AllNewSuperRobot wrote:If they have a toy, they have a better chance of survival.
Randomhero wrote: a soft reboot to G1 with the 84 toyline being the focus like everything these days. Crash landing on earth, a small group of humans discovering them and making friends and fighting the Decepticons who are evil because they’re written to be evil.
Addressing the Elephant in the room, but when has this actually happened, post-1984???
Dream Wave, perhaps? Outside of that, which I haven't read so wouldn't know, No cartoon or comic I've seen has ever reused the 1984 framework. IDW certainly didn't, nor did Beast Wars/Machines and the cartoons that followed them. I see a lot of chatter decrying this as a certainty, but I don't know where the basis for it stems from?
Transformers isn't really in the same boat as say, He-Man. Wherein the 2002 cartoon & toys predominantly relied on appealing to the nostalgia of it's original fanbase. Mattel realised too late, that to exclusively fixate on the old fans is a liability to your future success IE The show and toyline were soon cancelled and other than a single comic, He-Man hasn't been onscreen and/or relevant to pop culture in 15/16 years.
IDW did do it though. Just last year with retconning hearts of steel. Transformers crashing on earth and fighting. Granted it was all the machinations if shockwave but it’s still happened
Armada did it too. The cartoon and comics had the minicons crash on earth and starting the war there.
Devils due did it too with their Transformers VS G.I. Joe series
And don’t forget about animated. That was the start too. Crashing on earth
Also you should probably go back and watch beast wars. It opens with the maximals and predacons fighting in orbit and crashing on earth lol
Edit: oh! Don’t forget RID that also dealt with a ship crash landing on earth releasing a bunch of Decepticons