Transformers and More @ The Seibertron Store














Details subject to change. See listing for latest price and availability.
Liege Evilmus wrote:Are you for real with that one!
The comics conflict the shows which conflict the movie which conflicts the bios that conflict the manga which conflict the conflicting conflicts of the main confliction!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
As for being endorsed by Hasbro, they'll endorse flaming bags of dog doo with a TF logo on it if they think it'll make them a buck.
AND YES, if something has Hasbro's name or logo on it, they are getting a cut!
Now please tell me, if Hasbro truely cared for canon, why do they allow so many retellings? Hell, why did they just recently take 3 japanesse series, only 2 of which had anything to do with one another, and dub them together as as a TRILOGY?
With all the different stories out there in all the different medias. One book can't wrap it all up, and being endorsed by the main cause of this confusion only lessens it's crediblity(to me).
So at that point it realy falls to us to devise our own, which we were having fun doing, sharing our ideas and all untill someone kept trying to bitch slap us with only 1 of many books.
Liege Evilmus wrote:Are you for real with that one!
The comics conflict the shows which conflict the movie which conflicts the bios that conflict the manga which conflict the conflicting conflicts of the main confliction!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Liege Evilmus wrote:As for being endorsed by Hasbro, they'll endorse flaming bags of dog doo with a TF logo on it if they think it'll make them a buck.
AND YES, if something has Hasbro's name or logo on it, they are getting a cut!
Liege Evilmus wrote:Now please tell me, if Hasbro truely cared for canon, why do they allow so many retellings? Hell, why did they just recently take 3 japanesse series, only 2 of which had anything to do with one another, and dub them together as as a TRILOGY?
Liege Evilmus wrote:With all the different stories out there in all the different medias. One book can't wrap it all up, and being endorsed by the main cause of this confusion only lessens it's crediblity(to me).
Tramp wrote:Each retelling is a different reality. The Ultimate Guide tells us how those realities fit together into a greater multiverse.
Tramp wrote:When it comes to current canon, as a compilation of the entire TF saga and all of its myriad incarnations and realities, pretty much. The individual comics and shows only deal with their individual realities. The Ultimate Guide discusses all of them and how they relate to one another and, at least according to it, provides the "true" history of the Transformers race. IT draws information from the G1 cartoons, Marvel comics, Dreamwave comics, Universe stories from both 3H and the toys, the entire Beast Wars saga, RID, Armada, Energon, IDW, etc. The only things it didn't cover are Cybertron and the new movie. It is the most comprehensive source of TF canon published to date.Cyber Bishop wrote:Tramp wrote:I'm just supplying the information found in existing canon sources. IF David Wise or another TF author wrote a conflicting book, that would be one thing, but there isn't a conflicting book. The Ultimate Guide is considered by Hasbro to be autoritive. I'm just supplying the information. Eradicator asked for canon answers to his question. Thus, I have looked for those canon answers from the most reliable canon sources I can find.
So this guide is the only source of info out there?
Tramp wrote:Liege Evilmus wrote:Are you for real with that one!
The comics conflict the shows which conflict the movie which conflicts the bios that conflict the manga which conflict the conflicting conflicts of the main confliction!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
As for being endorsed by Hasbro, they'll endorse flaming bags of dog doo with a TF logo on it if they think it'll make them a buck.
AND YES, if something has Hasbro's name or logo on it, they are getting a cut!
Now please tell me, if Hasbro truely cared for canon, why do they allow so many retellings? Hell, why did they just recently take 3 japanesse series, only 2 of which had anything to do with one another, and dub them together as as a TRILOGY?
With all the different stories out there in all the different medias. One book can't wrap it all up, and being endorsed by the main cause of this confusion only lessens it's crediblity(to me).
So at that point it realy falls to us to devise our own, which we were having fun doing, sharing our ideas and all untill someone kept trying to bitch slap us with only 1 of many books.
Each retelling is a different reality. The Ultimate Guide tells us how those realities fit together into a greater multiverse.
Cyber Bishop wrote:The only way any of the stories could all be canon is if they considered them like the DC universe with the multiverse.
Each universe would be it's own canon entity.
G1 Toon - Beast Machines = Main universe
G1 & G2 Marvel comic = universe 2
Japanese toon = universe 3
UK comic = universe 4
RID = universe 5
Energon Armada and Cybertron = universe 6
Something like that makes more sense than lumping all of the continuities into one big "melting pot" confusing the **** out of everyone.
Cyber Bishop wrote:Liege Evilmus wrote:Are you for real with that one!
The comics conflict the shows which conflict the movie which conflicts the bios that conflict the manga which conflict the conflicting conflicts of the main confliction!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Exactly, how can they actually agree on what is 100% canon with all the various TF related media that has circulated since 84?
I mean just starting out they had 2 separate continuities, the Marvel continuity and the toon continuity.Liege Evilmus wrote:As for being endorsed by Hasbro, they'll endorse flaming bags of dog doo with a TF logo on it if they think it'll make them a buck.
AND YES, if something has Hasbro's name or logo on it, they are getting a cut!
I have to agree here.. Right now TF is a hot commodity and anything with TF on it sells.Liege Evilmus wrote:Now please tell me, if Hasbro truely cared for canon, why do they allow so many retellings? Hell, why did they just recently take 3 japanesse series, only 2 of which had anything to do with one another, and dub them together as as a TRILOGY?
Makes sense to me.Liege Evilmus wrote:With all the different stories out there in all the different medias. One book can't wrap it all up, and being endorsed by the main cause of this confusion only lessens it's crediblity(to me).
Makes sense as well.
The only way any of the stories could all be canon is if they considered them like the DC universe with the multiverse.
Each universe would be it's own canon entity.
G1 Toon - Beast Machines = Main universe
G1 & G2 Marvel comic = universe 2
Japanese toon = universe 3
UK comic = universe 4
RID = universe 5
Energon Armada and Cybertron = universe 6
Something like that makes more sense than lumping all of the continuities into one big "melting pot" confusing the **** out of everyone.Tramp wrote:Each retelling is a different reality. The Ultimate Guide tells us how those realities fit together into a greater multiverse.
Ah, so even though I never read any of these "ultimate guides" I got that part correct.
But tying them all together and putting it into book form is nothing but a silly moneymaking ploy.Tramp wrote:When it comes to current canon, as a compilation of the entire TF saga and all of its myriad incarnations and realities, pretty much. The individual comics and shows only deal with their individual realities. The Ultimate Guide discusses all of them and how they relate to one another and, at least according to it, provides the "true" history of the Transformers race. IT draws information from the G1 cartoons, Marvel comics, Dreamwave comics, Universe stories from both 3H and the toys, the entire Beast Wars saga, RID, Armada, Energon, IDW, etc. The only things it didn't cover are Cybertron and the new movie. It is the most comprehensive source of TF canon published to date.Cyber Bishop wrote:Tramp wrote:I'm just supplying the information found in existing canon sources. IF David Wise or another TF author wrote a conflicting book, that would be one thing, but there isn't a conflicting book. The Ultimate Guide is considered by Hasbro to be autoritive. I'm just supplying the information. Eradicator asked for canon answers to his question. Thus, I have looked for those canon answers from the most reliable canon sources I can find.
So this guide is the only source of info out there?
Don't start that highlighting **** with me.
Whiner-tron wrote:GOD DAMM IT!!!
Tramp, Damolisher, I have seen you two get one tread I was enjoying locked, could you try not to **** this one up two?
i_amtrunks wrote:Cyber Bishop wrote:The only way any of the stories could all be canon is if they considered them like the DC universe with the multiverse.
Each universe would be it's own canon entity.
G1 Toon - Beast Machines = Main universe
G1 & G2 Marvel comic = universe 2
Japanese toon = universe 3
UK comic = universe 4
RID = universe 5
Energon Armada and Cybertron = universe 6
Something like that makes more sense than lumping all of the continuities into one big "melting pot" confusing the **** out of everyone.
I'm someway surprised that hasbro has not done something like this already, it would give them even more freedom in re-releasing toys. ie: "Universe 4 Pretender Grimlock", "Universe 6 Snarl" etc etc.
The fact that every new series more or less ignores what has happened previously (barring G1-Beast Wars-Beast Machine, and Armada-Energon) You cannot make all the continuities fit snugly in together, there are similarities and nods to previous series, but that is no reason to try to force them into one large grouping.
Could you ever imagine trying to get the IDW stories to fit in with the Marvel Uk stuff??? They are even written by the same guy, yet they do not work at all together.
Tramp wrote:There is actually a very good reason for Hasbro and its affiliates trying to establish a set canon, including linking the Multiverse together with a common history while still keeping each story within the multiverse their own realities.
Tramp wrote:The whole point of a book like the Ultimate Guide is to show how it really is, and thus remove "personal interpretation" over what is true or not.
Most of the discussions I've been involved in have been ones regarding facts about TF canon, thus requiring canon answers or proof, which is why I go to these specific sources. IF you're trying to prove something, it is best to have canon proof to back it up. You can't back it up based solely upon your own personal views. That is why I go back to this source as well as the various other canon sources so much. They're necessary for the given discussions. I'm not trying to take away anyone else's fun. I'm just trying to answer the questions or support a side of a debate with canon evidence.Cyber Bishop wrote:Tramp wrote:There is actually a very good reason for Hasbro and its affiliates trying to establish a set canon, including linking the Multiverse together with a common history while still keeping each story within the multiverse their own realities.
yeah, to publish a book and make money.Tramp wrote:The whole point of a book like the Ultimate Guide is to show how it really is, and thus remove "personal interpretation" over what is true or not.
And where is the fun with that?
Part of the fun on this website and others like it, is to discuss and debate people's personal interpretations on the TF fandom and honestly you seem to be the only one that goes around and ruins that fun for others by spouting that books info. No one before you preached it so religiously like you do.
Lighten up and let people have their fun eh?
Cyber Bishop wrote:Tramp wrote:There is actually a very good reason for Hasbro and its affiliates trying to establish a set canon, including linking the Multiverse together with a common history while still keeping each story within the multiverse their own realities.
yeah, to publish a book and make money.Tramp wrote:The whole point of a book like the Ultimate Guide is to show how it really is, and thus remove "personal interpretation" over what is true or not.
And where is the fun with that?
Part of the fun on this website and others like it, is to discuss and debate people's personal interpretations on the TF fandom and honestly you seem to be the only one that goes around and ruins that fun for others by spouting that books info. No one before you preached it so religiously like you do.
Lighten up and let people have their fun eh?
Liege Evilmus wrote:So basicly we should just take whatever they give us, never question it, and be happy with that cop out excuse!
I'm sorry but I'm a creative intelligent person, my intrest and dollar demand better than "Because we say so"
There is still some inconsitancies, but they're relatively minor. Most of them are dealt with through retcons, and establishing which takes priority through a canon heirachy.You reference Star Wars, I'm not realy a fan. But in what I've seen and read, no matter what the source, you can see very close attention to consistancy in all their stories.
Well, Star Treak has it easy. Paramount only considers the TV shows and movies canon, and everything else apocrypha.The same goes for Star Trek, DragonBall(they mastered it), TMNT, Macross, and well basicly anything Hasbro doesn't touch.
Tramp wrote:Most of the discussions I've been involved in have been ones regarding facts about TF canon, thus requiring canon answers or proof, which is why I go to these specific sources. IF you're trying to prove something, it is best to have canon proof to back it up. You can't back it up based solely upon your own personal views. That is why I go back to this source as well as the various other canon sources so much. They're necessary for the given discussions. I'm not trying to take away anyone else's fun. I'm just trying to answer the questions or support a side of a debate with canon evidence.Cyber Bishop wrote:Tramp wrote:There is actually a very good reason for Hasbro and its affiliates trying to establish a set canon, including linking the Multiverse together with a common history while still keeping each story within the multiverse their own realities.
yeah, to publish a book and make money.Tramp wrote:The whole point of a book like the Ultimate Guide is to show how it really is, and thus remove "personal interpretation" over what is true or not.
And where is the fun with that?
Part of the fun on this website and others like it, is to discuss and debate people's personal interpretations on the TF fandom and honestly you seem to be the only one that goes around and ruins that fun for others by spouting that books info. No one before you preached it so religiously like you do.
Lighten up and let people have their fun eh?
Tramp wrote:Liege Evilmus wrote:So basicly we should just take whatever they give us, never question it, and be happy with that cop out excuse!
I'm sorry but I'm a creative intelligent person, my intrest and dollar demand better than "Because we say so"
It isn't a "cop-out" excuse. They're trying to establsih some consistancy and link all of the realities—both US/UK and Japanese—together while still keeping each story and reality independent.There is still some inconsitancies, but they're relatively minor. Most of them are dealt with through retcons, and establishing which takes priority through a canon heirachy.You reference Star Wars, I'm not realy a fan. But in what I've seen and read, no matter what the source, you can see very close attention to consistancy in all their stories.Well, Star Treak has it easy. Paramount only considers the TV shows and movies canon, and everything else apocrypha.The same goes for Star Trek, DragonBall(they mastered it), TMNT, Macross, and well basicly anything Hasbro doesn't touch.
Liege Evilmus wrote:
Please keep in mind, this is only how I work making sense of everything.
G1 through Japan is what it is. G2 is a step towards the evolution to The Beast Era, which began with a trip back in time.
For a short time Otimus Primal, carried Prime's spark. During this time, time itself warped creating a present in which RID occured.
Prime's spark was restored, the events of history went back to normal.
------------------------
Key side note, the sentient remains of Unicron, took advantge of this flux, and remined in the past, thehead cocooning into one of the moons to regenerate a new body. It's fractured planet side parts, spawned minicons like maggots.
------------------------------
Later BW megs took G1 Megs spark for a longer time creating another rift, with the unexpected into of things like minicons, this story becomes Armada, Energon, and Cybertron.
TF Classics are new bodies for tired G1 figures who don't want to give up the struggle, The Alts, are like a royal version of that.
The movie toys are new characters spawned from the sparks that touched Primus when he awoke....
-------------------------------------------
In all of this, 1 Primus, 1 Unicron(actualy he managed to split his body as I have 3, but he's the same guy in 1 universe).
All the different Primes and Megatrons and everyone else that have many figures, divide a portion of their spark off when ever a new body is built. It gives them individuality, but a shared mental kinship with others who share a piece of that spark.
---------------------------------------------
This isn't canon, it's just how my collection and the various stories make sense to me. Things like having a zillion of the same guy can get confusing. And the whole "alternate universe" thing is a cop out for writers to be lazy and just make it up as they go along instead of working on a single quality story.
Like it or lump it, thats all it is, my idea.
Predaprince wrote:I am very thankful to have posters like sto_vo_kor_2000 who is so energetic about improving others' understanding and enjoyment of the TF universe
Stormrider wrote:You often add interesting insights to conversations that makes the fledglings think and challenges even the sharpest minds
T-Macksimus wrote:I consider you and editor to be amongst the most "scholarly" in terms of your knowledge, demeanor and general approach
Liege Evilmus wrote:So basicly we should just take whatever they give us, never question it, and be happy with that cop out excuse!
I'm sorry but I'm a creative intelligent person, my intrest and dollar demand better than "Because we say so"
You reference Star Wars, I'm not realy a fan. But in what I've seen and read, no matter what the source, you can see very close attention to consistancy in all their stories.
The same goes for Star Trek, DragonBall(they mastered it), TMNT, Macross, and well basicly anything Hasbro doesn't touch.
Predaprince wrote:I am very thankful to have posters like sto_vo_kor_2000 who is so energetic about improving others' understanding and enjoyment of the TF universe
Stormrider wrote:You often add interesting insights to conversations that makes the fledglings think and challenges even the sharpest minds
T-Macksimus wrote:I consider you and editor to be amongst the most "scholarly" in terms of your knowledge, demeanor and general approach
Tramp wrote:Believe me, I don't take any of it personally.
sto_vo_kor_2000 wrote:Liege Evilmus wrote:So basicly we should just take whatever they give us, never question it, and be happy with that cop out excuse!
I'm sorry but I'm a creative intelligent person, my intrest and dollar demand better than "Because we say so"
You reference Star Wars, I'm not realy a fan. But in what I've seen and read, no matter what the source, you can see very close attention to consistancy in all their stories.
The same goes for Star Trek, DragonBall(they mastered it), TMNT, Macross, and well basicly anything Hasbro doesn't touch.
Are you a Treki as well?
Predaprince wrote:I am very thankful to have posters like sto_vo_kor_2000 who is so energetic about improving others' understanding and enjoyment of the TF universe
Stormrider wrote:You often add interesting insights to conversations that makes the fledglings think and challenges even the sharpest minds
T-Macksimus wrote:I consider you and editor to be amongst the most "scholarly" in terms of your knowledge, demeanor and general approach
Return to Transformers General Discussion
Registered users: Bing [Bot], blokefish, Cheetron, Glyph, Google [Bot], Google Adsense [Bot], Google Feedfetcher, MSN [Bot], Yahoo [Bot]