The Energon Pub

[Autobot032]

http://www.switched.com/2007/11/20/penn ... a-license/

Pennsylvania Law Forces eBay Auctioneers to Get a License

Posted Nov 20th 2007 5:01PM by Terrence O'Brien
Filed under: Computers, eBay
PA Government Tells eBay Sellers to Get a License
You know those people -- maybe even you -- who sell other people's stuff on eBay? Well, apparently you or they will need to get an auctioneer's license from now on, at least in Pennsyslvania. The law has actually been on the books for a while, but is garnering attention because it is only now being enforced. Two people who run online auctions for others are under investigation by the state government and face up to $1,000 in fines.

But some eBay auctioneers are speaking out. Pennsylvania-based Auction Inn, a small online eBay auction company, is speaking out against the law, though it is not one of the two cited by law enforcement. Auction Inn believes the law is unfair since eBay auctioneers don't perform the same function or duty as traditional auctioneers. Presumably, this means they don't have gavels or talk in sped-up-auction-selling-speak, since all they do is write nice descriptions, take pretty photos, and make sure the stuff gets to the buyer on time.

Getting an auctioneer's license can take six to eight months which would shut Auction Inn down for the better part of a year, essentially forcing the business to shutter.

State lawmakers are proposing bills to deal with the issue, one of which makes eBay sellers exempt from the auctioneer's law, but still requires them to register with the government.

You can already feel the garages, basements, and attics of Pennsylvania start to fill up with all the crap the won't get sold until this hubbub is sorted out.

What do you think? Is this law too much or do you think eBay auctioneers should have a license?

From WGAL News

I've got mixed feelings on this one, for sure.

On the one hand, eBay is the auction house/auctioneer and the people pay to get a piece of the action so they can sell their items. This should rest on the 'Bay's shoulders.

On the other hand, if licenses were required, it certainly would weed out all of the pricks that abuse eBay to Hell and back.

So, what do you think folks?

[Grahf]

I would support it. I've been burned a few times, plus it would knock down the number of ebay cases on Judge Judy.

[waaaaghlord]

I see ebay itself taking the role of the traditional auctioneer while sellers should be looked at more as the vendors in a traditional auction. This seems to be dealing with third party sales via ebay rather than direct sales though so other than one or two companies turning a profit via ebay I can't see the vast majority of sellers being affected. This raises the question for me though as to why anyone would go through a third party to sell an item rather than just opening an account and selling whatever they have to offer directly.

[KAMJIIN]

e-bay is acting as the auctioneer. but the group selling on behalf of someone else is acting as the auction house. here in South Carolina that requires them to have a firm liscence. PA apparently has their auction laws set up quite differently.

[GetterDragun]

What if you do "Buy it Now" that's more of a purchase than an auction. I can see getting around the law that way...I had a price I would sell it for, but I let people make me offers.