Rodimus Prime wrote:william-james88 wrote:Rodimus Prime wrote:I'm not sure if this question has been asked and/or answered, so I will ask:
Is Combiner Wars Devastator the closest we will get to a Masterpiece Devastator?
No, Takara's UW Devastator is. The interview with the designer who makes MPs and who did this Devastator said that his starting point was a design he had done for Masterpiece Devastator. He had to remove pieces to abide to Hasbro's parts count as the process continued but brought them back for the Takara release.
So that means we won't get an actual Masterpiece Devastator set? Unite Warriors Devastator should be considered the "masterpiece" edition even though it officially isn't?
Hey Rodimus, I fear I may have given you an unfair shake. I will give you a much better example and you can then decide for yourself if you would call United Warriors Devastator an MP Devastator.
He is basically the same thing as Legends Arcee. In a rare occasion nowadays, Arcee was redesigned by Takara and does not use the offical more CHUG design Hasbro wanted. The idea is that this is the first toy of G1 Arcee proper and there is no point in making an updated version if she never had an actual toy. So Takara made Generations Arcee to be G1 arcee. Unlike almost every other classics figure, the sculpt is cartoon accurate and features no "modern" update. Her vehicle is even cybertronian unlike the car found in the IDW comics. And the Legends version features the G1 show deco highlighting how the sculpt is faithful to the G1 character model.
Do you consider her an MP Arcee? Just as in UW Devastator, Legends Arcee is not in line with the rest of the Classics figures, and is designed by Takara. And also as with Devastator, there is no indication that she will have an MP anytime soon.
Devastator is also much more G1 than other CHUG figures and the Takara colours make him show accurate. He does have a bit of modernizing though, like with the cement dump truck. Actually, that makes Arcee more faithful to her G1 character model than any other CHUG figure ever, including Devastator.
So, by the logic of the MP line which is all about giving the most perfect interpretation of a character, Legends Arcee fits that bill more than UW Devastator. Do you consider her an MP? If not, then you shouldnt consider Devastator an MP either.