Review of IDW Transformers: Till All Are One #6
Wednesday, December 28th, 2016 9:37AM CST
Categories: Comic Book News, Reviews, Site ArticlesPosted by: Va'al Views: 93,077
Topic Options: View Discussion · Sign in or Join to reply
(Spoiler free-ish)
Synopsis
A wave of undead TITANS has touched down on CYBERTRON! Even with the help of the massive METROPLEX, WINDBLADE and STARSCREAM can only hold them off for so long. They need help from Elita-1—and they’re going to get it whether she agrees or not. The fate of CYBERTRON depends on it!
Story
With the weird time shifts of IDW's release schedules - seriously, even continuity has nothing on them - we're still working in the aftermath of Titans Return, and really quite heavily so. Said aftermath continues to provide an excellent backdrop to the evolving dynamics of the Council, and the whatonearthisgoingon-ness of Elita-1 and her Titan Carcer. How? Read on...
An issue which rolls much faster than the previous one, which was more focused on build-up than resolution, we start to see the direct consequence of having called all major players into play, and Elita One still unwilling to lend a hand - because something is up with Carcer, as everyone knows by now.
Though there is plenty of character building in the various scenes across the issue, and Windblade, Ironhide, Starscream, and even Metroplex get a good dose, the one that stood out the most was Obsidian, this time round. We've seen him loving his tiny 'gotcha' screens, being imposing and menacing and lurking and looming - we get to see a very different side of him, now that he's next to his First. She's probably worse things than him.
Mairghread Scott has also been able to do some subtle characterisation of the various names and faces that appear in group shots - keep an eye out for all of them as you dodge lasers, blasters, missiles. I have some further thoughts on the issue in terms of plot, but more on that below, of course.
Art
There is a lot happening all at once. It's a giant battle with giant Titans, occurring both in space and on Cybertron. It's a big canvas. Sara Pitre Durocher fills it masterfully, using panels, action layouts, character interactions and page breaks to convey the sheer scale of the event and of its impact upon Starscream's current rule, along with the Council.
And if crowd and battle scenes weren't hard enough for lineart, colourist Joana Lafuente blends her skill with equal mastery, and makes individuals in a crowd stand out, from the guards around Ironhide, to the Titans attacking, to the faces appearing between convicts, citizens, dwellers and ex-colonists. That, and we still have some excellent space scenes, too.
Tom B. Long, still on letters as we've come to expect, still delivers (as we've also come to expect) in fonts, captions, and interplaying the two and more into a coherent part of the visual storytelling. Metroplex's speech-style is still one of the highlights of this book, and so very nice to look at. We also then have Pitre Durocher on main cover, with a similar, echoing variant by Priscilla Tramontano (thumbnailed), plus a continuation of fan artist spotlights with Zoner taking a turn on RI.
Thoughts
Spoilerish ahead
Diplomacy also means strategy. Leadership also means compromise. Both definitely mean tough choices, and the unique mix of Windblade and Starscream's takes on the current situation at hand brings out a definitely intriguing and potentially incredibly consequential storyline revolving yes around Carcer, but also Metroplex, but even more also - and particularly - Elita-1.
As I said above, I like Obsidian's 'new' side, I like his interaction with Elita, I like that Windblade and Starscream are collaborating on a difficult task, I like that we have a side-support from Chromia, I like that we have everyone - and I mean everyone - in the issue (Check out ScottyP's spoilery character roster in our database!). I like that I have no idea where this is going. I can only think of other Titans, past storylines, speculate, and mostly, just wait for the evil to unfold. Join me?
News Search
Got Transformers News? Let us know here!
Most Popular Transformers News
ROTB Optimus Prime Lead Designer Discusses Why the Face Looks Similar to the 2007 Movie
56,768 viewsMost Recent Transformers News
Posted by Kurona on December 28th, 2016 @ 3:13pm CST
Posted by o.supreme on December 28th, 2016 @ 3:25pm CST
Posted by Targetmaster Kup on December 28th, 2016 @ 3:31pm CST
Posted by Va'al on December 28th, 2016 @ 3:38pm CST
Nik Hero wrote:They should have clearly labeled this as part of Titans Return.
It is, in the blurb/synopsis of last issue. The fact that it's not happening before Revolution is entirely IDW's scheduling fault. They're.. not very good at keeping schedules to schedule.
Posted by Kurona on December 28th, 2016 @ 3:57pm CST
o.supreme wrote:Agreed. It feels more like the natural continuation of RiD (which I always preferred to MTMTE) rather than Windblade Vol 3.
To be fair, Windblade's books have all been about Cybertron and it's relations with other planets. So in that sense, Windblade has always felt like a continuation of the political side of things with Starscream and such in pre-Dark Cybertron RiD while post-Dark Cybertron RiD feels like a continuation of the whole Orion Pax thing in pre-Dark Cybertron RiD.
Posted by o.supreme on December 28th, 2016 @ 4:10pm CST
Posted by Targetmaster Kup on December 28th, 2016 @ 5:19pm CST
Dr Va'al wrote:Nik Hero wrote:They should have clearly labeled this as part of Titans Return.
It is, in the blurb/synopsis of last issue. The fact that it's not happening before Revolution is entirely IDW's scheduling fault. They're.. not very good at keeping schedules to schedule.
I bet it would have sold more with the label on the front.
Posted by Bounti76 on December 28th, 2016 @ 5:41pm CST
Dr Va'al wrote:Nik Hero wrote:They should have clearly labeled this as part of Titans Return.
It is, in the blurb/synopsis of last issue. The fact that it's not happening before Revolution is entirely IDW's scheduling fault. They're.. not very good at keeping schedules to schedule.
Va'al, I checked out the database like you suggested, and I was surprised to see Slammer listed among the characters. I've studied every panel and can't see Slammer anywhere, unless he's got a robot mode that has hithertofore been unseen in the last 30 years.
Posted by Va'al on December 29th, 2016 @ 3:37am CST
Bounti76 wrote:Dr Va'al wrote:Nik Hero wrote:They should have clearly labeled this as part of Titans Return.
It is, in the blurb/synopsis of last issue. The fact that it's not happening before Revolution is entirely IDW's scheduling fault. They're.. not very good at keeping schedules to schedule.
Va'al, I checked out the database like you suggested, and I was surprised to see Slammer listed among the characters. I've studied every panel and can't see Slammer anywhere, unless he's got a robot mode that has hithertofore been unseen in the last 30 years.
ScottyP suggests that one of the guards - the one you see shouting at people, I believe - is in fact slammer, mostly due to the presence of Metroplex in the story. I cannot confirm or deny either way, but it's worth considering as an option!
Posted by Va'al on December 29th, 2016 @ 3:43am CST
Noticed there was no TAAO issue in the March solicitations; it's not cancelled, is it? D:
Nope. We’re just taking a month off for Sara to catch up. Unlike our characters (or like them, depending on how you define it) she is not a machine.
Posted by Bounti76 on December 29th, 2016 @ 5:04am CST
Dr Va'al wrote:Bounti76 wrote:Dr Va'al wrote:Nik Hero wrote:They should have clearly labeled this as part of Titans Return.
It is, in the blurb/synopsis of last issue. The fact that it's not happening before Revolution is entirely IDW's scheduling fault. They're.. not very good at keeping schedules to schedule.
Va'al, I checked out the database like you suggested, and I was surprised to see Slammer listed among the characters. I've studied every panel and can't see Slammer anywhere, unless he's got a robot mode that has hithertofore been unseen in the last 30 years.
ScottyP suggests that one of the guards - the one you see shouting at people, I believe - is in fact slammer, mostly due to the presence of Metroplex in the story. I cannot confirm or deny either way, but it's worth considering as an option!
That's fair. Considering we have such obscure characters as Greenlight, Lancer, Moonracer and the Devisen twins in this story, I wouldn't put it past Scott to slip Slammer into one of the issues. Though given that TAAO generally hews close to 'bots classic color schemes and Slammer's color scheme has always been white-on-white, and this bot's is predominantly gray.....eh, if it is Slammer, maybe Scott, Pitre-DuRocher and LaFuente are taking creative liberties with him, since he's never appeared in robot form before.
Posted by Randomhero on December 29th, 2016 @ 6:15am CST
Posted by ScottyP on December 29th, 2016 @ 8:07am CST
It's a case of me having fun with it for one, but also making the most educated guess that I can. If it comes out 'officially' that it's just a generic 'bot, I'll take it out of there prontoBounti76 wrote:That's fair. Considering we have such obscure characters as Greenlight, Lancer, Moonracer and the Devisen twins in this story, I wouldn't put it past Scott to slip Slammer into one of the issues. Though given that TAAO generally hews close to 'bots classic color schemes and Slammer's color scheme has always been white-on-white, and this bot's is predominantly gray.....eh, if it is Slammer, maybe Scott, Pitre-DuRocher and LaFuente are taking creative liberties with him, since he's never appeared in robot form before.
I did say educated guess and you were right to say that Slammer never had a robot mode. However, in the spoopy world of third party Transformers, the Iron Factory Generations Metroplex upgrade set came with a Slammer that has a bot mode that's at least a little like the one drawn in the book:
On another note, very glad to see that this is continuing on in April, and also glad they just skipped March instead of throwing out a solicitation that might not make it in.
Posted by Randomhero on December 29th, 2016 @ 11:21am CST
Posted by Va'al on December 29th, 2016 @ 12:12pm CST
Posted by Randomhero on December 29th, 2016 @ 1:39pm CST
Dr Va'al wrote:Yeah it's a shame that we're still using humans that have lives and the such. How dare they.
Nothing stopped Mark bagley frrom drawing 111 issues of ultimate Spider man in the span of 7 years. That's almost 2 issues a month continuiously through out his whole time on the book. Same with Charlie adlard on walking dead for 13 years. WD got delayed a couple times but never a point of slipping an actual solicitation. I'm just saying if you can't meet the monthly deadline then don't commit to it. That's why Sarah stone isn't drawing for Transformers anymore, she did great work but couldn't do the monthly deadline and drawing comics isn't a hobby it's a job.when you can't do it, a new artist comes in that can do it because when you miss a month, sales get smaller. I know, I've actually drawn comics and just had to turn down a story in a self published this month because my day job is in the way. I didn't tell the creator "gimme a few months I can do it" I said "I thought I could but I can't, if you want I can do a story for the next one"
Honestly I'd rather see some verterans on this book like dan khanna, Robbie musso or Emiliano Santalucia because those are artist that can draw good transformers comics on timely basis.
Posted by Va'al on December 29th, 2016 @ 2:53pm CST
Randomhero wrote:Dr Va'al wrote:Yeah it's a shame that we're still using humans that have lives and the such. How dare they.
Honestly I'd rather see some verterans on this book like dan khanna, Robbie musso or Emiliano Santalucia because those are artist that can draw good transformers comics on timely basis.
I'd rather we gave creators a chance to continue their own work, rather than drive them to burnouts and having to turn down work. I'm sure you also know that artists are pretty much all work for hire at IDW, and that this is not their only job.
We (readers and editors) gave Nick Roche a chance with Sins of the Wreckers. Happy to do the same for Sara Pitre Durocher. And much happier IDW did this than their usual -whoops, let's just publish two weeks late because the writers are too slow to get their work over to the artists.
EDIT: Image have been doing the couple of months hiatus for a while now, and none of their sales have been affected. It's a model I really do quite like: one monthly issue for five months, one month is the TPB, one month break, repeat.
Posted by Rael on December 29th, 2016 @ 4:24pm CST
Count me as another glad they're going this route with the schedule as opposed to sliding releases back a week several times in a row to even it out. Many of the fill-in artists IDW brings in are fantastic, but there's always something to be said for keeping the ongoing artist in the chair when it means consistent trades and minimized continuity oversights in designs and details.
Posted by Randomhero on December 29th, 2016 @ 4:49pm CST
Biggest reason i miss the Spotlights. they were an easy way to get new artists and see if they can handle it
Posted by Va'al on December 29th, 2016 @ 5:08pm CST
Posted by Sunstar on December 29th, 2016 @ 5:51pm CST
Posted by Go-Faster-Wings on December 29th, 2016 @ 6:03pm CST
Plus, as other people pointed out, this isn't her only job. Last I checked she was still an art director at a video game company or something. I think she deserves a break.
Posted by Kurona on December 29th, 2016 @ 6:26pm CST
Posted by Rael on December 29th, 2016 @ 6:38pm CST
Randomhero wrote:personally Id rather have consistency in release dates. im fine giving people a shot but if they cant keep up than they cant keep up. Its one of my biggest worries with Kei Zama, got total faith, shes great artist but this is her first go and we have now had one artist stop because she couldnt do it and another now that apprently needs a break. when that happens then maybe TAAO needs to go to a revolving art team like Lost Light. I know some people are being very harsh at Jack Lawrence not because of his art but because hes not Milne while Milne even admitting that all the delays the past 5 years on MTMTE were his fault. yeah he had an injury and i respect and understand that but he has admitted that couldnt keep up sometimes and a filler artist came in.
Biggest reason i miss the Spotlights. they were an easy way to get new artists and see if they can handle it
The thing is, claiming from this one instance that Sara Pitre-Durocher generally "can't keep up" is still quite an assumption. Given how far ahead this news comes, it seems incredibly likely this was done proactively (perhaps as a kindness to Sara after several months of continuous work on ex-RID, TAAO, and more and to Mairghread with the birth of her baby) instead of reactively due to a plea for more time.
With Kei being such a beast, as long as her health holds out I've got no concerns.
I don't really see how a Spotlight oneshot provides insight on how someone will handle months upon months of work back to back (especially if a oneshot and an issue for Marvel apparently couldn't do the same for Sara and Kei).
Regardless, it's pretty clear we've got a difference in priorities here, since I'd always gladly wait for the detailed, time-intensive art we see from Milne, Coller, etc. over letting them bench warm because they can't keep pace with people with looser styles.
Posted by ScottyP on December 29th, 2016 @ 8:46pm CST
She's laughing at you, btw.Randomhero wrote:Hateful garbage about an artist
Posted by Sunstar on December 29th, 2016 @ 11:19pm CST
ScottyP wrote:She's laughing at you, btw.Randomhero wrote:Hateful garbage about an artist
I am amused.
Posted by Randomhero on December 30th, 2016 @ 10:10am CST
Sunstar wrote:ScottyP wrote:She's laughing at you, btw.Randomhero wrote:Hateful garbage about an artist
I am amused.
Well it's nice to see she reads threads. Means she not making terrible slash/fic art of tailgate and Cyclonus because that's that relationship in a nutshell.
Posted by Rael on December 30th, 2016 @ 12:53pm CST
Randomhero wrote:Sunstar wrote:ScottyP wrote:She's laughing at you, btw.Randomhero wrote:Hateful garbage about an artist
I am amused.
Well it's nice to see she reads threads. Means she not making terrible slash/fic art of tailgate and Cyclonus because that's that relationship in a nutshell.
Idk man, some accomplished multitaskers can manage forum browsing and quality ship doodles at the same time—you never know.
Posted by D-Maximal_Primal on January 5th, 2017 @ 10:00pm CST
That would be my one complaint. The first arc felt like it should have been 5 issues, not 4, and it feels the same here. I wish it was a teensy bit paced slower and a little more "dense"
Posted by Va'al on January 16th, 2017 @ 1:45am CST
Posted by Va'al on January 24th, 2017 @ 11:49am CST
PEACE IN OUR TIME! STARSCREAM and WINDBLADE have given everything to bring together CYBERTRON’s Lost Colonies into a Council Of Worlds. But when the increasingly brutal tactics of STARSCREAM’s secret police increase tension among the former DECEPTICONS… how long can the Council maintain this fragile peace?
Posted by Bounti76 on January 24th, 2017 @ 12:45pm CST
Posted by Va'al on January 24th, 2017 @ 12:50pm CST
Bounti76 wrote:So, wait..... IDW's own website stated that TAAO #7 wouldn't be coming out until February 22nd. Just checked it again, and now it says #8 is coming out on the 22nd (and also doesn't list #7). Does that mean we get two issues of TAAO before the scheduled break in March? IDW, you so crazy!
In IDW's schedule we (DO NOT) trust.
Posted by o.supreme on January 24th, 2017 @ 12:53pm CST
Posted by ScottyP on January 24th, 2017 @ 1:08pm CST
Posted by D-Maximal_Primal on January 24th, 2017 @ 1:20pm CST
Posted by Bounti76 on January 24th, 2017 @ 1:51pm CST
o.supreme wrote:I thought we would get #7 end of January, February was TAAO's "off" Month, and it was returning in March with #8?
March was always the scheduled "off" month. There were no solicits released for TAAO in that month.
Posted by Targetmaster Kup on January 24th, 2017 @ 1:56pm CST
Posted by o.supreme on January 24th, 2017 @ 1:58pm CST
Bounti76 wrote:o.supreme wrote:I thought we would get #7 end of January, February was TAAO's "off" Month, and it was returning in March with #8?
March was always the scheduled "off" month. There were no solicits released for TAAO in that month.
ok...then we should get #8 in February then, to stay on schedule, and be back with #9 in April
Posted by Bounti76 on January 24th, 2017 @ 3:13pm CST
o.supreme wrote:Bounti76 wrote:o.supreme wrote:I thought we would get #7 end of January, February was TAAO's "off" Month, and it was returning in March with #8?
March was always the scheduled "off" month. There were no solicits released for TAAO in that month.
That's my understanding. #7 on February 8th #8
ok...then we should get #8 in February then, to stay on schedule, and be back with #9 in April
That's my understanding. #7 on February 8th, and #8 on February 22nd.
Posted by Sunstar on January 24th, 2017 @ 5:18pm CST
Posted by Bounti76 on January 24th, 2017 @ 8:01pm CST
Sunstar wrote:so when can I send my husband out to retrieve my books? I am starting to salivate now.
Check the post above.
Posted by ScottyP on January 24th, 2017 @ 10:32pm CST
Basically, don't expect anything more than 7 days out to have a solid release date that you can expect will be met, and this next part is important - this holds true even if IDW has put a date out somewhere on their own website. They'll send an email at some point tomorrow that will contain everything that is set to ship out in the coming days so that it can make it to shops in time for next week. Until that comes in, 2/1 or 2/8 or 3/1 for [insert book name here] is as good of a guess as any.
Posted by Randomhero on January 24th, 2017 @ 11:40pm CST
Posted by D-Maximal_Primal on January 24th, 2017 @ 11:49pm CST
Randomhero wrote:Lost Light #2 is released and is available on iBooks
where? I can't find it
Posted by Va'al on January 25th, 2017 @ 2:27am CST
D-Maximus_Prime wrote:Randomhero wrote:Lost Light #2 is released and is available on iBooks
where? I can't find it
The iTunes page does say released on 25th January...
https://itunes.apple.com/us/book/transf ... 2270?mt=11
Posted by Randomhero on January 25th, 2017 @ 5:49am CST
Va'al wrote:D-Maximus_Prime wrote:Randomhero wrote:Lost Light #2 is released and is available on iBooks
where? I can't find it
The iTunes page does say released on 25th January...
https://itunes.apple.com/us/book/transf ... 2270?mt=11
I managed to snag it at 11:05 central when I was getting Optimus Prime #3
Posted by ScottyP on January 25th, 2017 @ 6:17am CST
ScottyP wrote:IDW release dates really aren't known until the week before. Even then, weird stuff can happen (TF 57 being the latest example where it hit digitally, then not in shops for two more weeks.)
Basically, don't expect anything more than 7 days out to have a solid release date that you can expect will be met, and this next part is important - this holds true even if IDW has put a date out somewhere on their own website. They'll send an email at some point tomorrow that will contain everything that is set to ship out in the coming days so that it can make it to shops in time for next week. Until that comes in, 2/1 or 2/8 or 3/1 for [insert book name here] is as good of a guess as any.
My apologies for apparently totally jinxing itRandomhero wrote:Lost Light #2 is released and is available on iBooks
Posted by Randomhero on January 25th, 2017 @ 6:54am CST
ScottyP wrote:ScottyP wrote:IDW release dates really aren't known until the week before. Even then, weird stuff can happen (TF 57 being the latest example where it hit digitally, then not in shops for two more weeks.)
Basically, don't expect anything more than 7 days out to have a solid release date that you can expect will be met, and this next part is important - this holds true even if IDW has put a date out somewhere on their own website. They'll send an email at some point tomorrow that will contain everything that is set to ship out in the coming days so that it can make it to shops in time for next week. Until that comes in, 2/1 or 2/8 or 3/1 for [insert book name here] is as good of a guess as any.My apologies for apparently totally jinxing itRandomhero wrote:Lost Light #2 is released and is available on iBooks
iBooks is a weird one. Till a couple months ago Wednesday releases happened at 10pm central on Tuesdays, now it's 11pm and once in a while they really screw up on something. I got MTMTE #16 back in 2013 4 weeks before it came out. I was getting RID that night and there it was. I remember when remain In Light part 3 was part 2 for over a month.
Won't spoil anything ofcourse since it's not out legitimately for another week
Posted by Va'al on February 4th, 2017 @ 5:53am CST
Transformers: Till All Are One #7
Mairghread Scott (w) • Sara Pitre-Durocher (a & c)
As Windblade and her team fight their way through Elita-1’s Titan, Carcer, they face opposition at every turn to stop them from awakening the sleeping giant… and they soon find out why!
FC • 32 pages • $3.99
Bullet points:
- Variant cover by Joana Lafuente!