Tramp wrote:Technically, they are. They are part of the official Japanes line, are they not? They have an official story line and continuity. Remember, The TF canon covers multiple timelines and continuities, all of which happen simultaniously. Therfore, any officialy licensed line and story fits within canon, just in different continuities. Victory is part of the G1 continuity, with slight differences between the manga and the anime, particularly at the end of the series.Damolisher wrote:Will you please stop using a manga no-one's ever seen or cares about as an argument? If that manga's canon, Robot Masters and Kiss Players Manga must be canon too.
This is Esmeryl, Deathsaurus' wife:
You can also see the children of the Dino Force in the back ground too.
Besides, I have also shown you direct evidence from US continuities which also states quite clearly that bulding protoforms is not to only method possible for creating new TF life. I gave you a direct quote with page number. I have given you solid evidence of specific romantic relationships in both G1 and other continuities. I have shown you evidence which state that they have a genetic code, as well as solid scientific fact regarding what is the requirements for something to be life, and shown why Transformers need to meet those requirements, and how evidence shows that they do. Something cannot be alive if they have to build new mwmbers of its kind in a factory. They have to be able to do so from their own bodies. Evidence strongly suggests that Cybertronians can. and the fact that they have genders indicates that the method is some form of sexual reproduction. What form that takes is up for debate, but the evidence strongly supports it none the less.
You are lookign at one quote from a character, taken completely out of context, and can't look past the idea of them being robotic. Whether they are robotic, crystaline, organic, silicon based or anything else for that matter. What the basis of their make-up is, is completely irrelevant. They are still life forms and as such need to meet certain criteria, and evidence does indeed indicate that they do meet all of those criteria including the capability of autopoietic reproduction through sexual means. The only thing preventing it during G1 is a scarcity of females.
Oh my bloody God, you're like a broken record. THERE'S ROBOTS FOR **** SAKE! **** ROBOTS! THEY DO NOT HAVE **** CHILDREN! THE MANGAS DON'T MEAN JACKSHIT! **** HELL! THEY ARE ROBOTS! THEY ARE MADE OF METAL! THERE IS NOT A SINGLE **** ORGANIC THING ABOUT THEM! Christ, I think I'm gonna back out of this topic for a while before I BREAK SOMETHING! Because I am beginning to get pissed off with you basing your so-called facts on something only you can see, and on some lame crap some losers who wrote some crappy non-canonical comics made! Those comics ARE NOT CANON! CANON= OFFICIAL, NOT SOMETHING YOU THINK IS OFFICIAL, WHICH ISN'T!!!! GAAAAAAAH! THERE ARE NOT A STRICT **** SET OF RULES TO BE A LIFEFORM! BLOODY HELL! Why won't you open your freaking eyes! IF SOMEONE WANTS TO MAKE NEW RULES FOR BEING A **** LIFEFORM THEY CAN! A spacechip cannot fly fast enough to reach a plent within a few days unless it's going faster than the speed of light which is impossible, but that happens in cartoons!
THERE IS NOT A **** SET AGENDA! TRANSFORMERS ARE ALIVE, EVEN THOUGH THEY'RE **** ROBOTS! Seriously, Shadowman's right, you don't listen to logic.