How unfair, G1 Scourge and all his sweeps were just cannon fodder, so G1 Scourge would be vaped in minutes.
Black Convoy could probably take Rodimus because he's more well armed, IMO a better leader (I mean the guy had to do most of the leg work in RID and he never bitched about it like Rodimus did.), better melee skills (Sword of Fury), and last but not least, compared to Rodimus, he had massive robotic gonads.
Though, it pains me to say this, Sunstorm would take down Black Convoy in a couple minutes at most.