>
>
>

IDW Beast Wars #8 Review

Posted by ScottyP Sep 22, 2021 at 6:42am CDT 40,061 views
You Say 'That's Just Prime', But It's Probably Just Another Situation Gone Wrong
A Review of Beast Wars #8

Spoiler Free-ish

The title of Beast Wars #8 is "Pod Part 02", as in the second part of a longer story just called "Pod". In my review of issue 7, I took issue with the book's pacing, and the same issues linger here. It's not terribly slow, but things don't pick up quickly with this most recent release either. As the last mention of this for most of the remainder of this particular review, I'll let Blackarachnia share a word for you if you had expectations that this latest installment would avoid the "writing for the trade" pace the series has been taking -


Blackarachnia: Still Mean

Writer Eric Burnham does well in this issue at making the events that do happen feel engaging. Even with an idea in mind on roughly what will happen (unless you're new to Beast Wars entirely) there's a sense of tension and plenty of character-appropriate dialogue, resulting in a final product that was very easy to get absorbed in. Outside of Nyx who is pure background decoration in this issue, Burnham shows that he knows who these characters are effectively communicates some of their traits as the story moves along.


"It don't matter. None of this matters."

Without going into spoiler territory, it can be pointed out that while this issue (and presumably this story arc as a whole) is repeating the beat from the show's plot about recovering Maximal Protoforms from orbit, there's enough difference here to be encouraged by what may be yet to come. Put another way, while you may still generally know from point A on page 1 to point B on page 20 that point B was always the destination, there's some road construction on the way with enticing potential for the future.


Cats: Also Still Mean

The artistic team on issue 8 is the same from 7, meaning Winston Chan's on the lineart again with colors by SidVenBlu and letters by Jake M. Wood. There's a lot to like here, with fun action scenes and a regular helping of close-up character portrayals during the scenes of just dialogue. There's a particular instance where Cheetor's running through the Axalon in cheetah mode and the panel layout has him overlapping multiple panels to express a sense of speed, which was very enjoyable and clever, at least to me. There were some instances again when I thought Chan's expressions went a bit stiff or where some characters' poses looked unnatural that prevent a full helping of solid praise for the art, but in general it's well executed here and still feels consistent with the rest of the series so far.

Cover options include Andrew Griffith's take on Optimus Primal and Megatron duking it out, Martin Gee's Blackarachnia cover which is used for this review's news story's thumbnail, as well as a 10-copy retailer incentive cover featuring both spider Predacons by Ryan Miller. As always, you can find all the cover images and full credits for the issue through our Vector Sigma Database page for Beast Wars #8.

Verdict

Slowly, in this case, but sure

Beast Wars #8 was more fun to read than I expected, with just enough beneath the surface layer of plot to make things compelling despite a general overall expectation of events that went mostly fulfilled. The character development is proceeding smartly in most cases and while the art's not by any means perfect this time around it conveys the story effectively while still providing a standout moment or two. I'm excited to see where things develop, but please, please start getting us there quicker.

I really wanted to go up to a 4/5 this time, which is "very good" on my scale, but the pacing just won't allow me to go above the "good" below.
Final Score
. :PREDACON: :PREDACON: :PREDACON: ½
out of
:PREDACON: :PREDACON: :PREDACON: :PREDACON: :PREDACON:


Look out for this issue today, September 22nd, where you can pick it up at the Seibertron.com eBay store or at your local shop, check here to find the closest shop to you.
IDW Beast Wars #8 Review
IDW Beast Wars #8 Review
IDW Beast Wars #8 Review
IDW Beast Wars #8 Review
IDW Beast Wars #8 Review
IDW Beast Wars #8 Review
IDW Beast Wars #8 Review
IDW Beast Wars #8 Review
IDW Beast Wars #8 Review
IDW Beast Wars #8 Review

More Bots. More News. More Awesome.

Re: IDW Beast Wars #8 Review (view post)
Comment by Sabrblade Sep 22, 2021
AllNewSuperRobot wrote:As I said, after reading the last issue, Burnham doesn't get how Stasis Pods work. For one thing, how they can't leave orbit on their own.
It didn't "leave orbit on its own". It started falling because it had received part of the invasive code Tarantulas sent to it, which contained a command for the pod's onboard computer to activate its thrusters and send it down to the planet's surface.

The pods' computers in the cartoon were essentially in sleep mode while in orbit and didn't activate until after the crash-landings. Here, their onboard computers can be accessed with a long-range signal from the ground, a technology the cartoon characters didn't have.
Re: IDW Beast Wars #8 Review (view post)
Comment by Nexus Knight Sep 22, 2021
AllNewSuperRobot wrote:As I said, after reading the last issue, Burnham doesn't get how Stasis Pods work. For one thing, how they can't leave orbit on their own.


Whatever gave you that impression? Just coz we never saw them land on their own in the show, doesn't mean that it isn't possible. It seems to make perfect sense, actually, that the pods have both remote control and thrusters. Since the Axalon had to eject, it is presumable that this is a safety feature designed into the pods for the purpose it was used. Quickly get rid of the pods to keep them safe, they would need not only the ability to track and report on the status of the pod and the protoform within, but make it easy to retrieve. Giving the pods the ability to maneuver on their own makes perfect sense, thus a few commands to the computer's onboard computer to fire thrusters could very wasily send it into the planet's atmosphere.
Re: IDW Beast Wars #8 Review (view post)
Comment by william-james88 Sep 23, 2021
I prefer Burcham's art.
Also, not a fan of Burcham's art.
Re: IDW Beast Wars #8 Review (view post)
Comment by AllNewSuperRobot Sep 23, 2021
william-james88 wrote:I prefer Burcham's art.
Also, not a fan of Burcham's art.



I think it would be interesting to get a bit of artist rotation going in this book. A different one each arc. If these are being "written for trade", then give each trade it's own visual identity.
Re: IDW Beast Wars #8 Review (view post)
Comment by ScottyP Oct 26, 2021
You'll be singing "Hakuna Matata" on your way to the comic shop tomorrow, as the release of Transformers: Beast Wars #9 is upon us and, based one of the variant covers, it's time for Razorbeast to make his mark in the story. The five page preview below won't get around to that part, but hey, IDW Publishing shares these to help sell the books after all.

(W) Erik Burnham (A/CA) Josh Burcham
"Thicker Skin". The Predacons begin their hunt for other fallen protoform pods, containing potential reinforcements in their quest to crush the Maximals. But Skold, the Predacon powerhouse, is left behind because she'll slow the mission down, at least according to Terrorsaur. When Skold encounters a pod on her own, it'll be up to her to bring it to the Predacon's side... or put it down for good.

Check out the preview below and be sure to pick this issue up tomorrow at your local comic shop, through a licensed digital comics retailer, or via the Seibertron.com eBay store.

Image

Image

Image

Image

Image
Re: IDW Beast Wars #8 Review (view post)
Comment by AllNewSuperRobot Oct 26, 2021
That dialogue almost seems to be mocking the plot of The Agenda. It isn't really a good idea to poke fun at something of higher quality.

Speaking of which, after last issue, I really need to stop reading the letters page. Someone comparing the dialogue of Dinobot in this to Code of Hero. Which there isn't even a subjective comparison to be made. It just reads as "tell us you're a shill, without telling us you're a shill".
Re: IDW Beast Wars #8 Review (view post)
Comment by Sabrblade Oct 26, 2021
AllNewSuperRobot wrote:That dialogue almost seems to be mocking the plot of The Agenda. It isn't really a good idea to poke fun at something of higher quality.
To be fair, the characters in the show called Megatron's plan "madness" too.
Re: IDW Beast Wars #8 Review (view post)
Comment by AllNewSuperRobot Oct 26, 2021
Sabrblade wrote:
AllNewSuperRobot wrote:That dialogue almost seems to be mocking the plot of The Agenda. It isn't really a good idea to poke fun at something of higher quality.
To be fair, the characters in the show called Megatron's plan "madness" too.


True. But Megs himself rationalised it as: 'The ultimate risk... for the ultimate prize!' He knew what was at stake. But the benefits outweighed the potential drawbacks.

Always lamented the backtrack on that cliffhanger. Season 3 could have been so much more interesting. Set within a dystopian, alternate future >:oP
Re: IDW Beast Wars #8 Review (view post)
Comment by ZeroWolf Oct 26, 2021
Would have been hard to sell the toys that were already in production at that point though :lol:

I don't mind them poking fun at it. Might mean they're making more changes then we think.
Re: IDW Beast Wars #8 Review (view post)
Comment by Sabrblade Oct 26, 2021
AllNewSuperRobot wrote:
Sabrblade wrote:
AllNewSuperRobot wrote:That dialogue almost seems to be mocking the plot of The Agenda. It isn't really a good idea to poke fun at something of higher quality.
To be fair, the characters in the show called Megatron's plan "madness" too.


True. But Megs himself rationalised it as: 'The ultimate risk... for the ultimate prize!' He knew what was at stake. But the benefits outweighed the potential drawbacks.
Yet, he admitted to himself the enormity of what it entailed and, in his hesitance, held off going through with it until all of his other options were exhausted.

AllNewSuperRobot wrote:Always lamented the backtrack on that cliffhanger. Season 3 could have been so much more interesting. Set within a dystopian, alternate future >:oP
We got that dystopian future. It was called Beast Machines. :-D
Re: IDW Beast Wars #8 Review (view post)
Comment by AllNewSuperRobot Oct 26, 2021
Sabrblade wrote:Yet, he admitted to himself the enormity of what it entailed and, in his hesitance, held off going through with it until all of his other options were exhausted.


If not for Blackarachnia, it might have paid off too.

Sabrblade wrote:
AllNewSuperRobot wrote:Always lamented the backtrack on that cliffhanger. Season 3 could have been so much more interesting. Set within a dystopian, alternate future >:oP
We got that dystopian future. It was called Beast Machines. :-D


Image

Touché :APPLAUSE:


ZeroWolf wrote:Would have been hard to sell the toys that were already in production at that point though :lol:


To be fair, looking at how different the TM 2 line was. It wouldn't have been too far a leap to assume that was the "alternate" cast of Season 3. There was no Primal in that line, after all.

ZeroWolf wrote:I don't mind them poking fun at it. Might mean they're making more changes then we think.


Cynically, I'd say that is a nod to the fans. With a realisation this series won't last long enough to reach that point.
Re: IDW Beast Wars #8 Review (view post)
Comment by ZeroWolf Oct 26, 2021
Only IDW would know that, unless they make their sales figures public.
Re: IDW Beast Wars #8 Review (view post)
Comment by primalxconvoy Oct 26, 2021
Oh dear, we're back to "this" type of aesthetics now, are we? Perhaps this is the "dystopian" future mentioned in a post or two above?
Re: IDW Beast Wars #8 Review (view post)
Comment by AllNewSuperRobot Oct 26, 2021
Indeed. I just sighed when I saw the preview. The idea I opted for a while back IE a different artist per arc, could have been a much better way to go. Unfortunately, instead, we are back to Beast Wars Roar
Re: IDW Beast Wars #8 Review (view post)
Comment by Sabrblade Oct 26, 2021
AllNewSuperRobot wrote:
Sabrblade wrote:Yet, he admitted to himself the enormity of what it entailed and, in his hesitance, held off going through with it until all of his other options were exhausted.


If not for Blackarachnia, it might have paid off too.
He would have been better off not going through with it. The future without the timestorm ever happening at all would have yielded him a better conquest of Cybertron, this time with Predacons instead of Vehicons, and which would have lasted for years with Predacons hunting down and executing hapless Maximals before they'd finally give a more concerted fightback years after Megatron took over. Megatron's timestorm in the past changed all that and resulted in the Vehicon-takeover and Spark War instead.

AllNewSuperRobot wrote:To be fair, looking at how different the TM 2 line was. It wouldn't have been too far a leap to assume that was the "alternate" cast of Season 3. There was no Primal in that line, after all.
There is no way Mainframe would have taken the existing cast they spent two seasons developing and discarded them for all-new people. Especially since that would have required creating completely brand new CG models for everyone when they were trying to save every buck they could when making the ones they already had (Tigatron and Blackarachnia being modified from Cheetor and Tarantulas, Ravage being modified from TM Cheetor w/ Tigatron's head, etc.).

AllNewSuperRobot wrote:Cynically, I'd say that is a nod to the fans. With a realisation this series won't last long enough to reach that point.
In that interview I mentioned Burnham saying that Razorbeast was originally gonna be someone else that Hasbro vetoed, Burnham also revealed that the Ark and its occupants are currently "not on the table" for this series.
Re: IDW Beast Wars #8 Review (view post)
Comment by AllNewSuperRobot Oct 26, 2021
Sabrblade wrote: Megatron's timestorm in the past changed all that and resulted in the Vehicon-takeover and Spark War instead.

Which he would have won, if had just killed Primal & co outright. When he first took control of Cybertron.

Sabrblade wrote:There is no way Mainframe would have taken the existing cast they spent two seasons developing and discarded them for all-new people. Especially since that would have required creating completely brand new CG models for everyone when they were trying to save every buck they could when making the ones they already had (Tigatron and Blackarachnia being modified from Cheetor and Tarantulas, Ravage being modified from TM Cheetor w/ Tigatron's head, etc.).


The eternal noose around the show's neck - the budget. Hence no Coneheads for the Nemesis finale.

Sabrblade wrote:Burnham also revealed that the Ark and its occupants are currently "not on the table" for this series.


That would lead me to believe this series has a predefined length of time attached to it, assigned by Hasbro. Given the Beast Wars show narrative pivoted entirely in that direction for Season Two.
Re: IDW Beast Wars #8 Review (view post)
Comment by Sabrblade Oct 26, 2021
AllNewSuperRobot wrote:That would lead me to believe this series has a predefined length of time attached to it, assigned by Hasbro. Given the Beast Wars show narrative pivoted entirely in that direction for Season Two.
Twelve issues is the current plan, with more to come should the series do well enough.
Re: IDW Beast Wars #8 Review (view post)
Comment by AllNewSuperRobot Oct 26, 2021
Oh I see, one more arc I imagine? If only 12 ends up being the case, a third artist would have been a really good idea.
Re: IDW Beast Wars #8 Review (view post)
Comment by ZeroWolf Oct 26, 2021
Was there any clues to who the vetoed character was?
Re: IDW Beast Wars #8 Review (view post)
Comment by Sabrblade Oct 26, 2021
ZeroWolf wrote:Was there any clues to who the vetoed character was?
No clue. Burnham wasn't allowed to say who it was nor what their beast mode was since that would have given away its identity.

The only BW character that comes to mind that I could see Hasbro putting their foot down on is BW Grimlock, but it's fun to wonder if it could have been someone without any ties to G1.

I guess we'll have to see what kind of role Razorbeast plays. If he emerges from his pod a newly born Maximal, that'll make it harder to figure out who he replaced. But if he emerges as a preexisting person from Cybertron who was put into stasis, that might make it easier.
Patreon
Charge Our Energon Reserves. Join the Seibertron Elite.
Support SEIBERTRON™