Now, I know I've been agreeing with the charts so far. But Magnus is a case where the chart is full of beryllium baloney. It makes him way too small. His cab is the same size as Optimus, so his super robot mode is going to be bigger than that:

Going by the original toys, this is how it should be (of course, going by the original toys Galvatron was made way too huge but that's another discussion).

The Masterpiece version isn't bigger by as much, but it still comes out bigger than the chart says. And he was often drawn bigger than the chart. He was also consistently drawn at least as big as, or bigger than, Rodimus Prime.

Now, here is the modern Rodimus Prime. Same height as Titans Return Powermaster Optimus Prime and therefore the same height as Combiner Wars Ultra Magnus, because PMOP is a retool of CW Mags:

So, if Siege Magnus' head only comes up to CW Magnus' neckline he ends up too short next to Roddy.
SkyFire Prime wrote:How boring
Watch them release clean versions later this year with a special paint.
That's not boring. Boring would be if he'd drilled holes in them

Wolfman Jake wrote:ZeldaTheSwordsman wrote:Sideswipe is looking like his size might not be so bad ^^; I'll have to see him next to some Prime Wars and T30 deluxes to be sure. I'd also like to see the same for Optimus (plus Prime Wars Voyagers and pre-T30 CHUG deluxes like Wheeljack). I may well be eating crow on what I said, and I won't complain because I really like their designs.
Yay! Everyone wins! Really, you can't lose with these awesome looking Siege toys. I just hope they show up in my area soon.
ZeldaTheSwordsman wrote:I'm still worried about Ultra Magnus though. If I'm correct in recalling his stated super robot height as eight inches, that would mean his head would come up to Combiner Wars Magnus' neckline.
I too hope Siege Ultra Magnus isn't that short. Going by the Masterpiece scale of Takara, I think Siege Optimus Prime is better matched with Combiner Wars Ultra Magnus for scale accuracy. I'll probably be sticking with my Autobot Heroes version of CW Ultra Magnus anyway. The Siege version looks nice, but I don't appreciate the overkill on the greebling and I prefer the modern G1 look of the CW alt mode over the Siege version's Car Robots homage. CW Ultra Magnus isn't that terribly far off model in robot mode from his G1 rendering, either. He's just a bit more stylized. A perfect "Classics" style of Transformer, in my opinion.
To be fair, the original Ultra Magnus toy also has greebling overkill. Also to be fair, the RiD-based trailer was the only way to get away with a Voyager cab at the Leader-class price point without making the trailer look squashed-up.
Returning to the subject of that chart... Anybody got shots of
Siege Optimus and Megatron with Titans Return Galvatron?