The Energon Pub

Ok I know there is a topic similar to this, that's why I put this special condition to it!

Now, in a fight between the old school Batman and the old school Spider-Man, who would win?
And with old school I mean they original core characters from there first year of creation!
Meaning Batman is this:


http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Batman#Early_years


While Spider-Man is this:


http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Amazin ... #The_1960s


This is a fight at encounter, no time for researching, no time for getting near somebody important, no time for mixing a chemical to disintegrate one costume (I'm looking at you Peter!).
No attack under the belt!
OK, let the fight of the chearfull Detective ans the teenager begin![/list]

Aside from the guy who killed Uncle Ben, Spider-Man has had a strict "No-Kill" rule, which he tends to make certain other heroes (FRANK CASTLE) adhere to when in a team-up.

Batman, originally, was prone to not only killing people, but sometimes SHOOTING them in the BACK.

Look, if we were doing modern-day Batman, this would be a closer match, but with Batman doing anything to win, even killing, this'll be a walk in the park for the Dark Knight.

Shadowman wrote:Aside from the guy who killed Uncle Ben, Spider-Man has had a strict "No-Kill" rule, which he tends to make certain other heroes (FRANK CASTLE) adhere to when in a team-up.

Batman, originally, was prone to not only killing people, but sometimes SHOOTING them in the BACK.

Look, if we were doing modern-day Batman, this would be a closer match, but with Batman doing anything to win, even killing, this'll be a walk in the park for the Dark Knight.

Peter never killed that guy, he had a hart attack as he found out who Spider-Man was!

Oh as to batman, two words webfluid and spidersense!
Those wouldn't be the first bullets he would have dodged at the beginning of his carer!

Dead Metal wrote:

Shadowman wrote:Aside from the guy who killed Uncle Ben, Spider-Man has had a strict "No-Kill" rule, which he tends to make certain other heroes (FRANK CASTLE) adhere to when in a team-up.

Batman, originally, was prone to not only killing people, but sometimes SHOOTING them in the BACK.

Look, if we were doing modern-day Batman, this would be a closer match, but with Batman doing anything to win, even killing, this'll be a walk in the park for the Dark Knight.

Peter never killed that guy, he had a hart attack as he found out who Spider-Man was!

Oh as to batman, two words webfluid and spidersense!
Those wouldn't be the first bullets he would have dodged at the beginning of his carer!

Even with the Spider sence old school Spidy was knocked out cold by quite a few bad guys with a hell of a lot less skill then old school Bats had.
Even back then Bats was written as a person of Peak Physical Condition, he was a sharp shooter and a expert in hand to hand combat almost with out peer.And a expert tactician.

I dont even think it would be a close fight.Old school Bat's would put old school Spidy in a grave.

The modern Spidy has a better chance at winning but I still think he would lose.

sto_vo_kor_2000 wrote:

Dead Metal wrote:

Shadowman wrote:Aside from the guy who killed Uncle Ben, Spider-Man has had a strict "No-Kill" rule, which he tends to make certain other heroes (FRANK CASTLE) adhere to when in a team-up.

Batman, originally, was prone to not only killing people, but sometimes SHOOTING them in the BACK.

Look, if we were doing modern-day Batman, this would be a closer match, but with Batman doing anything to win, even killing, this'll be a walk in the park for the Dark Knight.

Peter never killed that guy, he had a hart attack as he found out who Spider-Man was!

Oh as to batman, two words webfluid and spidersense!
Those wouldn't be the first bullets he would have dodged at the beginning of his carer!

Even with the Spider sence old school Spidy was knocked out cold by quite a few bad guys with a hell of a lot less skill then old school Bats had.
Even back then Bats was written as a person of Peak Physical Condition, he was a sharp shooter and a expert in hand to hand combat almost with out peer.And a expert tactician.

I dont even think it would be a close fight.Old school Bat's would put old school Spidy in a grave.

The modern Spidy has a better chance at winning but I still think he would lose.

Fair enoght.

batman wins this one.

I hate to say this, but Batsy will win.

BATMAN Rules!!!!


Batman dadadadada Batman!

The old school intro of Batman!

Spiderman has the pproportanate strength and speed of a spider which would make him many times stronger and fster than Batman even at peak physical condition Batman strength and reflexes just dont compare to Spiderman. Spidey wins easily.

Galaxion wrote:Spiderman has the pproportanate strength and speed of a spider which would make him many times stronger and fster than Batman even at peak physical condition Batman strength and reflexes just dont compare to Spiderman. Spidey wins easily.

Dude, old school Spiderman got beat by guys like Hammerhead, Kingpin, Doctor Octopus and Mysterio.....and back in 1967 those guys were pretty lame.

Oldschool Batman was willing to kill to win a fight and on top of being at peak physical condition, he was a world class marksmen with a gun and had no equal.He was also taking on all kinds of monsters and shape-shifting aliens....and winning.

Oldschool Spidy doesnt stand a chance.

If Batman wears the pink suit, he takes this.

Old school = little boys. No powers, no gadgets, no vehicles.

I'm thinking that nerd Bruce Wayne is a bit stronger and tougher than nerd Peter Parker. My money's on Bruce.