The Energon Pub

[Sharpwing]

Oh, I'm so original

So, who'll win in a fight?

Let's say a physical battle and a music battle.

My vote goes to Metallica in both battles (I just have to )

[Venomous Prime]

Anthrax for a physical fight.

Megadeth for music

[Omega Scourge]

depends

If it's rust in peace era megadeth then I have to go with them, but if it's Master of puppets era metallica then I have to go with them

[Sharpwing]

depends

If it's rust in peace era megadeth then I have to go with them, but if it's Master of puppets era metallica then I have to go with them

So you'd say MoP > RiP?

Because that would mean you say Metallica has made better metal than Megedeth. And they have

[tequila stu]

Metallica. Both counts...I prefered load and reload.....to mop

[Psycho Warrior]

either Metallica or Megadeth

[Dagon]

Slayer, on both counts.

[Bartmanhomer]

Megadeth will win.

[Predacon Galvatron]

Oh boy, a topic about my favorite band...

Physical Battle:

Don't know much about the physical appearance of any of the bands but Metallica, but I will give the battle to Metallica.

Music Battle:

I like all 4 bands in a sense, but Metallica is the most diverse of the 4. They have sound that has evolved and changed over the years, given us something different from a metal band,which can work to their advantage, in my opinion, or depending on your opinion, it has worked to their disadvantage.

In my opinion, Metallica wins this battle as well, simply because of their diversity and appeal to many different rock audiences.

[DesalationReborn]

If modern Day, Slayer's the only one still rocking hard enough. If all in prime, I'd have to say Metallica (MoP or ...AJFA).

[snavej]

Some of these bands have disbanded. Some of the members have died. The rest will have to fight with zimmerframes.