by cybercat » Sun Oct 11, 2009 9:48 am
As someone who was so confused (and yet, oddly attracted) to these things with Y chromosomes that I have literally made studying masculinity into a career (hello, gender studies!):
American masculinity is a clusterf***. That's why DM (who is German) is having a hard time believing how awful your experience was. America is the country who brought you Matthew Shepard, getting beaten to death, right? Yeah, great country to be gay.
Basically, remember (you probably don't) the late '90s had the 'sensitive new age guy' that everyone now makes fun of? There's been a lot of backlash against that, which is really diminishing to what is 'acceptable' for American males to do. My students insist that the only things they are interested in are:
cars
girls
partying
sports.
That's it. That's the sum total of their existence. No art. No poetry. No music. No books. Not even movies or TV. Even guys in my college who study graphic arts run 'the risk' of being perceived as 'too gay' (their words, not mine). And guys...showing emotion at all? NO WAY. American men can...get angry. That's about it. They can't bounce up and down with happiness. They can't cry (except if they're a firefighter on 9/11). They can't show love or tenderness. Even in 'sexy' scenes, the guys just look...pissed. No wonder that young men growing up think that that's the role that they have to inhabit. And no wonder they're so mad about it!!
First the culture tells them the only emotion they *can* show is anger. Second, I suspect that secretly they find this role SO limiting that...they get kinda angry about it. I know that as a woman, I sure as hell got angry about the very tiny role I was expected to squash myself into: fashion, boys, makeup and romance? BLEURK!!!
So, they see gay guys and whoa, not only are you able to show and do things they can't (gay culture has...culture), but also, you threaten them by looking.
See, in American culture, the catchphrase is (and this is from waaaay back): Men act, women appear. Meaning women are there to be seen (and thus be pretty): men, do stuff. Men thus feel very threatened when someone tries to turn them into an 'appearance'. Anyone (but especially a gay guy) checking out a guy's appearance is intimidating. That explains the baggy saggy clothes (I mean, seriously, American guys? What's with those knickerbockers y'all call swimsuits? I'm supposed to wear a bikini and you're wearing *that*?!) Men do NOT want to be checked out. By anyone. (Again, compare this to the early 90s, or the 70s, where guys did most definitely *want* to be checked out, and dressed in a very different way (coughcough spandex))
So, you threaten them. They react...badly.
I suppose it's not very comforting to hear that it's endemic to our culture and thus, nothing necessarily against *you*, personally. (Didn't help Matthew Shepard, did it?) But that's the issue. Every guy on here, on Seibs, is one step (at least) away from that attitude, because being over the age of, say, 12, and still liking toys, is outside the heteronormative stereotype. (So, yay, you Seibs guys!)
Just remember, and hope, that they'll grow out of it. One day they'll find the role too limiting (such as when they, for example, have children and find that the angry cave man thing doesn't really work anymore). And don't let it change who *you* are.
HK, yay, gender studies?