Transformers Prime Cliffjumper "First Edition" vs. "Robots in Disguise" Pictorial Review
Thursday, January 26th, 2012 8:21AM CSTCategories: Cartoon News, Reviews, Toy News
Posted by: El Duque Views: 45,713
Seibertron.com member Azrail has posted a pictorial review comparing the two versions of the ill fated Autobot. Check out the side by side comparisons below.
No matter which Cliffjumper you get you will enjoy it! They are both really nice figures. Neither are perfect. Hopefully there will be another that combines them into an ultimate version.
IMG #1. He is considerably shorter than the FE version, but that one has large shoulders. I would say the RID version comes up to about the middle of the FE versions face.
The RID is only red and silver/gray now. No black for the body except the fake windscreen.
IMG #2. The back kibble hangs lower on him, if I did it right. You can raise it up a little if you ignore where it locks in. They do both have fake red wheels on the legs. The RID version though is more noticeable.
Also the back of his legs is hollow. Unlike the FE one which is covered by flaps.
IMG #3. I would say the kibble hangs out a bit farther on the RID one. But it fits with the overall style so doesn't detract.
The sides of his arms also have a big gap on it where the wheel arch is. The windows fold down slightly over his arms but really should go down further.
The doors clip together in a U style clip which is ok but can slip a little. The front grill folds down above his elbows.
IMG #4-5. The car mode is only slightly shorter, same width but not as high.
So when next to Bumblebee it looks like a whole different scale. Somewhere between Deluxe and Scout. Not that all scales match in a line.
It transforms much simpler than the First Edition and clips together much tighter with less obvious lines. There is no gap between the hood and the windshield now also. I didn't do a good job of transforming the FE and forgot to flip some windows up.
The windows are now very clear and there are no breaks in the side windows like the FE. What annoys me is behind the windshield. There is all these connector pieces I can't see much of a purpose for except to hold it on?
IMG #6. You can see the fake chest and the head below.
IMG #7. The fronts are very similar but the RID lights and horn are different colours.
IMG #8. Same with the back but no exhaust pipes. Plus added black.
IMG #9-10. There are holes on the top and sides for the weapon. Shame they couldn't have used the trick that DOTM Roadbuster does. Also there is no Autobot symbol anywhere on him.
For some reason I didn't take a pic of his robot mode with the weapon but there are a few of those around.
Some quick robot details:
He has an automorph feature. When you pull his shoulders down his head pops up from it's slight hiding place.
The wrists are on a ball joint but the movement is limited. They can only be moved down or left/right. The doors get in the way of everything else.
The feet are on a ball joint and have very good movement. He stands nice and sturdy.
He has a waist swivel that works well.
Legs are on a ball joint. Knees aren't and only go backwards.
Shoulders are on a ball joint but the wheels can get in the way. There is a swivel joint below the shoulders.
Elbows only bend up as far as the long arms allow.
The head will only move side to side and behind it are the cogs for the automorph. It does have light piping which should be good for the Terrorcon version
Most Popular Transformers News
SDCC 2014 Coverage: Official Images of Generations: Combiner Wars Aerialbots and Stunticons30,516 views
Most Recent Transformers News
Transformers Generations 30th Anniversary Leader Class Jetfire Pre-Order up at AmazonPosted 2 hours ago
Posted by Vicalliose on January 26th, 2012 @ 8:46am CST
Posted by Flakmaster on January 26th, 2012 @ 8:56am CST
Seriously, who are the idiots at Hasbro and Takara who keep dissing the good toys and keep telling the designers to make more gimmicky, kibbly figures instead?!
I blame the marketing division.
Edit: saw above figure comparisons.
SCRAP! That thing is smaller in vehicle form than Deluxe Rodimus, and I already felt cheated his small size!
This is bad Hasbro, real bad. I had hope for this line when I first saw the 'First Edition' line images, but this is terrible.
Posted by Autobot032 on January 26th, 2012 @ 8:59am CST
Vicalliose wrote:Sitting next to each other the RID one practically looks like a knockoff to me.
O_o... YES! Exactly! That's a perfect way to explain it.
Posted by mattwhite924 on January 26th, 2012 @ 9:03am CST
Posted by NamelessOne on January 26th, 2012 @ 9:04am CST
Glad I shelled out for Takara FE all the way, so far.
I really like the look of Wheeljack (RID), I may pick that up, along with a few vehicons, but I'd even hold back on those if I knew there was a FE Takara Wheeljack soon.....fingers crossed!
These RID figs seem to be what DOTM Deluxes are to ROTF Deluxes... Lacking.
Posted by Rated X on January 26th, 2012 @ 9:06am CST
Posted by Sodan-1 on January 26th, 2012 @ 9:13am CST
The only things that I preferred about RiD was his not-so-blocky lower legs and the fact his headlights were more prominent on his torso, but now I know its a fake chest (YOU SUCK!) and the legs are hollow the choice seems pretty clear. FE FTW!!!
P.S. Can't believe this thing is smaller than Backfiery.
P.P.S. I'll give it this to its credit, it's not often you see a red gorilla with horns. (The last time was when I went on that bachelor party to the zoo.)
Posted by WolfDawg on January 26th, 2012 @ 10:00am CST
Posted by GuyIncognito on January 26th, 2012 @ 10:09am CST
Posted by rpetras on January 26th, 2012 @ 10:26am CST
I ordered the last Takara FE Cliffjumper from BBTS based on this review.
Posted by Godzillabot Primal on January 26th, 2012 @ 10:35am CST
If they scaled the RID one to a larger size, I'd buy it.
Oh my brain hurts!!
Posted by kirbenvost on January 26th, 2012 @ 10:48am CST
Rated X wrote:Why did Hasbro/Takara waste their resources to create two different molds of the same characters instead of producing more characters ??? what a complete waste of effort and plastic. And then they complain when 3rd parties give fans the characters they really want.
I was wondering the exact same thing. But perhaps they were forced to change the line after the FEs were designed, or maybe the designers went above and beyond what Hasbro wanted. Then they saw how good the designs were and went "You know what, these are really good and you guys worked hard on them. Even though it's not what we planned for the line, we'll try to get them a release anyway." I guess if you think about it like that, we should be really grateful they still released them anyway. At least, those who were lucky enough to get the First Editions...
As for the comparison, even though RID is more screen accurate in some ways, I'm glad I managed to pick up the FE. He really benefits from the black in robot mode and the tinted windows in vehicle mode, and of course the more complex transformation. RID also suffers from some pretty bad monkey arms, whereas the FE one is not as bad.
Posted by T-Macksimus on January 26th, 2012 @ 11:30am CST
He certainly won't be a replacement for my Classics CJ and I can't say as I care for the whole horns on the hood gimmick but I like the classic muscle car styling enough that I can handle dropping just over $10.00 for this thing. I may actually buy 2 just because that alt-mode is begging to have a more traditional muscle car paint app. either in black or deep metal-flake blue just to do it some justice.
Posted by TheDownshift on January 26th, 2012 @ 11:40am CST
This is the worst piece of garbage since Beast Machines Nightscream.
I mean... just... Sweet Tapdancing Jesus this f*ucking sucks.
Posted by Fistful of Energon on January 26th, 2012 @ 12:04pm CST
Posted by AutobotTrainer on January 26th, 2012 @ 12:44pm CST
Posted by Chopperface on January 26th, 2012 @ 1:09pm CST
Posted by Azrail on January 26th, 2012 @ 1:44pm CST
Sodan-1 wrote:Thanks Azrail! I've been waiting for comparison shots and these were perfect.
Glad you liked them I was awake a long time the other day taking pics and finishing the editing
Was trying to think what scale people wanted to see and what else I could take pics with. It went from a small picture post to a full on review!
Posted by Azrail on January 26th, 2012 @ 1:49pm CST
rpetras wrote:Thanks for the comparison.
I ordered the last Takara FE Cliffjumper from BBTS based on this review.
Thanks a lot Glad everyone liked it. I've not done many reviews properly like this, just normally comments somewhere. But then again how often does the UK get a chance to!
As much as it has it's flaws and the FE version is better in a lot of ways. I'm really warming to this guy. So much so that I may keep 1 for myself instead of trading it. Once you have it and start playing it's still a really great figure.
So all I'm saying is if you don't have a Cliffjumper and can get this at a good price then it's worth looking at. The few cool things can outweigh some of the bad things.. But also get a First Edition too
Posted by Mykltron on January 26th, 2012 @ 2:18pm CST
Posted by Optimus1138 on January 26th, 2012 @ 2:33pm CST
Posted by Delicon on January 26th, 2012 @ 3:03pm CST
Posted by sabrigami on January 26th, 2012 @ 3:23pm CST
Posted by mightwork on January 26th, 2012 @ 6:53pm CST
Thanks for the pics Azrail! I'm now really happy with my choice of shelling out the dough for the FE deluxe
Posted by hpfabe on January 27th, 2012 @ 2:06pm CST
I understand the new design being one they might want to go with because it might be cheaper to make, but they already made the molds for the First Edition (which, in my opinions, looks WORLDS BETTER). Molds are not cheap, especially ones meant to withstand significant production runs, and these two don't look like they share any common pieces.
Why invest in the first molds for the superior product, and then make brand new molds for a second one, so soon, even if that run might be a bit cheaper?
Posted by trence5 on January 31st, 2012 @ 9:44pm CST
Posted by Azrail on January 31st, 2012 @ 11:19pm CST
trence5 wrote:Just going by first glance, honestly if didn't know these were official lines..... .......I'd think this was a KNOCK-OFF
I suppose with the hollow back legs and arms it does share similar features to a KO.