The Energon Pub

[cybercat]

I'm sure this has been done before, but just for the heck of it:

1986 Megatron/Galvatron

2007 Megatron

ROTF Megatron

Who wins? (I wanted to keep it to movies to keep it simple and so everyone could play, but feel free to add more Megsies!)

HK

[Rodimus Prime]

2007 Megatron is the most menacing, he would definitely take out 86 Megatron and RoTF Megatron, who, in my opinion, is a punk. Galvatron, though, I'm not sure. I would love to see that fight. Galvatron from season 3 would lose, but from the movie? Tough one.

[Shadowchacer]

Galvatron he was crazy as hell and his cannon Vaiped Starscream real good haven't seen the other Megs do that.

[Name_Violation]

86 galvs ftw.

[Bloodlust]

86 galvs ftw.

Close one between 86 galvatron and the movies.

I think 86 galvy takes it simply because he's bat s*** crazy

[Name_Violation]

Like DM said in another thread

[Shadowman]

2007 Megatron

ROTF Megatron

I would love to see this fight. Megatron just punching himself repeatedly. Like Jim Carrey beating himself up in Liar Liar.

I think I actually have to say it comes down to Movie Megatron (Calling the 2007 and RotF version different characters is like calling G1 Megatron and 1986 movie Megatron different characters) and Galvatron, and between them, I think I'd have to say Galvatron, seeing as how he was able to one-shot Starscream.

[Name_Violation]

i disagree

07 and rotf are as different as g1 megs and galvy.

rebuilt and seemed like more of a wuss, but had better firepower (he did oneshot prime)

[Shadowman]

i disagree

07 and rotf are as different as g1 megs and galvy.

rebuilt and seemed like more of a wuss, but had better firepower (he did oneshot prime)

So? TFs get rebuilt all the time, it doesn't make them different characters. BW Megatron didn't become a new character simply because he became Transmetal or Transmetal 2.

And no, he did not one-shot Prime. You see how he hit Prime several times before Prime died? One-shot means he died in the first shot.

EDIT: And no, his personality didn't change. He just had so much more characterization in RotF than the '07 movie, where he had fairly little characterization.

[snavej]

I think that Armada Megatron would win, especially when he's merged with Tidal Wave and has several Minicons attached, including the Requiem Blaster. That would vaporise any other Megatron or Galvatron. G1 Megatron has the black hole weapon but it's very difficult and slow to use.