The Energon Pub

[Evil Phil]

Both are the somewhat copies of the original Sonic. So who wins out right?

Terms of the battle: Metal gets all techniques from Cd and SA2 (electric dash, jewel shield, flight/hovering) can't turn in Metal madness/overlord. Shadow can't go super, can only use abilities from SA2(Chaos spear and control) no guns or chaos blast.

Whats the outcome?

[AxiomScion]

comic wise Shadow wins...

All of Shadow's Chaos powers in the comic book series come from the greatest power in the universe, the Chaos Force (also referred to as "The Power of Chaos"), a mystical energy field that serves as a wellspring for all Chaos powers. Knuckles states at one point that Shadow must have direct access to this energy, even without an Emerald, as displayed when Shadow sub-consciously halted a squadron of 'Metal Sonic Troopers' using Chaos Control in the absence of an Emerald.

I like Metalsonic but he's out clased by "the ultimate life form" just like Sonic.

or is he? techincle game story could make him potentially far more dangerous. Think JLA villain Amazo

Besides robotnik already switched to using his own metal knock offs of Shadow.

whose to say he hasn't just built a better metal hedgehog?

[snavej]

They both realise suddenly that they should be patrolling the hedgerows, feasting on bugs and slugs. Pratt's Old Peculiar wins.