Review for IDW Transformers Beast Wars Issue 2
Wednesday, March 3rd, 2021 5:22PM CST
Categories: Comic Book News, Reviews, Site ArticlesPosted by: william-james88 Views: 56,707
Topic Options: View Discussion · Sign in or Join to reply
Review for IDW Transformers Beast Wars Issue 2
The entire issue is discussed in this review
This issue was a series of interactions among various characters. Of course, that's what all stories are but what I mean here is that every 2 pages we got different characters talking to one another and this gave us a great sense of their relationships and personalities. It was basically a series of small character pieces all in one comic, ending with a pretty great action scene.
I especially like how different the Maximals are to the Predacons. All Predacon interactions are violent, with no sense of comradery. I loved the scene between Dinobot and Tarantulus, where the allegiance and disdain for hierarchy among Megatron's soldiers is made loud and clear. Dinobot is one of my favourite characters from my childhood and I am happy to see him interact with his fellow Predacons as an ally, since that's something we never really saw in the original Beast Wars show.
The other interaction I like is Optimus Primal and Nyx, but more for Primal's characterization. We see more of that younger and adventure hungry Primal here and how this side of him affects him as a leader. I like it. I already had the more world weary and pensive Primal, so it's fun to see this side of him. I also thought Josh Burcham drew him really well. The art will still not win a ton of people over but as someone who was not a fan, I did think Primal looked great. The simple approach to the fur in robot mode reminded me of the original toy where the molded fur detail would be more apparent at the edges. And speaking of the original toy, his transformation in the comic was a nice callback.
So, back to this less risk averse Primal, we see in this issue just what the consequences of this change can entail for the safety of his crew. It leads to a terrific scene with Terrorsaur. Once again Josh Burcham really delivers here with a great looking Pteranodon mode and some fun shots and angles, making for a very dynamic scene. I especially like the predatory POV shot we get (I won't spoil that shot in this review).
However, like I wrote earlier, the art in this issue won't change your mind. There are some odd choices, like how Scorponok's tail seems designed by Tim Burton and the lack of background in particular scenes is very glaring. The characters are expressive though, and the scenes are dynamic. So I choose to take the good and leave the bad. You do you.
We also get a small taste of the VOK and I am fine seeing them this early. We get a sense of all the players being brought to the table. I was never a fan of the VOK, they always felt anticlimactic to me in the original show, so I'll wait to pass judgement until I see more. At least their appearance this early already avoids the anti climax the show gave us when we found out what they really looked like.
Overall, I preferred this issue to the first, I really loved the character interactions. If you liked the characters from the original, especially the Predacons, then I recommend you check this out.
out of
News Search
Got Transformers News? Let us know here!
Most Popular Transformers News
ROTB Optimus Prime Lead Designer Discusses Why the Face Looks Similar to the 2007 Movie
56,813 viewsMost Recent Transformers News
News Categories: Toy News, Movie Related News, Cartoon News, Comic Book News, Site News, Rumors, Event News, Digital Media News, Collectables, Sponsor News, Game News, Site Articles, Store News, Reviews, People News, Company News, Sightings, Press Releases, Unlicensed Products News, Auctions, Transtopia, Interviews, Editorials, Collector's Club News, Knock Offs, Podcast, Heavy Metal War, Contests, Book News, Top Lists
Re: Review for IDW Transformers Beast Wars Issue 2 (2097124)
Posted by william-james88 on March 3rd, 2021 @ 5:26pm CST
You wouldn't want them being what the Quintessons evolved into then?
Why is this in spoiler text?
Posted by william-james88 on March 3rd, 2021 @ 5:26pm CST
Stormshot_Prime wrote:TOO MUCH ENERGON! wrote:Sabrblade wrote:No more Vok origins, please. We just got a new one four days ago and it's... meh.JazZeke wrote:I was kinda hoping this series will solidify them as an evolution of the swarm, but it doesn't look likely now.
The Vok don't need a known origin. They can just stay enigmatic. It's part of their charm.
When I was a kid I legitimately thought the “aliens” were supposed to represent the Christian God or some other figure indicative of intelligent design.
Oh man, that’s a lot to unpack. But I agree with Sabrblade, the more mysterious they are, the better. How the comic is presenting them so far alludes more to their goals as cosmic interferers/experimenters, not so much as to where they originated from. That is just fine with me, I’m hopeful to see them do new things with the Vok, the scope of their machinations, rather than like “Oh they’re X thing that somehow relates to old canon!”
You wouldn't want them being what the Quintessons evolved into then?
Dead Metal wrote:
It's weird how Rinox of all people is super pissed about Rattrap eating fruit.
Why is this in spoiler text?
Re: Review for IDW Transformers Beast Wars Issue 2 (2097136)
Posted by TOO MUCH ENERGON! on March 3rd, 2021 @ 6:45pm CST
Right? The guy who literally defeated Megatron with an Energon fart from eating too many wild bean vines.
Posted by TOO MUCH ENERGON! on March 3rd, 2021 @ 6:45pm CST
william-james88 wrote:Dead Metal wrote:
It's weird how Rinox of all people is super pissed about Rattrap eating fruit.
Why is this in spoiler text?
Right? The guy who literally defeated Megatron with an Energon fart from eating too many wild bean vines.
Re: Review for IDW Transformers Beast Wars Issue 2 (2097179)
Posted by AllNewSuperRobot on March 4th, 2021 @ 9:28am CST
First, the art makes them look terrible. Giving them names and petty attitudes makes them sound terrible too. Not a good first impression at all.
The show implied that the Vok knew of the Cybertronians from the probe in 'Chain of Command'. Their greater origin, motives etc were kept vague and mysterious for good reason. The Beast Wars interrupted one of their experiments. However, it wasn't enough to cause them to involve themselves directly. Not at first anyway.
The Vok don't need backstory or names/individuality and absolutely do not need to be "relatable" by any metric. They are 'The Other', an abstract entity, and that is all you need to know. Every Vok appearance in the show gave you zero information about them. Beyond vague concepts, one-off lines and hints. Did any of that detract from a single Vok story or lessen their impact? No. Because that was never the point of the Vok. You don't need to learn about lil' Vok JR's struggles with maths to make engaging stories about them.
Trying to humanise an ethereal being indicates someone who doesn't understand what they are and probably should have come up with an all new alien force instead.
Posted by AllNewSuperRobot on March 4th, 2021 @ 9:28am CST
TFfan1 wrote:And am I the only one who finds seeing the Vok named and arguing really...lame? I feel like their ominous mystique is totally ruined, especially because in complete opposition to other media, they don't seem to know what Cybertronians are.
First, the art makes them look terrible. Giving them names and petty attitudes makes them sound terrible too. Not a good first impression at all.
The show implied that the Vok knew of the Cybertronians from the probe in 'Chain of Command'. Their greater origin, motives etc were kept vague and mysterious for good reason. The Beast Wars interrupted one of their experiments. However, it wasn't enough to cause them to involve themselves directly. Not at first anyway.
Nexus Knight wrote:I think it remains to be seen. We haven't seen enough of this version of the Vok to form that poor of an opinion yet. Honestly, this feels fresh, while not retreading the original. True, enigmatic enemies are fun, but they can ruin the show too. Giving them personalities helps us build some of their backstory in a little, while also helping us identify who is who, allow us to relate somewhat with them (as they seem like they are going to be a large part of this series, at least in the beginning) and adding potential for different story writing and conflicts. Heck, they can be kept as mysterious as is brought out above, and still giving us different flavors to show that they are still individuals.
The Vok don't need backstory or names/individuality and absolutely do not need to be "relatable" by any metric. They are 'The Other', an abstract entity, and that is all you need to know. Every Vok appearance in the show gave you zero information about them. Beyond vague concepts, one-off lines and hints. Did any of that detract from a single Vok story or lessen their impact? No. Because that was never the point of the Vok. You don't need to learn about lil' Vok JR's struggles with maths to make engaging stories about them.
Trying to humanise an ethereal being indicates someone who doesn't understand what they are and probably should have come up with an all new alien force instead.
Re: Review for IDW Transformers Beast Wars Issue 2 (2097194)
Posted by snavej on March 4th, 2021 @ 12:03pm CST
Posted by snavej on March 4th, 2021 @ 12:03pm CST
What the Vok?! 
Just noticed that 'Vok' sounds like a swear.
Just noticed that 'Vok' sounds like a swear.
Re: Review for IDW Transformers Beast Wars Issue 2 (2097196)
Posted by Dead Metal on March 4th, 2021 @ 12:44pm CST
Because I didn't read the preview and thus didn't know if that was part of the preview. Don't see the point in reading a preview if I'm paying for the story anyway, especially not when the preview is probably 1/4 of the comic And I decided to keep all comic content in spoilers just out of a curtesy.
Posted by Dead Metal on March 4th, 2021 @ 12:44pm CST
william-james88 wrote:Dead Metal wrote:
It's weird how Rinox of all people is super pissed about Rattrap eating fruit.
Why is this in spoiler text?
Because I didn't read the preview and thus didn't know if that was part of the preview. Don't see the point in reading a preview if I'm paying for the story anyway, especially not when the preview is probably 1/4 of the comic And I decided to keep all comic content in spoilers just out of a curtesy.
Re: Review for IDW Transformers Beast Wars Issue 2 (2097228)
Posted by JazZeke on March 4th, 2021 @ 6:04pm CST
Posted by JazZeke on March 4th, 2021 @ 6:04pm CST
After a rather substantial first issue for the Beast Wars comic, I was annoyed by how short a read this month's issue turned out to be. Of the standard 22 pages, two of them were wasted on a recap of recycled art and a roll call page with tiny headshots adrift in a lot of empty space. So wasteful.
I don't mind the Vok showing up early and having a little more characterization. We've already seen them as creepy enigmatic entities; if the comic did everything 100% like the original series then there would be no point to its existence.
I don't mind the Vok showing up early and having a little more characterization. We've already seen them as creepy enigmatic entities; if the comic did everything 100% like the original series then there would be no point to its existence.
Re: Review for IDW Transformers Beast Wars Issue 2 (2097298)
Posted by AllNewSuperRobot on March 5th, 2021 @ 3:09pm CST
Posted by AllNewSuperRobot on March 5th, 2021 @ 3:09pm CST
The general flavour of the overly positive feedback I'm getting, is that they are trying to "MTMTE/LL" Beast Wars, which is being embraced by those fans.
Beast Wars already had that once before. It was called the 'Japanese Dub'. No one wants that as a supposed celebration of the anniversary of the show.
If you're not going to have the Vok Be The Vok, then what is the point in using them?
By that logic, Megatron doesn't have to be a Predacon or even a Transformer. Instead a down on his luck interpretive dancer. Struggling - Billy Elliot-style - to perfect his most difficult routine yet.
The jury is still out on that one.
Beast Wars already had that once before. It was called the 'Japanese Dub'. No one wants that as a supposed celebration of the anniversary of the show.
JazZeke wrote:I don't mind the Vok showing up early and having a little more characterization. We've already seen them as creepy enigmatic entities
If you're not going to have the Vok Be The Vok, then what is the point in using them?
By that logic, Megatron doesn't have to be a Predacon or even a Transformer. Instead a down on his luck interpretive dancer. Struggling - Billy Elliot-style - to perfect his most difficult routine yet.
JazZeke wrote:if the comic did everything 100% like the original series then there would be no point to its existence.
The jury is still out on that one.
Re: Review for IDW Transformers Beast Wars Issue 2 (2097320)
Posted by Burn on March 5th, 2021 @ 6:15pm CST
Posted by Burn on March 5th, 2021 @ 6:15pm CST
I know it's only two issues in, but it seems a little ... slow. In fact the whole issue felt a little short, like little to no progression has been made.
And I get that as a new book, that's to be expected. But given IDW's pacing with the main TF book and how dragged out that story is, I worry that this one will drag as well.
And I get that as a new book, that's to be expected. But given IDW's pacing with the main TF book and how dragged out that story is, I worry that this one will drag as well.
Re: Review for IDW Transformers Beast Wars Issue 2 (2097352)
Posted by Sabrblade on March 6th, 2021 @ 12:17am CST
All the hype and build up to their mystery in the first season was ultimately squandered and given the shaft because Season 2 opted to instead build up to Megatron's master plan of writing history, while Season 3 was too busy advertising Optimal Optimus, Depth Charge, TM2 Dinobot, TM2 Cheetor, TM2 Blackarachnia, TM2 Megatron, and Tigerhawk to leave any real room for the cartoon to actually do anything substantial with the Vok. Their only post-Season 1 episodes were either just an excuse to get Tigatron and Airazor out of the show for a while, or to shill Tigerhawk's new toy (and that episode was supposed to focus on the Vok, but Hasbro be like "Nah, new toy, Mainframe! Sell it!").
The Vok practically became the Beast Wars equivalent of the Pokemon anime's GS Ball: A hyped up plot device initially wrapped in mystery but whose existence ultimately wound up being pointless and wasted. For this comic or any new fiction to use them as faithfully as possible to how the cartoon used them would be to basically not use them at all.
Posted by Sabrblade on March 6th, 2021 @ 12:17am CST
Bruh, the Vok were a big fat load of nothing in the cartoon. All they ever amounted to was a generic nonentity race full of unfulfilled promises and unrealized potential.AllNewSuperRobot wrote:JazZeke wrote:I don't mind the Vok showing up early and having a little more characterization. We've already seen them as creepy enigmatic entities
If you're not going to have the Vok Be The Vok, then what is the point in using them?
All the hype and build up to their mystery in the first season was ultimately squandered and given the shaft because Season 2 opted to instead build up to Megatron's master plan of writing history, while Season 3 was too busy advertising Optimal Optimus, Depth Charge, TM2 Dinobot, TM2 Cheetor, TM2 Blackarachnia, TM2 Megatron, and Tigerhawk to leave any real room for the cartoon to actually do anything substantial with the Vok. Their only post-Season 1 episodes were either just an excuse to get Tigatron and Airazor out of the show for a while, or to shill Tigerhawk's new toy (and that episode was supposed to focus on the Vok, but Hasbro be like "Nah, new toy, Mainframe! Sell it!").
The Vok practically became the Beast Wars equivalent of the Pokemon anime's GS Ball: A hyped up plot device initially wrapped in mystery but whose existence ultimately wound up being pointless and wasted. For this comic or any new fiction to use them as faithfully as possible to how the cartoon used them would be to basically not use them at all.
Re: Review for IDW Transformers Beast Wars Issue 2 (2097370)
Posted by AllNewSuperRobot on March 6th, 2021 @ 10:09am CST
Posted by AllNewSuperRobot on March 6th, 2021 @ 10:09am CST
Well that's one interpretation. To me, they were interesting because the mystery was never revealed. The experiment put in play on prehistoric Earth, never elaborated on. Because our point of view was narrowed on the War. Not on The Other.
Anyway, Issue #2... Meh
First thing, The Art. As already noted, I don't like the fact that The Vok now look like graffiti. Also, apparently Arachnid legs and tails just curl up into nothingness. Who knew?
A particular bugbear however, came in the depiction of Rhinox (my favourite Maximal):
Note: His Mouth is big and opens wide.
I dunno, to me the art seems to be worse in this issue? Perhaps because more of the full body designs are on display (especially, The Feet). Primal could be a puppet, from the weird blue lines that trail off his arms to unknown heights.
Beyond that, this is a whole lot of redundant talking and not much else. Terrorsaur as an active aggressor is strange and different enough to be welcome. It would have been nice if his actual individual weapons were used though. Instead of shared Primal Shotguns???
The scene itself would have played out exactly the same with his signature shoulder blasters. Just seems like a lazy generic substitute was used for no reason.
This issue does nothing and doesn't really go anywhere beyond a seemingly hard push for Bat Girl. 3/10
As an aside, I'm far too cynical a person to take the letters page as being remotely genuine.
Anyway, Issue #2... Meh
First thing, The Art. As already noted, I don't like the fact that The Vok now look like graffiti. Also, apparently Arachnid legs and tails just curl up into nothingness. Who knew?
A particular bugbear however, came in the depiction of Rhinox (my favourite Maximal):
Note: His Mouth is big and opens wide.
I dunno, to me the art seems to be worse in this issue? Perhaps because more of the full body designs are on display (especially, The Feet). Primal could be a puppet, from the weird blue lines that trail off his arms to unknown heights.
Beyond that, this is a whole lot of redundant talking and not much else. Terrorsaur as an active aggressor is strange and different enough to be welcome. It would have been nice if his actual individual weapons were used though. Instead of shared Primal Shotguns???
The scene itself would have played out exactly the same with his signature shoulder blasters. Just seems like a lazy generic substitute was used for no reason.
This issue does nothing and doesn't really go anywhere beyond a seemingly hard push for Bat Girl. 3/10
As an aside, I'm far too cynical a person to take the letters page as being remotely genuine.
Re: Review for IDW Transformers Beast Wars Issue 2 (2097388)
Posted by Rtron on March 6th, 2021 @ 3:22pm CST
Posted by Rtron on March 6th, 2021 @ 3:22pm CST
So far, I'm still a bit on the fence on this one. Not particularly bad, not particularly good.
A detail I noticed: It seems like nobody can fly in robot mode! Primal sends Nyx instead of going himself, and given the way she talks about flying, she couldn't do it before adopting her bat mode. Also, when Terrorsaur transforms while chasing her, he starts falling, which seems to point to him being unable to fly in robot mode too. It would be a tiny but interesting difference, it reminds me of how in the G1 Marvel comics Decepticons couldn't magically fly the way they did in the cartoon.
A detail I noticed: It seems like nobody can fly in robot mode! Primal sends Nyx instead of going himself, and given the way she talks about flying, she couldn't do it before adopting her bat mode. Also, when Terrorsaur transforms while chasing her, he starts falling, which seems to point to him being unable to fly in robot mode too. It would be a tiny but interesting difference, it reminds me of how in the G1 Marvel comics Decepticons couldn't magically fly the way they did in the cartoon.
Re: Review for IDW Transformers Beast Wars Issue 2 (2097389)
Posted by AllNewSuperRobot on March 6th, 2021 @ 3:28pm CST
Posted by AllNewSuperRobot on March 6th, 2021 @ 3:28pm CST
To be fair, in the show only Fliers could fly. Waspinator's wings did actively move as he flew in Bot Mode, for example. At the time, with only Sunbow as a reference. It took a bit of getting used to that not everyone could fly.
Naturally, Primal and Inferno were strange exceptions. Especially Inferno, wherein his flight capability made no sense?
Naturally, Primal and Inferno were strange exceptions. Especially Inferno, wherein his flight capability made no sense?
Re: Review for IDW Transformers Beast Wars Issue 2 (2097390)
Posted by Rtron on March 6th, 2021 @ 3:31pm CST
Terrorsaur, Windrazor, Inferno and Primal had built in jetpacks in robot mode, that's how they flew. What I was pointing out is that nobody seems capable of flying in robot mode here. We'll have to wait and see with Waspinator, who was the only one in the show who used the same method of locomotion to fly in both modes.
Posted by Rtron on March 6th, 2021 @ 3:31pm CST
AllNewSuperRobot wrote:To be fair, in the show only Fliers could fly. Waspinator's wings did actively move as he flew in Bot Mode, for example. At the time, with only Sunbow as a reference. It took a bit of getting used to that not everyone could fly.
Naturally, Primal and Inferno were strange exceptions. Especially Inferno, wherein his flight capability made no sense?
Terrorsaur, Windrazor, Inferno and Primal had built in jetpacks in robot mode, that's how they flew. What I was pointing out is that nobody seems capable of flying in robot mode here. We'll have to wait and see with Waspinator, who was the only one in the show who used the same method of locomotion to fly in both modes.
Re: Review for IDW Transformers Beast Wars Issue 2 (2097391)
Posted by AllNewSuperRobot on March 6th, 2021 @ 3:40pm CST
I meant from a design standpoint, not how they flew. All Fliers had flying altmodes, aside from Primal and Inferno.
I'm not sure if Terrorsaur's dive was because he was falling or merely framing the scene in a more dynamic POV. Also remember the caveat of Season One, wherein travelling long distance was safer in Beast Mode due to Energon Radiation.
Posted by AllNewSuperRobot on March 6th, 2021 @ 3:40pm CST
Rtron wrote:AllNewSuperRobot wrote:To be fair, in the show only Fliers could fly. Waspinator's wings did actively move as he flew in Bot Mode, for example. At the time, with only Sunbow as a reference. It took a bit of getting used to that not everyone could fly.
Naturally, Primal and Inferno were strange exceptions. Especially Inferno, wherein his flight capability made no sense?
Terrorsaur, Windrazor, Inferno and Primal had built in jetpacks in robot mode, that's how they flew. What I was pointing out is that nobody seems capable of flying in robot mode here. We'll have to wait and see with Waspinator, who was the only one in the show who used the same method of locomotion to fly in both modes.
I meant from a design standpoint, not how they flew. All Fliers had flying altmodes, aside from Primal and Inferno.
I'm not sure if Terrorsaur's dive was because he was falling or merely framing the scene in a more dynamic POV. Also remember the caveat of Season One, wherein travelling long distance was safer in Beast Mode due to Energon Radiation.
Re: Review for IDW Transformers Beast Wars Issue 2 (2097395)
Posted by Sabrblade on March 6th, 2021 @ 7:16pm CST
For Inferno, it's as simple as the fact that his toy had a built-in rotor/thruster gimmick, so the cartoon model simply used it accordingly.
Posted by Sabrblade on March 6th, 2021 @ 7:16pm CST
Primal's flight was a vestigial trait from when Mainframe and Hasbro floated the idea of him being a bat/gorilla/robot triple-changer in the cartoon so as to advertise both of his toys at the same time. When this concept was dropped, they left in his flight in robot mode.AllNewSuperRobot wrote:Naturally, Primal and Inferno were strange exceptions. Especially Inferno, wherein his flight capability made no sense?
For Inferno, it's as simple as the fact that his toy had a built-in rotor/thruster gimmick, so the cartoon model simply used it accordingly.
Re: Review for IDW Transformers Beast Wars Issue 2 (2097410)
Posted by AllNewSuperRobot on March 7th, 2021 @ 3:07am CST
Posted by AllNewSuperRobot on March 7th, 2021 @ 3:07am CST
I mean, if they didn't keep that trait with Primal. The Maximals would have had a severe disadvantage until Episode 15, with Airazor's debut.
Personally, as I had the Bat Primal figure first and didn't like the proposed idea of a Triple Changer. I would have preferred Bat to Gorilla altmode in the show.
All they had to do was make TM Inferno a Flying Ant and it would have given credence to this built in thruster. But no, they made him/"Scavenger" a drill...
Besides the point that his thruster is horizontal. In contrast to every other Flier. I would have understood if they made him run really fast as a result. Or even hover over terrain. But his entire design had no lift for flight.
Personally, as I had the Bat Primal figure first and didn't like the proposed idea of a Triple Changer. I would have preferred Bat to Gorilla altmode in the show.
All they had to do was make TM Inferno a Flying Ant and it would have given credence to this built in thruster. But no, they made him/"Scavenger" a drill...
Besides the point that his thruster is horizontal. In contrast to every other Flier. I would have understood if they made him run really fast as a result. Or even hover over terrain. But his entire design had no lift for flight.
Re: Review for IDW Transformers Beast Wars Issue 2 (2097511)
Posted by D-Maximal_Primal on March 8th, 2021 @ 6:22pm CST
Posted by D-Maximal_Primal on March 8th, 2021 @ 6:22pm CST
Man, I am really enjoying this. I love Burcham's art, so seeing it fill a comic if fantastic. I just love it. I don't really have any complaints so far outside of fear of IDW2019 continuity slow speed, but I have faith in the creative team, they made excellent Ghostbusters comics
Re: Review for IDW Transformers Beast Wars Issue 2 (2097695)
Posted by Dead Metal on March 10th, 2021 @ 2:42am CST
Only the writer has made fantastic Ghostbusters comics, the artist only coloured two covers.
So yeah, complete faith in the story going to be excellent.
Posted by Dead Metal on March 10th, 2021 @ 2:42am CST
D-Maximal_Primal wrote:Man, I am really enjoying this. I love Burcham's art, so seeing it fill a comic if fantastic. I just love it. I don't really have any complaints so far outside of fear of IDW2019 continuity slow speed, but I have faith in the creative team, they made excellent Ghostbusters comics
Only the writer has made fantastic Ghostbusters comics, the artist only coloured two covers.
So yeah, complete faith in the story going to be excellent.
Re: Review for IDW Transformers Beast Wars Issue 2 (2099438)
Posted by william-james88 on March 26th, 2021 @ 9:12pm CDT
Posted by william-james88 on March 26th, 2021 @ 9:12pm CDT
Below is an iTunes preview for Transformers: Beast Wars #3, which will be coming out in April.
Unbeknownst to the Maximals, the Predacons have taken their first prisoner! As Megatron and Tarantulas run their interrogation, dissent stirs in the Predacon ranks. Who’ll give first—the dissatisfied Dinobot or the captured Maximal? The Beast Wars rage on!
AVAILABLE: April 2021
CREATORS:
Erik Burnham (Author) Josh Burcham (Artist, Cover Artist)
IMPRINT: IDW
PAGE COUNT: 32
COLOR: FC
Unbeknownst to the Maximals, the Predacons have taken their first prisoner! As Megatron and Tarantulas run their interrogation, dissent stirs in the Predacon ranks. Who’ll give first—the dissatisfied Dinobot or the captured Maximal? The Beast Wars rage on!
AVAILABLE: April 2021
CREATORS:
Erik Burnham (Author) Josh Burcham (Artist, Cover Artist)
IMPRINT: IDW
PAGE COUNT: 32
COLOR: FC
Re: Review for IDW Transformers Beast Wars Issue 2 (2099469)
Posted by megamanfan on March 27th, 2021 @ 7:59am CDT
Posted by megamanfan on March 27th, 2021 @ 7:59am CDT
i love how easy it is to imagine David Kaye reading those megatron lines.
Re: Review for IDW Transformers Beast Wars Issue 2 (2099494)
Posted by bluecatcinema on March 27th, 2021 @ 2:55pm CDT
Posted by bluecatcinema on March 27th, 2021 @ 2:55pm CDT
I like how they're showing Dinobot becoming more and more dissatisfied with the cruelty of his comrades, building up to his inevitable defection to the Maximals.
Re: Review for IDW Transformers Beast Wars Issue 2 (2099499)
Posted by AllNewSuperRobot on March 27th, 2021 @ 3:48pm CDT
Posted by AllNewSuperRobot on March 27th, 2021 @ 3:48pm CDT
Tarantulas looks awful, probably the worst one yet. I suppose giving Dinobot a completely different, if really generic, reason for leaving the Predacons does at least diverge this book from the original show. I was trying to think why it looked familiar... That's how it was done with Silverbolt!
Re: Review for IDW Transformers Beast Wars Issue 2 (2099537)
Posted by JazZeke on March 28th, 2021 @ 1:06am CDT
Posted by JazZeke on March 28th, 2021 @ 1:06am CDT
I've been on the fence about the art, but I'm rrreeeeaally not liking this, to the point where it may permanently swing me to the "dislike" side. Such a shame.
Re: Review for IDW Transformers Beast Wars Issue 2 (2099538)
Posted by Dead Metal on March 28th, 2021 @ 2:49am CDT
Posted by Dead Metal on March 28th, 2021 @ 2:49am CDT
Wow, the art just keeps getting worse and worse.
Could Livio Ramondelli take over art duties?
Could Livio Ramondelli take over art duties?
Re: Review for IDW Transformers Beast Wars Issue 2 (2099540)
Posted by AllNewSuperRobot on March 28th, 2021 @ 2:53am CDT
I thought we wanted the art to look better
Whoever did the Retail Incentive cover above, would be a vast improvement (after slimming down Primal a bit).
Posted by AllNewSuperRobot on March 28th, 2021 @ 2:53am CDT
Dead Metal wrote:Wow, the art just keeps getting worse and worse.
Could Livio Ramondelli take over art duties?
I thought we wanted the art to look better
Whoever did the Retail Incentive cover above, would be a vast improvement (after slimming down Primal a bit).
Re: Review for IDW Transformers Beast Wars Issue 2 (2099541)
Posted by JazZeke on March 28th, 2021 @ 3:09am CDT
Livio's a fantastic colorist, enough to hide the fact that his lineart leaves a LOT to be desired.
Posted by JazZeke on March 28th, 2021 @ 3:09am CDT
Dead Metal wrote:Wow, the art just keeps getting worse and worse.
Could Livio Ramondelli take over art duties?
Livio's a fantastic colorist, enough to hide the fact that his lineart leaves a LOT to be desired.
Re: Review for IDW Transformers Beast Wars Issue 2 (2099542)
Posted by AllNewSuperRobot on March 28th, 2021 @ 3:33am CDT
Posted by AllNewSuperRobot on March 28th, 2021 @ 3:33am CDT
The Primacy trilogy easily shares the honour, alongside Heart of Darkness, as the worst art produced by IDW. Akin to Skittles spewed over the page...
Re: Review for IDW Transformers Beast Wars Issue 2 (2099543)
Posted by Dead Metal on March 28th, 2021 @ 3:44am CDT
Posted by Dead Metal on March 28th, 2021 @ 3:44am CDT
Ramondelli isn't great, but he would be an improvement over this.
I would prefer the artist of the Retail incentive cover, but lets be realistic, idw doesn't put good artists on TF books anymore, it's just people who are willing to draw fast and cheap. And Ramondelli at least puts heart into his work.
I would prefer Liefeld over the art in this book, at least he knows curves exist.
I would prefer the artist of the Retail incentive cover, but lets be realistic, idw doesn't put good artists on TF books anymore, it's just people who are willing to draw fast and cheap. And Ramondelli at least puts heart into his work.
I would prefer Liefeld over the art in this book, at least he knows curves exist.
Re: Review for IDW Transformers Beast Wars Issue 2 (2099544)
Posted by AllNewSuperRobot on March 28th, 2021 @ 3:46am CDT
Seriously, what is Nick Roche doing these days? He'd be brilliant on this.
Posted by AllNewSuperRobot on March 28th, 2021 @ 3:46am CDT
Dead Metal wrote:I would prefer Liefeld over the art in this book, at least he knows curves exist.
Seriously, what is Nick Roche doing these days? He'd be brilliant on this.
Re: Review for IDW Transformers Beast Wars Issue 2 (2099545)
Posted by Dead Metal on March 28th, 2021 @ 3:53am CDT
Marvel.
He won't be back with idw.
Posted by Dead Metal on March 28th, 2021 @ 3:53am CDT
AllNewSuperRobot wrote:Dead Metal wrote:I would prefer Liefeld over the art in this book, at least he knows curves exist.
Seriously, what is Nick Roche doing these days? He'd be brilliant on this.
Marvel.
He won't be back with idw.
Re: Review for IDW Transformers Beast Wars Issue 2 (2099546)
Posted by AllNewSuperRobot on March 28th, 2021 @ 3:54am CDT
Posted by AllNewSuperRobot on March 28th, 2021 @ 3:54am CDT
That's a shame. Still, I'll look forward to whatever he is doing at Marvel then.
Re: Review for IDW Transformers Beast Wars Issue 2 (2099547)
Posted by Dead Metal on March 28th, 2021 @ 4:01am CDT
Posted by Dead Metal on March 28th, 2021 @ 4:01am CDT
It's not confirmed he won't be back with idw. But I would say it's a good guess. He did complain that his books never got any promotion, MTMTE being the exception. Hell Sins of the Wrekers was buirried so hard I only learned off of it because someone I have on FB stumbled upon the last issue and asked if anyone knew this existed.
And seeing how he's now ben noticed by the mainstream and has success with other indy books, I don't think he'll go back. Especially since it looks like he's getting regular and steady work at Marvel, unlike with idw where he got a cover now and then, and a comic every couple of years.
And seeing how he's now ben noticed by the mainstream and has success with other indy books, I don't think he'll go back. Especially since it looks like he's getting regular and steady work at Marvel, unlike with idw where he got a cover now and then, and a comic every couple of years.
Re: Review for IDW Transformers Beast Wars Issue 2 (2099548)
Posted by AllNewSuperRobot on March 28th, 2021 @ 4:07am CDT
Posted by AllNewSuperRobot on March 28th, 2021 @ 4:07am CDT
Sounds reasonable to believe he won't return then.
Ironic, considering I think Last Stand of the Wreckers is the best Transformers story IDW has produced. Also from reading the entire IDWverse run, via the part work, I'd say he was responsible for more of that success, outside of the artwork, than Roberts.
Occasion dodgy practices aside, at least Marvel historically appreciate good artists.
Ironic, considering I think Last Stand of the Wreckers is the best Transformers story IDW has produced. Also from reading the entire IDWverse run, via the part work, I'd say he was responsible for more of that success, outside of the artwork, than Roberts.
Occasion dodgy practices aside, at least Marvel historically appreciate good artists.
Re: Review for IDW Transformers Beast Wars Issue 2 (2099582)
Posted by D-Maximal_Primal on March 28th, 2021 @ 2:51pm CDT
Posted by D-Maximal_Primal on March 28th, 2021 @ 2:51pm CDT
Looking forward to the next issue. I am a big fan of Burcham's art, and I continue to like what he is doing with it. I really like it. Kudos to him for finally getting his own book, sticking to his style, and making it look great.
Re: Review for IDW Transformers Beast Wars Issue 2 (2099585)
Posted by AllNewSuperRobot on March 28th, 2021 @ 2:56pm CDT
You did notice Tarantulas in the preview, right?
Posted by AllNewSuperRobot on March 28th, 2021 @ 2:56pm CDT
D-Maximal_Primal wrote:and making it look great.
You did notice Tarantulas in the preview, right?
Re: Review for IDW Transformers Beast Wars Issue 2 (2099590)
Posted by ZeroWolf on March 28th, 2021 @ 3:06pm CDT
I agree, I like the art and the story. I was beginning to feel like I was the only one here who did like the art
Posted by ZeroWolf on March 28th, 2021 @ 3:06pm CDT
D-Maximal_Primal wrote:Looking forward to the next issue. I am a big fan of Burcham's art, and I continue to like what he is doing with it. I really like it. Kudos to him for finally getting his own book, sticking to his style, and making it look great.
I agree, I like the art and the story. I was beginning to feel like I was the only one here who did like the art
Re: Review for IDW Transformers Beast Wars Issue 2 (2099592)
Posted by D-Maximal_Primal on March 28th, 2021 @ 3:08pm CDT
I did, he looks good.
You've spewed your art and story hatred over this entire thread, hard to miss I might add, and I have shared my thoughts on the art and story and find it enjoyable. I for one hope Burcham keeps doing what he's doing because i love it.
Outside of the cliffjumper arc of Galaxies, this is the best art the comics have seen since IDW2005 ended.
Posted by D-Maximal_Primal on March 28th, 2021 @ 3:08pm CDT
AllNewSuperRobot wrote:D-Maximal_Primal wrote:and making it look great.
You did notice Tarantulas in the preview, right?
I did, he looks good.
You've spewed your art and story hatred over this entire thread, hard to miss I might add, and I have shared my thoughts on the art and story and find it enjoyable. I for one hope Burcham keeps doing what he's doing because i love it.
Outside of the cliffjumper arc of Galaxies, this is the best art the comics have seen since IDW2005 ended.
Re: Review for IDW Transformers Beast Wars Issue 2 (2099595)
Posted by AllNewSuperRobot on March 28th, 2021 @ 3:15pm CDT
Posted by AllNewSuperRobot on March 28th, 2021 @ 3:15pm CDT
No hatred at all. I don't feel that strongly about any media. But coming from an artistic background, ill suited art is hard to miss. It is an objective viewpoint. Not a subjective one.
I'm also far from the minority in vocal detractors of the art either.
I'm also far from the minority in vocal detractors of the art either.
Re: Review for IDW Transformers Beast Wars Issue 2 (2099597)
Posted by D-Maximal_Primal on March 28th, 2021 @ 3:18pm CDT
On here? yes, that's obvious, it's partly why i don't visit the comics threads that often anymore.
On Facebook? also not surprising, facebook typically holds the older G1 crowds who praise the Prime Wars trilogy and hate on anything post-1988.
On Twitter, far from it. It's incredible the praise Burcham has been handed for his work, and he has provided some fun insights into his work. It's been a blast.
Posted by D-Maximal_Primal on March 28th, 2021 @ 3:18pm CDT
AllNewSuperRobot wrote:No hatred at all. I don't feel that strongly about any media. But coming from an artistic background, ill suited art is hard to miss. It is an objective viewpoint. Not a subjective one.
I'm also far from the minority in vocal detractors of the art either.
On here? yes, that's obvious, it's partly why i don't visit the comics threads that often anymore.
On Facebook? also not surprising, facebook typically holds the older G1 crowds who praise the Prime Wars trilogy and hate on anything post-1988.
On Twitter, far from it. It's incredible the praise Burcham has been handed for his work, and he has provided some fun insights into his work. It's been a blast.
Re: Review for IDW Transformers Beast Wars Issue 2 (2099600)
Posted by ZeroWolf on March 28th, 2021 @ 3:22pm CDT
For a moment there I thought you meant people praising the prime Wars cartoon
though i suppose statistically, someone has to Like them 
Posted by ZeroWolf on March 28th, 2021 @ 3:22pm CDT
D-Maximal_Primal wrote:AllNewSuperRobot wrote:No hatred at all. I don't feel that strongly about any media. But coming from an artistic background, ill suited art is hard to miss. It is an objective viewpoint. Not a subjective one.
I'm also far from the minority in vocal detractors of the art either.
On here? yes, that's obvious, it's partly why i don't visit the comics threads that often anymore.
On Facebook? also not surprising, facebook typically holds the older G1 crowds who praise the Prime Wars trilogy and hate on anything post-1988.
On Twitter, far from it. It's incredible the praise Burcham has been handed for his work, and he has provided some fun insights into his work. It's been a blast.
For a moment there I thought you meant people praising the prime Wars cartoon
though i suppose statistically, someone has to Like them
Re: Review for IDW Transformers Beast Wars Issue 2 (2099602)
Posted by AllNewSuperRobot on March 28th, 2021 @ 3:24pm CDT
Posted by AllNewSuperRobot on March 28th, 2021 @ 3:24pm CDT
That sounds more like confirmation bias, than honest feedback.
Re: Review for IDW Transformers Beast Wars Issue 2 (2099605)
Posted by D-Maximal_Primal on March 28th, 2021 @ 3:28pm CDT
I was, Facebook was where the positive feedback for those cartoons came from.
So you are saying Facebook comments and forum comments here are honest feedback, but twitter feedback is not? cool cool.
Posted by D-Maximal_Primal on March 28th, 2021 @ 3:28pm CDT
ZeroWolf wrote:For a moment there I thought you meant people praising the prime Wars cartoon
I was, Facebook was where the positive feedback for those cartoons came from.
AllNewSuperRobot wrote:That sounds more like confirmation bias, than honest feedback.
So you are saying Facebook comments and forum comments here are honest feedback, but twitter feedback is not? cool cool.
Re: Review for IDW Transformers Beast Wars Issue 2 (2099607)
Posted by AllNewSuperRobot on March 28th, 2021 @ 3:35pm CDT
No, that's a strange conclusion to reach What I did say, by confirmation bias, is that by sticking with the source of perceived overly positive feedback would lead to an askew viewpoint. Honest feedback is the middle ground between positive and negative.
Posted by AllNewSuperRobot on March 28th, 2021 @ 3:35pm CDT
D-Maximal_Primal wrote:AllNewSuperRobot wrote:That sounds more like confirmation bias, than honest feedback.
So you are saying Facebook comments and forum comments here are honest feedback, but twitter feedback is not? cool cool.
No, that's a strange conclusion to reach
What I did say, by confirmation bias, is that by sticking with the source of perceived overly positive feedback would lead to an askew viewpoint. Honest feedback is the middle ground between positive and negative.
Re: Review for IDW Transformers Beast Wars Issue 2 (2099610)
Posted by ZeroWolf on March 28th, 2021 @ 3:39pm CDT
I think I'll have what those people are having if they enjoyed Prime Wars.
Posted by ZeroWolf on March 28th, 2021 @ 3:39pm CDT
D-Maximal_Primal wrote:ZeroWolf wrote:For a moment there I thought you meant people praising the prime Wars cartoon
I was, Facebook was where the positive feedback for those cartoons came from.AllNewSuperRobot wrote:That sounds more like confirmation bias, than honest feedback.
So you are saying Facebook comments and forum comments here are honest feedback, but twitter feedback is not? cool cool.
I think I'll have what those people are having if they enjoyed Prime Wars.
Re: Review for IDW Transformers Beast Wars Issue 2 (2099612)
Posted by D-Maximal_Primal on March 28th, 2021 @ 3:41pm CDT
Except I do not, I have read the Facebook and forum comments.
The forums here have approximately 5 active commenters in this thread, so it's pretty easy to get the point here.
On Facebook, once you take away the TRUKK NOT MUNKY-ers, it's a smaller but still balanced bag of positive feedback overweighing the negative feedback.
when you listen to the comic review podcasts, it's nigh universal praise.
When you read the Twitter threads, including reviews shared there, it is similar to the filtered Facebook feed: positive with some negatives, but overall trending a good positive outlook.
What I'm saying is you are far from alone in your thoughts, but you are also not the majority opinion you really think you are here.
Posted by D-Maximal_Primal on March 28th, 2021 @ 3:41pm CDT
AllNewSuperRobot wrote:D-Maximal_Primal wrote:AllNewSuperRobot wrote:That sounds more like confirmation bias, than honest feedback.
So you are saying Facebook comments and forum comments here are honest feedback, but twitter feedback is not? cool cool.
No, that's a strange conclusion to reach
Except I do not, I have read the Facebook and forum comments.
The forums here have approximately 5 active commenters in this thread, so it's pretty easy to get the point here.
On Facebook, once you take away the TRUKK NOT MUNKY-ers, it's a smaller but still balanced bag of positive feedback overweighing the negative feedback.
when you listen to the comic review podcasts, it's nigh universal praise.
When you read the Twitter threads, including reviews shared there, it is similar to the filtered Facebook feed: positive with some negatives, but overall trending a good positive outlook.
What I'm saying is you are far from alone in your thoughts, but you are also not the majority opinion you really think you are here.
Re: Review for IDW Transformers Beast Wars Issue 2 (2099616)
Posted by AllNewSuperRobot on March 28th, 2021 @ 3:49pm CDT
I never said that either. Nor do I care, one way of the other. Ultimately, all I said was that I'm not the only one who doesn't like the art. Which is true, regardless of percentages.
Specifically regarding that Tarantulas in the preview, everything about it looks like a child drew it. It is even at odds with the other character designs on the same page. Right down to the Tim Burton-style Spider legs. Which also applied to Scorponok's Beast Mode legs in the previous issue. So what is good about that?
Posted by AllNewSuperRobot on March 28th, 2021 @ 3:49pm CDT
D-Maximal_Primal wrote:What I'm saying is you are far from alone in your thoughts, but you are also not the majority opinion you really think you are here.
I never said that either. Nor do I care, one way of the other. Ultimately, all I said was that I'm not the only one who doesn't like the art. Which is true, regardless of percentages.
Specifically regarding that Tarantulas in the preview, everything about it looks like a child drew it. It is even at odds with the other character designs on the same page. Right down to the Tim Burton-style Spider legs. Which also applied to Scorponok's Beast Mode legs in the previous issue. So what is good about that?
Re: Review for IDW Transformers Beast Wars Issue 2 (2099619)
Posted by D-Maximal_Primal on March 28th, 2021 @ 4:00pm CDT
1) Tim Burton-esque legs are new and I like that art style where it appeared previously, so I see no issue with them here. It continues to trend with the way Burcham approaches arachnid legs.
2) Tarantulas has loud ass colors. They can distract from the overall style of whatever design they put on it.
3) The expressiveness of the face, Burcham has always been good with his expressions, and despite the way Tarantulas' mouth exists and having a visor, he still portrays his emotions clearly and in his first panel's case, entertainingly.
4) I love the approach to the claw hands, it's a neat touch to have that "heartbeat on a monitor" styled claw opening
Posted by D-Maximal_Primal on March 28th, 2021 @ 4:00pm CDT
AllNewSuperRobot wrote: So what is good about that?
1) Tim Burton-esque legs are new and I like that art style where it appeared previously, so I see no issue with them here. It continues to trend with the way Burcham approaches arachnid legs.
2) Tarantulas has loud ass colors. They can distract from the overall style of whatever design they put on it.
3) The expressiveness of the face, Burcham has always been good with his expressions, and despite the way Tarantulas' mouth exists and having a visor, he still portrays his emotions clearly and in his first panel's case, entertainingly.
4) I love the approach to the claw hands, it's a neat touch to have that "heartbeat on a monitor" styled claw opening
Re: Review for IDW Transformers Beast Wars Issue 2 (2099625)
Posted by AllNewSuperRobot on March 28th, 2021 @ 4:08pm CDT
Posted by AllNewSuperRobot on March 28th, 2021 @ 4:08pm CDT
Tarantulas colour palette isn't too far removed from Megatron. But in contrast (ignoring the beast mode) the line work of Megs is a lot more competently done.
The thing with a stylised art style is consistency. If you can't apply the same look to everything on your page, then it isn't stylised. It is just bad and/or lazy.
The thing with a stylised art style is consistency. If you can't apply the same look to everything on your page, then it isn't stylised. It is just bad and/or lazy.
Re: Review for IDW Transformers Beast Wars Issue 2 (2099630)
Posted by D-Maximal_Primal on March 28th, 2021 @ 4:17pm CDT
Except, looking at the preview pages, and even looking back at the prior issues, I fail to see how it's stylistically different? I am looking at Dinobot and Tarantulas side by side in the same/neighboring panels, and except for the spider legs (to a small degree, it's hardly a Tramontano facial expression on a Milne drawn bot), i don't see how the 2 could be considered different.
Posted by D-Maximal_Primal on March 28th, 2021 @ 4:17pm CDT
AllNewSuperRobot wrote:Tarantulas colour palette isn't too far removed from Megatron. But in contrast (ignoring the beast mode) the line work of Megs is a lot more competently done.
The thing with a stylised art style is consistency. If you can't apply the same look to everything on your page, then it isn't stylised. It is just bad and/or lazy.
Except, looking at the preview pages, and even looking back at the prior issues, I fail to see how it's stylistically different? I am looking at Dinobot and Tarantulas side by side in the same/neighboring panels, and except for the spider legs (to a small degree, it's hardly a Tramontano facial expression on a Milne drawn bot), i don't see how the 2 could be considered different.
Re: Review for IDW Transformers Beast Wars Issue 2 (2099633)
Posted by AllNewSuperRobot on March 28th, 2021 @ 4:22pm CDT
Posted by AllNewSuperRobot on March 28th, 2021 @ 4:22pm CDT
The rough, jagged edges make Tarantulas look unfinished in comparison to everyone else. Like the line work still needs to be cleaned up before the page can be finalised. Bottom line, it looks rushed and not consciously stylised at all.
