The Energon Pub

News Credits: 12 · Mon Dec 03, 2018 1:54 pm

Regarding Megatron's cloak, the problem with cloth on action figures (especially TFs) is it usually looks woefully out of scale. A fabric square that's for the sake of argument 6 metres in size will not behave the same as a square of the same fabric cut to 6 inches due to the effects of gravity and the fact the smaller square is proportionately thicker- you'd have to make the fabric much thinner and more flexible/less stiff for it to look convincing. And regrettably, even higher-end manufacturers like Mezco can't get fabric to not look overscale on their figures (hence why their figures all look like they're wearing woolen pyjamas) so what hope does a retail-budget toyline have? Short of using expensive microfibre cloth (which would push the price of the figure up) it just ain't happening. I'd like it if a 3P made a replacement that either went the route of the original DOTM figure with a soft vinyl cloak (except done better) or took a leaf out of the Revoltech Amazing Yamaguchi line and made a multi-part plastic arrangement connected by joints, allowing for positioning and a better looking (if somewhat stylized) solution.

Also, Bonecrusher looks a bit...small.

News Credits: 14 · Mon Dec 03, 2018 2:12 pm

Black Hat wrote:Regarding Megatron's cloak, the problem with cloth on action figures (especially TFs) is it usually looks woefully out of scale. A fabric square that's for the sake of argument 6 metres in size will not behave the same as a square of the same fabric cut to 6 inches due to the effects of gravity and the fact the smaller square is proportionately thicker- you'd have to make the fabric much thinner and more flexible/less stiff for it to look convincing. And regrettably, even higher-end manufacturers like Mezco can't get fabric to not look overscale on their figures (hence why their figures all look like they're wearing woolen pyjamas) so what hope does a retail-budget toyline have? Short of using expensive microfibre cloth (which would push the price of the figure up) it just ain't happening. I'd like it if a 3P made a replacement that either went the route of the original DOTM figure with a soft vinyl cloak (except done better) or took a leaf out of the Revoltech Amazing Yamaguchi line and made a multi-part plastic arrangement connected by joints, allowing for positioning and a better looking (if somewhat stylized) solution.

Exactly. The original DotM Megs vinyl cloak worked well enough. Yes it was shaped to only drape over him. but it works.

I don't really need the cloak to react to wind like it did in the movie, or be poseable. But just that looks better than this.

The original cloak worked well for Robot mode, but suffered in vehicle mode due to stiffness. I realize its going to be hard to get something that works well on both modes.

DC Action figures have managed to create good looking pliable vinyl capes and soft goods fabric capes for Batman in particular for some retail releases. Something like that would work for Megs.

Mon Dec 03, 2018 2:29 pm

Those clip on wheels look horrible. Such nice sculpted and painted wheels and they gut two thirds of the rim.

News Credits: 19 · Mon Dec 03, 2018 2:44 pm

Is nice to see him standing near a deluxe figure there so it shows he's not ridiculously tall compared to them which is what I worried about when he was announced as leader class. Doesn't look hugely different to seeing RotF Megatron and Jazz on my shelf here.

Yeah the cloth cloak looks a bit odd but I'm glad they got the chains this time and I'm liking the rusty deco he has all over him. He looks like he's gonna be a bunch of fun and can sort out a replacement for the cloak if necessary later on.

News Credits: 462 · Mon Dec 03, 2018 3:27 pm

Regarding Devastator's scale with the other figures, in order Devastator to be the correct size when set against everyone else, he would have to be the size of a real person, which would be a ridiculously large size and probably cost at least $800. No one here wants to have to pay that much for a Transformers toy, right?

News Credits: 4880 · Mon Dec 03, 2018 3:33 pm

Sabrblade wrote:probably cost at least $800. No one here wants to have to pay that much for a Transformers toy, right?

Isnt that how much MP Hound is gonna be at this point?

News Credits: 19 · Mon Dec 03, 2018 4:03 pm

Sabrblade wrote:Regarding Devastator's scale with the other figures, in order Devastator to be the correct size when set against everyone else, he would have to be the size of a real person, which would be a ridiculously large size and probably cost at least $800. No one here wants to have to pay that much for a Transformers toy, right?

Make it a Devastator costume and you can stomp about around (or onto) your other figures!

News Credits: 101 · Mon Dec 03, 2018 6:08 pm

Overcracker wrote:
ZeldaTheSwordsman wrote:
Overcracker wrote:Megs is looking better than I thought. Not feeling the soft goods shroud however. Seems just a bit cheap.

But still, makes me want to get Megs.

Also I want Cog and Sideswipe.

Why does having a piece that should be made of fabric, be made of fabric, feel cheap? Vinyl doesn't shift and drape and fall like actual cloth does.

Because it looks wrong, it doesn't drape correctly even though it is cloth. It's not even remotely close to what the onscreen shroud looked like. Very Soft vinyl, or another kind of fabric that is less stiff may have looked better and correctly draped on him. Also, it looks too clean.

The material used is what looks cheap.

Betcha an Etsy Mom could make a killer by making a bunch of custom Megs cloaks.

News Credits: 2 · Mon Dec 03, 2018 7:45 pm

Ugh. Yeah, its not the pose, he's just short. Even with Prime he's a little smaller than he should be (Prime is 28 feet tall, he's supposed to be 25 feet tall, his head should be at Prime's chest). He's even shorter than SS Ironhide, from what I can see here, which is just...wrong. Incredible letdown.

It's a pretty good looking mold, too! But one of the biggest appeals for me with this line is that we were finally getting characters in correct scale with each other, and this is way off. I can't believe they would do this AGAIN with the same character :BANG_HEAD:

.

News Credits: 1646 · Mon Dec 03, 2018 8:15 pm

Ugh, I am so excited for the line next year. Megatron looks absolutely amazing, The constructicons are gonna be a smash with the combining gimmick done right finally, the Jetfire/Prime is awesome, so glad I passed on the first SS Prime. WWII Bee is pretty fun too. And I cannot wait for Shatter. Gotta get Dropkick so i can have the 2 together!

News Credits: 101 · Mon Dec 03, 2018 8:16 pm

Son Bonnie should be a Leader then?

News Credits: 6 · Mon Dec 03, 2018 10:44 pm

At this point, the only way Bonecrusher gets a priority buy is if he is an alternate Devastator component.

News Credits: 1350 · Tue Dec 04, 2018 5:13 am

I don't quite understand people's frustration with bonecrusher...he looks the part to me and I'm my mind scales perfectly

So you may not want him but I do, and devastator aside, I think Studio Series has knocked them out of the park scale wise. All this just goes to show how hard it is to literally please everyone!

News Credits: 101 · Tue Dec 04, 2018 5:23 am

ZeroWolf wrote:All this just goes to show how hard it is to literally please everyone!

There's also a prime rule:
When trying to please everyone you ALWAYS end up pleasing no one.

News Credits: 1350 · Tue Dec 04, 2018 5:32 am

-Kanrabat- wrote:
ZeroWolf wrote:All this just goes to show how hard it is to literally please everyone!

There's also a prime rule:
When trying to please everyone you ALWAYS end up pleasing no one.

Well said

News Credits: 56 · Tue Dec 04, 2018 7:27 am

Yeah, the new Prime looks great, way better than the first one, and Bonecrusher looks awesome. About his scaling, wasn't he this size in the movie anyway? I mean I watched it yesterday, so it's still pretty fresh in my mind, but Bonecrusher did look to be that size. Anyway, everything coming out of Studio Series is awesome and I cannot wait anymore for them. My local Targets and Walmarts still have Stinger and Lockdown, with the occasional other figures from Wave 1. I didn't expect the dissappointment upon actually seeing SS Megatron in store. The pictures I saw didn't make his grey plastic this ugly. He is a great Megatron figure though. Siege of course is where I might actually buy some figures that I need, like Prime, Megatron, and Shockwave. And some Weaponizers. I love those guys

News Credits: 1350 · Tue Dec 04, 2018 7:38 am

Nathaniel Prime wrote:Yeah, the new Prime looks great, way better than the first one, and Bonecrusher looks awesome. About his scaling, wasn't he this size in the movie anyway? I mean I watched it yesterday, so it's still pretty fresh in my mind, but Bonecrusher did look to be that size. Anyway, everything coming out of Studio Series is awesome and I cannot wait anymore for them. My local Targets and Walmarts still have Stinger and Lockdown, with the occasional other figures from Wave 1. I didn't expect the dissappointment upon actually seeing SS Megatron in store. The pictures I saw didn't make his grey plastic this ugly. He is a great Megatron figure though. Siege of course is where I might actually buy some figures that I need, like Prime, Megatron, and Shockwave. And some Weaponizers. I love those guys

I think know is a great time to be a transformers fan

News Credits: 19 · Tue Dec 04, 2018 7:43 am

Nathaniel Prime wrote: I didn't expect the dissappointment upon actually seeing SS Megatron in store. The pictures I saw didn't make his grey plastic this ugly.

A small pot of metallic model paint works a treat on Megatron.

I need to add another thin layer to some places like the leg panels cos they a bit streaky but yeah overall much happier with how more metal he looks and it didn't take very long. Jazz is in front who comes silver painted as standard and you can see my Megatron has some shine to him too and better than the drab grey plastic he is underneath. I went with a sorta darker tone of metallic paint with this but there are other options to suit what sorta shade you'd like Megs to be.

DSC_0002.jpg

News Credits: 101 · Tue Dec 04, 2018 8:07 am

That paint touch up look great on Megs!
Make me want to do it myself.

News Credits: 19 · Tue Dec 04, 2018 8:14 am

-Kanrabat- wrote:That paint touch up look great on Megs!
Make me want to do it myself.

Thanks. I'm not a great customiser but it's an easy enough thing to do here. And it's actually kinda fun applying paint to that Megatron cos it's quite simple and you don't need to be super precise or skilled (due to lack of skill and my shakey wrists there's no way in heck I can do fine detail especially really precise work like Optimus' flames so I have to use Toyhax stickers there). The paint is only about £1.70 per pot so worth a go.

News Credits: 6 · Tue Dec 04, 2018 8:19 am

Nathaniel Prime wrote:Yeah, the new Prime looks great, way better than the first one, and Bonecrusher looks awesome. About his scaling, wasn't he this size in the movie anyway? I mean I watched it yesterday, so it's still pretty fresh in my mind, but Bonecrusher did look to be that size.

I think the main disappointment with everyone is that everyone wanted a bigger Bonecrusher that the first movie deluxe, then we were announced a voyager after so many years, and now we see it’s barely any bigger than the original even when standing upright

News Credits: 19 · Tue Dec 04, 2018 8:20 am

Ig89ninja wrote:I think the main disappointment with everyone is that everyone wanted a bigger Bonecrusher that the first movie deluxe, then we were announced a voyager after so many years, and now we see it’s barely any bigger than the original even when standing upright

Is there a comparison of both figures together that shows this?

News Credits: 6 · Tue Dec 04, 2018 9:39 am

Carnivius_Prime wrote:
Ig89ninja wrote:I think the main disappointment with everyone is that everyone wanted a bigger Bonecrusher that the first movie deluxe, then we were announced a voyager after so many years, and now we see it’s barely any bigger than the original even when standing upright

Is there a comparison of both figures together that shows this?

Not exactly, but we can use SS Bumblebee as a common dinominator(sic) and figure out his rough scale

News Credits: 19 · Tue Dec 04, 2018 9:57 am

Ig89ninja wrote:
Carnivius_Prime wrote:
Ig89ninja wrote:I think the main disappointment with everyone is that everyone wanted a bigger Bonecrusher that the first movie deluxe, then we were announced a voyager after so many years, and now we see it’s barely any bigger than the original even when standing upright

Is there a comparison of both figures together that shows this?

Not exactly, but we can use SS Bumblebee as a common dinominator(sic) and figure out his rough scale

I dunno. Looks larger than 'barely any bigger' as you described. The voyager looks quite taller and certainly chunkier than the old deluxe from those pics. I can't say it's as big as it 'should' be but there's certainly a fair bit bigger than the 2008 toy overall at least.

Until I see them both side by side I can't come to much of a conclusion. I'm likely buying the SS one anyways cos I like it.

News Credits: 2 · Tue Dec 04, 2018 10:08 am

ZeroWolf wrote:I don't quite understand people's frustration with bonecrusher...he looks the part to me and I'm my mind scales perfectly So you may not want him but I do, and devastator aside, I think Studio Series has knocked them out of the park scale wise. All this just goes to show how hard it is to literally please everyone!

He's just too short. He should be about the same height as Brawl (both about 25 feet tall), and maybe a head shorter than Prime (28 feet), but instead the toy comes up to Prime's belly.

He's clearly taller than Ironhide, but the toy looks to be about a hair SHORTER than SS Ironhide. It's frustrating because this is the second time they've done this to the same character, who for reason's i'll never understand, was only ever released as a deluxe in the past. This was a chance to FINALLY get him in a decent size, 10 years later, and they botched it again.