Posted by Qwan
Sun Oct 15, 2017 8:24 pm
Motto:
"There's no such thing as a no-lose situation, but if you try your hardest, you'll lose the least."
Weapon:
Hand-Mounted Lasers
I think I've finally nailed down why I, like many others here, am averse to the idea of Bee being the protagonist of another show even though I don't really hate the character in general. The problem is in his nature as a 'kid-appeal' character - as Skritz said, a hot-headed turbo-revvin' young punk who, over the course of the series/movie/whatever, learns how to take responsibility and matures into your generic competent and serious (if still wisecrackin') warrior.
And that right there's the problem. Kid-appeal characters tend to have exactly one character arc, and it's indisputably one that's best left in the background of a show. Any time Bee (or a similar character, say Hot Shot or... Energon Ironhide...) takes over as the protagonist of a show, then the protagonist's character arc - the main arc of the show - becomes an attempt to force the same tired kid-appeal progression into a starring role in the story. Boring and predictable, sadly, seems to be the name of the game when a character like Bumblebee takes the spotlight (in kid-focused media at least; I haven't read much of IDW but from what I know Bumblebee takes a primary role in that on occasion and he doesn't suffer from the same issue).
The good thing about this problem is that variety - any variety, really - can all but eliminate the entire issue. Even just properly good writing can do a lot to help! Animated Bumblebee has a similar arc to the one described above, but because his character goes from that of a child to a mature child (rather than the, IMO, more common immature-adult-to-adult - an important if fine distinction) I really enjoyed seeing it and it didn't feel forced or boring.
With any luck, the amnesia angle will help the plot of Cyberverse be more interesting than having a traditionally-kid-appeal character headlining would suggest - I won't count this show out just yet! But still, if you're relying on probably the most cliched trope in all of adventure media to make your adventure media seem interesting based on the synopsis, it might be worth thinking about better angles for marketing at the very least.
ultraimpossibleman wrote:Grand innacurration and heavy mistakes !
Diem wrote:This is exactly the kind of nonsense I'm here for.