Update On Transformers Movie Piracy Case
Posted by Raymond T.
Aug 21, 2007 at 4:48pm CDT
11,315 views
View Discussion
Sign in
or
Join
to reply
According to the new information, the 19 year old girl who recorded 20 seconds of the movie on her cell phone has gone to court and has pleaded guilty to the charges. The maximum fine was for $2.500 and one year in jail. But because the girl pleaded no contest, she was only fined $71.- with no jail time.
This was the first time in history someone has gone to court with the possibility of jail over piracy issues for non commercial use regarding a Hollywood movie. Yet another first in Movie history with the Transformers movie.
More Bots. More News. More Awesome.
Re: Update On Transformers Movie Piracy Case
(view post)
Comment by Skowl
Aug 21, 2007
That'll teach little girls to record 20 seconds of a movie on their cell phones!
I'm glad to see the justice system has it's priorities straight. Why bother with drug dealers, organised crime, counterfeiting, smuggling, murder and robbery when little girls are recording literally DOZENS of seconds of a movie! That's where all the man-power should go!
This should deter people from illegal copying movies... wait, no it won't.
I'm glad to see the justice system has it's priorities straight. Why bother with drug dealers, organised crime, counterfeiting, smuggling, murder and robbery when little girls are recording literally DOZENS of seconds of a movie! That's where all the man-power should go!
This should deter people from illegal copying movies... wait, no it won't.
Re: Update On Transformers Movie Piracy Case
(view post)
Comment by Windracer
Aug 21, 2007
All that hullaballoo for 20 seconds? ... yikes. While I'm not a fan of piracy that just screams "overkill" to me...
Re: Update On Transformers Movie Piracy Case
(view post)
Well bloody said.
Comment by Burn
Aug 21, 2007
Skowl wrote:I'm glad to see the justice system has it's priorities straight. Why bother with drug dealers, organised crime, counterfeiting, smuggling, murder and robbery when little girls are recording literally DOZENS of seconds of a movie! That's where all the man-power should go!
Well bloody said.
Re: Update On Transformers Movie Piracy Case
(view post)
Comment by Phorpus
Aug 21, 2007
Well, maybe the girl was cute?
Or hell, the way society is, this could all be a marketing ploy for the cell phone she was using.
Or if it wasn't, cell phone companies have a new marketing strategy.
Or hell, the way society is, this could all be a marketing ploy for the cell phone she was using.
Or if it wasn't, cell phone companies have a new marketing strategy.
Re: Update On Transformers Movie Piracy Case
(view post)
Comment by Liege Evilmus
Aug 21, 2007
Oh now I gotta get a bootleg!
Re: Update On Transformers Movie Piracy Case
(view post)
Comment by Vile MK III
Aug 21, 2007
ALL of that just for 20 sec of footage. Watta a waste of my tax dollors.
Re: Update On Transformers Movie Piracy Case
(view post)
Comment by Megatron Wolf
Aug 21, 2007
This is sad. There are murderers, drug dealers, and rapists out there and they waste the efforts of cops and the courts on some 19 year old chick who recorded a clip on her phone. Just goes to show you that all people care about is the all mighty dollar. Some times it sickens me that i live in the "great" USA.
Re: Update On Transformers Movie Piracy Case
(view post)
Comment by iconscons
Aug 21, 2007
While I agree is't kinda lame, don't rag on the justice system. If Movie company X says "this person is committing a crime against my company" it's not really up to judges/prosecutors to tell Movie company X "we don't care, so you have no recourse"
Re: Update On Transformers Movie Piracy Case
(view post)
Comment by Brakethrough
Aug 21, 2007
What she did was still illegal. Want to blame someone about tax dollars? blame her.
Re: Update On Transformers Movie Piracy Case
(view post)
Do you think we should let people who commit non-violent crimes run free? I don't! A crime is a crime. It came down to a petty crime in the end for only $71 but nonetheless it is what it is. You do realize that there are people in the crime force that's sole speciality is handling cases like this, right?
Comment by Seibertron
Aug 21, 2007
Megatron_Wolf wrote:This is sad. There are murderers, drug dealers, and rapists out there and they waste the efforts of cops and the courts on some 19 year old chick who recorded a clip on her phone. Just goes to show you that all people care about is the all mighty dollar. Some times it sickens me that i live in the "great" USA.
Do you think we should let people who commit non-violent crimes run free? I don't! A crime is a crime. It came down to a petty crime in the end for only $71 but nonetheless it is what it is. You do realize that there are people in the crime force that's sole speciality is handling cases like this, right?
Re: Update On Transformers Movie Piracy Case
(view post)
Make sure you direct your frustration at HER and not our justice system. Thanks.
Comment by Seibertron
Aug 21, 2007
Vile MK III wrote:ALL of that just for 20 sec of footage. Watta a waste of my tax dollors.
Make sure you direct your frustration at HER and not our justice system. Thanks.
Re: Update On Transformers Movie Piracy Case
(view post)
Comment by i_amtrunks
Aug 21, 2007
Glad to know that they did not try to make an example of her.
Still they would have been much better off just fining her on the spot, rather than drag it through the courts.
Still they would have been much better off just fining her on the spot, rather than drag it through the courts.
Re: Update On Transformers Movie Piracy Case
(view post)
I understand your point, and your right, but what gets me is that this is supposed to be the first time someone has gone to court over movie piracy issues, and they best they could find was a little girl who recorded 20 seconds of the film (which, if you go by the Supreme Court of Canada's ruling on distribution of music, is not technically illegal since she did not make a recording a over 10% of the film, which is the legal limit in Canada for copying of books and music, with a good lawyer, one could make the case for the same thing to be applied to film.)
Face it, small claims court or not, everytime a case opens, it costs tax payers money. They could have saved more than that 71$ fine was worth by just telling the girl not to do it again, and just move on to the bigger fish who are pirating... you know, complete movies.
Comment by Skowl
Aug 21, 2007
Seibertron wrote:Megatron_Wolf wrote:This is sad. There are murderers, drug dealers, and rapists out there and they waste the efforts of cops and the courts on some 19 year old chick who recorded a clip on her phone. Just goes to show you that all people care about is the all mighty dollar. Some times it sickens me that i live in the "great" USA.
Do you think we should let people who commit non-violent crimes run free? I don't! A crime is a crime. It came down to a petty crime in the end for only $71 but nonetheless it is what it is. You do realize that there are people in the crime force that's sole speciality is handling cases like this, right?
I understand your point, and your right, but what gets me is that this is supposed to be the first time someone has gone to court over movie piracy issues, and they best they could find was a little girl who recorded 20 seconds of the film (which, if you go by the Supreme Court of Canada's ruling on distribution of music, is not technically illegal since she did not make a recording a over 10% of the film, which is the legal limit in Canada for copying of books and music, with a good lawyer, one could make the case for the same thing to be applied to film.)
Face it, small claims court or not, everytime a case opens, it costs tax payers money. They could have saved more than that 71$ fine was worth by just telling the girl not to do it again, and just move on to the bigger fish who are pirating... you know, complete movies.
Re: Update On Transformers Movie Piracy Case
(view post)
Fair enough. Let's just not turn this into a trash-the-justice system thread, cool? She only had to pay a $71 fine so someone in the Justice system that's getting criticized in this thread also realized that this was rather petty. It's not like she only recorded 20 seconds and then went to jail for a year.
Comment by Seibertron
Aug 21, 2007
Skowl wrote:Seibertron wrote:Megatron_Wolf wrote:This is sad. There are murderers, drug dealers, and rapists out there and they waste the efforts of cops and the courts on some 19 year old chick who recorded a clip on her phone. Just goes to show you that all people care about is the all mighty dollar. Some times it sickens me that i live in the "great" USA.
Do you think we should let people who commit non-violent crimes run free? I don't! A crime is a crime. It came down to a petty crime in the end for only $71 but nonetheless it is what it is. You do realize that there are people in the crime force that's sole speciality is handling cases like this, right?
I understand your point, and your right, but what gets me is that this is supposed to be the first time someone has gone to court over movie piracy issues, and they best they could find was a little girl who recorded 20 seconds of the film (which, if you go by the Supreme Court of Canada's ruling on distribution of music, is not technically illegal since she did not make a recording a over 10% of the film, which is the legal limit in Canada for copying of books and music, with a good lawyer, one could make the case for the same thing to be applied to film.)
Face it, small claims court or not, everytime a case opens, it costs tax payers money. They could have saved more than that 71$ fine was worth by just telling the girl not to do it again, and just move on to the bigger fish who are pirating... you know, complete movies.
Fair enough. Let's just not turn this into a trash-the-justice system thread, cool? She only had to pay a $71 fine so someone in the Justice system that's getting criticized in this thread also realized that this was rather petty. It's not like she only recorded 20 seconds and then went to jail for a year.
Re: Update On Transformers Movie Piracy Case
(view post)
Comment by magnusupreme
Aug 21, 2007
serves her right
Re: Update On Transformers Movie Piracy Case
(view post)
Comment by Toyotus Superion
Aug 21, 2007
thats horrible.....if we dont fight these big movie companies they'll just trample all over us. I for one am glad I own bootleg copies of movies. I had my TF bootleg by the third week. Take that Paramount!
Re: Update On Transformers Movie Piracy Case
(view post)
Look at the issues in the rest of the world.
Think about that statement.
And if you still feel the same way, LEAVE!
Comment by Liege Evilmus
Aug 21, 2007
Megatron_Wolf wrote:This is sad. There are murderers, drug dealers, and rapists out there and they waste the efforts of cops and the courts on some 19 year old chick who recorded a clip on her phone. Just goes to show you that all people care about is the all mighty dollar. Some times it sickens me that i live in the "great" USA.
Look at the issues in the rest of the world.
Think about that statement.
And if you still feel the same way, LEAVE!
Re: Update On Transformers Movie Piracy Case
(view post)
Now that you have proclaimed how proud you are, do you mind if we forward this to paramounts lawyers so that you can fight the system and show us how it should be done? I love it when people are proud of "breaking the law".
Show us how to fight the good fight.
Comment by Robinson
Aug 21, 2007
Toyotus Superion wrote:thats horrible.....if we dont fight these big movie companies they'll just trample all over us. I for one am glad I own bootleg copies of movies. I had my TF bootleg by the third week. Take that Paramount!
Now that you have proclaimed how proud you are, do you mind if we forward this to paramounts lawyers so that you can fight the system and show us how it should be done? I love it when people are proud of "breaking the law".
Show us how to fight the good fight.
Re: Update On Transformers Movie Piracy Case
(view post)
True, the article ends with the fact that she admitted to what she did, and they just slapped a small fine in stead of the full extent of the law.
I'm not a fan of politics, and I beleive most cops are just legalized criminal facist(sorry Tony), but raging on a system that was CALLED IN to a situation is wrong.
Blame the people who placed that call, cause with the actual outcome of this situation, a minor fine to enforce an issue is realy nothing.
Do I believe the people who made the call over reacted, YES, do I think thats the courts fault, NO!
Comment by Liege Evilmus
Aug 21, 2007
iconscons wrote:While I agree is't kinda lame, don't rag on the justice system. If Movie company X says "this person is committing a crime against my company" it's not really up to judges/prosecutors to tell Movie company X "we don't care, so you have no recourse"
True, the article ends with the fact that she admitted to what she did, and they just slapped a small fine in stead of the full extent of the law.
I'm not a fan of politics, and I beleive most cops are just legalized criminal facist(sorry Tony), but raging on a system that was CALLED IN to a situation is wrong.
Blame the people who placed that call, cause with the actual outcome of this situation, a minor fine to enforce an issue is realy nothing.
Do I believe the people who made the call over reacted, YES, do I think thats the courts fault, NO!
Re: Update On Transformers Movie Piracy Case
(view post)
I agree with both of these statements. If they were gonna make an example of her, they shoulda gave her the max fine and jail time. Instead, they slap her on the wrist. Yeah, it's a petty crime. No, it won't stop pirating in the least. A huge over reaction, a huge waste of time and money. $71 doesn't even cover court costs, she should been made to pay the max if they were gonna drag it out this way.
Comment by D-340
Aug 21, 2007
Skowl wrote:That'll teach little girls to record 20 seconds of a movie on their cell phones!
I'm glad to see the justice system has it's priorities straight. Why bother with drug dealers, organised crime, counterfeiting, smuggling, murder and robbery when little girls are recording literally DOZENS of seconds of a movie! That's where all the man-power should go!
This should deter people from illegal copying movies... wait, no it won't.
Vile MK III wrote:ALL of that just for 20 sec of footage. Watta a waste of my tax dollors.
I agree with both of these statements. If they were gonna make an example of her, they shoulda gave her the max fine and jail time. Instead, they slap her on the wrist. Yeah, it's a petty crime. No, it won't stop pirating in the least. A huge over reaction, a huge waste of time and money. $71 doesn't even cover court costs, she should been made to pay the max if they were gonna drag it out this way.
