this will happen given HasTak's current attitude of making all of a team in the same line (though they probably did that so everyone would buy all the Siege seekers and datsuns before the "better" ER ones were revealed, a hurdle the Dinobots wouldn't have to jump over).
Personally, I don't think we'll ever get more than Grimlock in this scale, for numerous reasons.
As for Swoop, I'd really prefer him as a voyager. I think his wings would take up too much plastic for him to work as a tall deluxe, and even if the mass did work out he'd still only be as tall as Ironhide.
I actually meant getting all the Dinobots in Studio Series, the same way they handled Devastator, but looking back, I didn't make that clear, my apologies.
Return to Transformers Toys Discussion
Registered users: Bing [Bot], Google [Bot], Google Adsense [Bot], Google Feedfetcher, Immortal Starscream, Majestic-12 [Bot], Roadbuster, SupersonicShockwave, TF-fan kev777, Yahoo [Bot]