The Energon Pub

News Credits: 4 · Fri Mar 04, 2011 7:33 pm

Okay say Both of the Combatants were 50 feet tall,had no weapons or special abilities,and were pitted in a hand to hand melee fight...Who would win?

for me i say OP

News Credits: 1 · Fri Mar 04, 2011 8:07 pm

I'm pretty sure Prime already fought a Godzilla like creature (of similar size), in the G1 episode 'Prime Target'. Needless to say, Prime defeated that creature almost effortlessly. Scale them up to 50FT and the outcome would most likely be the same.

Sat Mar 05, 2011 4:59 am

prime has fought nothing godzilla sized. he was dead before the city transformers showed up and he never went up against one in rebirth.

you dont seem to know much about godzilla, im thinking you just dont like the idea of him and want to see everyone say prime wins. but he isnt just a random monster, and he isnt 50 feet tall. his height varies depending what godzilla you're talking about, the shortest being 164 feet and the tallest at 328 feet. if youve ever played shadow of the colossus then he dwarfs the tallest of them (malus, 195 feet).

beyond this he is nuclear powered, making him far more dangrous than any standard monster of similar size. he is near invulnerable to conventional weaponry, has a very impressive healing factor and has enough firepower to level a skyscraper in one shot. a variation is the nuclear pulse, which is a fully charged beam only it radiates outward from godzillas body. he is able to defeat most similar sized monsters on a regular basis, so even though he is beyond massive, he is still overpowered for his size. hes called king of the monsters for a reason.

im going to say that prime has nothing to hurt him. his laser rifle/ion blaster isnt going to do much of anything, and what little it can do is going to have a very limited effect given godzillas healing factor. prime can try to duck and cover, but even in new york godzilla could destory the entire city, there is nothing sturdy enough to hide behind that will make a difference. primes only real option would be to try and evade and hide long enough that he can approach godzilla from the top of a building and try and be eaten (without being chewed). if he could get inside godzilla he could do a lot of damage. this is how godzilla was beaten in gmk, so its established his organs are vulnerable.

i dont know if prime could actually kill godzilla, but he could probably do enough damage to drive him away and then claw out through godzillas throat. godzilla has every advantage going in though, he is effectively invincible from the outside and his beam is physically massive and has a lot of firepower so it will be very hard to evade. even if prime can jump straight into godzillas mouth one bite would probably end it. prime has a shot, but he will need to be extremely careful and precise and even then its more likely than not that godzilla will just beam spam until the surrounding area (and prime) are destroyed. if godzilla decides for a more hands on approach prime is sill going to be at serious risk of being crushed or bitten and if he tries climbing up godzillas back hes going to die because of the nuclear pulse.

if anyone so reletively small can win, prime can, but this is going to be far harder than driving up and shooting devastator in the face. im going with godzilla for probably 8/10.