Seibertron.com Energon Pub Forums

Sabrblade wrote:

orangeitis wrote:

Sabrblade wrote:

JelZe GoldRabbit wrote:Going by the "Thou shall not attempt to combine Japanese and US versions of any Transformers line backstory" commandment.

It's simple. Transformers defies most rules of foreign dubs that original is usually the more accurate, Word of God version, what with the existence of the Universal Streams system enabling the coexistence of all versions in the multiverse. Car Robots and RID are not the same show/universe. Fire Convoy is not the same guy as Convoy/Optimus Prime/whoever else, nor is Gigatron any version of Megatron, etc. etc.

The RiD cartoon is set in Viron 901.8 Alpha
And Car Robots is set in Primax 400.5 Alpha

And that's what I love about the Transformers.

So long as Hasbro don't mess it up with all that aligned continuity crap.

Aligned continuity material should have no bearing on the Multiverse, nor should the latter affect the former. The two are separate entities.

It shouldn't, but I'm not sure what Hasbro meant by past continuities not being included in future Transformers lore.

If they said that at all.

Y'know, if you really don't want Depth Charge, you could sell him to me.

Or better yet, just give him to me because you're such a nice person.

orangeitis wrote:It shouldn't, but I'm not sure what Hasbro meant by past continuities not being included in future Transformers lore.

If they said that at all.

They said that certain elements of past series will emcompass the Aligned continuity, but not the entirety of past series themselves. G1 is still G1 and so on. Think like how Animated had so many elements taken from past series while it was still its own thing. It's like that here with the Aligned continuity.

Sabrblade wrote:They said that certain elements of past series will emcompass the Aligned continuity, but not the entirety of past series themselves. G1 is still G1 and so on. Think like how Animated had so many elements taken from past series while it was still its own thing. It's like that here with the Aligned continuity.

Or in other words, they're going to make things so confusing that only Sabrblade can understand it.

Delicon wrote:

Sabrblade wrote:They said that certain elements of past series will emcompass the Aligned continuity, but not the entirety of past series themselves. G1 is still G1 and so on. Think like how Animated had so many elements taken from past series while it was still its own thing. It's like that here with the Aligned continuity.

Or in other words, they're going to make things so confusing that only Sabrblade can understand it.

How is it confusing? It's no different that any other continuity reboots we've had before. RiD, Armada, Movies, Animated... this is just another new one that has a lot of inspirations from previous series. Only difference this time being its longevity of seven years to a decade.

Sabrblade wrote:

Delicon wrote:

Sabrblade wrote:They said that certain elements of past series will emcompass the Aligned continuity, but not the entirety of past series themselves. G1 is still G1 and so on. Think like how Animated had so many elements taken from past series while it was still its own thing. It's like that here with the Aligned continuity.

Or in other words, they're going to make things so confusing that only Sabrblade can understand it.

How is it confusing? It's no different that any other continuity reboots we've had before. RiD, Armada, Movies, Animated... this is just another new one that has a lot of inspirations from previous series. Only difference this time being its longevity of seven years to a decade.

Hint - I was being sarcastic

Sabrblade wrote:

RAcast wrote:

Sabrblade wrote:

Flux Convoy wrote:

orangeitis wrote:Last time I checked, RiD wasn't in G1 continuity though.

You should have checked more thoroughly. RID is a far flung continuation of G1. Brave Max is simply Fort Max.

The short version is, it's a continuity headache. Just go with the logical route and call it a splinter continuity.

Or, simply put, RiD is not G1 continuity, period. Car Robots is, but not RiD.

I know logistics, minutiae and technicalities are your thing but come on. For the sake of argument they are the same thing. You can nitpick it out all you like. Go crazy. Same difference though. Simply put, Transformers continuity, as a whole, is a nightmare.

Flux Convoy wrote:I know logistics, minutiae and technicalities are your thing but come on. For the sake of argument they are the same thing. You can nitpick it out all you like. Go crazy. Same difference though. Simply put, Transformers continuity, as a whole, is a nightmare.

The English dub of RiD rewrote a lot of things from the original version Car Robots to make it stand out on its own. And, combined with the Universal Streams system, both can exist as different realities. One that is set in the Viron Cluster, where the inhabitants speak English and all have one set of names and identities, and one that is set in the Primax Cluster where they all speak Japanese and have a different set of names and identities.

Why, Brave Max got a whole unique history and origin story of his own that RiD Fort Max never got.

It's like how Scramble City, The Headmasters, Masterforce, Victory, Zone, etc. are all set in the same continuity as FSRLTF and 2010, but not the English G1 cartoon.

Or how Beast Wars Second, Beast Wars Neo, Beast Wars Reborn, and Beast Wars Diorama Story are all set in the same continuity as Beast Wars SLTF, Beast Wars Metals, and Beast Wars Returns, but not the English versions of Beast Wars and Beast Machines.

Certain aspects of different language versions differentiate them from other dubs enough to make them stand on their own, as well as tie them to other series that other dubs don't relate to. Like, The Headmasters and Masterforce couldn't possibly fit in with the English G1 cartoon since The Rebirth occurs instead of The Headmasters and "G1 season five" has Optimus Prime as a Powermaster at some point during/after 2007, when Convoy is still dead by that point in the Japanese cartoon continuity.

It also doesn't help that G1 season 3 takes place in 2006, while 2010 is set in 2010, leaving a five-year gap of events between the Japanese dub of the G1 movie (2005-2010) that is acknowledged in other Japanese G1 cartoon material. A five-year gap that is otherwise nonexistent in the English version.

A new dub creates a new universe/reality/universal stream/etc. That's how the Transformers multiverse work.

See, I would've gone with the movie Depthcharge for the mold. That way he'd at least have some kind of aquatic alt-mode.

Also he needs a less gaudy colour scheme.