DUDEATRICE wrote:Transforming alien robots that turned from vehicles to something that resembled anything other than humanoid would lose your attention and empathy. Plain and simple.
Scientifically, why not? Before you question why a ficticious alien race of robots would have certain features, question why they wouldn't. Comparing all other life in the universe to humans is selfish and ignorant. What's to say our life isn't a copy of theirs? We're obviously less advanced in every regard.
Ghost One wrote:Since machines are designed to be efficient, they would take a form that would improve their efficiency.
So what is their purpose? Originally, they were probably designed to defend and maintain their creators existence. If that was the case, they would have been designed to resemble their creators in order for a friendly integration into society.
So their creators were probably 30' tall humanoid insects?
No, Their size increase probably came before the revolution. Since their protocols required them to protect their creators, they 'decided' it would be better for their creators if they traveled inside them where they could be better defended against danger. Over two generations they grew in size and perfected their transformation ability.
So, the creators were probably 2-3m tall bipedal creatures.
At some point thereafter, the first Decepticon's logic processor realized that the only way to protect their creators was to confine them permanently. War. Decepticons vs Autobots and Creators. Then there were no more creators.
Logic then implied that they must defend themselves. Autobots decided to hole up where as the Decepticons chose to destroy all threats across the galaxy.
With the Decepticon's programming to conquer, an efficient way would be through fear. So, over time across worlds, the Decepticons picked up traits of the more fearsome creatues in the galaxy.
Where as the Autobots maintained a mostly isolationist position, they would maintain traits that were initially given them by the creators.
So, If you have an Autobot design question, ask if it could be because they resemble their creators.
If you have a Decepticon design question, ask if it could be because they resemble a terrifying alien they encountered.
Wigglez wrote:Just remember. The sword is an extension of your arm. Use it as if you're going to karate chop someone with your really long sharp ass hand.
Ghost One wrote:Since machines are designed to be efficient, they would take a form that would improve their efficiency.
So what is their purpose? Originally, they were probably designed to defend and maintain their creators existence. If that was the case, they would have been designed to resemble their creators in order for a friendly integration into society.
So their creators were probably 30' tall humanoid insects?
No, Their size increase probably came before the revolution. Since their protocols required them to protect their creators, they 'decided' it would be better for their creators if they traveled inside them where they could be better defended against danger. Over two generations they grew in size and perfected their transformation ability.
So, the creators were probably 2-3m tall bipedal creatures.
At some point thereafter, the first Decepticon's logic processor realized that the only way to protect their creators was to confine them permanently. War. Decepticons vs Autobots and Creators. Then there were no more creators.
Logic then implied that they must defend themselves. Autobots decided to hole up where as the Decepticons chose to destroy all threats across the galaxy.
With the Decepticon's programming to conquer, an efficient way would be through fear. So, over time across worlds, the Decepticons picked up traits of the more fearsome creatues in the galaxy.
Where as the Autobots maintained a mostly isolationist position, they would maintain traits that were initially given them by the creators.
So, If you have an Autobot design question, ask if it could be because they resemble their creators.
If you have a Decepticon design question, ask if it could be because they resemble a terrifying alien they encountered.
Shadowman wrote:Ghost One wrote:Since machines are designed to be efficient, they would take a form that would improve their efficiency.
So what is their purpose? Originally, they were probably designed to defend and maintain their creators existence. If that was the case, they would have been designed to resemble their creators in order for a friendly integration into society.
So their creators were probably 30' tall humanoid insects?
No, Their size increase probably came before the revolution. Since their protocols required them to protect their creators, they 'decided' it would be better for their creators if they traveled inside them where they could be better defended against danger. Over two generations they grew in size and perfected their transformation ability.
So, the creators were probably 2-3m tall bipedal creatures.
At some point thereafter, the first Decepticon's logic processor realized that the only way to protect their creators was to confine them permanently. War. Decepticons vs Autobots and Creators. Then there were no more creators.
Logic then implied that they must defend themselves. Autobots decided to hole up where as the Decepticons chose to destroy all threats across the galaxy.
With the Decepticon's programming to conquer, an efficient way would be through fear. So, over time across worlds, the Decepticons picked up traits of the more fearsome creatues in the galaxy.
Where as the Autobots maintained a mostly isolationist position, they would maintain traits that were initially given them by the creators.
So, If you have an Autobot design question, ask if it could be because they resemble their creators.
If you have a Decepticon design question, ask if it could be because they resemble a terrifying alien they encountered.
By God, that's perfect!![]()
Good arguement, man. You deserve a medal.
Zombie Starscream wrote:I wonder if they made the bad guys "evil looking" as a form of dumbing down?
I would have found it more scary if they had nice looking robots that just turned on you without you expecting it, instead of the evil looking things who you would obviously expect to act evil.
What is scarier, a robot you're standing next to who looks like the others but who's alliegence you're not sure of, or a robot that looks evil and you're able to figure out his alligence without ever having to get near him?
Salazaar wrote:Shadowman wrote:Ghost One wrote:So, If you have an Autobot design question, ask if it could be because they resemble their creators.
If you have a Decepticon design question, ask if it could be because they resemble a terrifying alien they encountered.
By God, that's perfect!![]()
Good arguement, man. You deserve a medal.
Uh, my argument is a LITTLE more realistic.
kjeevah wrote:Gobstopper wrote:Pretty impressive, well thoughtout, makes sense but kinda sounds alittle like the bible
no, it isnt the bible, its straight from 'i robot'
Salazaar wrote:You guys look too much into this stuff. The companies thought of the toy first, THEN the backstory. They had to make the toy recognizable to the children that would play with them. It wouldn't make a great toy, either. Little Jimmy would have a hell of a time transforming a giant metal octopus that turns into a motorcycle
Return to Transformers Live Action Film Forum
Registered users: Bing [Bot], Glyph, Google [Bot], Google Adsense [Bot], Google Feedfetcher, Mewtwo Ex, MSN [Bot], o.supreme, Psycho Warrior, Yahoo [Bot], Ziusundra