Gauntlet101010 wrote:It's jumping back a few posts, but I think Zelda is talking about a Prime that looks like Robot Masters Prime. It's chest and grille aren't fake while still retaining G1 Prime's whole look.
I'm sure there's a way to make that in a way that doesn't make the entire vehicle mode suck.
Ewww. That junk is soooo not what I was going for. Even if the chest and grille aren't fake it still suffers from faux-parts usage (like the bumper), the legs having to be turned backwards for vehicle mode, and an excessively complex transformation.

There's a reason I put a pic of the original (okay, it's a reissue, but) G1 toy in my last post. What I'm talking about is a Prime that largely looks like this except with:
1. The panels on the backs of the shoulders moved to his back to make the cartoon's backpack
2. Square forearms like the cartoon
3. Cartoon-style (at least somewhat) abdominal slopes achieved by flipping the front fenders (which would now no longer be attached to the forearms) up into the empty space left by the arms
4. The front wheels and bumper being hinged similarly to Cybertron Optimus' hip wheels and faux-bumper:

Gauntlet101010 wrote:TBH, I prefer Earthrise. In general I'm not a huge fan of faux parts, but I can't deny the results.
Well, if that's your taste.
For me, the transformation process is part of the result, and... A G1 Optimus Prime toy having a borderline Bayformer transformation scheme (based on what I've heard) feels off.
Regarding your gripes about ER Ironhide's feet... It seems pretty likely to me that the SIEGE Ratchet/Ironhide mold was never really designed with an Earth mode retool in mind. HasTak tried to shoehorn it into one anyway with a new windshield, new leg panels, and a roof shield and... Well, you can see how that worked out. The feet worked okay in the original version of the mold, and that was all they were really meant for.
Which 3D-printed feet were you looking at? The Funbie Studios ones look like they blend decently at least (although they're C.O.M.A.T. incompatible). Maybe it would work better to have a secondary shield piece that covers the feet to blend them (and can combine with the existing one in its ground platform mode).
I personally think ER Ratchet and Ironhide were a bad development investment... A new, Voyager mold with an A.I.R.Lock-compatible version of the G1 sled would have been a lot better I think.