Mkall wrote:Hey, I enjoyed Superman Returns and The Watchmen, but that's neither here nor there.
I enjoyed Superman Returns too, it's just that it missed some marks for the character and the movie ended up being one big homage to the Richard Donner. A lot of the movie lacked "heart" for me because it was a caricature of the 1978 movie. I think Bryan Singer should have totally gone in his own direction, which might have been worse but I couldn't fault him for doing his own thing with the character.
Catwoman was just way off base.
The Watchmen movie totally missed a major point of the story(fear of nuclear war). However, The Watchmen is a huge project to undertake so what Zack Snyder got right was done well and I think he achieved a lot by simply making an adaptation of The Watchmen that I think is definitely watchable. It wasn't an absolute failure but it just doesn't do justice to the series that, to be honest, is truly un-adaptable due to the integral nature of the comic art. Dave Gibbons' work on methods and concepts such as the deliberate structure of his panel arrangement are things you can't appreciate outside of a comic book format. Half the narration and subtext of the story comes from how the visuals are composed such as in Chapter V "Fearful Symmetry". Now if someone hasn't read the source material, they're going to be fine with the film adaptation but they won't realize how much they're missing because of what the comic does on a visual level. Unlike 99% of comic art, The Watchmen's art is actually vital to the experience.
Mkall wrote:If
this is a product of the new DC company, then I whole-heartedly support it.
Unfortunately, the article's title is misleading. BB getting its own comic mini-series is cool, though I wonder why Dan DiDio specifically said "Terry McGinnis mini-series". I would prefer another DCAU film feature for Batman Begins, though. I love BB because it was so different than the traditional Batman but entertained me just as much. I also loved how JLU tied up BB. "Epilogue" was such a great episode and tied JLU to BB in some neat ways.