Seibertron.com Energon Pub Forums

[AllNewSuperRobot]

So I finished reading The Dying of The Light. The first story I've read that gives me a flavour of what MTMTE/LL is all about.

I read in voices IE Cullen for Prime, Angel for Cyclonus, Nelson for Hot Rod, Stack for Ultra Magnus etc. It adds to my immersion if I can authentically hear what I'm reading in one of those voices. This is my first problem with MTMTE.

Now I understand I am missing a lot of context, so I can't really judge the story, setting etc. Yet when it comes to the dialogue, I take issue. Auto-Megatron doesn't sound like Welker, he sounds like Kaye. Not a bad thing as I think David Kaye was a better Megatron, voice and in characterisation. However, -Ations Megatron does sound like Welker. So you can see my disparity. This applies across the board. So far in everything post DoOP I've read, the only one that sounds authentic is Prime.

Second issue being one from a Con Fan focused viewpoint. Everyone looks the same! I don't know if this was by design or intention. The close up I just looked at, was that Getaway? Or Brainstorm? Or Chromedome? or Rewind? About mid-story I struggled to tell which was the Blue one or the Red one, Swerve or Tailgate? Doesn't really help get someone invested in a book when you can only tell a handful of distinct main characters apart from the rest of the cast.

Off to read Titan's Return now...

[Rodimus Prime]

"Dying of the Light" and "Titans Return." 2 stories that disappointed me. They both started very good and the 2nd half just took a nosedive. I will say that I have yet to read TAAO volume 2, which is supposed to be the conclusion of the TR story. From what I understand the story gets better somewhat. I think Roberts wrote the garbage parts of TR, and it was the disintegration of the story in DotL that made me realize just how inadequate a TF writer Roberts really is.

[ZeroWolf]

I still find it a bit odd that they aren't even attempting to do a tie in for potp. I mean in a way I don't mind as it let's barber and Roberts get on with their stories but does this mean that hasbro are going to let idw decide if they want to provide a link to the toy line?

[Va'al]

I still find it a bit odd that they aren't even attempting to do a tie in for potp. I mean in a way I don't mind as it let's barber and Roberts get on with their stories but does this mean that hasbro are going to let idw decide if they want to provide a link to the toy line?

I mean, there's plenty of Primes action going down in Optimus Prime, after the introduction in TAAO. And Alpha Trion has been around since forever, with Micronus showing up in Micronauts and Revolution. Maybe it's not a direct tie-in like Titans Return, but the elements are there!

[AllNewSuperRobot]

"Dying of the Light" and "Titans Return." 2 stories that disappointed me. They both started very good and the 2nd half just took a nosedive. I will say that I have yet to read TAAO volume 2, which is supposed to be the conclusion of the TR story. From what I understand the story gets better somewhat. I think Roberts wrote the garbage parts of TR, and it was the disintegration of the story in DotL that made me realize just how inadequate a TF writer Roberts really is.

So yeah, finished reading Titans Return.. Lame. The book starts off with a story of how the Combaticons first formed into Bruticus. Is it just me or have the Gestalts been heavily nerfed since their introduction via Monstructor? Bruticus, noted for being one of the strongest and most heavily armoured of all Transformers, is defeated by one shot in the eye in a single panel.

Then we have the return of "fan favourite" Sentinel Prime A bit player in Megatron: Origin, now given the same one dimensional motivation as virtually every other "Evil Prime". Oh he's also a Headmaster.. Even though I seem to recall that tech being introduced on Earth, via Scorponok.

Also returning from the dead (ala LSoTW) is Fort Max, apparently? Yet another rushed ending closes this one out too. Off panel 'death by smoke stack' one of the laziest, most plot convenient tropes there is.

I am really glad I didn't spend actual money following RiD/OP/MTMTE/LL... If these stories are an indicator, they're better than McCarthy and Costa, but not by much. It's really disappointing how far the quality of IDWverse has fallen since the -Ations.

[ZeroWolf]

Fort was alive all the time in MTMTE, as he's reckless when he runs into overlord again (a separate encounter from before dying of the light and after lsotw)

Sentinel became a headmaster because it had to tie in to the titans return toy line where sentinel was a wave one voyager (basically he was there to get another use out of the mold before astrotrain was released)

As for change in combiners, this is because of the shift, we had nexus prime (now the first combiner) and his enigma of combination (as seen on the current grimlock, starscream, elita 1 and hunn grr figures) which is what created defensor, menasor, skyreign and the girl combiner whose name embrassingly escapes me at this moment. Superion was created through megatron experiments (same with a newer version of devestator which had prowl as the head, this was awesome btw) you could argue the power difference as jihaxus making monstructor much stronger through repeated experiments. Though I have no doubt if monstructor was to reappear then he would be depowered compared newer combiners

[AllNewSuperRobot]

Fort was alive all the time in MTMTE, as he's reckless when he runs into overlord again (a separate encounter from before dying of the light and after lsotw)

Sentinel became a headmaster because it had to tie in to the titans return toy line where sentinel was a wave one voyager (basically he was there to get another use out of the mold before astrotrain was released)

As for change in combiners, this is because of the shift, we had nexus prime (now the first combiner) and his enigma of combination (as seen on the current grimlock, starscream, elita 1 and hunn grr figures) which is what created defensor, menasor, skyreign and the girl combiner whose name embrassingly escapes me at this moment. Superion was created through megatron experiments (same with a newer version of devestator which had prowl as the head, this was awesome btw) you could argue the power difference as jihaxus making monstructor much stronger through repeated experiments. Though I have no doubt if monstructor was to reappear then he would be depowered compared newer combiners

As I've said, I miss out on a lot of context and backstory given how the part-work is realised but what I read was average at best. A sign of a good story is that it can be read and enjoyed outside of context, as I did with LSoTW. Neither of these stories is even remotely close to the standard of Wreckers.

Admittedly I understand comprises always have to be made to a comic by mandate of the license holder IE why Pretenders and Action Masters (and other bad ideas) came into being in the G1 comic. I accepted that being branded 'Titans Return' a tie-in the story wasn't going to be good. It's often disappointing to be right in that scenario.

Looking back, the Gestalts felt that Mandate more than most. Being usurped by the New toy BUT, for Bruticus to be KO'd with one gunshot to the eye is just bad. Didn't help that the art was equally as atrocious. It reminded me of the art from the Primacy trilogy, which I can't stand.

I'm told the next book in the part-work is from Dreamwave, of which I know next to nothing. A previous book in the collection released "War Within", which was alright but really basic.

[ZeroWolf]

Oh the bruticus one shot thing would have been more annoying if it had been to his side or arm but it was a head shot, so I'm okay with it. Yeah hasbro certainly got more involved with idw as time went on and it shows. I don't know if it was because of how well idw were doing or other reasons. As for stories being able to be read out of continuity it all depends on the story as why would anyone be invested in Tarn without knowing about him previously, time being taken to develop him, and to be a end point for megs story arc.

You may like dreamwave you may not. Some on here swear by them, others don't. Will be interesting to see which you fall into.

[starfishy]

hello, new member here.

watched the old cartoons as a kid and read a few of the comics. That was many years ago, but recently my curiosity was renewed and decided to pick up a transformers comic.

I found the first TPB for MTMTE, read it in a day, then went to buy the next couple trades, I know that’s from several years ago, but I understand that this Lost Light series is a continuation, correct? Anyways I have some catching up to do, I’m thinking I’ll just pick up the latest of LL at the same time I’m reading through the MTMTE series.

Really enjoying it though, excellent storytelling and characters. really like the focus on lesser used characters, the tailgate stuff was hilarious, and great to see swerve, whirl, skids and cyclonus. Good mix of humor and adventure, good art, all around just good comics. Looking forward to seeing what happens with Rodimus and his crew.

[Va'al]

hello, new member here.

watched the old cartoons as a kid and read a few of the comics. That was many years ago, but recently my curiosity was renewed and decided to pick up a transformers comic.

I found the first TPB for MTMTE, read it in a day, then went to buy the next couple trades, I know that’s from several years ago, but I understand that this Lost Light series is a continuation, correct? Anyways I have some catching up to do, I’m thinking I’ll just pick up the latest of LL at the same time I’m reading through the MTMTE series.

Lost Light is indeed the continuation, but it's actually exactly the same series under a different title. Marketing/editorial reasons. Your approach sounds like you might spoil some things for yourself, but other than that, I see nothing wrong with it!

[starfishy]

ok, so it’s an actual continuation then. Maybe I will just wait for the trades then and finish MTMTE first. I go back and forth with whether I want to get TPBs or single issues a lot.

Really glad I found this comic, I’m part way though the 2nd TPB of MTMTE.

[Rodimus Prime]

ok, so it’s an actual continuation then. Maybe I will just wait for the trades then and finish MTMTE first. I go back and forth with whether I want to get TPBs or single issues a lot.

Really glad I found this comic, I’m part way though the 2nd TPB of MTMTE.

Personally, I think MTMTE is better when read in TPBs. Makes for a better read, because you get all the parts of a story arc at the same time, so you can read through from start to finish. Get the individual issues only if you're a completionist. Have fun with it, MTMTE is pretty good, the 1st 40 issues, anyway. Then it kinda went downhill, in my opinion, but I guess you will make up your own mind. I think the other series, titled Robots in Disguise, then reduced to simply Transformers, is the better story.

Welcome to Seibertron.com!

[starfishy]

Personally, I think MTMTE is better when read in TPBs. Makes for a better read, because you get all the parts of a story arc at the same time, so you can read through from start to finish. Get the individual issues only if you're a completionist. Have fun with it, MTMTE is pretty good, the 1st 40 issues, anyway. Then it kinda went downhill, in my opinion, but I guess you will make up your own mind. I think the other series, titled Robots in Disguise, then reduced to simply Transformers, is the better story.

Welcome to Seibertron.com!

I actually picked up the first trade for Robots in Disguise too, haven’t read it yet since I got caught up in the MTMTE storyline. I flipped through, looks like a lot of classic bots, Bee, Prowl, Starscream, art looks really good though.

Anyways I finished the second TPB for MTMTE. The stuff with Pharma and the rust virus thing was ok. Tailgates autobot education was really funny. And the Misfire and his scavenger pals versus Tarn and his crazy goons was great.

Drift is really cool. Whirl has some fantastic moments.

Fort Max going nuts was well nuts.

Poor Flywheels, lol

Also Swerve has a bar, brilliant.

[D-Maximal_Primal]

Remember how it was confirmed by James Roberts that Lost Light would run through issue 25? Well, it appears as though while this will remain true, the assumption made that the series would run one comic a month through December has been debunked.

Thanks to Roberts via Twitter, we have news that the plan has shifted somewhat, with the issues of Lost Light now set to come out on a bi-weekly schedule until issue 25. This has been seen in the recent several weeks, with 4 issues of Lost Light coming out in relatively short order, and this new bi-weekly schedule will continue on into the summer. Roberts says this new schedule is set up so that Lost Light 25, Optimus Prime 25, and Unicron issue 6 all hit at the same time, seemingly to act as the bookend to the current IDW transformers run this summer.

With this in mind, we have not gotten any confirmation that Optimus Prime will shift to a bi-weekly schedule yet, but as per the June Solicitations, June will be the month where Lost Light should catch back up to Optimus Prime, so it's possible that both will then start the bi-weekly schedule side by side starting in July and ending in September alongside the Unicron story.

What do you think of this new bi-weekly schedule? What are your thoughts on the uncertainty surrounding the series after Unicron's ending? Let us know in the comments section below!

[YoungPrime]

Reading LL at least twice a month is good news. OP has been hit or miss so I don't really care who that releases. Especially with Bumblebee pointlessly returning.

I'd rather see Kup, Sideswipe, Shockwave, Galvatron or more than 20 other characters return.

[AllNewSuperRobot]

Certainly Galvatron. That was one of the most pathetic and anti-climatic deaths I've seen.

[ZeroWolf]

I wouldn't expect galvy back till after the unicron event (or perhaps during if galvy becomes a herald)

[AllNewSuperRobot]

I wouldn't expect galvy back till after the unicron event (or perhaps during if galvy becomes a herald)

Hopefully if he does come back, under a better writer, he won't talk like Abe Simpson

[ZeroWolf]

You have a problem with barber? I didn't mind the way he talked, we've only really had two takes on him before, and one of them was done by the same one who started him off for idw! Also in idw terms he's ancient, fighting with the primes. He likes to be a bit theatrical.

[AllNewSuperRobot]

I didn't know who specifically wrote that dialogue and I don't really care. From his Spotlight to Infestation/Heart of Darkness to CHAOS, he had a distinct voice.. which doesn't mesh with Abe Simpsontron

[Randomhero]

Certainly Galvatron. That was one of the most pathetic and anti-climatic deaths I've seen.

No burying him under an iceberg with the power of friendship is one of the most pathetic and anti-climactic deaths ever.

[AllNewSuperRobot]

Certainly Galvatron. That was one of the most pathetic and anti-climatic deaths I've seen.

No burying him under an iceberg with the power of friendship is one of the most pathetic and anti-climactic deaths ever.

Touché

[ZeroWolf]

Certainly Galvatron. That was one of the most pathetic and anti-climatic deaths I've seen.

No burying him under an iceberg with the power of friendship is one of the most pathetic and anti-climactic deaths ever.

Hah! Nicely done

I've never had a problem with it but I'm quite used to tropes that crop up in Japanese media (I've read all of fairy tail where the power of friendship happened multiple times every story arc, and it's climax was the biggest power of friendship I've ever seen) so I'm more forgiving with things like that.

[Galactic Prime]

Blah who cares, the sooner this crap ends and they reboot the better, then they can get back to Autobots being Autobots and Decepticons being Decepticons and them actually FIGHTING a war

[ZeroWolf]

So the war is never allowed to end then? How boring.

Wait, you say you dislike idw but if that's your request for what the comics should be then surely you shouldn't have had a problem with the early idw stuff when the war was active.